Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Ha stlcard25, I thought of him too! They were similar in multiple ways.
BHC giving me a Seth Maness flashback.
Seems like Hudson’s 2019 “issues” are fixable. If you look at it that way, it does give hope to upside as much as downside.
why do some players swing at so many breaking pitches out of the zone. Is it lack of ability to pick up the spin on the ball? Is it lack of reflexes needed to adjust to the pitch?
Those are two big reasons. It’s often not a simple matter of plate discipline. It’s a talent/skill some will never develop to overcome the physics. A fastball takes about 0.4 seconds from release to reach the plate, while a curve takes about 0.5 seconds. Assuming a batter can recognize the pitch in a quarter of second to make any necessary adjustments, that leaves about 0.15 seconds for the fastball and 0.25 seconds for the curve. Percentage-wise, that’s a relatively huge difference. There’s no way most hitters are catching up to the fastball if they were sitting on the curve, and many will look foolish on the curve if they were expecting the heater.
Banging on trash cans was such a good idea!
I’ve never been to ST and am curious how the experience varies from the early days to the latter portion? I’m thinking of going for about a week and looking at the latter part, March 15-20 maybe, but am flexible to go earlier.
I’d like to see this program about the 80’s Cardinals. Is this going to be shown again?
Saturday Feb 1 at 5pm (eastern time) on MLBN according to my channel guide.
Also Sunday Feb 2 at 12am and again at 9am
gscottar, when the login box pops up, just click the X in the upper right corner. The box will go away and you can read the article.
Ha! I’m not betting anything on any team in this division. Could be a crazy year. Hope and need a couple of the young guys to rise to the occasion like Edman did.
bikemike, I loved the Carson-Uecker interviews — called him “Mr Baseball” — here are a couple good ones I remember, something like “I helped the Cardinals win the pennant. I got hepatitis……after the trainer injected me with the virus.”
Another was something like “I signed with the Braves for just a few thousand dollars. Yes, it was a little insulting. Seriously, I didn’t have that kind of dough to cough up.”
Pugs, it’s no wonder you thought of Brinkman over the likes of Mathews, Murray and Stanky! Who will ever forget Brinkman’s 2-month stint as a Redbird where he collected a HR and 6 RBIs? His HR added insult to injury in a laugher over the Giants. Couldn’t hit a lick, but he was a good glove guy.
Overall, the writers have made such a mess over time by not unanimously voting in players who were far, far, far better than Jeter.
Or to go one step further, how about guys perhaps better than Jeter who were outright snubbed on on their first ballot?
If Ozuna had accepted the Cards’ QO, could the Cards have given him another QO offer next year? In other words, is it possible a team would have been subjected to losing a comp pick by signing Ozuna after he refused a QO after next season? And, can the Braves offer Ozuna a QO after next season and be rewarded with a QO after a one-year deal? Just wondering how the strategy of all that benefits/hurts Ozuna.
On the MLBN announcement show, while discussing Schilling’s vote total, someone (Stark I think I remember) said that the last 11 players who fell short with at least 70% of the votes then went on to be elected the next year. So that does bode well for Schilling.
Jeter not unanimous — 396 out of 397 I think is what I heard.
Walker squeezed in at 76.6%. He had 6 spare votes.
We’re all sorry once we’ve been caught. And admitting guilt without qualifications is darn near impossible for most.
They must have concluded that his involvement in the scheme went above and beyond other players.
Maybe that’s part of it. Also, they might have been compelled to include Beltran because he had moved to a managerial position by the time of the investigation.
Secondly, I’m guessing that if two teams have been publicly exposed in the past 6 months, that they are not the only teams doing some variation of it. However, our beloved Cardinals have never done it!
Well CFICT, there were the other 8 “named” teams in the investigation. It’ll be interesting to see if evidence comes forward to implicate others. Gotta be careful who you trade away. 😉
I posted the quote below earlier in this thread. I was being serious.
“How widespread is this really, on an institutional level? As they say, if you’re not cheating, you’re not trying. Who here attends Cards’ games regularly and do you hear bangs or whistles frequently in the bottom halves of innings?”
MM3: Related to your question, I saw it somewhat addressed a couple days ago on MLBN. One person, don’t recall who, made a point that Astros’ hitters had a significantly higher take rate on off-speed pitches at home than they did on the road. I don’t recall the comparative numbers, but off-speed pitches tend to be out of the strike zone more than fastballs.
And then when the off-speed stuff was in the zone, it gave their hitters a better opportunity to spoil off the good pitches. I remember they mentioned Gattis as an example of this.
It’s an interesting point, but regardless if they benefited slightly, moderately, or greatly, I think the core issue remains unchanged.
A strong public deterrent has to be put into place to try to fend off future attempts. If they can’t do the time then they shouldn’t do the crime.
Baseball is a game of rules — just like other sports and businesses. This Astros’ cheating was in-house, but it impacted the entire MLB enterprise. It possibly impacted the following: the outcomes of games, final playoff standings, opposing players’ stats, which then could’ve led to opposing pitchers having lower contract and trade values, getting bounced out of the league, opposing managers being fired, etc. It’s out in the open because the Astros put it out in the open for us all to hear and see. And then they had the gall and arrogance to deny it like the rest of the world is stupid. Sorry, no thanks. To sort of halfway sweep it under the rug would be a negligence of leadership by the commissioner.
Sounds like a 5-10% chance that something happens.
So the odds have gone up?
Regarding Ryu fill in the blank, the answer is not “guy late for dinner.”
The Cardinals won this trade hands down
Seems like it based on needs, but you you never know and you just jinxed it! Seems like danger dealing with the Rays, but maybe they’re due for a rough one.
I read one scouting report that described Liberatore as a potential #3 starter. Seems inconsistent with other things that are being said.
Also, I think WAR should be looked at more along an exponential curve than a linear curve.
This brings up a related point to me that I’ve often wondered about. It seems wrong on the surface, because WAR is accumulated linearly by each player. However, consider 8 position players who average 2.5 WAR each. Is it better to have all 8 players be 2.5 WAR each? Or would a mix of one 6-WAR player, one 4-WAR player, one 2.5 WAR player, two 2-WAR players, one 1.5-WAR player, and two 1-WAR players. That’s also an average of 2.5 WAR per player.
I have believed the latter lineup is better because you have a couple of stars who can carry the team for important stretches and can instill fear in their opponents. In other words, it might make a team greater than the sum of its parts. Have nothing to back that up, it’s just my gut feel. Anybody else have an opinion?
If true, it would be important to sign a guy or two like Arenado every decade.
Heard a few of the analysts (Byrnes, Smotlz, etc.) on MLBN today talking about the pros/cons of using technology (e.g., electronic devices, random number generators, etc.) to communicate signs as a way to lower the chance of future cheating. Drew comparisons to the way football communicates plays and discussed ways baseball could move away from its current archaic approach. Emphasized how it could save prep time for pitchers, and especially catchers. Another important point was how it could improve the pace of play, which gets a lot of lip service these days.
Brian, cycling and Olympic sports offer a parallel. Lance Armstrong was stripped of seven TDF titles, but they weren’t awarded to anyone else due to a larger cloud of suspicion. Other years when riders (Landis and Contador) were stripped of titles due to doping, the runners-up were awarded the titles.
Jim Thorpe won the decathlon and pentathlon gold medals at the 1912 Olympic Games. He was later stripped of the medals due to playing professional baseball, so the gold medals were awarded to the runners-up. Seventy years later, the gold medals were reinstated to Thorpe — so you have two gold medal recipients in both events for 1912.
On a less serious note and using reverse logic, should the Reds be stripped of the 1919 World Series title because their opponent cheated against themselves? And for that matter, can the Cards have 1985 reconsidered, haha?
-
AuthorPosts
