Community 2024 Top 50 Prospect Voting

[blingboy]

I also think we were too hot on Saggese. If you set Winn aside as a ‘prospect’, I am not comfortable saying Saggese is the top prospect in the system. In hindsight, and as my thinking has evolved with all thinking and talking about prospects, I would probably put Scott in that position, ahead of Hence and Roby by a nose just due to the health risk factor with pitchers.

[cardsfan64]

Thanks jnevel, for getting us going and laying the groundwork for our top 50. I will indeed try to keep the 36 hour format to allow as many as possible to vote on their choices for top 50 prospects in the organization.

#27 – Quinn Matthews
#28 – Mike Antico
#29 – Moises Gomez

Glad to see the TCN top 50 post Matt Swanson today at #34. He looks like he could move up fast!

[mudville]

The thing about Saggese is that he has always hit, and hit, and hit. None of the other prospects in our top 10 have consistently put up the kind of hitting numbers that Saggese has.

[SoonerinNC]

#27 Mathews

I have not participated because I saw few minor league games but I think this guy is better than this.

[Nigel T]

27 Rincon
28 Antico
30 Mejia

[14NyquisT]

#27 – Mathews

#28 – Dunn

#29 – Cornwell

[stlcard25]

27. Antico
28. Inohan Paniagua
29. Jonathan Mejia

[cardsfan64]

SoonerinNC, are you voting for Matthews as your #27 pick, or just making a comment? Just trying to clarify…

[LACardFan]

27 – Levenson
28 – Matthews
29 – Antico

[CariocaCardinal]

27 Antico
28 Gomez
29 Panaiguana

[blingboy]

I have Mathews in my next group just outside of my top 30. But I admit I’m just throwing a dart until he takes the mound and we see what happens. I’ve got Trent Baker ahead of him.

[grenadier1]

27. Matthews
28. Antico
29. Gomez

[PugsleyAddams]

27 – Noah Bingham Mendlinger

28 – Alexander Edward “Corny” Cornwell

29 – Zachary “Spanky” Levenson

Muchos gracious, El Senor Cardsfan64!

[desmetlax12]

27 – Mathews
28 – Mejia
29 – Levenson

[cardsfan64]

Matthews-27/Antico-17/Levenson-12/Rincon-10/Cornwell-8/Mejia-7/Mendlinger-6/Gomez-5/Redemond-4/Paniagua-4/Baker-3/Dunn-2
Our #27 is Matthews, #28 is Antico, #29 is Levenson.
1. Winn
2. Saggese
3. Hence
4. Roby
5. Scott
6. Hjerpe
7. Graceffo
8. McGreevey
9. Davis
10. Bernal
11. Rajcic
12. Robberse
13. Cho
14. Kloffenstein
15. Crooks
16. Showalter
17. Hansen
18. Bedell
19. Mautz
20. Honeyman
21. Rom
22. Pages
23. Baez
24. Prieto
25. Granillo
26. Nunez
27. Matthews
28. Antico
29. Levenson

It seems we have differing views as we get into the middle of the prospect range. Lots of potential in our farm system, but don’t forget some of the “older” guys in AAA that haven’t quite made it. Some may never may never even get a cup of coffee, but then again, things could click this spring and they could take off! Gomez, Siani, Thomas, Svanson and Redmond are just a few that could show something this year!

[cardsfan64]

#30 – Moises Gomez
#31 – Inohan Paniagua
#32 – Hancel Rincon

[lrcardinal]

#30 Moises Gomez
#31 Jonathan Mejia
#32 Inohan Paniagua

[flood21]

30 Rincon
31 Pamiagua
32 Mejia

[Jnevel]

30. Mejia
31. Paniagua
32. Koperniak

[LouisEu]

#30 Redmond
#31 Mejia
#32 Dunn

[14NyquisT]

#30 – Dunn
#31 – Cornwell
#32 – Koperniak

[CariocaCardinal]

30 Panaigua
31 Gomez
32 Ryan Fernandez

[blingboy]

30. Trent Baker
31. Cornwell
32. Redmond

[PugsleyAddams]

30. Noah Bingham Mendlinger

31. Alexander Edward “Corny” Cornwell

32. Hancel Alexander “The Headhunter” Rincon

Muchos gracias, Senor Cardsfan64.

[blingboy]

64, a lot of people get excited about big numbers in rookie ball. A lot of the players won’t survive contact with advanced competition. But it’s good to hope.i agree that the ones still standing in the upper levels mostly don’t have that phenom shine anymore, so it takes some doing to attract interest. Its just different ways to evaluate.

[Author]

Posts