Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Primary starters threw 623 as a Cardinal (2 were traded)….Mikolas skews the # some b/c he was 4th in the majors for innings pitched
Wainwright….101
Mikolas………..201.1
Matz………………….90 (excluded his bullpen innings)
Montgomery..121
Flaherty…….109.2The rest came from a wide cast: like Hudson, Woodford, Thompson Liberatore , Woodforde, Rom
Matz, Thompson, Liberatore, Woodford and Hudson all had bullpen innings as well
I think that 2year $20 Mill contract would be reasonable. It would be a gamble maybe a little similar with what they did with Chris Carpenter…though I think Carpenter was an elbow where Woodruff might be a shoulder.
A little out of the box and while he may not be able to pitch in 2024 Brandon Woodruff might be a good gamble on an incentive laden 2 year deal(a healthy Woodruff and Gray would be a pretty good starting duo for 2025)…pending a look at his medicals
Well if they were to sign Montgomery one of 2 things will probably have to happen after he signs, Matz is 1) traded or 2) Matz is moved to the bullpen (Lynn could go to pen instead but I doubt that happens)
If Matz is traded, maybe the Mets are desperate for a starter, that saves some $ to pay for Montgomery’s salary this and next year.
I still think they sign 2 relief pitchers which was somewhat reported they were looking to do after Gray’s signing
I still am unclear on their budget though….it looks like they have added around $8 million in projected salary so far according to spotrac who have them around $165.5 million right now
I don’t think the Cardinals can give up their top starting pitching prospect (Hence) under any circumstances with the cost of starting pitching nowadays in MLB and the cardinals budget
The money per year is not to bad, but 5 years I wouldn’t be all that thrilled with…but that might be my bias fearing another Bret Cecil implosion
I doubt they could play the dodgers any worse than they did at the end of April of last season.
Padres will not be as good as last year, marlins still little offense and no Alcantra, Phillies are solid but not world beaters, Dbacks same as Phillies.
The lack of urgency in bullpen signings is puzzling, but the silver lining may be if they are terrible this year I would expect a major house cleaning from manager to GM to president of baseball ops
My guess Yamamoto will be pretty good from what I saw in the WBC but 12 years is a deal that a small or mid mid market team could never do.…my guess is they are going to do some type of a tv deal in Japan with him and Ohtani, but $325 million plus the additional $50 million posting fee could be interesting if things don’t go to plan with his production….12 years is a long time for a pitcher
December 21, 2023 at 11:09 pm in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2021-2023 #240153If you add the posting fee they have to pay Orix it is $375 million for 12 years
From what I saw last year they have very little bullpen help at AA or AAA unless they plan to start Graceffo in the pen when he is ready if he is ready in 2024.
Some of the free agent options are:
Hector Neris…would think he gets b/w $8-11 mill a year, but would probably be best option 68 IP, 41 hits 77 K’s, 31 walks in 2023
Robert Stephenson…did well last year with Rays but seems to be good every other year.
Jordan Hicks…was good in Toronto but seems to always be close to being really good but doesn’t quite get there
Phil Maton…pretty solid last 3 years with Astros but like Gallegos has pitched a lot of Innings and has a lot of appearances
David Robertson…old, was good with Mets was just short of horrible after trade to Marlins
I’d probably try to sign both Neris and Maton, and then hope a couple of the lefthander’s they already have b/w Romero, Libratore (who was pretty decent out of the pen end of last year) King, Naughton can get the job done at least till the summer trade dead line.
Outside of Hader, Matsui (padres I assume), wandy peralta and Matt Moore(injuries) there is not a lot in LH relief….don’t see the Cardinals looking at Chapman I guess they could take a flyer on Brent Suter from Colorado he would be cheap which seems to be the Cardinals M.O. these days.
The problem with Hader is he has made a lot of appearances and the guy was terrible in 2022; if he reverts back some you are stuck with a long term deal with a lot of money tied up each year….it’s a pretty risky move with the Cardinals budget and Dollar Bills penchant for spending
I don’t really see the Cardinals signing or trading for any more A or B list starters so I might take a flyer on Frankie Montas if he can pass a physical in an incentive laden deal.
It would definitely be a risk, but there could be some upside possibilities if it is the right price
Jim Bowden (not the most informed but a former GM) in the Athletic predicts that:
Yamamoto will get a contract of 9 years $304 million
Montgomery will get 6 years $167 million
Snell will get 6 years $162 million
Wacha will get 2 years $28 million
Giolito will get 1 year $15 million
Seth Lugo will get 2 years $24 millionMay not be accurate in the end, but it’s at least a ballpark
The Braves are the model the Cardinals need to copy not the Dodgers
The Cardinals cannot be any worse than the 3 they played at LA last year …that and the Giants series right before it pretty much ended there year to close out April
Not sure I would want to be on the hook paying Ohtani $15 million when he is 60 to sign baseballs
I have to think the Giants are the biggest loser in this one, they need a superstar player desperately and their attendance hasn’t really came back to pre pandemic levels
December 9, 2023 at 2:41 pm in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2021-2023 #239433For a little perspective on this deal the cardinals rotation last year (6 pitchers)…Mikolas, Matz, Waino, Monty, Hudson and flaherty made $67 million
The Projected Rotation this year w/ Gray taking 10 mill the first year for 5 pitchers is $62 Million
I would look at it as they have an additional 5.5 mill to spend….hopefully they will spend it….O’Neill has had 2 years to capture 2021 and hasn’t done it b/c on injury and a lack of contact, I doubt much would have changed for him in St.Louis, so Boston may be a good change of scenery for him
The difference b/w Arozarena/Garcia and Tyler O’Neill is that the cardinals gave hardly any major league at bats to Arozarena/Garcia where O’Neill has had ample at bats & seasons to show he is an oft injured inconsistent hitter at best
With Gray getting $10 million the first year that puts the projected starting rotation at around $62 million, that is $5 million less than last years(2023)starting rotation…so they still have some flexibility and could have even more if they say were to add Matz in a trade with O’Neil or Carlson.
They also have to address the bullpen. Gallegos I think is a big key he has made 186 appearances the last 3 years.
Right now I guess the bullpen looks something like:
Helsley….injury plagued year in 2023
Gallegos…gave up more hits than innings pitched for first time in 5 years
John King…was pretty solid after the trade from Rangers in 20 appearancesLiberatore…pitched well in September 12 ip over 10 appearances 5 hits allowing 2 earned runs …still not sure on him though
Pallante….not a good year at all, after a solid 2022, needs to have a goood spring
Romero….needs to cut down on the walks but does have a lot of strikeouts
Naghton may be a lefthanded option if he can stay healthy and they don’t really have that many righthanded options left
A minimum 2 quality arms will probably be needed in free agency or a trade
Zach Thompson would I guess be in the mix or the #6 starter/long releif
2024 cardinals pitching rotation as it is now makes around $10 million more than the 2023 Rotation going by Spotrac
Going to be real interesting to see how much Yamamoto gets I have seen anywhere from $200 million up to $280 million over the length of his contract….plus the posting fee to Orix
Grays stats last year in 32 starts he gave up more than 3 earned runs only 3 times, he led the AL in FIP and HR allowed per9….3 years $75 million
2023 Cardinal starters
Mikolas had 35 starts gave up more than 3 earned runs in 13 of them
Matz had 17 starts gave up more than 3 earned runs in 6 of them
Flaherty had 27 starts gave up more than 3 earned in 9 gamesOther free agents
Montgomery 32 starts gave up more than 3 earned runs in 6 of them
Snell had 32 starts gave up more than 3 earned runs in 2 of them
Nola had 32 starts gave up more than 3 earned runs in 15 of them…7 years $172 million
Stroman 25 starts gave up more than3 earned runs in 7 of them
Giolito 32 starts gave up more than 3 earned in 12 of themAlready Signed
Gibson 33 starts gave up more than 3 earned in 11 of them…..1 year $12 million
Lynn 32 starts gave up more than 3 earned in 15 of them…..1 year $10 millionI think Walker has played outfield for a a year and a half so he should improve some, don’t think he will ever be much more than an average defender.
I would bet he improves quite a bit at the plate next year and he was pretty solid for a rookie this past year.
I don’t see anyway they could afford Soto unless they trade Goldschmidt for him
-
AuthorPosts
