Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
It is how much of the problem is DeWitt?, Mo?, or all of the above.
Mo has a poor record in almost every phase of the game, free agents, trades, international. I have always questioned the major league level scouts.
The international program is a disaster. Luhnow had it turned around. I did a study in mid September. Current Latin sourced player who have played this season. Cardinals were 13th in number signed, 5th in career WAR of those signed (86.0) and 27th in career WAR currently in the organization (6.4). There is no longer an excuse. Everyone is working with a cap. The Cardinals have been going for quantity over quality and signing a lot of older prospects. Everyone wailed over the big spending year but that is one of the few recent years of success. The whole system has to be reworked.
Mo has had some spotty success with both free agent signings and trades but not nearly enough. Too many of what I term as “Mo’s Misfits”. Players who were once succesful, aging and coming off a bad year. Hope for rebound. Not very often. I often wonder how much room he gives his subordinates to operate.
I am not for keeping Ollie. His lineup decisions are a puzzle and very few can count on a consistent role. He is far too platoon oriented. For example he has on some occasions pinch hit for a hitter early in the game only to have the rejplacement having to face a same side pitcher in crunch time. He seems to like to give young player a chance but is also very impatient with them and some are sent to Memphis at the first sign of difficulty. He removes too many pitchers in the middle of an inning for platoon reasons only to have the replacement pitcher get torched. In a number of occasions resulting in the pitcher being pulled is stuck with a loss or even loses a win. Not good for the club house. A bad clubhouse usually results in uninspired play. With the sweetheart press coverage in St. Louis it is hard to measure the atmosphere in Ollie’s clubhouse. I also don’t like his use of green pitchers in late innings when we are a run or two behind.. It is like he has given up on the game.
Finallly he has no sense of roles. Players want to understand their role on the team and be able to count on it. Not in Ollie’s clubhouse.
My dilema is Flores. He has had some good drafts but has been spotty and I think his drafts after 2020 have not been productive.
The Cardinals have a history of finding diamonds in the rough but I fear those days are gone forever. There will be exceptions but fewer with current technology measuring so many things like spin rate on breaking pitches, movement on pitches, bat speed, etc. I don’t think in todays world the Cardinal would have picked up Kieth Hernandez in the 42nd round. If there was a 42nd round. The whole scouting system may need to be modernized.
September 28, 2024 at 12:06 am in reply to: StL 2024 Game #160 thread – Friday, Sept. 27 at Giants #268079Helsley with his 49th save. A Cardinal record I believe
September 22, 2024 at 10:11 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #156 thread – Sunday, Sept. 22 vs. Cleveland #267747I think Helsley’s 47 save ties him for the all time Cardinal record for saves.
September 19, 2024 at 9:10 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #153 thread – Thursday, Sept. 19 vs. Bucs #267563Welll lour boy genius struck again. With two out and a runner on first he pulls a 30 hold pitcher to match up with a right handed hitter. Then our right handed pitcher gives up a hit, then a game winning hit to two right handed hitters. So JoJo gets a loss out of his control. How do you think he feels about Ollie’s managerial genius tonight.
then in the bottom of the ninth everyone is swinging first pitch rather than working to get on base. Like let’s get this game over and get the hell out of here.
September 8, 2024 at 1:05 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #143 thread – Sunday, Sept. 8 vs. Mariners #266889Suprised not to see Pages in the lineup. Does Ollie not understand momentum.
I saw a segment on MLB.com a few days ago. The Cardinals were criticized for pushing Walker so hard to hit fewer ground balls. There may be a hint about some our hitting woes. As I understood it the conflict between Shildt and Jeff Albert is that Albert wanted the hitters to pull most everything and get more loft in their swings. Shildt disagreed and got fired. Previously the Budda Bedansky was let go for disagreeing with Albert.
Apparently the Cardinals want to be a home run team in a pitchers ball park.
We have a young player trying to hit low outside pitches in the air. He only set a Cardinal rookie record for hits in consective games to start his career which has now turned to ashes.
We have Aranado chasing a lot of pitches out of the zone and while he hits some of them he also misses a lot in crucial situations.
And I wonder if the statistics people are making up the lineup every day.
How is that for conspiracy theorys.September 1, 2024 at 6:16 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #137 thread – Sunday, Sept. 1 at Yankees #266289Good win and nice game by Walker.
Still perplexed by Ollie’s bullpen strategy. O’Brien has been scored upon in his first two appearances and Ollie puts him in with a lead and then it goes away. Then in the 8the with a 5 run lead he uses Kitteredge instead of saving him for the next game against the Brewers.
August 30, 2024 at 11:48 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #135 thread – Friday, August 30 at Yankees #266102Did Ollie just give up. Sent probably our worse pitcher out in the 9th trailing by only one run and sure enough he made it 3 down. that is just a dumb decision. There had to be someone else available.
August 27, 2024 at 9:52 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #132 thread – Tuesday, August 27 vs. Padres #265758Our boy genius manager really messed this one up. Pinch hit for Burleson with Pham who comes up in the 8th with the tying run on second and fans. Then Baker hitting 3rd fans. Why have Baker hitting 3rd. No other manager above little league would have Baker hitting 3rd. Anywhere but third. He didn’t even hit above .250 at Memphis. ou have your best hitter hitting third.
As a final stroke of genius, down one run in the 9th he brings in a player with 4+ major league innings and a career average of over 8 ERA and sure enough we go into the bottom of the 9th down 2 runs.
How can players get excited about playing for a manager who makes such dumb decisions. Meanwhile Shildt has the Padres up 18 games over .500 while we are 2 games under. How can the fans enjoy watching the clown show Mo and Ollie are putting on.
August 21, 2024 at 3:50 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #126 thread – Wednesday, August 21 vs. Brewers #265100Kind of premature but Shildt has the Padres 17 games over .500 and is on the Dodgers heels for the Division Championship along with the Diamondbacks. This after taking over a team that missed the playoffs last year and lost their best player to free agency. Similar to his seasons with the Cardinals he has had a strong second half. I call him Second Half Shildtie.
I first saw Shildt when he was managing the Johnson City Cardinals in the former Appalachian League. It was very apparent to me that his players were motivated and playing the game with confidence. I thought at the time that we have someone special here. It was clear that the players were enjoying playing the game. I also got to see Oscar Tavares in those games. He was sensational.
I don’t know the rules but I believe there is a minimum based on his current salary that they can tender and offer to Goldschmidt and it would be much more than he will get as a free agent. They have to tender him to get a draft choice if he doesn’t sign.
I agree that Burleson would be the replacement. As for platooning him, I think it is insane. He has become one of our best hitters and is still developing. How is he ever going to develop his hitting against lefties if he doesn’t play against them. Same with Gorman who would be the third base replacement if we can get someone to take on Aranado and get anything of quality for him.
But can Mo really get anyone of quality. I could be wrong but I believe that we have zero contribution for all the supposedly hot prospects we got at the 2023 deadline deals.
August 13, 2024 at 6:46 am in reply to: StL 2024 Game #119 thread – Monday, August 12 at Reds #264041With 16 of our 25 roster players over 30 how can we expect to get better next year.
August 12, 2024 at 8:38 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #119 thread – Monday, August 12 at Reds #264032Playing platoon baseball again. Benched three lefty hitters (burleson, Gorman and Nootbar). Same result as usual when benching more than one regular
July 30, 2024 at 1:17 am in reply to: StL 2024 Game #107 thread – Monday, July 29 vs. Rangers #262201Poor bullpen decisions by Ollie again. He has a mania for platooning and pulled Fernandez brought in King to face one batter. Waste, One inning instead of two by solid relief pitchers.
Then in the 7th brings in Roycroft who had a lot of early success but had been roughed up some lately. Young pitchers usually get hit hard when they come up or do well until they get rougherd up in a game. Then often they lose a bit of confidence and the edge that gave them the early success. No need to waste Fernandez and King that way. Then trailing by only one run could have had us in the 8th trailing by only one run and time to use our best bullpen members.
Ollie seems very reluctant to use our top relievers when trailing in close games. Quite a few losses when his bullpen choices allowed a one run deficit turn into larger margins. much easier to come back from a one or even a two run deficit than the 4 run margin they faced tonight.
July 24, 2024 at 8:27 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #103 thread – Wednesday, July 24 at Bucs #261517Didn’t get to watch game but why did Gibson not pitch. It was his turn.
July 20, 2024 at 3:28 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #98 thread – Fri, July 19 at Braves, PPD to Sat Game 1 #261003With a fresh bullopen our genious manager goes with a rookie and the game is tied and then in the bottom of the 10 goes with another rookie and we lose. he has been doing that all season and getting away with it but over time things even out.
Not downing the two young guys. They have performed well but how does it make sense to not use your proven bullpen guys with a late lead.
Also to me it is irritating that he removes so many pitchers in the middle of an inning. Gibson has a 2-0 lead and watches it vanish out of his control with a rookie pitcher replacing him. How do you think it makes him feel.
Iwonder if Ollie loves to go out on the field. Many managers make pitching changes at the beginning of an inning. But when you make a change with a runneror two on you are jeapardizing the removed pitchers era and record. They get salary increases and new contracts based on those records.
Just poor decisions.
Don’t understand what they are doing. Everyone picked after the first round was a reach with only 3 choices ranked in BA’s top 250. I understand the need to shift money but it appears the Cardinals have taken a flyer on every one but Westeholt.
Not good in this day and age when scouting is far more accurate.
Hope for Prageror Beam in the 3rd
Think it was the choice available to the Cardinals. Glad they didn’ take a flyer on a lower rated player.
does anyone know why Helsley was not availale
July 4, 2024 at 11:13 am in reply to: StL 2024 Game #87 thread – Wednesday, July 3 at Pirates #258875Ollie seems obsessed with platooning. Should have left Kitteredge in. So he gets burned with a switch hitter and a lefty swinger.
I agree that he is pulling starters too soon and making poor use of Libratore.And why is Gallegos in a close game anytime. He has been good but not this year. Also I suspect a mid inning change is a little disruptive.
I think Ollie is improving but he is over his head and only had that good first season because of Albert, Molina and Wainwright. The Cardinals should be able to attract a more experienced and accomplished manager.
I agree that it was a gray area whether to use Helsley and Brian reported that he was not available. Don’t know if that was Helsley’s decision or Ollies or even Mo’s.
If the Cardinal sell at the deadline I would go with Goldy for some prospects. We have guys who would play first base better than the positions they are playing now. Gorman and Burleson for sure and maybe even Donovan who seems to have really come along as an outfielder.
Kurtz is the last player I want to see the Cardinals draft.
June 19, 2024 at 4:14 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #75 thread – Wednesday, June 19 at Marlins #257025Ollie gets burned again using a rookie in late inning tight situations. He has been lucky but things even out.
June 18, 2024 at 11:09 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #74 thread – Tuesday, June 18 at Marlins #256947Ollie has been gambling with rookies late in tight games all year. This time it burned him. Is Winn injured or is Mo determined to prove that he made genius moves signing Crawford and Carpoenter.
Brian – 2016 to date. Flores years with the draft. I just did a spot check on the Guardians and their total WAR for that period is in the 80’s, so that is an organization that has prospered from the draft.
-
AuthorPosts
