Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
In my estimation, the approach should center more on conventional concepts such as the eye test applied in real time and devoting attention to what’s happening at that very moment on the field of play.
Nah, cause then you might get some manager in a playoff game saying something like “Quintana is still looking so great today I’m not taking him out yet.” Thinking like that screws up the lockdown bullpen’s rhythm and ability to close out the win.
I’m reasonably certain I’ll get a look at him in some ST games.
Ah, we’re already talking about games? Get your MLB.tv contracts finalized early.
Am I missing something
Brewers should be pleased, but I’m not sure what to make of this trade either. An explicitly included PTBNL is one thing, but here it’s almost like there’s a later deal they’ll make to compensate for this one, but that would be against the MLB rules/ethics, right?
For the last couple of years Rodon is the guy I’d love for the Cards to snag. There are risks with everybody, but I believe Rodon is on an elite trajectory. His combination of stuff is filthy and toxic to hitters. He is the ace-type pitcher the early-round-bow-out Cardinals need. But no worries if you’re scared by the risk — rest assured Mo believes the Cards are just fine with a stable Dakota Hudsons.
Woodford probably feels like George Jetson felt when Cosmo Spacely flicked his cigar ashes on top of George’s head.
At this point, it’s clearly more than isolated/periodic lapses in judgement. The man has a serious problem. It’s never too late to overcome, but at some point the resolve has to come from within. We all deal with something. I wish him the best.
I am thankful this day is almost over, haha, had to spend most of it driving. Fed and relaxed now, though. Hope you all have much to be thankful for.
The Mo speak was obvious from the beginning. Maddux wanted to scale back or change gears….or whatever was said. Yeah, that’s the ticket.
VerHagen is just another in the too-long list of examples of Mo being bad at signing relievers to contracts. I fear for Gallegos’ performance going forward.
Actually it would be best to let VerHagen go now. That way the Cards won’t see the mirage of something valuable in him during ST that you know they will — value that nobody else would see — just because already spent cash happened. Yes, the money is spent and is just another Mo sunk cost blunder waiting to happen by adding on to an already bad decision. These are the things that contribute to keeping the Cards out of the money in October.
Last season the Cardinals only managed to draw 3.3 MM fans, but that’s just the beginning of the tragic story.
Haha. Yep, the boys in the ivory tower never lie about anything. And don’t believe the little boy who said they aren’t wearing any clothes.
I thought the Phils were probably done when Marsh struck out with one out late in Game 5 and didn’t bring in the tying run from 3B. Game 5 had that must win feel to it for the Phils.
I though Mo said Maddux was looking to scale back. So who’s fibbing here: Maddux, Mo or Grant? Or maybe Maddux just had a quick change of heart.
Marsh strikes out with runners on 1st and 3rd, one out, in the bottom of the 8th, down 3-2, swinging from his heels. Put the freaking ball in play. If there was ever a time to shorten up and focus on contact, that was it. It’s just not in the arsenal of so many guys. Probably means a loss.
I felt like Matz was about to bust out and turn into a great acquisition. Then he got injured on the goofiest looking play you’ll ever see on fielding a simple ground ball.
Figuring out how Matz fits in compared to Hudson is like rearranging the deck chairs in the wake of an iceberg encounter. Getting a top tier starter is the best answer. That’s like getting five new pitchers, i.e., 1 though 5 all get better in one fell swoop.
This guy’s been touched up for 4 HR’s and he’s still got the baseball.
Taters can be hypnotizing
LOL, obviously Dusty’s only objective tonight was not to burn any bullpen arms. Mission accomplished as well as it possibly could be.
I didn’t want the Cards to allocate that many $$$,$$$,$$$ to Harper either. Not because he wouldn’t be a huge asset, but limited resources and all. Seems like any of these mega contract guys have too much downside with respect to potential negative return on investment. But just like the thread on developing prospects into big stars, there is so much randomness and risk involved.
So, teams like the Cards who seem to be fairly judicious in spending, at least as we laymen can understand spending mega-millions, can do fairly well with development and acquisitions. However, it seems like teams need to hit the lottery to get the mega impact guys like Pujols or Harper with high WAR / MVP resumes and actually lead their teams to a World Series championship.
Speaking of lottery, Powerball is over a billion now? It’s also a bad return on investment based on expected value, but some idiot/smart person is going to win it, haha!
Do they release the SDI after the awards?
Yes, they did last year. Link below.
Also I read the SDI data is on the ballots for the voters. SDI is weighted at 25%, but it probably has a real impact that is larger than 25%. Reasoning is having the data on the ballot might influence some voters who don’t really have a strong basis or lean for casting their vote otherwise.
A lower volume doesn’t necessarily mean the guy with the better rate is better at the position.
Right, it doesn’t necessarily meant the guy with the better rate is better at the position. There’s really no way to ever say that, especially if you don’t go by the data. What it does mean though, is that per the data, the guy with better rate played the position better in his allotted innings than the guy with the higher volume did in his allotted innings. I would expect the person with the lower volume also has to overcome a built in disadvantage of not being able to focus day to day on the unique challenges of a position like shortstop.
November 1, 2022 at 11:52 am in reply to: Are the Cards cursed when it comes to developing top prospects… #205824Nolan Gorman is a prime example. He had nothing left to really prove at Triple A this season, but he also wasn’t hitting well enough to play on a team that was trying to win the division. So, he ends up either on the bench in St. Louis or toiling away in Memphis. Ultimately, nothing productive can really be done with him and his development kind of stalls. You look at guys like Goldschmidt and Arenado, they both played on some bad teams and had nothing but time and opportunity to work through their issues as young players.
Quite the dichotomy here and an interesting observation. Wonder how much cause and effect is really at play here?
You can’t compare Edman and Swanson at SS on a counting basis. You have to eval them on a pro rata basis. Swanson paled in comparison to Edman.
October 31, 2022 at 11:34 pm in reply to: Are the Cards cursed when it comes to developing top prospects… #205788I’d be curious to know how many draft choices out of a thousand even make an appearance at the Big League level?
1td, it’s close to 2/3 for 1st round picks. However, that includes guys like Nick Plummer, Tyrell Jenkins and Rob Kaminsky, guys who barely scratched. 2nd round picks go down to slightly below 50%. When you get down to the double digit rounds, it’s about 1 in 10 and continues to go lower as you get deeper in the draft.
October 31, 2022 at 11:14 pm in reply to: Are the Cards cursed when it comes to developing top prospects… #205787There’s no such thing as a “can’t miss” prospect. Prospects don’t excite me until I see them perform at MLB level — Peter Principle and all. Too many variables.
I became a skeptic of prospect hyping way back in the 70s, just a few years after I started following the Cards, when the ballyhooed David Clyde was drafted overall #1 by the Rangers. I was amazed at all the press coverage on Clyde and thought this guy must be tremendous. He was the “next Koufax”, “phenom”, “sensation”, etc. Many scouts said he was “the best pitching prospect I’ve ever seen.” His #1 status was as consensus as it gets. When he signed with the Rangers, Clyde said his goal was to be the best pitcher ever. He pitched his last high school game in 1973, then 20 days later started his first major league game. By 1976, the Rangers gave up on him and left him unprotected in the expansion draft. Nobody drafted him. Clyde is not an anomaly. Most don’t make it.
The one constant enjoyment I had watching the Cards this year was the infield defense. The offense was inconsistent with too many dead spots in the lineup, but the defense never seemed to falter. Didn’t see Walker much, but if he’s better than Goldy I’m sure the D-back fans really like watching him too.
I read the brain needs 17 repetitions of a new word to put it permanently in your vocabulary. Valdez was learning the word “stymied” tonight. He stymied the Phils again and again this game — a total 19 outs or repetitions. He’s got it.
-
AuthorPosts
