Bob Reed

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 25 posts - 876 through 900 (of 1,093 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Top 10 GM's of the past 20 years #80166
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “I recalled reading a BA story about this, which I liked because it had a formula behind it. The story, which just ran in November, ranked active GMs using a scoring system tied to World Series, League titles, Division wins, wild cards, 100-win seasons and total regular season wins.”

    Thanks for being patient Brian, while I’ve been lazy for the past couple of days. I like the idea of a systematic numerical analysis like Baseball America’s, but I see a few flaws with BA’s rankings.

    1) They don’t include a GM’s financial resources
    2) They don’t give any weight to what talent a GM inherited
    3) They don’t consider what that GM left behind
    4) They probably give too much weight to the playoffs, which involve a LOT more luck than the regular season, and in my opinion reflect managerial wisdom more than GM acumen

    “Either you are going back 20 years or you are not. Arbitrarily leaving Schuerholz off is ignoring the fact the Braves were in the playoffs every year from 1995 through 2005, winning more than 100 games five different seasons, all while he was GM. Even if you start with 1999 and end after 2007 when he moved up, he is unquestionably among the best of the last 20 years.”

    Fair criticism. More than fair, in fact. I should have thought it through better and made fully explicit the parameters. Let’s say that my list only includes individuals who’ve been active within the last 5 years in a GM or GM-like capacity. That way Walt Jocketty is of course still included, but guys who retired a decade ago, or were promoted beyond conventional GM responsibilities, would be excluded.

    The logic is, if I were to include Gillick and Schu (easy Hall Of Famers both), then I’d be comparing them to guys like Antonetti and Luhnow, against whom they never competed head-to-head as GM’s. Instead, I want peers v peers.

    “For example, Theo has three rings, including in two places that had gone 100 years without titles. The guy has his warts, but seventh in the last 20 years? How? Why?
    Friedman second with zero World Series wins? Beane third despite never having got past the first round? etc…”

    Okay, we get to the meat & potatoes of it.
    Theo Epstein did not break any curses. Or maybe I should say that I don’t believe in curses — so no bonus there, not for me. Theo won World Series rings with huge player payrolls, for two of the top four revenue franchises in the sport. The Red Sox and Cubs are penthouse teams, not outhouse.

    Then and now, as a reflection of general manager skill, winning a World Series in Boston or Chicago is less impressive to me than winning a pennant in Tampa Bay. Speaking of which, during Theo’s 9 years in Boston, his Red Sox won fewer division titles than the Devil Rays. And that’s even though Tampa stunk during Theo’s first 5 Beantown seasons.

    Now let’s see what Epstein inherited from his Carmines predecessor when he took over following the 2002 season. The 2002 BoSox were a juggernaut, outscoring their opponents by nearly 200 runs, and featuring a 6-man core, all 30 or younger, that averaged more than 6 WAR apiece. (Pedro Martinez, Manny Ramirez, Johnny Damon, Derek Lowe, Nomar Garciaparra, and Trot Nixon.) In Theo’s first season they averaged 5.5 WAR each.

    With massive team revenues/payrolls and a core like that, how could things be any better? Here’s how. In the minors Epstein also inherited future stars Hanley Ramirez, Kevin Youkilis, and Jon Lester. Between the majors and minors that’s A LOT of talent. I would argue without fear of contradiction that Theo Epstein inherited the best starting position of any first time GM in modern major league history. Maybe of any GM at any time in MLB history. (Unless one believes in curses, which I don’t.)

    He inherited all that, and won one division title in nine years. He left the team with bloated contracts and mediocre prospects. They finished last in 3 of the next 4 seasons after he left. Much of that was due to Theo protegee Ben Cherington, but some was surely on Theo as well. Howard Bryant at ESPN summed it up well when he described the historic 2011 Red Sox collapse. Bryant anticipated the last place finishes to come, with his critique of Epstein’s generally dismal free agent signings. https://www.espn.com/espn/commentary/story/_/page/bryant-111005/theo-epstein-held-accountable-red-sox-collapse

    As for his next stop, Epstein in Chicago inherited in Chicago a situation almost identical to what Mozeliak inherited in St. Louis. In both cases: old team, mediocre farm system, losing record, and a crappy run differential around -100. Remarkably, Mozeliak’s first team finished 10 games over .500, and not by luck. They improved their run differential by over 150 in one year. And they kept on improving from there, making the playoffs the following season. (And of course they’ve only had winning seasons since.)

    Next to Mozeliak, what Epstein did was comparatively easy: gutting a team for three straight years in order to accrue top draft picks (and the high draft budgets that accompany them) and also bloated int’l spending budgets, and accumulate the dirt cheap high end talent that results from them.

    Overall, Epstein’s cubs have averaged 84 wins a year. They have two division titles, one pennant, one Series. Mozeliak’s Cards have averaged 90 wins a year, won four division titles, two pennants, and also one Series. Theo’s only had 7 years and Mozeliak 11, but then Theo’s team has the sport’s 4th-most resources and right now the 2nd-highest player payroll. If Theo didn’t have his Boston years, then for me Mo would rank ahead of him.

    I think that the Epstein essay pretty much explains the relative placements of Friedman and Beane also. Friedman inherited nothing in Tampa, had few financial resources throughout his tenure, yet won the division more often than Theo Epstein, hired goofy iconoclast Joe Maddon, and won an A.L. pennant. Now that he has resources, Friedman wins his division every single year, and has two more pennants for his office wall. And his team looks very well positioned for the future. Markedly better than the cubs, in my opinion.

    Billy Beane you already know plenty about, likely more than I do. And he’s easily the toughest guy to grade, because of the extraordinary record of playoff futility. How much should he be punished for that? I have no idea whatsoever. His regular season record is very good, and very lengthy, and hindered by payroll constraints that haven’t handcuffed the others on the list. (At least not since Friedman left Florida.)

    Again, these GM’s are so tightly bunched that if you want to drop Beane from 3rd to 7th or 8th or even lower, I might not bother with rebutting. They’re all so darn close together. All ten guys would grade somewhere between a straight B and an A- for me. In fact, Antonetti might be the only B grade. Everyone else could receive B+ and A-, and next year Antonetti or Luhnow could be top 3, if their team wins 100 games and the World Series.

    in reply to: Next Man Up #80163
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    RF: This is one of the more subtle reasons why I want Jose Martinez traded for relief pitching. With Martinez gone, Mike Shildt would effectively be forced to play Tyler O’Neill when Fowler gets injured or simply doesn’t hit. (And that IS a when, not an if.)

    1B: I go with the latter option, CC. Gyorko would upgrade the hot corner defense, and his bat has consistently been above average since joining the Cards. I don’t dislike Jose Martinez, honestly. I would play Jose at first base if Goldy got hurt, if the alternative were weaker than Jedd for third base.

    CF: Tyler O’Neill is fast. Faster than you think. Fast enough for centerfield with room to spare. According to the statcast numbers, out of 549 major leaguers in 2018, O’Neill was 20th fastest. Link: https://baseballsavant.mlb.com/sprint_speed_leaderboard
    No way in the world would I ever play Dexter Fowler in center field again.

    LF: O’Neill should simply be getting maximum playing time, however possible. He’s nearly a decade younger than Jose Martinez, and even though Jose is the better bat right now, O’Neill is the better ballplayer once defense and baserunning are included. Short term and long, O’Neill makes more sense.

    C: If Yadi goes down in April or early May, perhaps you go with Pena for awhile. Francisco’s been an average hitter in AAA for 3 or 4 years, so he really shouldn’t be nearly as terrible in the majors as he showed last year. By June, assuming he’s playing well for Memphis, Knizner gets the call.

    2B and 3B: Agreed, absolutely. Gyorko would be a Steady Eddie at either spot.

    SS: Ride a hot hand. If Munoz is on the 25-man and hitting distinctly better than Gyorko at the time, you go with Yairo. Last year’s plethora of errors at the MLB level were not consistent with Munoz’ more solid minor league track record, so I think he’d be fine. Anyway, DeJong is going to play 154 games so don’t even THINK about it, CC.

    I love the Redbird position players. The starters, the depth, and the minors. If they play their best players, they make the playoffs no doubt. (But don’t play any geriatrics for 27 games in a row, Skip. In the immortal words of the bard Big Boi, act like you got some sense.)

    in reply to: Less and less demand for traditional sports writers #80162
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Thanks for the heads-up, Ny. I think I’ll look into this.
    Obsessive about accuracy, that’s me all over!

    On the other hand, I don’t really possess any social media savvy whatsoever. I’m not particularly open to direction or feedback from others. I don’t know anything about baseball’s lighter side, and I couldn’t care less about casual fans. Who needs casual fans? I can’t relate to casual fans.

    I’m also no good at reacting quickly, objectively self-editing, working on deadline for demanding bosses, or juggling numerous responsibilities like so many chainsaws. And I won’t work weekends or nights.

    Maybe I’m not the best choice.

    in reply to: Manny Machado thread #80161
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “…if a guy admits he does not want to hustle right before becoming a free agent and then tries multiple times to injure opponents in the post-season, I don’t want him on my team, especially for the next 7-10 years. There is more to the game than just good stats and a nice contract, IMO.”

    I am forced to concur with the above quote from Mr. Walton, Pads.

    Machado’s October antics went way beyond poor sportsmanship. Relative to the standards of his sport, he frankly behaved like a lunatic — in the playoffs, on national television, several times. In my opinion there’s something fundamentally wrong with him, as a human being. Maybe morally, maybe ethically, maybe emotionally or psychologically. But something ain’t right.

    For me the most interesting questions about Machado do not center around “Who will sign him, and for how much?” The real question is, has he been behaving like this throughout his career, kicking, grabbing, stepping on people? If he has, then how has it been kept such a secret? And if not, then why on Earth did he choose the highest possible profile setting to display his bizarrely dangerous behavior? Either way, something ain’t right.

    in reply to: Jose Martinez thread #80037
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    In awfulness, Jose beats Skates hands down, Wiley. Lonnie Smith was only 31 runs below average for his career per Fangraphs. And rather stunningly just minus 23 at Baseball-Reference.

    Lonnie was a pretty idiosyncratic defender. Lots of errors, but lots of assists. And he covered quite a bit of ground when he wasn’t slipping. I guess (for the non-AARP members reading this) you could liken him to Vlad Guerrero, at least the young version of Vlad — although I’d wager Vlad’s miscues were mostly of the throwing variety. Not what you’d call good glovemen, but certainly entertaining!

    And CC, I’d say that Brian summed it up well. According to the B-Ref site, it goes like this:

    1882 St. Louis Brown Stockings
    1883-1898 Browns
    1899 Perfectos
    1900-infinity Cardinals

    Bob Caruthers led the franchise with three straight double-digit WAR seasons (1885-87), before Silver King’s big year of course.

    I will mentally strike Tartabull from the list, Pugs. Partly for you, partly for the sake of his Seinfeld legacy. Thanks to George Costanza, I smile when I hear Tartabull’s name, deadbeat or not.

    in reply to: Jose Martinez thread #79958
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Since you asked, Pugs, I checked the defensive numbers at Fangraphs (because they’re so easily sortable).

    There are 177 players in MLB history with a negative 100 runs or worse, per F-G metrics. Ranking them by negative runs per 600 plate appearances, The clear worst two are Brad Hawpe at -22 runs/600, and Danny Tartabull at -21. Third worst ever is Hidecki Matsui at -18.

    Before you bring him up, Pugs, Dr. Strangeglove Dick Stuart averaged a -16. Stuart was atrocious, yes. But not the worst, apparently.

    Jose Martinez has thus far averaged -14 runs per 600 PA’s — but then, he still has his age-related decline phase to come. We know you can do it, Jose! Catch some of those guys!

    But let’s move on to a happier subject.
    As for batting, Jose currently sports a terrific career 130 wRC+, a number he shares with such notables as Tim Salmon, Bucketfoot Al Simmons, Toy Cannon Jimmy Wynn, Carl Yastrzemski, Pete Reiser, Christian Yelich, and the great Parisian Bob Caruthers, the ancient Cardinal who was baseball’s best pitcher at age 21 and best hitter at age 22.

    in reply to: Less and less demand for traditional sports writers #79957
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Good for her, she’ll be missed. She offered informed and highly readable reportage throughout her tenure, by gosh.

    in reply to: Cardinals arbitration eligible players #79920
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Maybe I’m about to oversimplify the situation, but here goes.

    Since Bud Selig took over in 1992, MLB revenues have risen by an average of just over 5% per year.

    But over the past 8 years the luxury tax threshold has increased by roughly 2% per year, and will increase even less than that over the next 2 years (just a paltry 1% a year.) It’s the players’ fault for agreeing to this in the previous CBA’s.

    The tax threshold was $174M from 2011-2013. If the tax threshold had kept pace with revenues, the threshold for 2019-2021 would be about $260M instead of $206-$211M. And it would be $283M for 2022-2024 based on the $189 tax threshold of 2014-2016. Believe you me, it ain’t gonna be $283M.

    The players negotiated poorly, and now the free agents are paying the price — and thus the “rising tide” of free agent contracts isn’t rising at all, isn’t lifting any other boats. So salaries have stagnated. And will continue to do so until the next CBA is negotiated better by the boys we pay to see.

    in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2019-2020 #79844
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Of course, during our vote, both Urias and Edman received some top 10 votes. Edman, Urias, Schrock, Sosa, and Young got some votes in the #11-15 phase. They all wound up in that 20-26 range. It’s not all that clear. Young only had 150 PAs at the AA level and will be 25 during the 2019 season. I don’t like his ML chances nearly as much as the other 4.”

    Agreed, Pads, re Andy Young. I can’t see any way to rate him above Tommy Edman or Edmundo Sosa — and especially not above Ramon Urias. What Young did in Arizona may have made him more marketable, but it didn’t change his profile one jot.

    The funny thing is that every year without fail, just before the Arizona Fall League commences, numerous national prospect-ranking voices (the scouty types, I mean) admonish us, their reading public, not to change our opinions of players based on events of the AFL. And then, every year without fail, they do that very thing themselves.

    “Oh, I didn’t change my previous opinion. My previous opinion was correct. The player had changed, when I saw him!” is their standard rationalization. Kiley McDaniel in particular indulges in that one a lot.

    Anyway, a quick comparison illustrates the multiple advantages Urias has over Young. (The head-to-head is very convenient, since they played on the same AA team at the same age within a handful of weeks.)

    In Springfield, Urias walked twice as often as Young. That’s huge of course, as walk rate gets more and more predictive for prospects the closer you get to the majors. And Urias also struck out less often than Young, posted a slightly better batting average and higher isolated slugging than Young, and showed better overall glovework than Young, with some ability to play shortstop in a pinch, as well.

    I’m not suggesting that Andy Young is negligible. But I believe that among position players Urias is the most underrated Redbird, and one of the 15 or 20 most underrated guys in all the minors, a plausible cusp-of-the-top 100 type. I expect him to rip through Triple-A in 2019.

    in reply to: What is wrong with Dexter Fowler and what should be done? #79674
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “This baby just may rival “War & Peace” in longevity before the last post is one day finally submitted on this controversial yet meaningful thread.”

    More like War & War for me, Mr. Addams. This thread really brings out my pugnacity.

    “His (Derrick Goold’s) chat sessions are almost unbearable for me because of all of his condescending replies. It seems to really trouble him to have to spend time trying enlighten all of the rubes out there in Cardinal land.”

    I almost feel a little sorry for him sometimes, gscott. Goold does seem to having less fun than he used to. But then, three years without the playoffs has somewhat soured the entire St. Louis baseball community, as it were. (It doesn’t help that the Rams left town and almost immediately became great.)

    The thing about Goold, I used to hold him in very high esteem. Good wordsmith, rigorous mind, patient with fans. But it looks like he’s been absorbed over the past couple of years by the Twitter sensibility, i.e., preferring feelings to facts. In a bizarre microcosm of his generalized decline, Goold refuses now to use classic vivid imagery to describe an outfielder’s powerful throwing arm. Won’t say “howitzer” or “cannon” or “rifle.” Might somehow hurt someone’s feelings by obliquely evoking notions of violence and militarism. Or some such blather. (Pointless aside: this reminds me of Keith Law saying he’ll never watch The Godfather because it depicts Italian Americans in an unfavorable light. Deep thinker, that guy. Mustn’t participate in anything that might have hurt anybody’s feelings, at any time.)

    But I do not respect the way that Derrick has tried to sell us Dexter — both as a ballplayer and as a suddenly sympathetic depressive. (Not clinically depressed, mind you. I mean, maybe clinically, but maybe not. The P-D writers & Fowler are conveniently playing that one both ways. But the important thing is that we should be sad, that Dexter is sad. Or was sad. And therefore we need to help make him un-sad. Because Dexter’s feelings are of course more important than all of his teammates put together. Dexter must be prioritized. And how do we make Dexter un-sad? We give him whatever he wants, like a screaming 3-year-old. We play him every day! Probably need to bat him near the top of the lineup, also. You know, for protection. (Not that the protection did him any good in 2018.)

    Goold wants us to believe Dexter was turning things around under Shildt, even as he admits there is scant evidence. Feelings over facts. Goold has contempt for everyone who wants Carpenter to hit leadoff — even though there is no evidence yet that he can hit anywhere else. Again, it isn’t the disagreement that is off-putting. It’s his unshakeable disdain, his CERTAINTY that he’s right and you’re wrong, even though every bit of objective evidence is in YOUR favor, not his. Feelings over facts.

    (It reminds me of when during a Q & A chat someone showed Ben Fredrickson the outstanding Redbird bullpen numbers during the six years under Derek Lilliquist. BenFred’s response was: “I don’t care about the numbers. I know the bullpen management was bad.” Again, feelings over facts.)

    Goold gives of his time. His chats are epic in length, and I applaud him — and Keith Law for that matter, and BenFred, for the identical reason. But God bless them all, I wish they’d all get off of Twitter and go pick up a copy of The Art Of Clear Thinking by Rudolf Flesch. And binge watch about 40 episodes of South Park, because that show has the best BS detector in TV history. And it does not truck with ideologues.

    “Bob, if the data is easy for you access, it would help to see the at-bats or plate appearances of the various outfielders during the key periods of time you mention – up to June 12 and then the next month until Matheny was fired. OPS is one view, but since the primary point is about playing time, that data would be important. Thanks.”

    I guess I’m a bit dense. I’m not sure precisely what you’re looking for, Brian. But anyway, I’ve bloviated and researched so much during the past 24 hours, I’m disinclined to say or do much more right now. Could you clarify, though? Gracias, Sir.

    in reply to: Brewers thread #79616
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Wow. If you include the surplus value of a 3rd round draft pick, it works out to be more like $20M for one year. These are not your father’s Brewers.

    Grandal’s thinking, I guess, is that he goes to Wisconsin, eats a variety of delicious cheeses*, has a good season, and during next winter’s free agency he doesn’t have a Qualifying Offer draft pick penalty to contend with.

    Milwaukee is now a tri-favorite for the division, in my mind. Strong division, the Central. It won’t be 2015 redux or anything, but I could see the Cards, cubs, and Brew Crew each winning 91-93 games.

    I only hope this motivates the Cards to make at least one more substantive upgrade to their team — preferably the bullpen. Have I mentioned that I think they should upgrade the bullpen?

    *If the shoppe carries his brand.

    in reply to: Jose Martinez thread #79615
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “10 or 20 yrs ago a consistent ‘opener’ would have been laughable. No telling where the game is going but I dont see stat sheet guys creating the mess.”

    I don’t have a canine in this skirmish, but I do wonder about the “opener” philosophy in general. It seems to me that the opener should be a very good reliever, because you’re asking him to face the top of the opposition order. And yet, your best 3 or 4 relievers should of course be saved for the higher leverage situations. And the first inning — even against the top of the order — would ordinarily be among the lowest leverage situations in a game. Wouldn’t it? So I guess I’m a bit baffled by the whole thing. And obviously too lazy to research it.

    Maybe someone here could clarify the underlying thought process. Thanks in advance.

    in reply to: What is wrong with Dexter Fowler and what should be done? #79614
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    I’m not fond of re-animating this thread, however I’m afraid it is necessitated by a recent statement from one of our local scribes. But before discussing that, a quick recap.

    This thread began way back on May 13th, when Dexter Fowler had a nightmarish .545 OPS. The participants of this website got it right, as they wanted Fowler to be either shunted into a platoon role, reduced to pinch-hitting exclusively, or traded/released before he could do any more damage to the team. (At VEB someone quite predictably used so-called advanced analytics to “prove” that Fowler was going to be much better any minute, because he’d merely had “bad batted ball luck.” If those folks over there were half as smart as they think they are, they’d be twice as smart as they actually are.)

    Anyway Matheny, stoic that he is, stuck with him. He kept him in the starting lineup for another entire month, during which Dexter raised that OPS all the way up to a dreadful .562. That brings us to June 12th, that fateful date.

    On June 12th here were the OPS numbers for Redbird outfielders:

    Jose Martinez .913
    Tommy Pham .786
    Tyler O’Neill .768 (He’d been in the minors since the end of May, though, where he had a 1.004 OPS)
    Harry Bader .767
    Marcell Ozuna .737
    Dexter Fowler .562

    And so, mercifully, finally, Fowler was benched. It is rumored that on June 12th the expression “better late than never” was spoken more frequently in the St. Louis metropolitan area than on any date since Jeff Fisher’s firing. After starting 48 of the first 64 games of the season, and being quite clearly the 6th-best outfield option, Dex was benched. (When I say 6th-best, I know I might be short-changing some of the AA and AAA guys who could easily have topped a .562 OPS. I apologize to them.)

    And now, gentle Redbird fans, Derrick Goold wants us to believe that Dexter Fowler was benched too soon. No, really. The craziest thing is, he endorses Fowler’s assertion that he was mistreated by Matheny when benched on June 12th — but in the next breath Goold astonishingly claims he isn’t taking any sides or expressing any opinion of his own. As an exercise in both illogic and hypocrisy, it was surreal to read. Excerpts:

    “I have not offered an opinion at all on these things, chiefly because I don’t really have one. What I have attempted to illustrate is that Fowler has a point when he talks about the inconsistent playing time.”

    If you believe that you “illustrate that Fowler has a point,” then by definition you are agreeing that he has a point in the first place. That’s a very important distinction. Goold is not simply articulating Fowler’s nonsensical point that he was benched too soon, and leaving it at that. No. Goold is expressly claiming that “Fowler has a point.” That’s a statement of opinion.

    “I have attempted to explore this notion by pointing out how his playing time shriveled in the month before Matheny’s firing, and that he did not get what he said he needed to get right.”

    There’s nothing to “point out.” Of course his playing time “shriveled.” He was benched. Rightly benched, after an horrific 2 1/2 month slump, with numerous better players available, for a team trying to make the postseason. There is no “notion” that needs to be “explored.”

    Fowler wanted an infinite amount of playing time to try and get right. That’s a natural and normal thing, for a professional athlete. And no, he did not get that infinite amount of time to get right. It is absolutely true that Fowler did not get the time that Fowler wanted. But Goold acts as though by definition this means that Fowler was ill-used. That Fowler “has a point.” And that makes zero sense.

    The real question isn’t “Why didn’t Fowler get more time to get right?” The real question is, “Why on earth did Matheny wait so long before finally benching him, with so many better choices available?”

    “I’ve taken no stance on whether Matheny’s move was correct or whether Fowler would have stirred from his slump giving the playing time. Again, I don’t have one. I just want to make it clear that Fowler has a point…”

    When you repeatedly state that someone “has a point” and you furthermore never present the other side of the argument, you are defacto taking a stance. And no, Fowler does NOT have a point. The mere fact that he was benched is NOT any sort of a POINT. At all.

    Because when Dexter Fowler was finally benched, every one of the four necessary conditions for benching a veteran professional athlete was quite clearly met:

    1) Veteran is playing very poorly
    2) Veteran has been given a lot of rope
    3) At least one clearly superior choice is available
    4) Every win matters

    If Fowler had been OPSing .670 or .690, maybe he would have a point — but again, he was at .562. With his good baserunning and below average defense, that made him one of the 3 or 4 worst players in major league baseball.

    If he’d been benched in early-mid May, perhaps then he’d have a point. But he was given until mid-June, nearly 40% through the season to snap out of it. (This was nothing like 2017, by the way. Not remotely similar. In 2017 Fowler’s OPS never dropped below .710 after May 8th, and never below .730 after May 28th.) If Goold believes that Fowler “has a point” then I’d really, really like to know exactly when the BBWAA prez thinks a guy on a negative 3 WAR pace should be benched.

    If, as with the Allen Craig/Oscar Taveras kerfuffle of 2014, the likely replacement for Fowler was also having a poor year, then maybe Dexter would have a point. But as shown above, five other Cardinal outfielders had an OPS at least 175 points above Fowler’s on the day he was removed from the starting lineup.

    Or finally, if the Cards hadn’t needed every win, then there might be an argument for Fowler. But as we all know, then as now, every win counts.

    I’m so glad that Al Gore invented the internet, because I might otherwise have spent the last hour drinking heavily or punching walls. This way I feel cleansed, much more like Peter Finch in Network — but for the computer generation!

    in reply to: Jose Martinez thread #79547
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Luhnow did a great job for the Cards. But I can’t see giving him credit for anything that happened since he left.

    And that would include the acquisitions of Wacha, Bader, DeJong, Hicks, O’Neill, Piscotty, Aledmys Diaz, Grichuk, Flaherty, Carson Kelly + Luke Weaver (or Goldschmidt if you prefer), Alex Reyes, and all of the young talent simmering in the minors right now. (Regardless of what Fangraphs is selling, the Cards have a top 6-8 farm system right now. Just like one year ago.)

    As for the Luhnow years and post-Luhnow years…well let’s look at the numbers. In a manner of speaking.

    Luhnow was obviously never the GM for St. Louis, so in a sense there were never really any “Luhnow years” per se. But let’s compare the post-Luhnow Cards to their immediate predecessor.

    The outstanding Tony LaRussa/Albert Pujols Cardinals averaged just over 90 wins during their 11 seasons together, which was the 3rd-best record in MLB. LaRussa and Pujols both left during the same offseason that took Luhnow to Houston. So what happened afterwards?

    The disappointing Mike Matheny/Matt Carpenter Cardinals averaged just over 90 wins during their 7 seasons together, which was the 3rd-best record in MLB.

    I kid you not.

    in reply to: Jose Martinez thread #79506
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Forgive my nitpicking, but I believe there was a minor typo in your post, Pugs. I think you meant to say that you were a fan of the Coryell Cardiac Cards. Dierdorf and Dobler, the Three Jims, Metcalf and Mel Gray. No worldly and devoted Redbird fan of a certain age could have a different football favorite.

    And Wiley, thanks for the gracious sentiments. I’ve ripped many of Mo’s moves over the past couple of years, and wouldn’t retract any of the criticisms.

    But I’m also not asking for his head on a platter, because his overall record remains among the best in the biz. He took over an aging, sub-.500 team after the 2007 season — and inherited a middling farm system as well.

    Despite that lowly starting point, since Mo took over the Cards have posted 11 straight winning seasons, with the 3rd-best overall record behind only the Yanks and Dodgers. The last 3 years have disappointed, but consider the following:

    From 2016-2018, 257 wins and no playoffs
    Frisco 2012-14, 258 wins and two World Championships.

    Sometimes being merely good during the regular season is enough. Sometimes not. (And Giants fans like Grant Brisbee claim that it’s the Cardinals that possess the Devil Magic. That’s a hot one.)

    in reply to: Opening Day roster 2019 #79499
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Okay, I’ll bite. If she’s right it’ll almost surely mean that (1)everyone’s healthy, (2)Tyler O’Neill is the 4th outfielder, and (3)Jose Martinez was traded for a much-needed relief pitcher.

    Those would all be very positive developments.

    Will they all come true? I think Ponce last year showed that he was done with the minors, nothing much really left to learn. Looks like a classic case of “decent starting MILB starting pitcher becomes solid reliever in the majors.” So I think he makes the team.

    Who would be dislodged then? Probably Leone, possibly Shreve. (Man would I love to hear a Redbird manager, coach, or executive at any level, just come out and say: “We don’t have to have multiple lefties in the bullpen. Not if the righties we have are very good, and can get lefty batters out.” It would be such a magical commonsense moment.)

    Jen L. lists Drew Robinson as a bench guy. Which reminds me of another quote I’d like to see: “Yes, Drew Robinson hits left-handed. but he’s has never hit major league pitching, not even a little, and he hasn’t hit this Spring Training. So we decided to go another direction for the bench. After all, handedness barely matters, really. And doesn’t matter at all, compared to talent.”

    I understand about a team potentially being too left-handed in hitters — because lefty bats can often be exploited when they face the real tough lefty arms. But the same is just not true of righty bats. True righty platoon hitters are much rarer than their lefty counterparts. So I think people (incl. the Redbird front office) are far too preoccupied with the idea of a lefty bench bat. If he stinks, what the heck good is it that he bats from one side or the other?

    Now I hasten to add that Robinson was worth a shot in the dark. He’s hit in AAA, no doubt about it. But if he doesn’t hit in Spring Training, after failing so dismally last year in MLB, then send someone else north with the team. Maybe they got another Hazelbaker, we’ll see. But if not, then let’s hope they don’t shoehorn him into the roster due to nothing more than handedness. That would be silly. To me.

    in reply to: 2019 TCN top 50 prospect list countdown #79467
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Okay, here’s some more Edmundo info.

    On April 26th the 22-year-old was hitting just .221/.229/.353 in AA. Over the next two months he hit nearly .300 with a roughly .800 OPS, earning a promotion to AAA, where he held his own for a couple of months with a boringly adequate line of .262/.321/.408. (Certainly adequate for a 22-year-old shortstop in the Pacific Coast League.)

    And that was in a pretty severe hitting environment, relative to the PCL.

    In Memphis: .198/.274/.256
    On the road: .314/.360/.533

    It was the addition of medium power that made his season interesting. The 30 doubles were more than he hit in 2016 and 2017 combined. The 12 homers equaled 2014 + ’15 + ’16 + ’17. What happened for Edmundo Sosa in 2018 was more or less what happened for Lane Thomas: Sosa had his first fully healthy season since leaving rookieball, and he drove the ball like never before.

    Sosa still has question marks, of course. The plate discipline indicators are weak, and obviously his health history remains a red flag. But I like him as an MLB utilityman going forward. Maybe a very good one, if he can add patience to his power. (Assuming he retains the latter.)

    in reply to: Brewers thread #79466
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Bob, if you want more, please scroll down to the Wainwright thread. He has explained his problem last year, which of course is taken care of now.

    I spoke to my doctor and he says I suffer from Wainwright Explanation Saturation. It’s a mostly harmless condition, but the doc advises me to avoid psychoactive drugs and Wainwright quotes — they’re bad for both brain and ticker.

    in reply to: 2019 closer/relievers thread – Miller + ? #79465
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Our starting pitcher depth chart AFTER the first five goes:
    Alex Reyes
    John Gant
    Austin Gomber
    Dan Poncedeleon
    Dakota Hudson

    Our bullpen will likely be Miller, Cecil, Gregerson, Leone, Hicks, Shreve, Mayers, Brebbia. After those (8), we would first backfill from the above (5)

    Then you get into the 40-man Triple-A relievers such as Giovanni Gallegos and Tyler Webb. Then you have Genesis Cabrera and Ryan Helsley.

    I am pretty comfortable with our bullpen beyond Cecil, Gregerson, and Leone.

    Thanks for the response, Pads. And I do wish I were as optimistic as you. (I like the bullpen okay for 2020 and beyond, because by then some of these guys will have separated themselves from the pack. And they’ll likely be adding Woodford & Kruczynski to the mix as well.)

    But for 2019 there just aren’t that many guys listed above who I’d bet even money will be (1)healthy for at least 5 of 6 months, and (2)will also post a sub-4.00 ERA for the Cards.

    Alphabetically, that would be Brebbia, Gant, Hicks, Hudson, Miller, and Ponce. That’s it, those six only. And Hudson or Ponce or both may stay stretched out in AAA, at least to begin the year.

    That’s why I coveted Kikuchi as much as I did. He would’ve pushed Wainwright to the pen — where he might actually be able to post a mid-3’s ERA for months on end. Then, add one more legit relief arm in exchange for Jose Martinez, or Martinez plus a prospect if necessary, and you have a mucho more reliable relief corps.

    I don’t know exactly what the White Sox (or Mariners) are thinking, but I suppose this makes a Nate Jones trade less plausible. Hard to tell who’s tanking these days. Perhaps they could each fly oversized flags outside their stadiums, but instead of an L or W, it could be a T.

    in reply to: 2019 TCN top 50 prospect list countdown #79458
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Kyle Reis is some guy. One minute he’s helping destroy the Terminator, and the next he’s making prospect lists.

    I don’t have Sosa in my top 10, but do have him 12th, and roughly 280th overall. I don’t have the numbers in front of me, but he had a long stretch of good hitting in AA — like his final two months there or so. Something of that nature. And he’s considered an actual shortstop. Nice boring average defender at the position, is the consensus I believe.

    Nunez is 6th for BPro and 28th for Fangraphs — who has the Cardinals as the worst of the 10 farm systems they’ve evaluated so far. Nice to see BPro not discounting Nunez too much for his excessive physical strength.

    in reply to: Wainwright or Ross in 2019 #79456
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    It’s been five years since Waino pitched 50+ innings with a sub-4.50 ERA. It ain’t all because of body weight.

    I was mildly optimistic when the Cards re-signed him. Because it was very little dough, and my personal expectation was that he could buttress the relief corps, maybe. I thought his velocity could get just enough of a bullpen boost to make him viable in that role.

    But now we’re hearing that he’ll report as a rotation pitcher (blecch) and the “best shape of my life” type of stories are starting already. You’re old, Adam. Forget starting. Go out the way you came in — saving the final game of the World Series.

    in reply to: Manny Machado thread #79454
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    After watching Machado grab, kick, and step on his opponents during the playoffs, perhaps the WWE would be interested in signing him?

    I’m betting on the Phightin’ Phillies, though.

    in reply to: Brewers thread #79450
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Well I hate that Bumgarner news, Brian. While you’re at it, why don’t you give me a nice paper cut and pour lemon juice on it?

    For me this would make the Brewers slight favorites to repeat as division winners, pending any additional Cards/Cubs activity. Milwaukee has decisively out-Cardinaled the Cardinals over the past 2-3 years, and this would seem to be yet another example in the offing. Shrewd and opportunistic, and upgrading where they need it most. (Unilke the Cards who have made one solitary move to improve the 2nd-worst bullpen in the National League. Sigh.)

    The Birds should be targeting Bumgarner themselves now that Kikuchi is off the board. Unless of course they believe — after all that’s happened over the past 3-4 years — that Adam Wainwright should be a starting pitcher on a championship contender. In which case they should have their collective heads examined.

    in reply to: Jose Martinez thread #79371
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Thanks for the kind words, Brian and BHC.

    in reply to: 2019 closer/relievers thread – Miller + ? #79342
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    I like the Redbird deal for Miller more than the Yankee Britton deal. Robertson’s deal is preferable to both, but that’s mostly moot since he was reported to strongly favor east coast teams — in much the same way that Kikuchi unfortunately was rumored to like the left coast best.

    Question is, who do the Cards target for the bullpen now? Because it is NOT good enough yet. Not enough quality or depth. Not when you figure that (1)at least one bullpen candidate and possibly two from among Gant, Gomber, Poncedeleon, and maybe even Dakota Hudson, will need to stay stretched out as a starter in Triple-A, and (2)some guy or guys will come up with a bum flipper during Spring Training.

Viewing 25 posts - 876 through 900 (of 1,093 total)

First-hand news and commentary on the St. Louis Cardinals™ and minor league system for over 25 years