SoonerinNC

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 25 posts - 151 through 175 (of 805 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: 2024 MLB draft #256116
    SoonerinNC
    Participant

    Free

    Sorry Edmans also still with the team

    in reply to: 2024 MLB draft #256106
    SoonerinNC
    Participant

    Free

    With the draft coming up I thought it would be well to check out Randy’s performance vs other top teams. Checked him out against the Dodgers, Yankees, Braves, Phillies, Orioles and the Astros. Took a quick look at the Brewers and found that they would have been about the middle of the pack vs the above group.

    Ranking – # 1 Picks Reaching Major Leagues. Number and Positive WAR according to Baseball Encyclopedia

    Team No +WAR
    Dodgers 6 – 26.7
    Cardinals 5 – 14.5
    Orioles 7 – 14.5
    Phillies 4 – 10.7
    Yankees 4 – 8.9
    Braves 8 – 6.7
    Astrol 4 – 0.0

    Ranking – Top 5 rounds
    Orioles 18 – 40.7
    Dodgers 16 – 38.6
    Cardinals 13 – 35.6
    Braves 18 – 22.5
    Phillies 11 – 19.1
    Yankees 14 – 15.0
    Astros 16 – 14.8

    Ranking – 6th round or later
    Cardinals 11 – 32.2
    Dodgers 22 – 26.5
    Yankees 20 – 21.8
    Astros 21 – 18.8
    Phillies 11 – 8.5
    Braves 11 – 5.3
    Orioles 8 – 3.1

    Total Positive WAR
    Cardinals 24 – 67.8
    Dodgers 38 – 65.1
    Orioles 26 – 43.8
    Yankees 34 – 36.8
    Astros 37 – 33.6
    Braves 29 – 27.8
    Phillies 22 – 27.6

    Some observations, some pure speculation on my part.
    1. Gorman is the only major positive contributor still with the team.
    2. The high number of players reaching the major leagues by the Yankees and Dodgers could be a result of willingness to spend on more lower ranked players.
    3. There probably teams with higher numbers. I did a study a couple of years ago and while the Cardinals were high I recall that the Blue Jays were higher at that point.
    4. This is wild speculation. Hard to know what goes into draft decisions. Randy may have wanted a higher cieling player but the powers that be may not have been willing to meet the players over slot demand
    5. The Orioles low number of players reaching the major leagues may be a result of them not willing to spend on the lower rounds because of the size of their pool for top choices. They got a lot of early picks.
    6. Finally, it is aparent from the above numbers that many of the top teams are top teams not because of the draft but rather trades, free agents and international players. The Cardinals low performance on the field in recent times could well reflect a weakness in those catagories.

    SoonerinNC
    Participant

    Free

    So if we need to have Pages defensively then why not DH Herrera. Woeful bottom of the lineup with Carpenter, Pages, Siani

    SoonerinNC
    Participant

    Free

    Why was Herrera not in the game. We had a day off after a day game. We have a weak enogh lineup without taking a regular out of the lineup for no good reason.

    in reply to: StL 2024 Game #60 thread – Monday, June 3 at Astros #255012
    SoonerinNC
    Participant

    Free

    Actually I think he has been pretty lucky with some of his bad decisions. Some say I would rather be lucky than good. I think maybe Ollie is one of those guys.

    in reply to: StL 2024 Game #60 thread – Monday, June 3 at Astros #255008
    SoonerinNC
    Participant

    Free

    Having mixed emotions. Want the Cardinals win but if they do we have to put up with this manager beyond this season. I have never criticized a Cardinal manager before but this guy makes decisions that a little league coach would avoid.

    Why is Donovan batting 6th. Why has Winn been batting 8th most of the season. Why does Ollie sit Winn as much as he does. He is only leading the Cardinals in hitting and ops but is leading the major leagues in runs saved on defense.

    Why are rookie pitchers making their major league debuts in late close games. He has been lucky so far but it makes no sense. It is like he is conceding the game if we trail in the late innings.

    Why are key bullpen pitchers idle for 3 and 4 games while Ollie is exerimenting with the rookies.

    What is the point in dropping Aranado to 5th instead of 4th. Why ever bat him 3rd with Goldy in the lineup.

    Why does he sit multiple regulars in the same game. Why is he constantly changing the lineups. Roles play a key part in keeping player heads straight.

    I begin to think he is gaining some sense then he makes a bonehead decision. He is obsessed with platooning. He brought a left handed pitcher in the game to face a great hitter who is 11th in the American League in average against left handed pitchers.

    SoonerinNC
    Participant

    Free

    Win is having a good year and playing all-star shortstop and Gorman was just heating up. How could either be on the bench today with a chance to win against a bad team. But it is both of them including Herrera.

    And why is Carpenter leading off? Ollie drives me crazy with his stupid lineups.

    in reply to: What’s it gonna take to fix the Cardinals #252067
    SoonerinNC
    Participant

    Free

    I am not sure about Madden but he is right about a lot of things.

    1) The nerds have apparently taken over, the obsession with platooning, the knee jerk reactions. They have no clue how to build a ball team and how to keep player focused on playing the game. Many of them have to be constantly looking over their shoulder worrying about what Ollie is going to do next.

    2) The going quantity rather than quality in the International program. They have spending limits in place which should allow them to compete with anyone for talent. They keep looking for the diamond in the rough and with the tools available to evaluate talent now those days are almost over that you will find a phenom that everybody has missed. The few good international prospects we have signed have largely been dealt off with little in return.

    3) Field management- strictly amateurs. Inside the box thinking. Ollie is not qualified to be a major league manager and Mo not only brings him back but gives him a two year extension. Poor decision after poor decision.
    – Good thing he was out of the game yesterday. He has the habit of using other than the best relief pitcher late in close games. Sometimes it works for him but often ends up being further behind late. Yesterday whoever was running the team used our best relief pitchers even though trailing in the late innins and viola a walk off win. Using a struggling Gallegos in the 8th inning of a close game is a perfect example of how clueless Ollie is about use of him bullpen.
    – Resting multiple regulars to the extent we have regulars. Winn is leading all baseball in defensive WAR for defensive shortstops and has hit well but he has not started in a least 6 games. I think Ollie is trying to satisfy everyone and satisfying no one.
    – Lineups- Putting high strikeout guys in the 2 and 3 holes is a recipe for low scoring. Batting the speedy Winn 7th and usually 8th in the lineup takes away his value. He should be second or ninth. Too much platooning.
    – Impatience with young players. Doesn’t use them for days and when they fail it is off to the minors.

    We need a new General Manager and a Manager with a good track record who will bring in a new staff

    We probably need to take a hard look at major league scouting. Too many bad pickups. Too many aging players who are coming off a down year and eternal hope that they will turn it around.

    The international program needs to be totally revamped with a different approach and possiby a vast change in personel. We do not hava an international player in the system that we have more than a hope that they will be a solid major league player much less a star.

    I think Flores is doing a pretty good job in the draft but the drastic switch from pitching to hitting has not paid off that well. At one time his draftees had one of the highest collective WAR in the game but I haven’t checked lately Picking late had to hurt with the emergence of better evaluation tools but that is unlikely to be a problem in the future.

    I am 89 years old and am facing the bleak prospect that I will never see an outstanding Cardinal team again.

    SoonerinNC
    Participant

    Free

    Where was Libratore. He had two days rest after pitching one inning three days ago. Ollie continues to insist on using the rookie in critical situations why not him in the 6th or 6th and 7th. Then you have Kitteredge, Romero, Helsley and Libratore to finish the game. Probably use Fernandea for an inning and go to Kitteredge in the 7th.

    Why are our hitters having so much trouble. If anyone knows are we still pursuing the Albert pull everything and upercut approach at the plate.

    SoonerinNC
    Participant

    Free

    Ollies bullpen use continues to confuse me.

    Yesterday in game 2 he uses Gallegos, arguably our least effective bullpen guy in the 8th inning with us just down by one. Got burned. Gallegos has done well for us in the past but very inconsistent this year. So we go into the ninth inning down 5 instead of down one.

    And what is he trying to do with Libratore? He is supposed to be our 6th starter and long reliever but Ollie is using him in the late innings and sometimes on consecutive days. The trio of Romero, Kitteredge and Helsley has done fine so far so why mess around with other things. And I know they can’t go everyday, but Gallegos?

    And Winn who is leading the team in defensive WAR, offensive WAR and total WAR has sat for 3 games and didn’t start two other games. Young guy and unless there are injuries we don’t know about why take him out of the lineup. He must be wondering what he has to do to be out there every day.

    in reply to: Ollie’s Bullpen Usee #250352
    SoonerinNC
    Participant

    Free

    Still puzzled by Ollies bullpen moves. Yesterday in game 2 he goes with Gallegos late and down one. Gallegos has done well for us in the past but is probably the most ineffective bullpen guy we had. Got burned again and we go into the ninth down 5 instead of 1.

    Also if Libratore is our long relief guy why has he been used late and on succesive days. He is probably unavailable for long relief until at least Friday or later. Romero, Kittersdge and Helsley work fine for 7,8 and 9. Why keep messing around. And I do understand you can’t use that trio every day–but Gallegos.

    in reply to: Ollie’s Bullpen Usee #248978
    SoonerinNC
    Participant

    Free

    Maybe Mo wants a manager who does what he says. Most of the Cardinal field staff has little championship background as field staff.

    SoonerinNC
    Participant

    Free

    Almost everyone is underperforming. That is a bad sign. And I also feel they are just going through the motions. I know you are supposed to keep and even keel but it would be nice to see a little more emotion.

    I feel that they know they in a deteriorating system.

    in reply to: Whitey Herzog Passes #248333
    SoonerinNC
    Participant

    Free

    I have felt that Whitey has been the best Cardinal manager in their history. He had an eye for not just talent but for winning ball players and was a very smart game manager. Saw him outmaneuver the Cubs for a win in Wrigley once. Don’t remember the details but a late inning move that left the Cubs at a disadvantage.

    I believe had he remained as General Manager he would have excelled there as well. When Gussy gave up control of the team it really hampered Whitey and certainly led to his retirement.

    One of the greatest Cardinals ever. RIP and condolences to his family.

    SoonerinNC
    Participant

    Free

    Ollie has no sense of roles. If Thompson is to be long relief he should have been in the game in the 6th and probably the 7th. That would have got them to their stress inning guys in the 8th and 9th. If he was going to use Thompson then Pallante should not have been in the game. No saying that because he got torched but because players need to understand their role on the team. They are more comfortable and know what to expect. Sometimes I wonder if Ollie has any semblence of a plan.

    And starting a game with more than one regular on the bench. Winn has been going great. Why rest him now. If he needed to get Crawford some game time, there is always the DH. Then if he was going to give Winn the day off why bring him in in the middle of the game. Giving a player a day off and then using them for anything other than a late inning pinch hitting role makes no sense.

    When players are uncertain about their role on the team that effects their play. Tony LaRussa was a genius at identifying roles for players and using them as planned.

    SoonerinNC
    Participant

    Free

    Ollie continues to make stupid bullpen decisions. Got away with it today but having a guy make his major league debut down one run in the 8th inning is not a smart decision. He had all spring to establish a 7th, 8th and 9th inning relievers but goes with a major league debue in the 8th in a tight game.

    And I agree. He is platoon obsessed. Why take Winn out of the lineup when he has been going good. If he wanted to get Crawford in the lineup there is always the DH spot. And if Walker is the regular why pinch hit for him. His record last year should have earned him a solid regular status.

    These kind of moves has to be a disrupting factor in the clubhouse.

    Also it appears to me that we are hitting an abnormal number of popups. Wonder if they are still following the Albert strategy of pull and loft. Mo was so enamored with that approach that he fired a successful manager because of the conflict over that. And a relatively inexerienced hitting coach would not dare disagree with Mo.

    SoonerinNC
    Participant

    Free

    Same formula that put us in last place last year.
    Keeping Goldy hitting second and putting Gorman, a strikeout risk in the key #3 position.
    Using set up bullpen guys in the critical 8th and 9th inning. Should have pulled Palante as soon as the lead off hitter got on. Pallante is not a 8th or 9th inning guy. It is early in the season, why go more than one inning with a relief pitcher.Who are Ollie’s 8th and 9th inning guys. He seems to be cool toward turning the 9th over to Helsley and gives up on him the first time he gives up a run.

    Why was King even out there. He is not a critical inning guy.

    in reply to: Oli Extension #244275
    SoonerinNC
    Participant

    Free

    I thought it was stupid to bring him back for 24. Don’t know what to call this deal.
    I can’t remember a Cardinal manager I had less confidence in.

    in reply to: Tommy Edman wrist surgery #240849
    SoonerinNC
    Participant

    Free

    I like GameCard’s lineup. Edman can be 1 or 2 but Noot and Donovan are better offensive players. Still don’t see the point in announcing a starting lineup befor spring training even starts. Mo should leave preseason lineups to Pugsley and gang.

    I would alsp rotate Donovan, Gorman and Walker at DH, 2B, LF

    Noot in RF

    in reply to: Molina joining coaching staff? Descalso is in! #239582
    SoonerinNC
    Participant

    Free

    I would think a team would want a veteran coaching coaching staff with a young field manager.

    The Cardinals seem to be going in the opposite direction.

    in reply to: What’s it gonna take to fix the Cardinals #239580
    SoonerinNC
    Participant

    Free

    We should have known and certainly the front office and Ollie should have known we were in trouble with our starting rotation whith an aging Wainwright as a key member if not the #1 starter at the beginning of the season.

    Not sure we won’t regret dumping Flaherty and moreso Hudson. I thought both were showing signs of regaining their pre-injury form.

    Flaherty certainly didn’t show much at Baltimore though.

    in reply to: Community 2024 Top 50 Prospect Voting #239097
    SoonerinNC
    Participant

    Free

    #27 Mathews

    I have not participated because I saw few minor league games but I think this guy is better than this.

    in reply to: The clubhouse vibe #238989
    SoonerinNC
    Participant

    Free

    The biggest problem is Mo.

    Poor trading, poor record with free agents, no international program, keeping prospects beyond their trade value, etc. But worst of all bringing Ollie back. Ollie did a terrible job in 2023.

    Tony LaRusa was a genius at defining roles and getting players who fit and was willing to fill the role. Very few 2023 Cardinals had a well defined role. And that is very important to players.

    Donovan is an ideal number one and two guy and possibly number nine but Ollie had him batting all over the lineup a good part of the season. And in and out of the lineup. Donovan probably never knew if he was going to be in the lineup or not or where he would bat in the lineup. Player like to know what role they are going to play.

    Apparently Goldy likes to bat second but he rarely batted third and he was probably the only decent #3 hitter we had.

    Strikeout guys like Gorman and O’Neill batting second, third and cleanup. He needed to put Goldy third and Aranado 4th and leave them there if on the field.

    Players also run hot and cold. Ollie seemed to be obsessed with platooning. Playing Motter with Gorman on the bench. Dropping Walker to the bottom of the lineup with a right hander itching. In late August Edman had two walkoff hits in a row and Walker went 5 for 5 batting 5th. The next day they were batting 7th and 8th. Edman should never bat anywhere but 1,2 or 9.

    Ollie never established a 7th, 8th and 9th inning bullpen and kept using middle relievers in games where we were one or 2 runs behind in the 8th or top of the 9th inning usually with bad results.

    I don’t think he likes Helsley. Even in 2022 when Helsley was lights out in the pen Ollie kept pushing Gallegos to be the closer and after a few poor outing early in the season he dumped him from the closer role. Then he had Gallegos all over the place but while Gallegos had a poor season the uncertainty of how he was to be used had to weigh on his performance.

    Ollie was also very impatient with some while seemingly had a lot of patience with Motter, Verhagen, Stratton.

    His handling of Contreras was abysmal. Contreras seems to be a very conpetitive guy and like many joining a new team with a big contract probably was trying too hard and got of poorly and Ollie began messing with him and dumped him as starting catcher very early

    Thompson opened the season with 9 straight scoreless outing and after a few poorer ones was off to the minors. Walker sets a franchise record for consecutive games with a hit to start the season and off to the minors when he hits a soft spot supposedly to learn to play the outfild better but was a worse option than Contreras or Burleson who Ollie seemed to have enduring patience with.

    I don’t know who the bigger problem is. Mo or Ollie. Mo announces the Ollie will be back and then Ollie starts throwing players under the bus. And Mo might want to wait until after spring training to announce the starting lineup.

    I am usually a glass half full person but I am 89 years old and beginning to doubt that I wil ever see another good Cardinal team.

    in reply to: Former Cardinals in the News – 2017 to Aug. 2024 (closed) #238413
    SoonerinNC
    Participant

    Free

    Good to see Shildt get another shot at managing.

    in reply to: What’s it gonna take to fix the Cardinals #236718
    SoonerinNC
    Participant

    Free

    The pundits are not seriously considering the Cardinals for top tier starting pitchers and Mo has a poor track record in selecting second tier pitchers so I don’t have a lot of hopes that we will land a real number one or two starter.

    What DeWitt needs to do is get a front office that can really evaluate baseball talent and go after a Bruce Bochy type manager like the Rangers did. And spend up to the luxury tax level.

    It is unbelievable that they are standing pat with Ollie. His first year success was largely due to a career year from Goldschmidt, and all-star closing effort by Helsley and a great swan song by Albert. He was a terrible manager this year.

Viewing 25 posts - 151 through 175 (of 805 total)

First-hand news and commentary on the St. Louis Cardinals™ and minor league system for over 25 years