Bob Reed

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 25 posts - 901 through 925 (of 1,093 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: What is wrong with Dexter Fowler and what should be done? #79300
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    I’m probably being naïve in this, but I’m mildly relieved that Girsch is at least presenting the façade of an actual Spring Training competition for the right field spot.

    The question becomes, if everyone is healthy leaving Florida, how much better than Fowler would Tyler O’Neill or Jose Martinez have to be, in order to claim the Opening Day RF slot? Would it require an advantage of 250 OPS points? 300? 400? Even more? (It’s likely a LaRussian style spring training competition, i.e., a competition in name only. But one can dream, can’t one?)

    in reply to: Jose Martinez thread #79218
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    I didn’t want to tack this on to the previous post. Probably enough info in that one already. But here, from Feb. 2016, was a thorough post of mine on Harrison Bader, including some pre-draft analysis from Rob Ozga, who’s very good at that sort of thing. Someone asked why I liked Bader as much as I did.

    —————————-

    Well, there’s a few things.

    Before the draft, I liked the way his hitting profile evolved through his 3 seasons at Florida. First year, he batted .312 while fanning just 9% of the time and managing a meager isolated slugging of .063. Next year, he hit .335 and bumped the ISO up a bit to .095 while whiffing 16% of the time. Then in 2015 it pretty much all came together, as his K% increased to an acceptable 19%, while his ISO improved all the way to .258, while batting .297 — a still-impressive batting average, given the level of competition in the SEC last year. Here was the prolific Rob Ozga’s pre-draft analysis:

    I want to say that Florida JR OF Harrison Bader can do a little bit of everything, but that would be a lie. Harrison Bader can do a lot of everything. He’s a legitimate five-tool player and I’ll fight anybody who says otherwise. I’d take him over any bat in the conference not named Bregman or Swanson without a second thought. Above-average raw power, above-average to plus speed, and the ability to play center make him a lot like Vanderbilt JR OF Rhett Wiseman to me, but with a markedly better approach at the plate. If he’s there in the second, it’s an easy call. Also, I’m not a scout and smarter people have disagreed with me, but I love his swing. It’s not conventionally pretty, but his lower half and upper half are coordinated really well and there’s just enough of an uppercut (but not too much) to suggest his power surge is real.

    And then Ozga again immediately before the draft:

    42. Florida JR OF Harrison Bader: plus to plus-plus speed; really good CF range; above-average arm; above-average raw power; quick bat; 5-11, 190 pounds

    So I liked it when St. Louis nabbed him in the 3rd round. And then I saw him play in Peoria (Midwest League) in July. I ‘m no judge of swings or plate discipline just by looking, but in the field/on the bases I saw a player both quick & fast, a real ath-uh-lete. Probably not 6’ tall, maybe not even 5’ 11″, but certainly strong enough to project for average or better pop.

    In Peoria, Bader did basically exactly what he did in college, playing CF well and hitting for a very good average and excellent power, posting a wRC+ of 152 via a slashline of .301/.364/.505. Now, minor league wRC+ numbers do not include park factors, and Bader’s home park is generally considered at least a bit of a drag on offense; in fact, on the road he hit a whopping .351/.415/.586. So even the excellent 152 wRC+ may be underestimating his abilities compared to league peers.

    Here’s John’s profile from September: https://www.minorleagueball.com/2015/9/18/9346637/prospect-on-the-rise-harrison-bader-of-st-louis-cardinals

    So I see a guy who has a lot going for him, in pretty much every phase except plate patience. (Just 15 walks in over 200 MWL at-bats.) With a better BB/K ratio, he’d be in my overall top 40-50 right now. As it is, I can’t see any way of keeping him off a top 100 list, and would personally put him in the 65-80 range.

    by Mekonsrock on Feb 29, 2016 | 12:35 AM up 3 recs flag

    in reply to: Jose Martinez thread #79217
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Thanks for the response, Brian. I’m very glad you brought up Bader’s splits, because I want to talk about those. And yes, I am and was suggesting the Cards should not have even considered signing Fowler, not to any sort of long term deal. Because they already very likely had their centerfielder of 2018 and beyond. (Bader was NOT going to be ready at the start of the 2017 season. I would never claim that. But he was clearly going to be ready soon, and Fowler was too old and too mediocre to justify any contract substantially exceeding the one he signed with the Cubs pre-2016. (One short year and a measly 8 million bucks, I believe. Cubs got it right.)

    But I want you to be sure there is no “Monday morning QBing” going on. So here are some of the innumerable comments I made about Bader while he was in the minors. These are each mined from the now defunct John Sickels site.

    Late August, 2015, the year Bader was drafted:

    Of the 23 college bats drafted ahead of Bader, only 9 have even advanced to full season ball. Very encouraging — for Bader AND DeJong.
    I like Bader as a potential Victorino, or at least Victorino Lite.

    Posted by Mekonsrock on Aug 25, 2015 | 2:41 PM

    So you can see my early interest and enthusiasm.

    ——————————–

    From March of 2016:

    Per Fangraphs, a total of 2,781 minor leaguers garnered at least 150 plate appearances last year.
    Of those 2,781 players, only two guys had double-digit homers while going yard at least once every 7 games, stealing a base at least once per 5 games, fanning less than 20% of the time, and batting at least .280.

    One was Carlos Correa. The other was Harrison Bader.

    While the two are of course NOT truly comparable talents, the above numbers do help put Bader’s fine (and admittedly abbreviated) 2015 season into context. There’s a very appealing balance of skills there, and if Bader plays CF as well as the scouting reports and available MiLB defensive metrics imply, he’ll be an up-the-middle defender for quite a while.

    by Mekonsrock on Mar 11, 2016 | 2:17 AM flag

    ——————————-

    Next, June of 2016.

    Yeah, Eloy’s got a bit of the “Harrison Bader problem,” where the BB/K/AB ratio puts people off — probably more than it should.
    Jimenez and Bader are both top 45-60 types for me. (With room to move up 10-15 slots over the next two months, too.)

    Posted by Mekonsrock on Jun 19, 2016 | 5:23 PM

    So there you see a ranking range, midway through the 2016 season. Note the “room to move up” remark, as well. Because they both did in fact move up. Eloy for everyone. Bader just for me, apparently.

    ————————————

    By September of 2016 Bader was top 50 for me.

    With his 143 wRC+ at age 21 in AA, Bader is still a top 40-50 guy for me despite the poor AAA stint. I’d give him a solid 30% chance to be an annual 3-4 WAR guy over his prime. That feels like bottom of a top 50.
    Posted by Mekonsrock on Sep 7, 2016 | 8:33 PM

    Yes, I was the voice in the wilderness. Even just one year ago, Fangraphs barely had Bader inside their top 200. (Kinda like now, when they don’t have Elehuris Montero inside their top 250. But their bizarrely biased incompetence with Cardinals is a topic for another day.)

    —————————————–

    If you have access, Brian, to the Dexter Fowler post-signing thread of December, 2016, you’ll find me vehemently arguing that the advantage of Fowler over Bader, during the total run of the 5-year contract, would be ONE GAME in the standings for the Redbirds. One game. For $82M plus the surplus value of a mid first round draft pick. (I vividly specifically recall going overboard a little and estimating that surplus draft pick value at over $15M, just so I could say that Fowler cost the Cards ~$100M for one win. Nice round number, $100M.)

    This “one game for $100M” conclusion was based on a combination of standard aging curves, plus Clay Davenport’s projections for Dex and Harry. Find the thread if you can. Because I was indeed in the wilderness when I made that statement, even though I backed it up with much more than opinion. People did not want to hear it. BikeMike agreed with me at the time. Don’t think anyone else did. Well, I’m sure at least a couple of folks did. But I don’t remember them by name. People wanted Fowler. World Series ring! Steal him from our rival! By and large, people mean well. Like 90-95% of the time. But in many instances they also cannot be reasoned with, unfortunately.

    Anyway now it seems I very likely underestimated Bader. Which brings me, at long last, to the subject of splits.

    Bader had a good season at Springfield but it was EXTREMELY imbalanced. His OPS against LHP was 1.224. Against RHP, his line was a mediocre .249/.319/.377/.697.

    The line v. righties is correct, but Bader actually did this against lefties in AA: .426/.485/.1.000

    That’s no typo. in A-ball in 2015, he did this against southpaws: .419/.468/.907
    And in AAA in 2017 it was .389/.456/.778

    Yes, he likes lefties. And that line versus righties in AA? It was .249/.319/.377, right? You’re probably going to think I’m pulling your leg, but The Texas League average that year was .249/.316/.378.

    So what we have is a batter who is average against same-siders and absolutely destroys oppo arms. On balance that’s a very good hitter. Like a football team that plays .500 on the road, but wins all their home games.

    Only one year removed from college ball, and just 21/22 years old, Bader did indeed struggle in his first taste of Triple-A in 2016, as you mentioned, Brian. Then he was much better in his second try. Same with the majors. Struggled in 2017, and a bit above average in 2018.

    And we should expect him to be above average going forward, because here is a very telling split that people should be focusing on a lot more, in my opinion.

    2018 for the Cardinals
    Home .357 slugging, and a .678 OPS
    Road .492 slugging, and an .840 OPS

    And before anyone asks, that excellent road number was in no way padded by Coors or some other hitter’s haven. (He didn’t homer once in Colorado.) His four best road parks were Atlanta, San Diego, KC, and Frisco. In just 38 combined AB’s he homered 7 times.

    Harrison Bader is the Cardinals’ Lorenzo Cain. Like Cain, never a top 100 prospect. Like Cain, a lot of value in CF and on the bases. Like Cain, hits lefties much better than normals. Like Cain, he can be a 4-WAR guy as nothing more than a league-average hitter. Let us embrace our Bader.

    in reply to: Jose Martinez thread #79205
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    But isn’t the “textbook rationalization” also what is behind your assumption they would start Fowler for close to 100 more games before taking him out of the lineup?

    “They did it last year, so they will do it again this year.”

    Good question.

    One case is about athletic ability, expecting a player to repeat a specific hitting trait, despite the fact that (1)some element of hitting is random, and (2)hitters all decline eventually, often precipitously, especially in their 30’s. Dexter Fowler is almost by definition a different (and very likely lesser) hitter entering his mid-30’s than he was just a few years ago. (This is expressed most starkly by Fowler’s inability over the past two years to hit “power pitchers” as categorized by Baseball-Reference, after being just fine against them over his career.) So expecting Fowler to do what he did in the past, is folly. To me.

    The other case is much more about human nature, expecting an individual (Shildt) or group (front office) to keep doing the same thing they’ve done in the very recent past, unless they’ve expressed an understanding that the first time they did it, it was a mistake. Shildt and Mo have never expressed any understanding whatever that either the Fowler contract was a mistake, or that re-inserting Fowler in the starting lineup in mid-July was a mistake.

    Now, I know what your reply might be here. “Of course they’re not going to say those things in public.” And that’s true. But the other reason I don’t trust them to do the smart thing, is that front office has also shown zero sense that they understand how good O’Neill is — just like 12 and 24 months ago when they showed no sense of how good Harrison Bader was. If they’d known what they had in Bader after 2016 when he dominated Double-A at age 21, they would never have flushed all of the Fowler money down the toilet.

    Warning. Pointless belligerent aside coming.

    (And it all flows from John Mabry. Mabry stunk as a hitting coach. So young Cardinals were failing to develop, over and over again. Adams, Wong, Grichuk, Piscotty, Diaz. But the front office did not understand the cause and effect. They thought [and maybe still think] that their minor leaguers simply weren’t as good as their minor league performances made them appear. So 24 and 12 months ago they severely underestimated Harry Bader; and maybe worse, eventually they fired their highly successful pitching coach, and they retained the worse-than-useless Mabry.)

    The mere fact that they’ve declared not an open competition for right field — no, not that, can’t have that — but rather that the suddenly sensitive Dexter Flower, that delicate depressive personage, will instead be handed the starting job right now, is in and of itself ample evidence to me that the organization is prioritizing Dexter’s happiness to a literally insane degree.

    in reply to: Jose Martinez thread #79199
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    I hear you, Brian. But I really, really don’t want to talk about how long they go with a struggling Fowler, because I don’t think there’s a limit, honestly. I think he could be bad, and stick all year.

    Fowler was as terrible as just about any player in the sport in 2018. And yet it took Matheny nearly 2 1/2 months to finally bench him. And then, a month later, Shildt comes in and puts him back in the starting lineup. It was mad, and maddening.

    Fowler probably won’t be that terrible again in 2019 — but if he’s a .680-.720 OPS guy, as I fear he will be, that would only embolden the club to keep his replacement-level play in the starting lineup indefinitely.

    But okay, I’ll go along with the premise, sort of.
    Let’s say that Fowler is exactly as execrable in 2019 as he was in 2018. I think that Shildt keeps him in the starting lineup until the All-Star break. (He must of course keep Dexter in the starting lineup markedly longer than Matheny did in 2018, or Derrick Goold will call Shildt a meanie, will say that Shildt makes Dexter depressed. Can’t have that, as Dexter’s emotional well-being is obviously the key to the entire organization. Just ask Goold.)

    Now, how long should they go with the 33-year-old Fowler, if he hits like 2018 again? One month, that’s it. Too many good alternatives to stick with him longer than that.

    And please don’t anyone tell me about how Dexter Fowler was slumping during some period of some other season, and then turned it all around. That argument could be used to defend any excessive use of any aging failing player in any season. “Remember when he had a bad streak that one time, then got much better?!” Textbook rationalization.

    On the Martinez matter, I would trade Jose for a very good reliever — even if I had to include a prospect as a sweetener. I’ve listed lots of trade targets over the past several weeks. If anyone asks me to list them again, I will. But I feel like I’ve beaten that deceased equine more than once.

    in reply to: Jose Martinez thread #79196
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “If we have to stash O’Neill in Memphis for awhile that is a good problem to have. Most teams would like that kind of depth.”

    It’s great to have depth, couldn’t agree more. But given the events of the past 12 months, and their respective long term major and minor league track records, if Fowler is in the Opening Day lineup and O’Neill is demoted back to AAA after batting .311/.385/.693 for Memphis in 2018, something is terribly wrong with the StL manager & front office.

    The thing of it is, as both the fans and front office very well know, the Cardinals figure to need every single win they can get in 2019. And Tyler O’Neill projects as their 2nd or 3rd-best overall outfielder, depending whether you look at the Davenport or Steamer forecast. (For that matter, Davenport has him in a virtual tie with Ozuna for best outfielder on the roster.)

    In 2018 Mo & Co. kept Hudson and Poncedeleon down in Memphis for faaar too long, stubbornly trying to get full value from several bad reliever contracts. That obstinance, coupled with Fowler’s eyesore of a season, inarguably cost the team a playoff spot.

    If the front office did not learn anything from that experience, then a pox on their house.

    in reply to: Baseball America Cardinals prospect rankings #79178
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    I’m one of those who may be underrating him, cranny. But a reliever-only, who’s well on the wrong side of 25 already, generally has so little upside that he isn’t worth talking about. For me.

    Or another of putting it, the Yankees are a very shrewd organization, and they didn’t even give him a Sept. callup until age 25/26, in his 6th year in their system. Probably a symptom of something. Not for sure, but probably.

    As for those harsh words from the chat, Pads…I agree with Glaser at least 90% in every instance. In fact it was refreshing to read a BA chat where so much common sense was being applied — instead of a near fanatical clinging to ancient scouting reports of dubious merit.

    I’m not completely giving up on Seijas, not at his age, not before he’s even been given a shot at bullpen work, which has had a salutary effect on so many arms through the years. But scrawny Johnny Machado failed dismally at two levels above rookieball, and Delvin Perez has turned out to be nothing, and I think we all understand why. I don’t have any of the three in my top 30 Cardinals. Seijas would be top 35-40 or so.

    in reply to: Baseball America Cardinals prospect rankings #79115
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    1. Reyes an overall top 10 prospect still in Glaser’s eyes.
    2. Cards “comfortably in top half” of team ranks, with 5 top 100 guys.
    3. Gorman compared to Moustakas (blech), a .240-.250 hitter. O’Neill in the same hit category.
    4. Montero .280+, 25HR+ but will be 1B or LF.
    5. Mateo Gil singled out as a potential 2019 breakout.
    6. Ivan Herrera a bad defender, even considering his age.
    7. No one to compare Nunez to, because you shouldn’t comp 17 y/o players.

    1) I still have Reyes number 1, but for me there’s no way that someone with his injury history should be in a top 10. I’ve got him ~35th.

    2) BA includes Tyler O’Neill among the Redbird prospects, so the farm would be top 4-6 with his inclusion. Best collection of power hitters in the minors, and it’s not close. Gorman, O’Neill, Montero, Leandro Cedeno, Malcom Nunez, Jhon Torres, and even Lane Thomas and Ramon Usias could be loosely categorized as “power hitters.” And who knows how much pop Dylan Carlson will have at maturity. (Davenport says 25 homers or so.) Without Tyler O’Neill, the farm should rate roughly between 6th and 9th.

    3) The Moustakas comment was mildly disheartening, but a .240-.250 average isn’t as bad as it would’ve been just a decade ago. This year’s N.L. average? Only .247. In 2008, it was .260. If Gorman and O’Neill can hit .250 with 40 homers, that’s exactly equivalent to the .280 average and 25 bombs forecast for Elehuris Montero. (Every ten points of batting average is worth five homers, for a full time player.) And in 2018, over 600 plate appearances, that would be an OPS+ or wRC+ of roughly 130-140, depending on the doubles/triples/walk rate.

    4) Even at first or a corner outfield, that’s still excellent production. See #3. Or just look at Anthony Rizzo. Last five years he’s posted a 141 wRC+ and averaged 4.5 WAR per Fangraphs.

    5) With sooo many youngsters to choose from, Mateo Gil would never have popped into my head as a prime breakout candidate. But he was just 17 in the Gulf Coast League, and that’s a tough place for a young guy, and he did post league-average numbers. I just don’t see any speed or pop to build upon. Did show good patience for a kid, though. And it’s probably meaningless, but in a truly miniscule sample of 50+ PA’s he did perform very well when batting leadoff (.362 with a .901 OPS and a lucky 7/11 BB/K ratio).

    6) Herrera had a lot of passed balls, but just one error, and he gunned a firm third of basestealers, so I don’t know how Ivan’s arm was “fringey” or “marginal” or whatever it was that BA’s Mr. Glaser called it. (In 2017 he had too many errors, but gunned 40%. There’s requisite defensive talent for backstop — and if there isn’t, the bat he’s shown so far will play anywhere at all. (Two seasons, young for both leagues, and a wRC+ of 155 in 2017 was the bad year.)

    7) Perhaps I’m being unfair, but that feels like a cop-out, and a weird one coming from a “scouty” place like Baseball America. Every scout who sees him will draw upon their expansive storehouse of knowledge & memories to place his strength, swing, balance, bat speed into some sort of context — and that context is usually going to be a comp. I’ll do it, because I’m irresponsible anyway. I think the kid is going to hit like prime Allen Craig, roping line drives all over the field. (Sorry, Black Hills.)

    “If Montero is our best hit for average player and he is only around .280 then we have a problem.”

    Don’t worry about that, CC. The best hitter for average will probably be Knizner, Nunez, or Herrera. One of them will crowd the .300 mark at least once or twice. And again, .285 these days is like .300 just a decade ago. Standards have shifted, for now anyway.

    in reply to: 2019 Carlos Martinez #79037
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Thanks for the kind words, Pugs. And a happy new year!

    And funny coincidence, not ten minutes ago I just said more or less the same thing on another thread, re Alex Reyes.

    in reply to: 2019 TCN top 50 prospect list countdown #79036
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Seems like RB didn’t trust Reyes to not be injured, and did like the upside of the other guys. Personally I can’t see any reason anyone would put Reyes any lower than #2, and that’s only if you are dreaming on Gorman becoming a good 3B with a big bat.”

    Well I still have Reyes #1, if just barely. But I can understand why a rationally frustrated and perhaps somewhat pessimistic (fatalistic?) analyst would place him considerably lower.

    I understand it, but disagree with it. The thing is, Reyes was SO amazing during his rehab appearances, that I perceive his ceiling as now probably higher than it’s ever been — although, rather paradoxically, achieving that ceiling is lower in likelihood than ever, due to Reyes’ injury inclinations. In the past, his inefficiency, the lack of command, always made him a #2 upside guy for me. Now however, if he’s not physically broken, in my opinion he could be a Cy Young type.

    I don’t imagine anyone here needs a reminder, but the rehab games totaled 23 innings and featured an otherworldly 44-to-7 strikeout/walk tally (and as a bonus, just 7 base hits). He fanned 26 of the 49 batters in the two AA and AAA starts. Alex hadn’t shown anything like that sort of domination since his final month of Low-A ball, when he had a 38/6 K/BB over 25 innings pitched.

    Maybe my glasses are Cardinal-colored, but with the recent seasons of Tommy Pham and Marco Gonzales, I’m less quick to give up on “injury guys.” For a bigger talent, I’ll cross my fingers and hope for health. So I’m giving Alex Reyes one more year. If on the other hand he comes up badly injured this Spring Training, and is therefore still eligible for prospect lists 12 months from now, he’ll get a HUGE downgrade from me. Almost surely lower than 6th.

    in reply to: Yadi Molina, 54 WAR and maybe more #78807
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Didn’t want to start a whole new thread, since this Molina “update” ties in with the topic. For those who don’t already know, Baseball Prospectus has updated their hitter values, based on their new batting metric, the name of which escapes me at the moment.

    By this shiny new yardstick, Yadi Molina gets a nearly 10% boost to his career WAR, but Harrison Bader has his MLB value, and value at every level of the minors for that matter, almost gutted. So I suspect that what’s going on here is that B-Pro’s exciting new acronym is over-correcting for outliers of infield hits/BABIP — and said over-correcting excessively helps the slowest of slowpokes while stealing from the Baders of the world.

    Anyway, this metric being applied by B-Pro to Yadi and (presumably) his fellow backstops, shouldn’t give any one individual player any meaningful advantage. They pretty much all run like catchers, right? So here are the top 10 tools of ignorance wearers, by career WAR, per B-Pro’s latest update:

    Carlton Fisk… 77.1 WAR
    Yogi Berra… 73.4
    Johnny Bench… 72.9
    Mike Piazza… 70.6
    Gary Carter… 67.7
    Yadi Molina… 59.2
    Ivan Rodriguez… 57.9
    Bill Dickey… 53.2
    Mickey Cochrane… 53.0
    Ted Simmons… 52.1

    The other Hall Of Fame catchers for whom B-Pro has WAR values, range from 33.3 career WAR for Rick “maybe they meant to phone my brother” Ferrell, to 46.7 WAR for Gabby “gloamin’ homer” Hartnett.

    All in all, the 12 HOF catchers with B-Pro WAR values (the other two are Campy & Lombardi) score an average of 57.7 career WAR. Toss out the high and low men, and the average is 58.2. Keep the high and low, but toss the two probable PED cheats, and the average becomes 56.6.

    So any way we slice it, Yadi Molina with his 59.2 WAR definitely belongs with this Hall Of Fame group.

    (For the sake of completeness, the other six enshrined backstops are Roger Bresnahan, Buck Ewing, King Kelly, Biz Mackey, Louis Santop, and Ray Schalk.)

    in reply to: Bryce Harper thread #78804
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    I just want mostly to echo Brian’s thoughts: thanks for all the math, CC!

    I do enjoy speculating on all things baseball, so…looking at that prospective roster, I’d replace Harper with O’Neill, Gomber with Mikolas, and Reyes with Kikuchi. Reyes is pushed to the bullpen. O’Neill’s bench slot is likely filled by Randy Arozarena or Justin Williams or Lane Thomas.

    CC’s powerful lineup would almost surely lead the National League in runs scored, and maybe all of baseball. But I’m not crazy about the rotation or bullpen — and I also don’t like what’s happening in the minors right now, in terms of twirlers. There’s a non-zero chance that 12 months from now the top 16-18 Cardinal minor leaguers will all be position players.

    The top 4 pitchers could all lose rookie eligibility by then (Reyes, Hudson, Helsley, Cabrera), and the fifth just got suspended for abject idiocy. (I do think Angel Rondon is being overlooked by many. The fastball velocity and curveball snap were both average or better when I saw him this summer. Couldn’t tell if the third pitch was a slider or straight change, but he began to show some feel for it after the 3rd inning or so. A solid 4/5 starter is not unrealistic with lucky health.)

    in reply to: Jose Martinez thread #78801
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    I think Davenport’s projection model continues to punish Jose Martinez for his uneven and quite lengthy minor league track record. I agree entirely that it is too conservative, given what Martinez has done in MLB over the past two years.

    2017 .309 with an .897 OPS
    2018 .305 with an .821
    Davenport 2019 50th percentile .266 with a .749 OPS

    On the other hand, it’s one of the things I do like about Davenport’s model in general — it does clearly give a LOT of weight to minor league performance when forecasting MLB hitters. Much more so than Steamer, ZiPS, and other publicly available projection systems.

    But in this case it bites Jose in the backside. Not unlike the fairly bleak 2019 Max Muncy forecast.

    Max Muncy 2018 MLB actual line: .263/.391/.582
    Davenport 2019 50th percentile .244/.356/.450

    Just for kicks, here are some other notables, with their Davenport 2019 50th percentiles per 600 PA’s. (Bearing in mind of course that some will get many fewer trips to the plate than that.)

    Paul Goldschmidt 5.0 WAR
    Matt Carpenter 4.2
    Kolten Wong 4.2
    Tommy Pham 4.2
    Yadi Molina 3.8
    Jedd Gyorko 3.6
    Paul DeJong 3.0
    Luke Voit 2.4

    Davenport’s system doesn’t like DeJong’s glovework nearly as much as, well, everybody else. But still, nothing shabby about a 3-win player. It just looks a little weak compared to the rest of the lineup.

    Looking back, in late July when Mo wanted to get Harry Bader back into the lineup after Shildt removed him for Dexter Fowler, maybe instead of trading Tommy Pham it would have been better for Mo to simply release Dexter, and ever-so-subtly recommended to Mr. Shildt to start Ozuna, Bader, and Pham. But maybe that’s just me.

    in reply to: Jose Martinez thread #78725
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “I really hope they don’t bump O’Neill down to AAA to carry Martinez and Gyorko though.”

    Presented without comment, the 2019 Clay Davenport 50th percentile projections for some Cardinal outfielders, on a per 600 plate appearance basis.

    Marcell Ozuna 3.7 WAR
    Tyler O’Neill 3.6
    Harrison Bader 2.9
    Dexter Fowler 1.9
    Justin Williams 1.5
    Randy Arozarena 1.3
    Jose Martinez 0.8
    Lane Thomas 0.7
    Jose Adolis Garcia 0.0

    in reply to: Bryce Harper thread #78724
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    …and I could have but did not mention three other variables that favor the pitching troika over Bryce Harper.

    1) Cards almost surely don’t have to offer opt-outs to the pitchers

    2) No loss of draft pick/budget with hurlers

    3) No commitment beyond the five years, with the twirlers

    The third point might be the most important, as I just glanced at Harper’s Baseball-Reference page and noticed that his “most similar player by age” for each of the past three seasons has been Andruw Jones — who aged exceptionally poorly after age 30. Nearly 60 WAR in his 20’s and fewer than 5 WAR in his 30’s. Sure, it likely means nothing. But it doesn’t help.

    in reply to: Bryce Harper thread #78723
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Bob, for me, it is a simple equation. Harper is worth between 4.5 and 5 wins.”

    I value Harper lower than this, based on Fangraphs and Baseball-Reference. The only way I can see to possibly value him as a 4.5 to 5 WAR player is to look at his collective last 4 seasons only. Not the last 3 or 5 or 6 or 2. Just 4 and only 4. (Over the last 3 seasons for example, he’s averaged a mere 2.5 at B-Ref and 3.8 at Fangraphs.)

    For his seven year career, Harper has averaged 3.9 WAR at B-Ref and 4.4 per Fangraphs. If we remove his outlying worst and best season at each website, he’s averaged just 3.3 WAR at B-Ref and 4.0 at F-G. This does not look like a generational, transformational player to me. At best, he’s apparently a 4.4 WAR guy, and at worst a 3.3 talent. Again, that’s not ME talking. That’s the two most respected player valuation websites.

    “Harper is a moot point. I already said many times why I prefer to sign Harper but I am a minority of one.”

    No need to repeat your arguments for my sake. I just wanted to frame the discussion in a very specific either/or manner, to clarify the waters a bit. I’d take Harper in a vacuum, too. In fact I’d happily sign the guy for $22M a year, at up to 12 years. But he’s not signing for that.

    “If the Cardinals really want to get better and the Front Office has intimated that they do then let’s do both.“

    I cannot argue against accruing talent. But the point of the exercise was to choose, because every team, even the Yankees, Dodgers, and Cubs with their truly massive revenues, has to make choices. As the philosopher observed: you can’t have everything, where would you put it?

    But okay, how about another Harperthetical. Would you rather invest $350M for 10 years of Bryce right now…or invest $500M for 10 years of Mike Trout, starting two years from now? Me, I prefer the latter, and it’s not remotely close.

    Thanks so much for ALL of the responses, guys!

    in reply to: Molina announces Pena's return for 2019 #78719
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Oh, okay. Thanks much everyone, for all the clarifications/feedback.

    My only concern remains the same as 24 hours ago. I hope Mike Shildt understands that he should not ever again start Yadi for 27 games in a row — much less during the summer dog days.

    Yadi career OPS splits by month:
    April through July, all between .721 and .728
    August .797
    Sept./Oct. .742

    Yadi 2018 splits
    April through July, all between .746 and .854
    August .664
    Sept. .672

    Has Shildt publicly admitted yet that he screwed up last year with the 27-in-a-row? It wouldn’t be much of an admission, since everyone already knows it. (Of course the Post-Dispatch won’t ever mention it, since criticizing Shildt in any manner could be construed somehow as vaguely indirectly wordlessly praising Matheny, and we certainly can’t have that.) I’d like to see Shildt show some understanding of the Yadi situation.

    in reply to: Bryce Harper thread #78704
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Just a quick question for the Bryce Harper advocates.

    Would you rather the Cards invest $175M on the next 5 years of Bryce Harper…

    OR invest the same $175M on:

    2 years of Andrew Miller ($25M) plus 5 years of Miles Mikolas ($85M) plus 5 years of Yusei Kikuchi ($65M)?

    Based on the Cards’ current talent in the majors and minors in terms of pitchers and outfielders, I would personally much rather load up on the arms if given the choice.

    in reply to: Molina announces Pena's return for 2019 #78699
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “That’s hilarious. Some people on here are about to go into fits of apoplexy, I’m guessing.”

    I enjoy getting upset, about baseball. But what should I be upset about?

    The fact that Pena is back? Or that Yadi hasn’t adhered strictly enough to recuperation protocols? Or that Yadi might want to return after the 2020 season? None of these surprise or upset me very much, if at all.

    Or is it something else? I apologize for my obtuseness.

    in reply to: 2019 ST. LOUIS CARDINALS TOP PROSPECTS VOTING #78694
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    I would have left Carlson in Peoria for more than a couple of weeks this year…but other than that, I’d say the Redbirds have handled him okay.

    I do agree with Pads, in that I’d like to see Dylan get plenty of high minors seasoning. (Heaven knows the club has outfielders aplenty in AAA and the majors right now.) We shouldn’t look down our noses at what DC managed to do as a teenager in the Florida State League, however. His BB/K was distinctly better than Ryan Braun had at age 22 in the FSL, and his isolated power topped both Bagwell and Big Frank Thomas in the same league when they were each 21. Here are some details:

    Dylan Carlson at 19 in the FSL, .136 isolated slugging overall and .158 in the 2nd half.
    Elehuris Montero at 19, .122 ISO.
    Frank Thomas at 21, also .122
    Bagwell at 21, .109 ISO.
    Ryan Braun at 22, 23/54 BB/K
    Matt Carpenter at 23 batted .219/.286/.342 with a mediocre 10/24 BB/K

    I don’t mean to imply that Montero or Carlson will be stars — best bet, they’ll be solid regulars instead. Just wanted to illustrate with historical context what you guys already knew: it can be very hard for anyone to hit baseballs in the Florida State League.

    in reply to: 2019 Carlos Martinez #78613
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Carlos became an MLB starting pitcher in 2015.

    Here’s a list of pitchers who’ve thrown more innings, with a lower ERA than Carlos, since 2015:

    Kershaw, Scherzer, DeGrom, Kluber, Sale, Greinke, Verlander, Arrieta, and somehow Kyle Hendricks. So that’s the entire list of pitchers who’ve definitely been better than Carlos since he became a starter 4 years ago. Except for the sore thumb inclusion of Hendricks, it’s nothing but stars and superstars. Mostly superstars.

    I don’t blame anyone for hating the dumb hair color. But let’s not equate Carlos’ hair or Yadi’s neck tattoos or Wainwright’s dugout dancing with a lack of commitment to craft. Could Carlos be better? Almost certainly. Is he terrific as is? Also almost certainly.

    We are lucky to have him.

    in reply to: 2019 closer/relievers thread – Miller + ? #78612
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Please don’t take this as a criticism, CC. But why do you believe that the Brewers aren’t already contenders?

    Not only did they of course win the Central in 2018, they also led the N.L. in victories, didn’t lose much to free agency, and could get Jimmy Nelson back in 2019. (I know, it’s probably just that you and I differ somewhat in our use of the word “contender.” I suspect you’re more strict than I.)

    At any rate, here are the very latest World Series favorites at Sportsbetting.ag

    Dodgers… 6-1
    Red Sox… 7-1
    Astros… 7-1
    Yankees… 7-1
    Cards… 12-1
    cubs… 12-1
    Brewers… 12-1
    Braves… 14-1
    Injuns… 14-1
    Phils… 16-1
    Nationals… 20-1
    Rockies… 25-1
    Mets… 28-1

    https://www.sportsbetting.ag/sportsbook/futures-and-props/mlb-futures

    So 3 of the top 4 are A.L. franchises, but 8 of the next 9 are N.L.. And I can’t disagree. But it’s still rather weird to see the odds reflect this peculiar reality. The numbers are generally about right, I’d say. And IF the Birds add Yusei Kikuchi in the next week or so, they become the division favorites in my mind. (Obviously the same could be said for the Brewers, unfortunately.)

    in reply to: 2019 ST. LOUIS CARDINALS TOP PROSPECTS VOTING #78588
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Do the Cards keep Carlson at PB, or do they move the 20-year-old to the more hitter-friendly AA Texas League?”

    Oh, I think it’s nearly a fait accompli that he’s going to Springfield to start the season, Ny. Barring injury, anyway.

    Despite superficially uninteresting numbers in 2018, Carlson was an above average hitter (112 wRC+) for the Florida State League — and moreover he was markedly better during the second half.

    First half: .237/.333/.341
    Second half: .253/.352/.411

    That .352/.411 would be a roughly 120 wRC+, and it came with a sturdy 34/50 BB/K ratio. Solid enough for any budding corner outfielder, and terrific for a teenaged one in that league.

    in reply to: Bryce Harper thread #78206
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Maybe I’m being unfair, but I think Puig’s head is going to explode, going from a first place Hollywood team to the cellar-dwelling Reds — who will remain cellar-dwellers, despite the additions.

    Brian said it best. The Cincy pitching is flat out bad. (And I’ll be shocked if the Kemp renaissance continues. The 34-year-old has been worth a total of 0.5 WAR over the past 4 years. The Dodgers sold high on him, for sure.)

    Reds improve by 2-3 games, maybe 4. Which is a lot! But they need a lot more.

    in reply to: 2019 closer/relievers thread – Miller + ? #78196
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Those rankings surely do not include Reyes or Hudson.”

    The rankings do include Hudson, but they do not include Alex Reyes. (One failing of projection models is that they do not — as far as I know — take into account an extreme groundball pitcher like Dakota Hudson. They see his miniscule HR rate as largely luck rather than talent.)

    “Joakim Soria has been signed by the A’s.
    I would be all in on a Will Smith trade though!”

    Thanks for the Soria update, gscott. I need to be more attentive. (And someone should tell Fangraphs.)
    There are a few trade targets who could also offer Soria type production. Guys I’ve probably harped on too much already, like Mychal Givens, Joe Jimenez, Drew Steckenrider, Andrew Chafin, Yoan Lopez, and of course Taylor Rogers. Jace Fry and Jose Leclerc look real interesting as well.

    I find it hard to believe that NO team would take a reasonable trade offer for ANY of the aforementioned eight relievers — especially if the Cards were willing to take on a bad contract in the bargain. Like Trumbo, Cobb, etc..

    All I want for Christmas is the Birds to be above average or better across the board. Hitting, fielding, rotation, bullpen. And just one more very good reliever will do it. C’mon, Mo Kringle!

Viewing 25 posts - 901 through 925 (of 1,093 total)

First-hand news and commentary on the St. Louis Cardinals™ and minor league system for over 25 years