Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
I am a little biased because I was a big Garcia fan and was not critical of the Cardinals international splurge where they picked up Garcia, Arozarena and Oviedo.
But Garcia clearly had two high tools. Power and throwing arm. A key would be who did they keep on the 40 man roster. Today’s roster (probably far from set) includes Naile, Rodriguez, Suarez, Zuniga, Querecuto and Siani. How many of them have big tools.
And why did they give Ravelo and Drew Robinson major league time in 2019 and not Garcia.
I am sure that part of the reason to give up on Garcia was the need to protect others. Wonder how many of them had two above average tools.
In the last 6 or 7 years Mo has come up on the short end of free agent signings and trades even with the addition of Aranado and Goldschmidt.
Add to that 11 international players first signed by the Cardinals played in the major leagues this season. Those 11 players have accumulated a WAR of 81.6 Unfortunately only Herrera remains. Net WAR of those 11 players in 2023 was 16.2 including Alcantara (3.4), Arozarena (3.5), Garcia (4.2), Oviedo (2.0) and Solalno (1.9). Total net WAR for the Cardinals for 2023 was 24.8.
The Cardinals just announced that Ollie is returning next year. Should have been gone at the all-star break.
Ollie’s lineup construction makes absolutely no sense. Maybe Goldschmidt wants to bat second but he needs to bat third for the team. Also for Goldy because they would pitch him different if Aranado is in the on deck circle instead of high strikeout guys like O’Neill. That would also allow them to have a couple of on base guys with speed batting in front of them.
I think he also is way too platoon oriented. In late August Edman had just hit walkoffss two games in a row batting leadoff and Walker batting 5th went 4-4. The next game against the Pirates with a right handed pitcher Ollie has Edman batting 7th and Walker batting 8th.
Also it appears to me that the Cardinals are still using the Jeff Albert approach to pulling everything and the uppercut swing. That got Shildt fired when he protested and wanted to get rid of Albert. I think this one is on Mo rather than Ollie since Jeff is no longer around. Gets more homers in a pitchers park but fewer runs and wins.
September 12, 2023 at 9:03 pm in reply to: 2023 StL Game #145: Tuesday, September 12 at Orioles #233798Anyone know why Contreras and Gorman were taken out of the game? I can’t watch Baltimore games, Washington or Atlanta games her in North Carolina.
baseball-reference.com
Everything is up to date. For example, the WAR accumulated by Goldy is 22.0 since his acquisition by the Cardinals. For players who have been acquired and subsequently moved on the WAR achieved with their new teams are added as a plus to Cardinal acquisitions. For example The accumulated WAR for Ozuna is 8.4, 4.3 with the Cardinals and 4.1 with the Braves. The entire 8.4 is in the positive trade calculations for the Cardinals.
Unfortunately the better prospects seem to be the infielders where we are pretty solid. None of the pitchers excite me. Mostly typical Mo picks. Guys withoutsolid minor league numbers who he expects to perform better ine major leagues.
At best don’t see much help for 2024
4 all-stars. Unfortunately the only ones that came up through the system are playing for other teams.
We supposedly had a wealth of outfield prospects. The two we have remaining of the dream outfield of O’Niell, Bader and Carlson have a collective WAR of 0. The four that Mo has traded away have acollective WAR of 8.9. Two of them on the all-star teams.
Fired a manager who made the playoffs each year and was voted Manager of the Year because he objected the coaching staff Mo pushed on him. Then the coaches left afer the next season under mysterious circumstances.
Hired a manager who seems to be over his head and making knee-jerk decisions left and right. That is a topic for later.
Has an international program that is contributing nothing to the major league team and has no top 100 international prospects. Everyone wails about the big spending year but Garcia and Arozarena seem to be representing that class pretty well for other teams. Way to go Mo.In all fairness Mo landed Goldschmidt and Aranodo and brought Albert back for a final season. And made deadline trades that helped us make the playoffs. Most of his free agent purchases have been a disaster. He seems to thing an aging player coming off a bad year will suddenly reemerge.
But bottom line Mo will never build a strong team unless he changes his approach significantly.
I think Baker is a good trade prospect.
Bullpen by committee rarely works.
People criticised Shildt for the number of different lineups but Ollie has exceed him by far as to the different lineups.
My biggest criticism is the Cardinals knee jerk reactions. They have changed approach constantly. With talented young players you have to give them time. Gorman is one of the top RBI producers in the league and is still being platooned. Sure he strikes out a lot but he has contributed to a number of victories this year and seems to be really good late in the games.
Guys like he, Donovan, and Walker need to get steady action. They have the ability but need to have a chance to adjust and get things like timing right.
Same thing for the bullpen. Pick your main guys for the long relief, 7th and 8 innings guys and your closer and stick with it until it is obvious that it will not work. Helsley was an all-star closer last year but is not being used like a closer.
I think Nootbar is ok as a leadoff, but you have to have Donovan staying at second and move Goldy to third and drop Gorman to fifth and leave him there. Walker probably needs to be 6th or 7th. I’m ok with Edman 9th.
But pick a lineup and put them out there until it is clear that there is a need for change. And I don’t mean just after 3 or 4 games. Gorman is controlling the strike zone much better but swings through too many pitches. That is a timing issue and is not solved by being on the bench and pinch hitting.
Actually if you look at Flores tenure we rank even higher. Only if the international program could do as well. The Cardinals strategy of signing quantity over quality and signing older players have resulted minimal if any help at the major league level. And no one in MLB or BA top 100 prospects.
I feel that Ollie has made a lot of questionable decisions. He had an all-star closer who got off to a rough start and Ollie pulled the trigger on him quick. Somehow he keeps thinking Gallegos is his closer and he is not. Gallegos doesn’t have the lights out stuff that Helsley has and doesn’t have a closer mentality. Quick triggers on Gorman, Donovan, Thompson and Walker who could have adjusted his swing in St Louis rather than Memphis. And he keeps putting Burleson out there who barely hits over the Mendoza line. And I could go on and on about his bullpen decisions like the time he went with Stratton in a pressure situation in a 1-0 game when his two bullpen guys did not pitch the night before.
The kind of knee jerk decisions that he/and the front office are making creates uncertainty among the players. They are not statistics they are real people with real emotions whose performance is often affected when they feel that they may not be treated fairly.
They were still platooning Gorman when he was among the leader leader in almost all offensive categories. Sometimes you have to let players, particularly young players have some time to adjust. If I remember right, Mike Schmidt hit below .200 his rookie season.
The front office is certainly complicit in at least the International Program where we have no home grown international players on the except Mercado who is a retread and Mikolas if you want to count him. We also have no home grown international players in the MLB or Baseball America top 100 list.
Randy Flores is the lone bright spot in the front office as even with low draft picks his picks sport on of the top cumlative positive WAR of any organization.
I am a little dissapointed that the Cardinals have not used the absence of players to the world classic to give some of their top prospects more exposure. Instead we are getting a steady diet of Mo’s Misfits (Players who have never been good and players who may have been pretty good once but coming off a bad year.) And very unlikely to do better with the Cardinals.
What would be wrong with Graceffo or McGreevry stretching out with multiple innings in a game. But we are getting Packy Naughton and VerHagen on a regular basis.
I am not an advocate of the Cardinals going after the mega-stars. There is a reason the one of the players association wants to have free agency earlier. Many of the players have reached their prime when they are eligible, particularly a late bloomer like Carpenter and Fowler.
But I think the Cardinals do a very poor job of signing good free agents. I refer to most of their signings as “Mo’s Misfits. Most of them fail even at the AAA level. When I looked at the other contenders and the players they signed I see many missed opportunities. I wonder whether the reason for signing such poor quality is scouting or management philosophy. In all fairness they have picked up some helpful guys at the trading deaeline.
How often they have signed guys like Holland, Miller and Cecil who was coming off a bad year and was worse. Or the guys who were never that good and still perform poorly. The reason we perform poorly in the playoffs is that our constantly low draft position prevents us from getting the high upside players that are the players needed for playoff wins.
I don’t know if the problem is Mo or DeWitt or both. But DeWitt could solve the problem. Mo will continue to sit idly and rely on the farm system.
So making bad decisions cause you to stop trying. If you look at the bios of the MLB top 100 many of the international players who made the list were also top prospects. In fairness some diamonds in the rough made it too.
Bottom line the quantity vs quality and waiting until the players get older is not providing the level of talent that many of our competitors are getting. And it will get worse as scouting get even more tools to evaluate prospects. Our top guy is Herrera (MLB #8 in Cardinals top 10) and the Cardinals didn’t even take long to send him back out even with Yadi’s injuries and Knizner’s weak bat.
Back to quantity over quality. The Cardinal international system is badly in need of overhaul.
The results of the Cardinal approach is clear. They have no international prospects in their top 5 and none in the MLB Pipeline top 100. Meanwhile there are 9 international prospects in the top 17 on the MLB list. There are 25 international prospects in their top 100. The Cardinals have only 2 home grown international players on their 40 man roster.
The current international system is like a second draft. The Cardinals highest rated signee is ranked 36th best. That is like waiting until the middle of the second round of the draft to select someone.
The days of finding diamonds in the rough are fading away with all of the technical tools now available to scouting. You have to compete for the top talent and the system allows the freedom to spend what you need to do that without getting ovewhelmed by the rich teams.
There are four sources of talent available to major league teams. Draft, Trades, Free Agents and International. The Cardinals have 6 players on the MLB top 100. Five from the draft (Walker, Winn, Hence, Burleson and Graceffo). One (Liberatore) from trades. No free agents and international. That is like trying half as hard as your competitors.
Mo is sitting back with a lackluster international program, making crappy free agent decisions and counting on the draft to bail him out. You do have to give him a better grade in trades for landing Goldschmidt and Arenado but how much of that was due to the Cardinal tradition. But he also gave up the current Cy Young winner and another front line starting pitcher to get Marcel Ozuna.
It was good to get Contreras but it was like we turned out the lights and shut down for the offseason after that signing.
Good pickup. Cardinals needed him. He is a tough out when you need a hit. Has hurt the Cardinals numerous times in the past. Always hated to see him come up in close situations.
If he thinks message board stuff is harsh, wait until he experiences the New York press and fans.
Burleson #5
November 6, 2022 at 6:44 pm in reply to: Holliday New Bench Coach, Blake and Turner Promoted #206218If I were a manager I would want the hitting and pitching coaches to keep the players healthy and spend lots of time with the young players adjusting to major league competition and improving their techniques.
I never saw Albert or Maddux working with the young players much during the game. They were usually talking to the vets and the young players appeared to be gravitating to Waino, Albert and Yadi for game advice. And I am very alarmed at the high rate of injuries, particularly among the pitchers.
Also the meltdown of Carp and DeJong and the dropoff in performance in O’Neill and Carlson (although injury related).
At any rate I am ready to try something new. Obviously Ollie was too because I don’t buy the spin. An Mo wisely decided to go along with his manager this time.
They are all good. I think Hernandez had a little edge in range.
I have my likes and dislikes but I am always ready to give credit where credit is due.
November 6, 2022 at 2:10 pm in reply to: Are the Cards cursed when it comes to developing top prospects… #206193The Cardinals missed the boat during the years before the cap on the international players was established.
Picking late they had a lower cap from the draft. That should have left them sufficient money to compete for the top international talent available. Instead they went cheap until this year and even since the cap they have given up cap dollars in trades. Consequently, they have had virtually no top international prospects since Oscar Taveras, Alcantra (who was never top 100, I don’t think)and Martinez.
It may just appeared so but it seemed that the young players and pitchers went to talk to Wainwright, Yadi and Albert more for advice than to Maddux and Albert. Of course a lot goes on behind the scenes and the TV guys can create a false picture if you are looking at the overall scope of things.
-
AuthorPosts
