Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
September 27, 2020 at 4:07 pm in reply to: 2020 Cardinals Game #58 – Sun, Sept. 27 vs. Brewers #142209
I hope you like Shildt’s decision after the game. I like his decision to bring Gallegos back out again. I hope I like that decision after the 6th.
September 27, 2020 at 1:29 pm in reply to: 2020 Cardinals Game #58 – Sun, Sept. 27 vs. Brewers #142135Royals said they moved the game up in hopes of avoiding the rain.
Cards lost, but so did SF. We’re down to the final day. Here are the paths to the playoffs for the contenders as I see them for Sunday’s games (or at DET if necessary).
STL:
1 – STL beats MIL, OR
2 – SD beats SF, OR
3 – STL beats DET onceMIL:
1 – MIL beats STL, OR
2 – TB beats PHI and SD beats SFSF:
1 – SF beats SD and STL beats MIL, OR
2 – SF beats SD and MIL beats STL and DET beats STL twicePHI:
1 – PHI beats TB and STL beats MIL and SD beats SFSo, games at DET are necessary only if MIL beats STL and SF beats SD.
September 26, 2020 at 7:04 pm in reply to: 2020 Cardinals Game #57 – Sat, Sept. 26 vs. Brewers #142050Wainwright gave up five outfield fly balls in the 4th. Unfortunately, two of them landed on the wrong side of the fence.
Yep, I just looked it up — extra innings will return to “normal” for the playoffs.
so cal, no I didn’t look at that. I thought it was interesting when you brought it up to gscottar. Definitely a valid point, kind of like the advantage in NCAA football overtime of getting to go 2nd on offense so you know if you you need just a field goal or a TD.
I guess we get the same extra inning rules in the playoffs?
Discussion on home field advantage above reminded me that I’ve seen articles in recent years stating the perceived home field advantage in MLB playoffs has not been backed up by actual results. That led me to wonder if home field advantage was reduced this year due to no fan attendance.
Through yesterday’s games, MLB home team winning percentage has been .557 (482-384). That seems like a significant advantage, so I compared it to last year. In 2019, home teams enjoyed a .529 (1286-1143) winning percentage. Hmmm, so having fans in the stands cheering for you is a disadvantage?
Maybe the COVID protocols and restrictions are more distracting when a team is on the road. Whatever, I thought it was interesting.
As for games in Detroit, here are the possibilities I came up with after reviewing it.
1. Cards win last two games against MIL. No games in DET unless cubs lose their last two games.
2. Cards win just one more game against MIL. No games in DET.
3. Cards lose both games against MIL. Games in DET are more likely, but still unnecessary if PHI loses at least one more and SF loses its final two.
Cards don’t need the Rays to beat the Phils if they take one more against the Brewers. 25’s post above shows why — one more win against the Brewers clinches the Cards will finish ahead of them and own the tiebreaker against the Phils.
Cards also win the tiebreaker against the Reds should they end up even.
September 25, 2020 at 7:37 am in reply to: 2020 Cardinals Game #54 – Thu, Sept. 24 vs. Brewers #141757I knew those scampi would do the job. They even produced one more run than I expected.
Coming from the guy in France, I have to ask.
Double entendre? Your stomach okay? Shrimp/prawns can do that, you know.September 24, 2020 at 10:54 pm in reply to: 2020 Cardinals Game #54 – Thu, Sept. 24 vs. Brewers #141739So maybe it’s a combo of losing body fat and adding muscle. I honestly don’t know if my mental image of Reyes before tonight was from before or after 2019.
September 24, 2020 at 10:44 pm in reply to: 2020 Cardinals Game #54 – Thu, Sept. 24 vs. Brewers #141733Reyes has provided much more than I guessed this year. Tonight is the first game I have actually seen him. Has he lost weight?
thejager posted REPLY #141283 (too long to quote here)
That was a helluva post. It captures some of the logical fallacies that have led the organization to being deficient at the plate and a predictably boring watch. We better hope they keep developing good mound talent because top shelf free agent hurlers will be hard to attract.
stlcard25, I think there are more factors with O’Neill’s performance to chalk it up as completely due to poor BABIP. The BBs are up slightly and Ks are down, but so are the barrel and hard hit percentages. That means there’s more than just bad luck involved. How much though? He changed his approach some and that plays into how the ball is coming off the bat. Not all balls in play are equal. I think he’s in an adjustment phase and not sure where he’ll end up. I’ve seen some of these guy eventually revert to their old, more comfortable ways when the new approach doesn’t yield the desired results. Does any of that concern you?
25 wearing his thinking cap.
September 20, 2020 at 6:38 pm in reply to: 2020 Cardinals Game #50 – Sun. Sep. 20 at Pirates #141067I’m with you on a couple things tonight, Pugs. I had a feeling Miller was going to drill Moran in the hip when he was up 0-2 and bad things might happen. Glad he went with the slider low and away to allay my fears. Also, the wife is no better than #2 on my list right now behind Miss Bonnie (4-legged family member of 13 years). I’m sure Bonnie is ahead of me on the wife’s list.
Speaking of Bonnie, if Rat reads this, how is Whitey doing? I remember you saying Whitey was going through some tough health issues. Do I recall it being pancreatitis? If so, how did the vet treat it? We thought we were losing Bonnie earlier this month. She was diagnosed with pancreatitis and she barely ate or lifted an eyebrow for a couple of weeks. She now appears to be on the mend, even barking her demands at us now, after multiple stays with the vet.
September 18, 2020 at 5:14 pm in reply to: 2020 Cardinals Game #46 – Thu, Sept. 17 at Pirates #140723Like I said, no one wants to be preached to unless they walk into the church. That goes for activists from Hollywood, MLB, a neighbor, or the commoner who shares an office cubicle with you at work. I don’t think performance is the main factor. Maybe ESPN can get Ricky Gervais to host the ESPYs next time.
Also, if you’re criticizing the critic of an activist for having a political bias, then the bias probably goes full circle.
September 18, 2020 at 12:48 pm in reply to: Former Cardinals in the News – 2017 to Aug. 2024 (closed) #140667I haven’t criticized the Voit-Gallegos trade, but . . . you have fans of a team devoid of offense who are criticizing a recent trade where the team gave away a guy who’s hit 20 HRs this year and has an OPS+ of 167 for a guy who’s pitched all of 11 innings . . . and some guy’s response to the criticism is to quote his own tweets from a year ago and say the pitcher is good while calling the fans dorks. Petriello sounds double dorky to me.
September 18, 2020 at 12:05 pm in reply to: 2020 Cardinals Game #46 – Thu, Sept. 17 at Pirates #140663People watch baseball because they like . . . . BASEBALL. When a player decides to “use my platform” for something other than baseball, then he changes that balance. You don’t get one-way traffic in this scenario. To expect that is hypocritical at best. People don’t like to be preached to unless they walk into the church.
Off the field issues affect player performance all the the time and they are discussed ad nauseum. Does FG have charts on how financial problems affect performance, how legal issues affect performance, how drug use affects performance, how domestic issues affect performance, etc.? Are they discussed? Same with politics, probably even more so. If you’re going to dish it out, grow some skin in the other direction. White knighting for unsolicited activists is a personal bias.
And the thought if player performance has not degraded, the issues don’t get discussed — well, that’s not the case here, is it?
September 15, 2020 at 10:55 pm in reply to: 2020 Cardinals Game #43 – Tue, Sept. 15 at Brewers #140292Vogelbach looks like a latter-day Smokey Burgess. Never really saw Smokey, other then occasional highlights of the 1960 World Series, but he has the same general build, and I think he hits the same way – basically taking what they give you.
Even though I never saw him play, Smoky is a guy I heard a lot about since he was born, passed away and buried in my home county. He retired about the time I started watching MLB as a kid. Trivia question: Who caught Harvey Haddix during the 12 perfect inning game? Yep, it was Smoky.
We know Covid outcomes are worse for people in their 60s and over. Article said Peterson is 46, so I hope that gives him a good chance to win this battle. Wishing him and his family all the strength they need and more.
Brian, unless I’m missing something, part of your issue with Ny’s statements is a mis-read. Ny said “excluding” Goldy. I know there are others that you took exception to, but Goldy was the main one I believe.
Pugs, you might need to deliver one more round of mediation to make sure the lid stays on and none of our redbird fans fly the coop.
If you guys were watching the ESPN . . .
I wasn’t, but not surprising ESPN would take a player’s focus away from the action on the field. Glad Shildt told them to buzz off.
RIP. Started following the Cards and MLB in ’68 as a pre-Little Leaguer and Lou was the guy. I closed my batting stance just like Lou. It never felt quite right, but for a long time I figured it had to be the best way since Lou did it like that.
The DP with Yadi was certainly a concern and I’m sure factored into the decision. You had to weigh that against the likelihood O’Neill would whiff against Iglesias. That decision is not a layup.
-
AuthorPosts
