Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
I have tried tô stay out of the eligibility argument since my days of being the leãd moderador of the prodpect ranking thread. But I will at least provide some historical context
At the time of starting the comunnity ranking there was only one popular ranking system. That was Baseball América. There was no mlb pipeline rankings. No fangrahs ranking. Not even the Post Dispatch. We were cutting edge! BA at the time used the 130 abs/50 IP standard and ignored service time (I dont know what they currently do). The community had discussion among itself every year over which standard tô use but evry year ignoring service time won out. Tô me that makes sense and would be my choice. Why does it make sense goes tô the meaning of prospect. A player who sits on the bench all year is still a prospect because there is noo evidence of his ability tô perform. We are voting on a players potential impact. Whether a player is still a prospect (unproven) really hás nothing tô do with rookie eligibility. (I will be the first tô admit that 130/50 is also not sufficient tô know a player’s potential but you have tô draw a line somewhere. Where ignoring service time becomes most controversy is with relief pitchers. It is possible for a reliever that gets injured tô have as many as 2.5 tô 3 years of mlb service time but not have 50 IP
Só that is some historical context mixed with some personal commentary.
#6 -Graceffo
I have said for 3 years that Pages is the Cardinals long term catcher of the future. I started tô question that after the Contreras signing but he appears he may not last 5 years back there.
Pages is undoubtedly the closet thing tô Yadi in the system.
For those liking Scott because of his minor league Gold glove, remember that Randall Grichick won a minor league Gold glove in 2013 but turned out tô be an average at best defensive outfielder in the majors.
#4 Scott – soley based on the hype
At 3 Hence is an easy coice. Despiste the concerns of fragiliza he is rhe one that would make me crente if traded.
The question is how much difference does a manager make. It is not Just strategy and pitadinha matchup (though that is big). It also keeping guys motivated and sharp. Can you quantify these things? If só It seems managers are underpaid in general. If one WAR is worth 9 million It would make sente a good manager is worth the investment. The question then becomes can you identify a good manager vs a medíocre one?
Tremor Baur anyone?
I would like tô see Gomez get a look but I doubt he will.
Prepare yourselves for a Frankie Montas signing on a 1 year low base + incentives contract. You heard it here first!
Advanced metrics are results based? Bat speed? Spin rates? Ground Ball rates? Those are results based compared tô Wins and scoring runs? I dont think só. Both have their place but advanced metrics are not more results based. I would call them more predictive
Avançado metrics are resulta based? Bat speed? Spin rates? Ground Ball rates? Those are results based compared tô Winston and scoring runs? I dont think só. Both have their place but advanced metrics are not more results based. I would call them more predicativo.
1 FA
1 Trade
1 competition between 5-8 optionsShould have been called up 10 games sooner tô make sure he got 130 abs and lose rookie eligibility. The consequences of losing a year of control for beng rookie of the year are too high tô risk. Especially when they can be avoided só easily.
Not sure where I read it but read that Hence’s motion was high arm stress which is why they built him up slowly. Didnt say whether they tweeked his motion tô reduce that stress
Craig was an athlete (SS in college and his first year in the org). Baker is basically a bat. O believe Craig got as high as #7 on our prospect list só he was more highly regarded. Baker might be ranked that high in the system this Winter if he could play anywher but 1B. But since he cant ……
#1 available starter. #1 available reliever. Decente guys in Flaherty and Dejong. Carson reportedly being available. And we cant get a top 100 prospect?
Just a curiosity – if Richardson had gone undrafted would there have been a cap on his signing amount?
How much will teams lose in concession Sales due tô faster games?
If Dunn is not yet ready for AAA will he ever be?
Reported as 84-87 in recent Spring game.
Article on mandatory opt out clauses but I dont think it affects any of our guys
Agree with Euro on that this could help save Waino’s arm for more critical games.
Can Hjerpe really be considered a solid prospect with a 86 mph fastball?
Brian, can you do some Sluething and find out what minor league free agent signings have opt out classes if not called up and if só what dates (particularly Suárez, Motter, and the catcher whose name escapes me)
I though I read once that minor leageu free agent signings with a certain amount of service time (dont remember how much) were required tô be given an opt out.
-
AuthorPosts
