Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
No doubt the error should be given to Sosa. Just like when a pitcher bounces one that the catcher should block, but doesn’t. It’s always a wild pitch. I’ve just been surprised how bad Hoskins is in the field. He’s botched some easy ones, and he sure ain’t making anything that’s not routine. They don’t play him for his glove, though. There might be some DHing in his future.
Wheeler got roughed up in the 1st. Score is 3-0. Defense gave up the 3rd run. The run scored on Sosa’s throwing error, but he’s been used to Goldy picking that one like it’s routine. Although he didn’t get the error, Hoskins needs to pick that one if you’re a Phillies fan. Hoskins has shown he’s just plain bad with the glove numerous times now this postseason. Good thing he’s hit a few big HRs. I guess he was even worse in the outfield when he first came up.
Yep, the Castellanos catch was a game saver. Pretty clutch for a guy who’s not very good in the field. He got a very good jump on the fly, unlike when Marsh got a horrible jump on the earlier hit by Altuve, who would’ve scored the walk off run.
Yea 1td, that started to look like disaster for the Phils with all those Robertson misguided tosses. I thought he was going to pull a Helsley.
You don’t often see the ump not grant a HBP when the pitch hits the batter. It looked like a good call though. Diaz definitely leaned into it and Dusty didn’t protest that I noticed.
Former Cardinal factor in full effect. Edmundo Sosa throws out Aledmys Diaz to end the game 6-5.
Former Cardinal factor in play. Diaz pinch hitting with 2 outs, bottom of the 10th, runners on 1st and 2nd, score 6-5
Robertson going for the save in the 10th after Realmuto’s HR in the top of the inning. Got a big K to get Alvarez leading off and then Bregman doubles off the short wall in LF. I can hear the Phillies’ fans, “It’s never easy.”
Still 5-5 going to the 8th. Good game. Not stressful, lol.
Adam will probably be one of the top 2 or 3 Cards’ starters again next year. Speaks well of him, but probably says more about the oveall reliability of the rotation. Not a lot of swing and miss there. Unfortunately, the last few seasons the guys who have been touted as swing and miss end up being more like sling and miss.
bling, seems a little different to me too.
EuroDandy…Point well taken, but when Mookie hit that soft GB to the right side, the most important defensive position on the entire field of play became 1B…
I’m a tall southpaw, so I pitched and played 1B. If you ever watched me play, you know 1B is an extremely difficult position.
Tell me Google didn’t watch the last 3 innings of the 68 World Series without telling me Google didn’t watch it. 😉
I hate it when things remind be of that. Denkinger too.
Not sure if it’s been mentioned in this thread, but Pena’s dad is Geronimo Pena, a Cardinal for several years.
Maybe Goldy, Arenado, & Judge can go hang out with Harper, Hoskins, & Schwarber this winter after the World Series.
Yankees down to their final 3 outs.
Daughter and 7-month-old granddaughter came today for a several-day visit. I guess I don’t really need baseball for a few days. Daughter doesn’t let the grandbaby see a lighted monitor. I guess the current pediatric thinking is that babies should not look at screens for many months. Wife sat down in the family room to rock the baby to sleep for the night and asked me to mute the TV. That didn’t work as grandbaby kept turning her head 180 degrees to watch the game. I think she likes baseball.
It does seem like the Yanks keep shooting themselves in the foot. I want the Yankees to win tonight, not because I want the Yankees to win, but because I’d like to see another ALCS game.
When the Yanks come back from down 3 games, Bader will be a lock for postseason MVP.
The mental aspect is tremendously important. Organizations assess it in candidates before the draft. Once they are signed, there are baseball ops people whose job is mental skills building. Organizations do pay attention with much more focus than just the eye test.
But those not with a team regularly have no way to accurately know.
You know they have to do this, otherwise they’d be fools with the investments they are making. More of what I was talking about are the 20-80 scouting evals we fans often see on prospects — the kind forsch listed earlier on Winn-Edman. They usually focus on the 5 tools for position players, and other physical skills for pitchers/catchers. You don’t see that type of explicit scoring as readily available on the “mental skills.”
Following scouting to assess future performance and ceilings for baseball prospects is almost a fool’s errand for fans if you’re expecting high accuracy. It’s fitting though because baseball is a sport of failure, e.g., hitters who fail 70% of the time make it to the Hall of Fame. So why should scouting be any easier? But it’s fun for fans to track players as they develop, but a grain of salt usually comes in handy. Some of the assertions people make about prospects seem funny to me. Obviously, organizations have to try to do all of this very well.
Prospects tend to rise up the minor league levels until they reach their level of respective incompetence. They are promoted to each level based on their success at the previous level — until they reach the level at which they no longer perform. This is most likely because their skills at one level did not necessarily translate to the higher level. That’s the part that’s so hard to see — until it’s been tried!
I paraphrased the last paragraph from Dr Laurence Peters’ book. The Peter Principle is alive and well in baseball as much as it is in the world of business management.
I also liked bccran’s point about the mental aspect. It’s often overlooked compared to the physical measurements. Too hard to measure I guess. But mental intelligence goes a long way toward a player’s growth. Maybe even more importantly, the ability to perform in high pressure situations is not random. Some people excel, other crumble. That’s hard to measure too.
George Scott, 60s and 70s 1B with Red Sox. He said he loved his taters (sweet potatoes). And he loved his homeruns just like his taters. It took off from there.
This one is for you 1td. I saw a sign in the stands after J.T. hit his homerun. It said:
J.T.
Jackin’ TatersTrivia ?. Why did the homerun get labeled as a tater and who did it? I didn’t know, but read it this morning.
Yep gscott, din-din is not very polarizing. That’s the obvious difference. FWIW, bikemike sometimes chimes in, so he thinks they are okay. I usually don’t, but sometimes do chime in and think it’s fine. Plus, they are in game threads, which are here today and gone tomorrow. It adds to the social element and interest of it for many. A group of people “watching” a game is a social event. It’s not like there are din-din discussions cluttering threads like “Questions for 2023” or “AFL.”
As Tim McCarver would say, “This is the big leagues!” You don’t build a major league OF defense on hope and a prayer.
Why stop now? They’ve been doing it for years, e.g. Matt Carpenter, Matt Adams, Yairo Munoz, Jose Martinez, Wong, Edman, Yepez, etc. I even think Gyorko got a taste in the OF.
This begs the question, why didn’t he do it before being released?
As Carp himself said, he needed “new eyes on me” and consultation with people outside the organization to get it fixed. He worked with Votto, Holliday and a couple of hitting instructors who he thought could help him rebuild his swing.
An ugly postseason for Matt Carpenter. He has 10 plate appearances with 1 flyout and 9 strikeouts. I’ve seen a couple swings where I thought his head might spin off his neck. Also, Judge hearing the boos.
-
AuthorPosts
