Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
IMO, Gorman should be DH most of the time. He’s getting better and better at hitting the ball. His throws are embarrassing and his range is inadequate for 3B. As long as my opinion really is just an opinion, I’ll say that Gorman is playing 3B so they can showcase him as trade bait for the coming offseason. I get your logic and it makes sense. But after watching Rolen and Arenado play third base, I have a hard time thinking of Gorman playing there regularly. I will acknowledge that Gorman could be out of synch because he played mostly 3B in college and the minors, and he was taken away from his natural position when Arenado came to town. But I didn’t think his defense at 2B was anything to rave about either. If we take Gorman out of the running for 3B, I don’t know who could handle it other than probably Donovan, so far. Maybe Jesus Baez could, one day. But that’s to be determined.
Right now he’s neither. He’s made quite a few throwing errors but even worse – he appears to have very limited range – he simply doesn’t get to balls that, while not errors, are extra hits for the opposition.
I’m rooting for him, too. But, truth be told, his range at 2B wasn’t that good, either…. and then there are those atrocious throwing errors. He’s still young and he’s been improving as a hitter. He’ll make his millions as somebody’s DH, IMHO.
I’m thinking that Wetherholt is our second baseman going forward. I still like Donovan at third base although you’d like to see more power out of a corner infielder. Saggese is my second pick for third base. I’m not convinced that he has the defense for 3B. But he has not at all reached his ceiling as a hitter, IMO.
Well now, it’s time to find out what he can do at the major league level. He certainly deserves this call up based on his numbers alone. I’m looking forward to seeing how his arm plays.Those were some impressive accolades regarding his arm from the pundits at BA. Now if they can only find a way to give Koperniak the chance he deserves.
I greatly prefer optimism and hope over pessimism and negativity, also. My optimism and hope turns out to be misguided at times (and I don’t want to call out the players that come to mind). But I still prefer anticipating success to expecting failure. And I’m not saying I’m Pollyanna about everything. It’s just that I reject the constant cynicism. It all boils down to a conscious choice.
August 15, 2025 at 9:07 pm in reply to: St. Louis 2025 Game #123 thread – Friday, August 15 vs. New York Yankees #290611Helsley and Maton both having terrible outings again tonight! Rangers and Mets didn’t get much it seems!
So far it doesn’t look like the Cardinals got much either, unless you want to count Jesus Baez for the time being. Hopefully, 2026 tells a different story about the trades the Cardinals made at this years trade deadline.
I noticed that Josh Baez was in centerfield for Springfield last night.
August 15, 2025 at 5:53 pm in reply to: St. Louis 2025 Game #123 thread – Friday, August 15 vs. New York Yankees #290593One of the things that I thoroughly dislike about the Cubs is their owner, Tom Ricketts. All he does is bellyache about the money he’s been spending. Too bad, Tommy boy, and the rest of your clan. Tom Ricketts is responsible for depriving the Cardinals of their small market compensation pick by changing the rules just to hurt the Cardinals. What a cheap shot! Granted. The Cubs won the World Series n 2016, but I doubt if they’ll win another one for the next 108 years.
I really enjoyed the in depth discussion of Matthews. After he blew through the system in 2024, I thought we were onto something big. Now I’m in wait and see mode, and feel okay about it. Still looking forward to how it all pans out for Matthews.
Kyle talks with an in depth, and fully researched, appraisal of players and pitchers. Love his enthusiasm. Brian is always right there, fully informed, as you might expect. Thanks for a very entertaining show.
I wasn’t sure where to post this….. But I just noticed that the Cardinals have 3 18 year olds, 1 20 year old, and 2 21 year olds listed in their Top 10. Of the remaining players listed in the Cardinals Top 30 all are grown ups, except for Deniel Ortiz, 20 years old and ranked at No.24 and Kenly Hunter, 17 years old and ranked at No.30. And then there’s Tanner Franklin and Jake Gurevitch. Both are 21 years old and no doubt have a drivers license to prove it. They both just turned 21 a few weeks ago and should be mentioned, also, IMO.
August 12, 2025 at 3:28 pm in reply to: St. Louis 2025 Game #121 thread – Tuesday, August 12 vs. Colorado Rockies #290360He’s got to be tired after the ramp up in innings this year.
I sure hope that’s all it is. And I hope some of McGreevy’s levelheadedness rubs off on Liberatore and Pallante. Both are talented, but neither can get his head screwed on tight.
i don’t know who’s going to replace him in the bullpen. But lately it’s been looking like Leahy is a lock for the rotation next year.
I agree that there’s zero chance of the Cardinals signing Dylan Cease or Framber Valdez. Cease’s numbers aren’t even that good and Valdez is 31 years old old, turning 32 in November, and the pundits are saying that the benchmark his agents will probably be using is the 14.5M$-31.5M$ (203.5M$) that Max Fried will be getting over the last seven years of his contract which encompasses his age 32-38 years old seasons. No sense in even giving those two pitchers a second thought about signing with the Cardinals. That’s not to say that one of the moronic owners won’t do it, though.
My guess is still that they bring Mikolas back for 10-12M$ for a year while Hjerpe, Roby, Matthews round into shape and Mautz, Henderson, maybe Hence emerge.
August 10, 2025 at 9:47 pm in reply to: St. Louis 2025 Game #119 thread – Sunday, August 10 vs. Chicago Cubs #290222Thoroughly enjoyable game to watch. It’s amazing what a difference it makes when a player like Gray is really feeling it.
August 10, 2025 at 8:25 pm in reply to: St. Louis 2025 Game #119 thread – Sunday, August 10 vs. Chicago Cubs #290182Gorman has got to go this offseason. His glove wasn’t that reliable at 2B either. His bat ought to bring a high ceiling pitcher if he grts traded. Donovan or Saggese can handle 3B.
August 10, 2025 at 7:57 pm in reply to: St. Louis 2025 Game #119 thread – Sunday, August 10 vs. Chicago Cubs #290176Saggese has a quick bat. It will be fun watching him mature..
Every time I see this new guy’s name I think of the Genesis song.
Too bad about Phil Collins. I remember hearing back in the day that his song ‘Something in the Air Tonight’ was the most requested and played song in St. Louis when it was first released. It was a Phil Collins song. No Genesis yet at that time.
Raniel Rodriguez is only a few months past being 17 years old and he’s OPSing almost .800 at Palm Springs. This is pure speculation, but it wouldn’t surprise me at all if he eventually starts getting some playing time in one of the outfield corners.
I’m hoping WDWJr hangs around for another 10 or 20 years.
bb and Jnevel, thanks for posting your take on what’s going on with Matthews. I’m still going to go on hoping that he gets his arm strength up so that he can be a 1 or 2 in the rotation. Wainwright’s curveball, when it was really on, was almost like an eephus pitch, IMO. I don’t know how he did it.
I’m going to love seeing Molina in the dugout. But I still want to see Oli stay on as manager.
What ever happened to the days of investigative reporting? Matthews pitched a gem last night, it was like he was pitching in 2024 again when he bolted through the system. But no explanation was ever given as to why his velocity dropped in 2025 followed by a drop in success. Is his velocity back up to 2024 standards? Were his coaches insisting that his velocity be lowered in 2025 so that he ocould concentrate on his breaking stuff? Was last nights performance a fluke, an outlier? I feel like I’m being left in the dark. And not a peep about Alec Willis. This kid looks like a stud. But there hasn’t been a word said about him that I can recall since ST. I’m going to guess that development staff is absolutely forbidden to talk to reporters. What else could it be? I know I’m sounding harsh. But Matthews pitched like a top of rotation guy last night. What’s going on?
Whitey was a fine manager. I think he won because of his ability to recognize real talent when he saw it, and get the most out of it when he had it. That’s a rare talent, IMO.
Craig Counsel is the highest paid manager in the game, and he has a 210M$ payroll to work with. And he’s 4 games out of first place.
I’m not criticizing Gary LaRoque, former Cardinals field director. But I can’t help but wonder if he didn’t stay around a few years too long.
I seem to be in the minority, definitely one of the least vocal about Marmol. But I like the way he manages. He’s more inclined to give the younger players a chance to show what they can do. I didn’t like LaRussa. Without Chris Carpenter, Dave Duncan, Molina, Pujols, Wainwright, McGwire and a whole lot of other really good players, he wouldn’t have won more than any other manager, IMO.
August 6, 2025 at 5:27 pm in reply to: St. Louis 2025 Game #116 thread – Wednesday, August 6 at Los Angeles Dodgers #289849Walker drives in two with a base hit instead of striking out trying to hit a home run. The homers will come in time.
August 6, 2025 at 5:02 pm in reply to: St. Louis 2025 Game #116 thread – Wednesday, August 6 at Los Angeles Dodgers #289848The Cardinals had so many chanced to bring that 3rd run home. But no success.
The high point of this game has bee Leahy’s pitching.
August 6, 2025 at 4:59 pm in reply to: St. Louis 2025 Game #116 thread – Wednesday, August 6 at Los Angeles Dodgers #289846Smart move by Oli. Bunting Pages over to 2B makes more sense than waiting for VS II to move him over.
August 6, 2025 at 4:54 pm in reply to: St. Louis 2025 Game #116 thread – Wednesday, August 6 at Los Angeles Dodgers #289843This turning out to be a gift game to the Dodgers. The Padres should be mad at us, so far.
Liberatore holds onto his composure and the Dodgers are forced to live with a 1 run lead.
-
AuthorPosts
