Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Marmol is sitting in his office talking to himself right about now…
Willie McGee is probably trying to cheer him up.
So, did they quit for different reasons or for the same reason?
Social media comments really seems like a smoke screen to me – Generally speaking, the Cardinal fan base is pretty tame.
(1) Will they reappear on Schumacher’s staff?
(2) Is this is any way related to Schildt’s firing?
(3) Is it related to Marmol and his personality?
The mass exodus is too much to be a coincidence, I think there are one or more underlying reasons.
If Arenado opts out coupled with Goldchmidt’s season ending swoon something is rotten in Denmark….
It looks to be a crazy off-season (by Cardinal standards).
Catcher, starting pitcher, outfielder with some punch is my guess. I think they work with what they already have at 1b, 2b, ss, & 3b.
Same here Bling. If it gets to a game 7 I will probably watch that.
Even though the Cardinals benefited in 2011, I just don’t like the expanded tournament where – as was stated earlier in the thread – 2 front line starters, 2 good relievers, and a couple of bats getting hot can undo a 162 season.
I want to see each league go to 4 divisions with only championns advancing. Does that format completely solve the problem? No, but at least the regular season has a real purpose and it would tend towards rewarding the deeper teams who are built for the 162 game marathon not a 3, 5, or 7 game sprint….
Is there any way both teams can lose??
DeJong needs to call Carpenter and find out exactly what he did to fix himself at the plate and go do it.
If he’s going to be taking up a roster spot then may as well try it. Carpenter did it on his own after being released by the Cards…
Montgomery pitched extremely well for the Cards after coming over.
If Bader performs in the long run for NY about like he did for the Cardinals that’s an easy win for StL.
Cards have outfield options and a good starting pitcher is more valuable in my opinion.
It will all depend on the club’s internal evaluation of the assets they control up and down the system including when they project the minor league talent to arrive in StL.
I think the common consensus is that they need to go get a starting catcher, a front line starting pitcher, and a left handed power bat in the outfield?
Are the Cardinals unique in MLB with their management / manager approach?
Why worry about a deep pitching staff? Just relax, grab a wc spot and pay 2 really good starting pitchers, setup, closer to do the job in short 3/5 game series….
Cards had game 1 bagged. You never know but if they close that game out I think they win the series…
I think I read that August 26th was when the worm turned for Goldschmidt.
Reminds me of Carpenter’s 2018 – 36 HRs and plenty of salsa but a late season swoon and he stank up the joint for 3 years after that.
I hope that scenario is not in store for Goldschmidt…
I sure do like to see high OBP for the 1 and 2 spots.
.350 or higher if I can get it…
Yes 1TD, Albert 5th might have helped. Line up construction matters.
Having very slow baserunners also takes a ton of pressure off the defense and leads to burning the bench to pinch run.
The Cardinals will look a lot different next season and if they (a) get a good starting catcher, (b) get a front line starting pitcher, and (c) get an outfielder that contributes to the offense then they will likely be better – maybe a lot better.
Carlson and Nootbar have to improve at the plate or become the #4. Carlson was a major disappointment for me this year.
Don’t know what to really make of Dickerson….
October 12, 2022 at 8:02 am in reply to: 2022 Wild Card Series Game 2 thread – Saturday, October 8 vs. Phillies #204350Do teams in the same division play the same inter-league teams?
If not, in a tight divisional race 6-12 games against different opponents could very well be the difference.
Schedules need to be identical.
October 11, 2022 at 8:05 am in reply to: 2022 Wild Card Series Game 2 thread – Saturday, October 8 vs. Phillies #204240NLCS should be the goal.
At that point anything can happen.
Getting to the WS has to be considered a big success.
I’d like to see each league go to 4 divisions with only champions advancing OR go to a 120 game regular season for seeding purposes and then let all but last place teams into ‘the tournament’.
I think he’s pretty good.
He can only work with what he is given.
Shocked that between him, Marmol, and Molina none of them pulled the plug on Helsley before it was out of hand Friday night…
DeJong gets 9M in 2023 doesn’t he? Is he for sure gone?
Even if the Cards have to eat 100% of that he should not take up a roster spot. He can cut the grass, wash equipment, and sell peanuts to earn his pay.
Added to the 6M he pulled in this year I think he will be able to get by.
October 10, 2022 at 8:04 am in reply to: 2022 Wild Card Series Game 2 thread – Saturday, October 8 vs. Phillies #204124Follow the money. No matter how much is generated it will never be enough.
Baseball should go to 4 divisions in each league with only the division champions advancing.
WC spots cheapen the regular season. Why do you need to play a 162 marathon if 1/2 the league advances to the playoffs?
Money. We all pay the big fat salaries because where do you think the tv money from paid advertisements that cover the obscene salaries comes from? Consumer pockets.
October 9, 2022 at 11:50 am in reply to: 2022 Wild Card Series Game 2 thread – Saturday, October 8 vs. Phillies #204054Remember this. 93 wins in a very bad division with three teams effectively taking the season off. The Cubs, Reds, and Pirates are all going to improve some. What will the Brewers do? So to stay at 93 wins the Cardinals will have to get a little better too. To get to 95-98 wins they will have to improve even more. Put the Dodger’s in this division and they might have won 120 games.
Starting catcher, outfielder that can consistently contribute at the plate, front line #1 pitcher.
Can / will the FO do all that? In the past they have not.
Puhols 2nd half made up for O’Neill’s absence. Now what?
Wainwright needs to retire. DeJong does not need to take up a roster spot next year no matter what that means for his 9M salary.
Need a true #1 starter to go with Quintana, Montgomery, Mikolas and whatever revolving door of names is the #5. What to do with Matz???
Need a starting catcher, Knizner is ok as a back up.
Infield is in good shape – for now – Goldschmidt will likely begin to fade but Arenado should be solid for 3-4 more seasons. Edman at short / Donvan at second.
Need a big bat / offensive producer for the of to go with Carlson / O’Neill / Dickerson. Nootbar and his .228 average cannot start – just can’t.
Hopefully some of the younger guys like Donovan and Yepez will actually improve and not pull a Carlson / O’Neil and go backwards.
Three biggest disappointments for me this season were Carlson, Flaherty, and O’Neil.
Jordan Walker likely won’t be with the big club when the season starts but may be by mid-season.
FO has got to know that they have a window here with a pretty decent core to actually be good for a few seasons instead of just ‘competative’.
That is a lot of players.
Flaherty should be lucky to keep the salary he’s making.
Relief pitching is so up and down year to year that I hope they don’t overpay Helsley as his era could easily be over 4 next year. You just never know. Look at what he did in 2021.
October 8, 2022 at 11:49 pm in reply to: 2022 Wild Card Series Game 3 thread – Sunday, Oct 9 vs. Phillies (if necc.) #204012I guess Flaherty would have been the game 3 starter since Marmol burned Montgomery tonight. Doesn’t matter now though…
October 8, 2022 at 10:57 pm in reply to: 2022 Wild Card Series Game 2 thread – Saturday, October 8 vs. Phillies #203983That was Pathetic.
I give Marmol a big fat F for his managing.
He pulled Quintana too early, how did he not know Helsley was hurt and regardless he left him in too long, he pulled Mikolas too early, he should have pinch hit for Molina in the 7th, and in the 9th (regardless of the hit), there is more.
F.
The entire offense for both games was one swing. Its clear that this team needs at least 3 more good bats in the line up…
But this disaster lays mostly at Marmol’s feet.
Congrats on winning the worst division in baseball, I guess, but when 3 teams take the year off it’s not that grand of an accomplishment.Please for the love of God will the FO fix this offense. You can’t have 3-4 guys in the line up that can’t hit their own weight.
October 8, 2022 at 9:12 am in reply to: 2022 Wild Card Series Game 2 thread – Saturday, October 8 vs. Phillies #203790Ours is not to reason why; ours is but to do and die.
Charge!!!
-
AuthorPosts
