Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Agree with the basic concept of younger players getting the short end of the deal. Even though the Cardinals paid Albert well above the minimum in his pre-fre agency years I always thought his salary rediculously low. Possible reason for his defection to Los Angeles.
Several missing bits of information and unfortunately some like profit levels are not available.How much have team profits increased. Also how the current system favors the big market teams and how do you fix that.
Also no information on the effect of the system on the fans. How much has the cost of attending a game gone up in the same time period. Also how about having your favorite player gone to the big money teams. I don’t believe in the old system before free agency. Unfortunately, the owners exploited that system and the Cardinals Sam Breadon was one of the major exploiters.
Also what is the inflation of the minor league players salaries during the same period. How about a deal where minor league salaries are tied to revenue growth.
IMHO the losers in the current system are the fans, the young stars and the minor league players. Also the minor league owners. Television has made the owners and the high paid players with free agent contracts much richer. The minor leagues were much more robust when the fans had to go to their local ballpark to see baseball. Of course I among most would not want daily TV access to Cardinal games go away.
Unfortunately, the total picture is not available or unwanted. In this day and age people seem more inclined to base their opinions on only the information that supports their bias. Until that changes the hope of the best and fairest system is probably beyond our reach.
It is good to see the Cardinals change from their older lower priced International signings. Scouting has improved to the point that if a player is highly rated they have a chance to be good. If they can land a top Cuban it would be great.
The old system results in the Cardinals having none of the 20 plus international players in the MLB and BA top 100 prospects. Our top guy seems to be Herrera supposedly an offense first catcher who didn’t have a great offensive year in 2021.
We will not see serious negotiating until just before the deadline. Works that way in all labor negotiations.
I could be wrong but I have felt that the majority of the participants on this site generally are in favor of the players.
I think it interesting that many laud the players for using the economic system for getting a huge contract but on the other hand many hammer the same system when a brilliant CEO of a company that provides great products and many good paying jobs earns over a million dollars a year.
I am generally pro business but in this case I don’t have a favorite. Only the fans have anything to lose in these negotiations. Any significant increase in player cost will just be reflected in ticket, concessions and other game costs. Further, earlier free agency will benefit the big money teams a little more. Not good for the Cardinals but they don’t usually dabble much in huge contract negotiations.
I don’t think either side can afford an extended strike but somethimes these things really get out of hand.
If we don’t have a major league season I will enjoy lots of minor league games.
21 Walsh
22 Ralston
23 Love
24 Nunez
25 Torres16 Baker
17 Pacheco
18 Perez
19 Nunez
20 Hence11 Donovan
12 Pallante
13 Nunez
14 Perez
15 BakerMcGeevy for #10. Barring a trade Donovan is not going to crack the infield. He is not a shortstop and he is not going to get ahead of gorman. I do love his stats and progress through the system. So far Baez has been all talk.
Thompson @#8
One of the litmus tests for me is how much do they improve when moving to a higher level. Both Edman and Carlson had better numbers at AAA than at lower levels. It is a sign that they are making good adjustments and ditching bad habits.
A guy to watch is Luken Baker. He was destroying AA pitching before he hit the IL. A guy who alway had the power but was unable to translate it to live action. He may have found the formula and if so would be a great DH and backup to Goldy. May have been just a one time hot streak but seemed more to me.
If it is Marmol it could be really good.
He has been an exceptionally fast riser in the organization. That could mean 1) he is a good politician or 2) he has exceptional talent. If the former is the case we have more of Mo running everything. If not, maybe some important changes on how things are being run.
If the Cardinals are making this move to keep him in the orgainzation what will they do to keep him in the future. May even interfere with him less than many feel they interfered with Shildt. Maybe give him more authority in player transactions.
I have been a Shildt supporter and think he not only did a good job but a better job than many on this site felt he did. I hope for the best for him but baseball is full of traditionalist and I think it is hard for them to accept that someone who had not played professional baseball could be a good major league manager. Even hard for the press to accept.
I am normally not a conspiracy theorist but if you have a young talent who you believe will be a superior major league manager and other teams are already sniffing around what are you going to do? Use the conflict with Albert to make a change. I really don’t think they would dump Shildt just to keep Marmol. The sloppy handling of the announcement of the firing hints that mild mannered Mike decided it was time for them to treat him with respect and it got out of hand.
Having read Mike’s description of analytics I now suspect that Shildt had little choice going into the meeting. Management had already decided that Shildt had to buy into Albert’s approach or else. The explanation to the somewhat chaotic handling of the firing could be that they expected mild mannered Mike to accept.
Shild had converted the Cardinals to a strong defense and base running team. Many of the players would not fare well in a hit em high and pull approach.
In 2021 Alberts hitting philosophy resulted 76 games where the Cardinals scored 3 runs or less. 54 games with 2 runs or less. Winning 90 games with that kind of offense, most of your starting pitchers out a good portion of the season and an inexperienced bullpen seems to be a pretty good effort.
If Albert’s approach is the way to go in baseball Mr. Shildt may have a hard time landing another gig.
I would like to know what about analytics does Shildt object to so much. I would like to see specifics. Analytics is an awfully big topic.
You know Pugsley you may have something. Shildt certainly gave him a strong parting endorsement.
It is possible that the analytics thing is a smokescreen used to justify the firing. It doesn’t fit Shildt’s attitude and personality to be unwilling to try something that supposedly leads to success in other organizations. I also recall a story that said that the Cardinals were among the leaders in baseball in the use of defensive shifts. I think that requires some use of analytics.
I would be more inclined to think that the conflict would come from:
1) Shildt demanding that he not be restricted in player and playing time decisions.
2) Difference of opinion about the coaches. From what I could determine from the Cardinals story he only specifically pointed out Marmol. I think he had a real problem with Albert. While he was constantly conferring with Maddux and Marmol during games I didn’t see much interaction with Albert.
3) Hard to believe that the company man that Shildt has been that he would fight much about building from within. He may not agree but he has done pretty well with that approach and I don’t see him making a red line issue about that.
Shildt in his farewell statement showed his usual class. He said what most decent people would say and took the high road.
Did he get a chance to inform his players before that announcement. If not, that was pretty tacky of DeWitt and Mo.
You are not going to get someone who is able to get a regular spot to play off the bench with spot starts. And I don’t want to get anyone in front of our three young outfielders all of whom showed signs of breaking out to something special.
Seager or Correa would be my targets, and yes bid with the big guys. We have enough payroll coming off the books.
Pitching is harder for me.
Could have been over the control of coaches. I think the ownership said they want all of the coaches to stay. Maybe Shildt didn’t want that and felt he could push the matter.
Shildt had a better record after he was hired than Francona who many lust after.
The Cardinals had a dramatic improvement after he was hired in defense, and base running.
I find it hard to believe that the team suddenly grabbed the Albert approach after 3 years of frustrating offense. Those players are apparently very stubborn. All I have seen in Albert’s tenure is taking fat first strike pitches, lunging and overswining at marginal pitches with two strikes, and countless swings at WOZ’s (Way out of Zone), often on 3-2 counts.
How can we believe that we have the capacity to win with what we have in the system. Terrible minor league year with a few hitting prospects thriving but abysmal pitching.
Latin program unproductive. Recent top 100 prospects by Baseball America and MLB Pipeline had 26 and 22 Latin players in their top 100 lists. No Cardinals in either group. So where is the internal help going to come from. A few hitters but little else.
I liked Shildt. Found that I disagreed with some of his moves but he was right a lot more than I was. Fans always second guess managers and have a very good record after the fact. If he had used Hudson or Flaherty rather than Reyes and they had given up the dinger Shildt would still have recieved the grief. If you don’t believe that then you don’t remember the grief Matheny got for going with Wacha in the exact same situation. I probably would have gone with Hudson because of his ground ball rate but he and Flaherty were clearly were not quite up to form both in velocity and command because of their limited use.
I am looking forward to the next manager not because I am happy Shildt is gone but as long as management insists on an unproductive International program, fat contracts for players past their prime, a questionable hitting coach and apparent pressure and second guessing from the top, I don’t have a lot of hope for more success. But I am always for whoever the Cardinals put on the field.
I remember the outrage over the use of Wacha who like Hudson and Flaherty had minimal recent action. If Flaherty had came in and gave up the dinger Shildt would have still been just as stupid in the minds of those who were steamed because we didn’t hire someone like Terry Francona (who by the way has won fewer games than Shildt since the day Mike was hired).
I think the Cardinals came together because 1) The additions of the vet pitchers filled the gap probably beyond what most expected and 2) The young outfielders and Edman matured and suddenly the Cardinals had a lineup that could hurt you at any time or any place in the lineup. Probably that also relieved some of the pressure from Arenado and Goldschmidt so they didn’t have to carry the whole offense.
September 25, 2021 at 7:41 am in reply to: 2021 Cardinals MLB Game 154 thread – Friday, September 24 at Cubs (DH G2) #173454Think the Cardinals erred by not sending Flaherty to Memphis. Batting facing a couple of teammates is not the same as facing hitters in competition.
Thought both Flaherty and Hudson looked a little short on their normal fastballs. Hopefully they will get a couple of outings before the end of the season.
Did the article say specifically that the Cardinals had Wong do that he quit doing? I am concerned about all of the pitcher injuries and that goes back all the way to Matheny. I am more concerned about the inconsistent offense. I would say change hitting first.
Don’t know who is to blame for the young relievers (Cabrera, Gallegos and Reyes) hitting the wall. I count 7 games lost by relievers since August 1 where we were tied or in the lead going into the late innings.
So far Shildt has a track record of a strong second half. Going to be very strong this season as far as we are out of the wild card.
I don’t think I have a problem with Maddux unless his program is leading to the excessive injuries. The control problem with the young pitchers is inconsistency in repeating deliveries and trying to do too much and overthrowing, which is a problem the world over with young pitchers.
I find it hard to be critical of Shildt’s game management when prior to the meltdown against the Cubs he had not lost a game this season that we entered the 9th with a lead.
Part of our young relievers problems could stem from the poor offensive support which causes a lot of stress situations.
I think the #1 problem is Albert. The Cardinals have scored 2 runs or less in 35 of their first 97 games and 3 runs or less in 50 of 97 games. They rank 26th of 30 teams in Runs scored, on base percentage and OPS. They are 22ng in home runs, 24th in walks and slugging. They are not among the top 15 teams in 10 of 12 offensive stats.
The next question is why do players go to other teams and perform better. The numbers Kelly has at Arizona would rank him 4th in batting average, 1st in on base percentage, 3rd in slugging and 2nd in OPS. Wong would rank 1st in batting average, 1st in on base pct, 3rd in slugging and 2nd in OPS. I know, different ballparks but there has been a consistent trend of position players who didn’t get a shot and went to other teams and accomplished a lot more. Has not happened with the pitchers.
In 2018 the newly hired Albert got in a conflict with assistant Mark “the Buddha” Budasky resulting to the Cardinals letting Buddha go. The official line was Albert’s approach would take some time to take effect.
As the guy said in the movie Caddy Shack—WELL, WE ARE WAITING. It has been 4 years of poor inconsistent offense with Albert.
Seems to me that other teams do not fear our hitters. We are constantly behind 0-2, particularly the young players and Carpenter. We do not do a good job of fouling off marginal pitches with two strikes on the hitter. We seem to swing from the heels on two strikes, again especially the young guys.
I’m more impressed with Perez improvement than Plummer but I watch a lot of Springfield baseball on the net and Plummer usually looks pretty good. Also Nunez got off to a terrible start at Palm Beach but has had some good outings in the last 2 months. Some guys, like Toerner don’t appear to ever be major league talent so they are just filler for a prospect list.
Gorman 3 HR’s tonight. Should get an all-star break callup to Memphis unless they keep him at Springfield to work on other defensive positions.
-
AuthorPosts
