Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
“I don’t have any personal issues with JL. She seemed professional in her time with us.”
I agree 100%, booyah. She’s covered the Cards very well for years, and I was ungallant at best in my comments. In truth there was really no reason for me to mention the author by name at all. It’s a mindset, not any individual writer, that I just cannot stomach for the life of me. This selling of Fowler we’ve all endured since October when he went public with his finger-pointing at Matheny — that’s the sin. The selling is the sin.
And as they say: hate the sin, love the sinner.
“…it’s early but Fowler still looks horrible either at the plate or in the field.”
Well you must be mistaken, willie. Didn’t you read the postgame from Jen Langosch? Jen had nothing remotely negative at all to say about today’s Dexter debacle.
Here are the quotes from and referring to Fowler:
“Fowler saw six pitches in one at-bat, five in another, reflecting the sort of patience he can show when things are going well.”
“Though Matt Carpenter, Dexter Fowler and Goldschmidt (in that order) combined to go 0-for-5 with a walk and two strikeouts in Sunday’s 12-2 loss to the Nationals, the trio offered a glimpse of what could be the top of St. Louis’ lineup in the regular season.”
“The three combined to see 11 pitches from Nationals starter Erick Fedde on Sunday.
‘That’s three tough at-bats,‘ Fowler said. ‘Any time you can wear down a pitcher like that whether you’re getting hits or not, it’s going to help.’ ”So what we have here is: Dexter Fowler thinks he’s a success even when he fails about as badly as a hitter can. Even when he goes 0-2 with a whiff and popup, as he did today, in his mind he’s actually succeeded. Isn’t he amazing?! He “helps” while fanning and popping up, because he made the pitcher throw an extra pitch or two. Yay for you, Dex!
And for those who didn’t see the game (Most fans didn’t. It’s an exhibition game after all.) not only did Jen avoid telling the readers that Fowler had two at-bats with the worst possible results. She also said nothing about Fowler’s costly misplay in the outfield. (Standard Fowler defense. Bad read, bad jump, bad result. Or maybe I’m just not “giving him the benefit of the doubt.”)
This isn’t reporting from Ms. Langosch. It’s a nauseating salespitch for Fowler — and worse than that it’s a salespitch for Fowler batting second in the lineup. The spot where a terrific hitter should be batting. Like Bader or Martinez when a lefty is on the mound, for instance. Since they both destroy southpaws. Shame on Ms. Langosch for misleading her readers and joining the Fowler P.R. campaign. She’s better than that. Or used to be, anyway.
Is it really too much to ask that Dexter Fowler be treated like everyone else? When he’s good, say that he’s good. And when he is terrible, just say nothing. Don’t quote his nonsense or pretend that he was “helpful.”
“Brian, but shouldn’t a system wide ranking include both quantity and quality?”
Quite so, CC. The Angels have enjoyed seven years of the greatest ballplayer since Mantle & Mays, and what has it gotten them? Four sub-.500 seasons and one playoff series, wherein they were swept.
Why? Because basically their farm has failed to give them enough good cheap depth. If their farm system could have simply filled in around Mike Trout, just routinely added league average or slightly above average hitters and pitchers, they’d at least have made the wildcard almost every year.
This should go without saying, but it’s a good idea for prospect rankers to not just glance at, but to look closely at every single member of every team’s farm system. And that’s obviously a lot of work — if you can call it “work” to do anything related to baseball research. Anyway, 12 months ago I examined over 1,000 minor league position players and checked the Davenport Translations for each, to see if there were some well-projected but obscure prospects I’d never heard of.
I won’t bore you with the methodology right here, but in total 157 players projected as useful big leaguers, guys who might be starters for a year or two but would more likely be solid bench pieces at their peaks. Another 63 projected as everyday regulars, and 24 as stars and superstars in their primes.
So across all of baseball that was 244 total “meaningful” position player prospects. Therefore, with 30 MLB franchises the average organization would have about 8 such guys. Well, the Cards led with 20, Tampa was second with 16, then the Yanks with 14 and Phils with 13. But that’s the quantity argument of things. Let’s look at quality.
Of the 87 regulars-or-better as projected by Davenport’s computer model, the Cards had 8 and Tampa and the Phillies had 7 apiece. Those were the three best totals in baseball. And which two teams in 2018 led their leagues in rookie position player WAR? That’s right, the Redbirds and Rays.
Brian’s right that the national voices overly focus, even fixate on the shiniest toys. They get hypnotized by top talent and forget that depth is not just a good thing, not just a cute convenience. It’s often a great thing — in part because you need depth guys to fill in around your stars…but also because if you have half a dozen prospects who project to be 2-WAR regulars, the odds say that one or two will bust, but also that one or two will actually be better than projected. You might even get a 4-5 WAR star out of the group, as the Cards got from Matt Carpenter and may get from DeJong, Bader, or both. Not infrequently, the weed of quantity bears sweet quality.
Sorry, forgot to mention the final rookie WAR tally, top 5 from 2016-2018, all of MLB, per Fangraphs.
1) Dodgers 25.7 WAR
2) Yankees 24.7
3) CARDS 23.2
4) Tampa 17.4
5) Rockies 15.7Even though Milwaukee would have been next on the list with an excellent 15.5 WAR, the Brewers plus the Cubs, Bucs, and Reds combined for just 24.7 WAR over the three seasons. As for the Cards, elite results can’t come from middle of the pack farm systems, folks. And 3rd-best in baseball looks pretty elite to me.
“History is cool, but the present situation is really what matters most. The Cards appear to be a middle of the pack system again, still.”
If you want to discard the overlooked players from 12 or 15 or 20 years back, Brian, I won’t put up an argument. Guys like Crisp and Pujols and Haren and Molina are admittedly really only an indictment of Baseball America, since the other national voices didn’t truly exist until more recently.
But speaking of recently, I believe that very recent history solidly supports my contention that St. Louis prospects remain almost annually underrated — and sometimes radically so. It’s all a matter of reputation versus reality.
If the reality is that the Cards have actually been a middle-of-the-pack system, every year, year after year, for the past 5 years, then we would expect rather middling results from our rookies at the MLB level.
Per Fangraphs, these were the top 5 N.L. teams for rookie position player WAR in 2018:
1) CARDS 4.1 WAR
T1) Braves 4.1
3) Nationals 3.7
4) Phils 1.8
5) Padres 1.7And now the top 5 for rookie pitching WAR in 2018:
1) CARDS 4.5 WAR
2) Braves 4.2
3) Padres 4.1
4) Giants 3.8
5) Dodgers 3.7So we see that rather than middle of the pack, those supposedly so-so St. Louis prospects led in overall rookie WAR, nudging out the Braves 8.6 WAR to 8.3 WAR. Then there was a gap to the Padres at #3, then another gap to the Dodgers at #4.
With their 8.6 rookie WAR, the Cards totaled more than twice as much rookie WAR as the Cubs, Reds, Pirates, and Brewers put together (4.1 WAR total). A middling farm system cannot do that.
If we go back a year to 2017, the Cards were 2nd in the N.L. in rookie position player WAR. Go back yet another year, and they were 3rd in the N.L.. So three straight years at or near the top. They are the only team to be top 3 in each of the past three seasons. That’s the reality, regardless of reputation.
As for pitchers, in 2017 the rookie Birds were only 9th in WAR — but they were 1st in ERA.
In 2016 the Redbird rookie hurlers were 4th in WAR, but led in FIP. So for three straight years, both pitchers and hitters have produced quality, quantity, or both. The Cardinal draft & development people are doing a bangup job, no matter what Law or Mayo or Callis or some poor misguided fool at Baseball Prospectus or Fangraphs has to say about the matter. The numbers tell the tale.Now, I hasten to add that three years ago I agreed with the national consensus. I did, and said so! The Cards really did have a middling farm system. Everyone said they were ranked between 14th and 19th or so, and I concurred. But then 2016 happened. In 2016 (1)the Cards drafted very well, (2)many players and pitchers already in the system had impressive breakthroughs, (3)the pitchers stayed uniformly healthy (or nearly so anyway), (4)the organization graduated very little talent to the majors, and finally (5)the Cards invested internationally like they’d never done before.
In reality, this vaulted the team into the 5-7 range among all farm systems. And how could it not? Why the national voices curled up into a fetal ball of denial at the time is beyond me. Of the above five points, only the first could be disputed at all, back then. The rest are and were straightforward statements of fact.
And in reality that’s where they’ve remained ever since, among the top 15-25% of farm systems. Which is of course why they’ve had such impressive results from their rookies over the past three seasons, and particularly in 2018.
“While I agree that the current situation matters the most, perhaps it’s either a flaw in the way raters project the Cardinal prospects or something in the Cards’ development program that causes them to consistently produce better results than expected. It’s ok to discuss that, and Bob made a good list of players that possibly make the points above.”
The Cardinals have consistently produced major league results that aligned with their minor league performances. That’s all. Nothing fancy. But their minor league performances have frequently been discounted or dismissed outright by the national prospect raters, considerably more so than similar hitters and pitchers from other organizations. I’m not a licensed psychiatrist, so I can’t tell you what pesky mental block is happening at Fangraphs or Baseball Prospectus or MLB Pipeline or anywhere else. But minor league performance is now, has always been, and will always be the single best predictor of major league performance — once the entirety of the performance is taken into consideration and analyzed dispassionately. That’s the reality, regardless of reputations.
So when a Redbird performs spectacularly well in the minors but is dismissed by the national voices, believe in the player and performance not the pundit. Only one of them is full of crap.
“But even then, there are certain organizations that tend to outperform consensus projections on their prospects pretty routinely, the Cardinals being one of them. So while the consensus says that the Cardinals system is middle of the pack, I expect we will actually realize better mlb production from our system than the organizations we are grouped with due to our track record of doing just that.”
Exactly. But with one tiny tweak. I would modify “track record” to “20-year track record.”
Never a top 100 prospect: Coco Crisp, Yadi Molina, Jack Wilson, Dan Haren, David Freese, Allen Craig, Lance Lynn, Jon Jay, Tommy Pham, Matt Carpenter, Paul DeJong, Aledmys Diaz, Jordan Hicks, Randal Grichuk, and Harrison Bader. Dakota Hudson made Baseball America’s top 100, but no one else’s.
And the thing is, that laundry list of overlooked guys still doesn’t nearly tell the entire story. It’s the degree to which most of them were underrated — that’s what stands out. Solid regulars who were barely supposed to play in the majors; stars who weren’t supposed to start. And then there’s Albert Pujols, who should have been an easy top 10-12 overall prospect based on his one supremely dominant minor league season (at the plate and in the field, by the way). But he couldn’t scratch the top 40.
So anyway. The Cardinals actually have the 6th-best collection of minor league talent right now.
1) San Diego
2) Twins
3) Tampa
4) Atlanta
5) Toronto
6) Cards
7) Reds
8) White Sox
9) & 10) Astros and Dodgers in some order, what do we care, we’re Cardinal fansThe Birds are top 3 in position players and perhaps 15-18 in pitching. Maybe lower. Probably more like 18th to 20th come to think of it. Other than Reyes and Hudson, there may not be another minor league arm who’s ever more than a setup man or 5th starter. And we all know how risky Reyes is.
But now the good news. Across all of pro baseball there are 29 current minor league position players who posted at least a 150 wRC+ in 2018 while young for their level of competition. The Cards have seven and no other organization can claim more than two. Moreover, beyond that magnificent seven the Cards saw Leandro Cedeno log a 1.000 OPS as a teenager in the Appy League, Adanson Cruz post a 145 wRC+ in the DSL, and Tyler O’Neill blister AAA with a wRC+ of 170 at age 22/23. (I mention O’Neill since some folks do consider him still a prospect.)
And then there’s Ramon Urias and Andrew Knizner, who according to the ZiPS computer model are both already MLB league-average regulars, if given the opportunity. So let’s just say there’s a wealth of position player talent. Upper and lower minors.
As Brian Walton and others have quite rightly pointed out before, the pitching is fairly troubling below Triple-A, however. I hate to see any baseball team “draft for need” — at least in the first 4-6 rounds — but the Birds should find some way to replenish the pitching at the lower levels, and fast. Maybe draft, maybe trade, but some way.
“The hint was some kind of hybrid or changing role as relievers do not throw 100 innings. They want to be careful with him but also not leave unused innings short of what they think he is capable of.”
I’d love to see Alex kept on a starter’s schedule of rest, but pitch exclusively from the bullpen for at least the first five months. He could gradually escalate the pitch count from 40 in April & May, up to 85-90 by Labor Day and beyond. This would get him the 100-110 or so innings desired by the club — and also have him prepped for 5-6 innings as a playoff starter if needed.
Yes, the bullpen would lose some flexibility, having Reyes available only once every 5-6 days. But he’d also be eating far, far more innings than current conventional relievers, so I’d say that his value would be roughly the same as if he were used for 60-65 high-leverage innings. And I have to believe that the lengthy regular rest would be more likely to keep him healthy.
Actually, now that I think on it, I really don’t see any other possible way to accomplish all of the stated 2019 Reyes goals. So let’s see how bold and analytical and forward-thinking the front office and new manager really are. Let’s see if they’ll try something that nobody else is doing.
February 18, 2019 at 11:17 pm in reply to: What is wrong with Dexter Fowler and what should be done? #82193“What would suggest to you that a thirty-three-year-old, mediocre player will make up 74 points in average against Braun?”
I’m not Pugs of course, but I believe that Fowler will unquestionably hit much better than last year, now that John Mabry’s gone. Not good enough to justify a starting lineup slot, but still far better than 2018.
To estimate how much better Dex will hit, let’s average the 2018 post-Mabry hitting improvements of Grichuk, Wong, Pham, Ozuna, Voit, Piscotty, and Aledmys Diaz. Some of those batters will of course be compared to their 2017 St. Louis performances, and some to their 2018 half-seasons with Mabry.
Voit improved by 151 points of batting average (or 93 points above his career Cardinal number)
Wong improved by 104 points
Pham by 95 points
Ozuna +31
Piscotty +32
Diaz +4
Grichuk +7So let’s see. That’s 424 points of batting average, divided by 7, or just over 60 points apiece. An improvement of 60 points for Fowler would leave him with a 2019 batting average of .240 (the Marcels forecast says .236). In 2018 Ryan Braun hit .254, worst of his career. So it’s tough to imagine Fowler catching him. But here’s hoping.
(Sorry for usurping, Pugs. Also, thanks for the kind comments of a few weeks back on another thread. I was out of town, incommunicado for a protracted spell. Thanks also to gscott, Euro, Pads, and muddy for their generous remarks back then. Please forgive the extreme tardiness of my response, gents.)
“It would be a good move to get Lodolo if he is still available at #19.”
I confess my ignorance of college baseball, Ny. What makes you like Lodolo so? (To me all of the numbers just look kinda okay, at a glance. Strikeouts, walks, homers, ERA, all good not great.) Thanks for any insights!
“Different people have different egos and approaches toward their jobs, but that is their business, IMO. All I really care about regarding Dexter Fowler is how he performs on the field. Skip all the talk and play ball!”
Well we can certainly agree about the above, Brian. Bring on the games! (And I did enjoy our debate. Thanks for all of the responses.)
“We all understand what is happening. Word play will not change it. Fowler will be the regular right fielder in 2019 until he proves he shouldn’t be.”
Since all I’ve read is Goold’s second-hand words, and nothing from Shildt or Mo or Fowler himself, I have to gently disagree and say that No, I don’t think that “we all know what is happening.” But I do understand that you are retracting your statement about Fowler “re-earning” anything. Fowler already has it. No earning necessary. Fine & dandy. Then in my opinion perhaps you should not have said it in the first place — giving suckers like me a scrap of false hope — if you meant something else. So let’s edit.
“He will be given
a shot in spring training to re-earnthe starting RF job.”On a remarkably similar note, just yesterday….
“I’ve got to go out there and earn my spot,” Adam Wainwright said after the team wrapped up its rain-shortened workout on Wednesday. “When you pitch like I’ve pitched the last year and a half when I’ve hardly pitched, you haven’t earned anything. I have to come in here and earn my spot.”
And then Jen Langosch, b’gosh, commented: The Cardinals intend to give Wainwright every chance to break camp as a starter. But his fit isn’t a guarantee.
Wow. Wouldn’t it be nice, in fact wouldn’t it be absolutely amazing if Dexter Fowler said something like what Wainwright said?! A mature, humble, practical, professional approach to his job?
Something like: “I was bad, but I’ve been good for a long time. I’m going to try like **** to be better this year, and I am going to earn my spot in the starting lineup. This isn’t Christmas and I’m not asking for a present from anyone. I want to earn it! And I’m going to earn it!”
And wouldn’t it be nice, in fact wouldn’t it be absolutely astonishing, wonderful, and wacky to read a quote from someone, anyone, any journalist or member of the Cardinal braintrust, that Fowler would be “given every chance to break camp as a starter, but his starting role is not guaranteed“?
Gifting Fowler a starting role regardless of Spring Training events is money-driven madness, and I’ll keep railing against it. If I’m wasting my breath, that’s okay. I got lots of breath. Every instinct I possess, and every publicly available computer model, says that Fowler is NOT one of the three best outfielders in the organization right now. Probably not top four. So make him earn it back.
“Of course, some fans wanted Fowler thrown over the side months ago. But that is not happening. He will be given a shot in spring training to re-earn the starting RF job.”
Aaaah, but that’s exactly the words I want to see, Brian, from the mouths of Shildt, Fowler, and Mo. An honest competition for the Opening Day assignment — or even one that’s slightly slanted toward Fowler, due to seniority. Even that would be wonderful! A competition, with no concern whatsoever for anyone’s feelings! Sports is supposed to be about competition, not group therapy. If I want to see group therapy I’ll watch a Bob Newhart rerun.
Sports exists for the competition. Competition between teams, and within teams. But re Fowler I have yet to see the word competition anywhere. Maybe I’ve missed it, I have yet to see anyone within the St. Louis organization directly or indirectly say that Fowler will be “given a shot to re-earn the starting job.”
Instead what I’ve read — primarily if not exclusively from Mr. Goold, is that as of today the Cards are “committed to Fowler” as their starting right fielder, or that currently it is Fowler’s starting job to lose. Big difference.
“Generic comments like Vasgersian’s are nothing more than that – generic. Being specific matters. So lets discuss how long Fowler’s rope should be and how to measure it.”
Okay. Last year at the moment that Fowler was benched on June 12th, the Cards had 5 other outfielders with an OPS at least 160 points above Fowler. And of course, except for Jose Martinez they were all better defenders than Fowler as well. (Which is why Fowler in mid-May should have been demoted to AAA to figure out what was wrong, or simply released if he refused the assignment. Because he was blocking clearly superior players, and the Cards needed every win.)
This year, if Fowler wins the starting job in Spring Training, he should keep it until there is someone clearly better — beginning at any point after May 1st. If after May 1st there is another outfielder with an OPS at least 100 points above Fowler’s, then you bench Dexter. (Obviously this rule wouldn’t apply if Fowler has, say, an .800 OPS and Jose Martinez has a .900 OPS in limited duty. If Fowler is playing well, he keeps his job. Conversely, if Fowler starts the year in an 0-40 slump, you bench him of course.)
What you absolutely don’t do, is repeat the destructive stubbornness of 2018, and allow Fowler to keep the job into June if he’s terrible. Matheny generously stayed with him 3-5 weeks too long. And then Shildt behaved like an insane person by re-installing him into the starting lineup, dislodging Bader, the team’s finest outfielder at the time. No more of that crap, please.
“Are you assuming he did ok in spring training? I wonder if he ended camp batting just .235 if the pressure would not be on to replace him already – especially if Martinez and/or O’Neill have a big camp.”
Whoooah. Hold the phone. A minute ago, Brian, you said that Spring Training was a competition. You very specifically said that Fowler would get “a shot” to “re-earn” the starting job. Now you certainly seem to be saying that it’s Fowler’s starting job to lose. And you’re questioning whether it’s fair to “replace him” if he has a poor spring and bats just .235 for example. If it’s a real competition, then no one is being “replaced.”
So which is it, good sir? Is Dexter Fowler an honest competitor alongside his fellow professional outfielders, or an incumbent to be gifted the benefit of the manager’s faith & patience? Is this a fair fight between challengers, or is Fowler the champ who must be knocked out? I don’t think I’m splitting hairs here. I believe this is an important distinction.
“Of course, if the team is winning in spite of Fowler, that would help to buy more time. But if the team is not winning at a high enough rate, there will understandably be pressure to act sooner.”
If Fowler is terrible and the team is on pace to win 110 games, he should be replaced with exactly the alacrity as if the team were on 65-win pace. Not just Fowler. Any truly terrible hitter or pitcher. Manage by math, not emotion. No reason to “buy more time” for any failing player, not if there’s a superior talent to take his place. Play your best team. That’s the rule. Whatever your record, play your best team. Always play your best team — with one eye toward the future, of course.
I’m honestly curious about one thing. Where do people get the idea that the Cards “owe” something to Dexter Fowler? Goold has said it, and Bernie Miklasz as well. That the Birds need to “do right by Fowler.” As if Fowler’s been a big part of franchise history or something. As if for some reason the Cards should bend over backwards to give Fowler chance after chance to prove himself. It’s unfathomable to me, this mindset. They owe him his paycheck, and that’s all they owe him. This isn’t Molina, this isn’t Wainwright.
I’m not worried, Brian. Oh, maybe a 2.5 on the 1-10 WorryScale.
But maybe I’m too blasé about the whole thing. Let’s do a direct comparison of Joey Gallo & Tyler O’Neill, with a wide angle lens, and see what we find.
Seems that Gallo’s ugly MLB strikeout rates are simply a continuation of his minor league numbers.
Low-A at 19, 37% whiff rate
Double-A at 21, 34%
Triple-A at 22, 35%And now Tyler O’Neill.
Low-A at 18, 32% K rate
Double-A at 20, 26%
Triple-A at 22, 25%As we can see, O’Neill’s professional track record bears only the slightest passing resemblance to Gallo’s, when it comes to contact conflicts. Not only that, but Tyler’s whiff rate was trending downward, from the lower to upper levels of pro ball. So I would opine that based on the entirety of Tyler’s past, there’s just no reason to think that his strikeout rate will remain remotely as bloated as it was in his brief MLB debut.
More likely it regresses downward toward 30% or so, and soon. And I’m not alone in this belief. In point of fact, if we average the five publicly available forecasts (Steamer, ZiPS, Clay Davenport, ATC, and THE BAT) we find that Tyler O’Neill’s strikeout rate is indeed predicted to plummet all the way to a mildly irksome but acceptable 30.4% in 2019.
So fret not, fellow fan!
“Hicks really should be plying his trade as a starter in the minors, but because we are desperate at the top level he has had to adjust.”
I could not agree more, BikeMike. To recap, Hicks started his professional career at age 18, same as Waino, Reyes, and Carlos Martinez. The latter three pitchers logged an average of roughly 500 pro innings cultivating their stamina and skillset before making their MLB debuts. Hicks got just 166 before being shoved to the majors.
Martinez, Reyes, and Wainwright got an average 220+ innings at Double-A/Triple-A to truly hone their craft. Hicks of course got zero.
“I think Wong will take a big step and become an all-star this year.”
Well there’s no disputing he was certainly much better off without John Mabry.
2018, with Mabry: .213/.304/.361 with a 7% walk rate and 16% strikeouts.
2018, post-Mabry: .317/.384/.439 with a 9% walk rate and 12% strikeouts.As you can see, he actually had a distinctly higher isolated slugging with Mabry (7 homers, to just 2 over the second half) but everything else was worse with Mabry. Quite a bit worse. Then, once Mabry was mercifully jettisoned, Kolten got some good coaching for the first time in his MLB career, and…well I’ll let Mark Saxon of The Athletic tell the rest.
Mark Saxon
Aug 17, 4:23pm
@Luke M. I did a story recently highlighting his (Wong’s) relationship with hitting coach Mark Budaska. Last month, Budaska advised him to forget about launch angle and concentrate on getting on base, hitting line drives into the gaps, and running. Since then, Kolten is batting .321 with one home run, five doubles and an .851 OPS. Maybe I’m wrong, but that relationship seems to be a pretty good working theory.An additional curiosity: Wong was hit by pitch 13 times during the first half of the season, and just once after the managerial/hitting coach changes. Might be nothing, or might be that over the season’s second half he wasn’t crowding the plate so much, trying to pull the ball almost every time. I don’t know the underlying mechanics of it, but the results from July-September speak for themselves. Kolten clearly traded away the occasional homer to be better at everything else. More consistent sharp contact, more walks, fewer whiffs.
“While I would like to think Jeff Albert as hitting coach will improve things history doesn’t let me put too much faith in coaching changes.”
As crushingly terrible as Mabry was for young Redbird hitters, I agree with you in general, CC. I do not expect Albert to turn Bader or O’Neill or anyone else into something they aren’t. And in the cases of Harry & Tyler I really pray that he doesn’t try. The best to realistically hope for from Bader is an average around .280, and O’Neill maybe 20 points less. But with the glove and running advantages of Bader, and the extreme power of Tyler, they can still be outstanding 4 WAR players even with those batting averages. I just hope that Albert’s approach doesn’t result in sacrificing power in order to minimize strikeouts. Kolten Wong’s game is high average, with gap power. That’s not Bader and Tiny Kingman.
Let’s think about it for a sec, about Tyler O’Neill’s power. Triple-A baseball has existed since 1946, and Tyler O’Neill just posted the second-highest isolated slugging in the history of Triple-A competition, at .382. Only Willie McCovey at .387 back in 1959 was ever better. In 73 seasons, across three different AAA leagues, Tyler O’Neill was one bloop double away from the highest isolated slugging ever recorded (min. 200 PA’s, age 23-and-under).
By the way, based on Baseball America’s own publicly available scouting grades, Tyler should be every bit as good a major leaguer as BA’s #3 overall prospect Eloy Jimenez. I won’t bore you with the granular grade details, but in effect they have Eloy 60 points of OPS better as a batter, but Tyler counterbalancing that (and perhaps even surpassing it) through his substantial edge in both baserunning and defense.
Again, not my grades, not contrived biased hyperbole. Baseball America’s grades, as displayed during their MLB Network program of a few days ago. If Eloy is #3, then based on their own grades Tyler should surely be in BA’s top 6 or 7, rather than down at #36. (Personally I’d have Jimenez in the 8-10 range and O’Neill in 14-17 territory. For me Eloy’s lower K rate makes him a safer pick, hence the higher slot. The upsides are more or less identical: slugging stardom.)
“Shouldn’t we be pretty optimistic about 2019?”
Absolutely, cranny! After the midseason purge, the club went 41-28 despite playing 50 of 69 games against winning teams. (First half only 43 of 93 games versus winning teams.) Moreover, they played at 100-win pace after Fowler finally left the lineup for good. And there’s this:
In the seven seasons since LaRussa retired the Cards have beaten the Vegas number by an average of 4 wins per year, the Baseball Prospectus PECOTA total by 6 wins per year, and Clay Davenport’s computer model by 5 victories per season. So if we “translate” this year’s over/under predictions, we get:
Vegas 88.5 = 92.5 wins
PECOTA 86 = 92
Davenport 85 = 90So I expect somewhere from 90-93 wins this year.
“Shouldn’t the rotation be better?”
Not realistic, I don’t think. Mayyybe as good, but not better. The starters were 5th in the majors in ERA, and not in a flukey way; numerically they were closer to 3rd than 7th. I’d say 10% chance to get better, 50% chance to stay roughly the same, and 40% to be worse.
“The bullpen better?”
Yes, for sure. It would almost have to be, because last year was the worst in modern Redbird history. But will it be better than merely below average? Much will depend on rookie and second-year arms. I hope they protect Reyes by having him pitch every 5-6 days, 2-3 innings at a time, then gradually stretch him out in August/September, so that he could throw 5-6 innings in a playoff start if necessary. This would obviously limit bullpen flexibility — but it would also mean Reyes logging more innings than any other reliever in the sport, perhaps as many as 110 in the regular season, but with lots of rest between appearances, a starter’s rest, and never throwing more than 75-80 pitches. So I think it’s worth the tradeoff.
“The starting 8 better?”
Including offense, defense, and baserunning, if generally healthy it should be the best Senior Circuit everyday eight this side of the Dodgers. If Fowler runs away to be a pro golfer or something, they could perhaps be even better than the Dodgers. Here are the ZiPS projections, per 550 at-bats:
Carp 4.6 WAR
Goldy 4.4
Wong 3.0
Yadi 2.8
Ozuna 2.8
DeJong 2.7
Bader 2.7
Fowler 1.6“The bench better?”
The bench was great in 2018, and should remain so. More ZiPS projections, per 550 AB’s:
Gyorko 3.1 WAR
O’Neill 2.6
Jose Martinez 2.3
Knizner 2.0
Ramon Urias 2.0OK, I gratuitously added that last one just to illustrate how good Ramon might already be; I do not really expect him to play in the majors this year. At least not until September. As for the others, a strict RF platoon of Martinez/O’Neill would probably generate something like 5 WAR if Jose continues to mash LHP’s at a .968 OPS rate. But that would make Dexter Fowler sad. I mean, depressed. I mean, he would likely suffer from depression. (I believe the very latest re-write of reality, via Fowler and his unofficial mouthpiece, Mr. Goold.) And above all else, Cardinal fans, Mike Shildt must NOT make Dexter Fowler suffer. He must compose and conduct a symphony of sympathy for Dex, whatever the on-field results. So that platonic ideal platoon ain’t happening.
“A better hitting coach?”What? There’s a new hitting coach?
Great post Bob.
Gorman doesn’t look like a moving-off-third candidate. He just recently shifted off of shortstop. Look at a couple of tidbits that were included in his prospect write-up, for instance:“In my opinion, I think he is going to be a solid-average to plus third baseman….. He was for us for the 18U Team last year. He was an exceptional defender at third base.”
– Former Cardinals area scout and now 18U National Team Director for USA Baseball, Matt Blood.Thanks for the generous words, Pads. I know my posts often go on too long and can degenerate into tedium, but I’m trying like the dickens to be thorough.
And thanks also for the insightful quote from Mr. Blood. I’m not worried about Gorman’s defense, not since he started his pro career by amazingly turning 20 double plays in approximately his first 50 games. And then I saw him in Peoria and he looked comfortable & confident at the position, charging a slow roller with aplomb and firing to first in plenty of time. Just one instance, but he displayed the “actions” for a third baseman, no doubt. Footwork, balance, composure, timing.
It’s just kind of a shame that two guys from among Montero, Gorman, and Nunez will have to find a new defensive home. Or all three of them if the Cards can get Nolan Arenado somehow. Either way, I think a Nolan at third base is the future of the Redbirds.
“…how many teenagers put up a 150 wRC+ or better in A ball and were buried outside of top 100 lists? I’d bet there are almost none…”
And you’d be correct, sc25.
Unfortunately I don’t have any Sally League numbers. But I do have some info on prolific young Midwest League hitters of recent vintage. In addition to Elehuris Montero in 2018, here are all the MWL teenagers to post a 150 wRC+ this decade (min. 200 PA’s):
Bo Bichette, Fernando Tatis Jr., and Vlad Guerrero Jr. in 2017. Eloy Jimenez the year before that. And prior to him, Bobby Bradley, Corey Seager, Byron Buxton, Javy Baez, Oscar Taveras, Wil Myers, and some guy named Trout. That’s the entire list, just 11 other guys besides Montero.And following their Midwest League seasons, all 11 of them were top 100 per Baseball America. Average rank, 24th. Toss the highest and lowest ranks Olympic-style, and the average improves to 19th. Of course, in smaller samples averages can be easily distorted, so how about the median? If we include all 11 again, the median is 14th.
Now, Elehuris Montero isn’t really their precise peer, as 4 of the 11 were already considered at least somewhat elite before their dominant MWL performances. Therefore Montero would best be compared to the guys who, like himself, were NOT already top 100 prospects prior to their full-season debuts. Those 7 players were Bichette, Bradley, Tatis, Taveras, Seager, Myers, and Eloy. Their average rank following the massive Midwest League breakout was 35th. Not 24th, but still pretty terrific. The median ranking on the other hand remains an uber-elite 14th. And I rank Montero roughly 40th. (As opposed to 340th at Fangraphs.)
“…perhaps it indicates some anti-Cardinals bias on prospect analysts’ part.”
A conscious anti-Cardinal bias? Naaah, I truly doubt it. Or at least very, very rarely. But every outlet, every national voice (individual or collective) has prospect biases. Maybe it’s for power hitters, or college shortstops, or speed guys, or changeup artistes, or triple-digit fastballers with faulty command.
And the single most sweeping bias, the one persistent and pernicious phenomenon is the Sweetheart Organization. If you’re a Sweetheart Organization, places like Baseball America & Fangraphs & Baseball Prospectus tend to lean more favorably for almost ALL of your prospects — at least for that one season of rankings. (To his credit, ESPN’s Keith Law does NOT fall into this trap very often, if ever. He has his foibles, but when it comes to baseball he usually possesses a rigorous enough mind to dodge commonplace intellectual errors. He sees racists in his soup, but that’s a whole other type of intellectual error.)
Every winter when prospect rankings come out, there are perhaps 3 or 4 such organizations. Usually the same 3 or 4 at each outlet. Right now, Tampa is one of Fangraphs’ Sweetheart Organizations, so the Devil Rays have between 21 and 26 prospects rated above Elehuris Montero for example. Which, relative to player evaluations, is pretty much clinically insane. (If it feels like I’m picking on Fangraphs, well they are supposed to be a leader in the field of baseball analysis. If not THE leader. I’m not punching down a weight class, at some poor slob managing an obscure blog. Fangraphs should be better than they are.)
The Cards on the other hand have only been an S.O. once in my memory, six years back when they had power arms Miller, Martinez, Wacha, and Rosie. The high-octane numbers were too big to ignore. And for bats, there was Taveras at the top, with Wong, Adams, Pham, Carson Kelly, and Piscotty for flavor. Just boatloads of talent there.
The corollary to the S.O. is unsurprisingly the anti-S.O.. And last year and this, the Birds are clearly an anti-S.O. for Fangraphs, if not THE anti-S.O.. And they’ve quite frequently been an anti-S.O. for Jim Callis wherever he goes, and John Manuel as well. (Manuel’s bizarre and inadvertently hilarious rationalization for excluding Jack Flaherty from the top 20 Midwest League prospects a few years back remains one of the best examples of bad baseball analysis available anywhere. It should be cited in Logic 101 classes, for how not to use your brain.) Hence the years of dismissiveness by Baseball America, and now MLB Pipeline. For the anti-S.O.’s the (mostly if not entirely subconscious) principle is simple: when in doubt, downgrade the prospect. Sometimes massively.
“Our best bet to get the elite talent is through the international program, particularly since there is a firm cap on what teams may spend.
Gorman could turn out to be elite but he has to get the K’s under control.”Agreed all around, Sooner. And I do expect Gorman to limit the strikeouts enough to keep his average over .260 during his prime 5-7 years. Probably struggle until age 23 or 24, though. Now that I think of it, that sounds like a Matt Williams career, if Gorman’s glove is as good as I anticipate. And I’d take a left-handed Matt Williams any day.
“I see it with my own eyes. There is POTENTIAL for top end talent, but a number of the names you cite are not there yet.”
I suspect we’re mostly just tussling over terminology, Brian. Forgive me for speaking for you, but when you say “top end talent” you seem be talking about the top 20 or 30 or 40 overall prospects. Something of that nature? And when I say “top end talent” I’m talking about any hitter of the right age who does something spectacular in the minors, at any level. (In some cases this might include simply performing very well at a very young age for his league — like if Dylan Carlson should post, say, a 125 or 130 wRC+ in Double-A at age 20.)
Here’s a convenient example of a player who showed his extraordinary talent at a very young age, but was ignored anyway: Cleveland superstar Jose Ramirez came up in Kiley McDaniels’ Wednesday Fangraphs chat.
Jeff: Franco and Brujal sound amazing. At this stage how much better are these two than Lindor and Ramirez?
12:33
Kiley McDaniel: Ramirez wasn’t really a prospect when in Double-A, so most guys we talk about were ahead of him at that stage. Lindor was a top-10 pick at the age Franco is now a top-5 prospect in the game, so Franco seems ahead.Right on cue, this is exactly the brand of Fangraphs intellectual dishonesty described earlier in this very thread. With his Ramirez remarks McDaniel is actively misleading his readers, because Jose Ramirez was in fact a absolutely tremendous ballplayer as a teenager in full season Low-A ball. In fact, as a funny coincidence Ramirez posted a 145 wRC+, which is precisely the same as Drew Waters did in 2018 as a teen in Low-A. You remember Waters. He’s the one who Fangraphs nearly drowned in praise:
“(Waters’) full season debut in 2018 was a smashing success; he demolished the Low-A Sally League…”
Yes, Waters had a great 2018. But not quite as great as Ramirez was in 2012, because not only did Jose Ramirez hit exactly as well as Waters at the same age and same level, the future superstar Ramirez did so while striking out less than half as often as Waters. This made him much more of a sure thing than Waters is now. But Ramirez was short, so the scouty types belittled him — when they weren’t ignoring him altogether. One person who scouts the stat lines noticed him, though.
“Anyway, the Most-Overlooked Award shouldn’t go to Garcia, but to Jose Ramirez. The little switch-hitting keystoner got overshadowed by Lindor, but Jose hit lefties and righties, hit at home and away, stole some bases, and committed just two miscues in more than 60 games afield. As a teen in the MWL. Darn impressive, even if you are 5’ 9″ and limited to second base.”
commented on BA’s Top 20 Midwest League Prospects from Minor League Ball, Oct 2, 2012, 2:48pm PDT
Sometimes it’s honestly just not that hard to evaluate prospects. About 80-90% of the time the good ones will let you know. You simply need to be attentive and reasonably intelligent. McDaniel regularly appears to be neither, or he’s just a liar. Jose Ramirez quite clearly showed his top-end talent at age 19 in the Low-A Midwest League. He was spectacular but the scouts incorrectly ignored him then, and guys like Kiley McDaniel continue to, well, lie about it to this day. Bizarre, the allergy to admitting mistakes that some “scouty” types have.
But enough negativity. This is the internet, Home Of Good Cheer. And in keeping with the thread title, I have one fun fact.
Harrison Bader, career minor league line versus southpaws: .387/.441/.798 in 272 plate appearances.
And he’s been great in the majors, too. Though obviously not THAT great. In any case, there is no way that Bader should ever hit lower than cleanup when the opposition starts a lefty. Never, ever lower than cleanup. Best choice: second or third, with Goldschmidt taking the other.“Bob, where would you estimate you would rank Herrera nationàlly if he puts up a 150 wRC+ in 2019 across SC and Peoria? What if it dips to 120 (still excellent for his age)?”
Quite the question, CC! Herrera will still be just 18 for the first half of the 2019 season — nine months younger than Eleh Montero was when he played for Peoria as a teenager in 2018 — so I’m not even sure the organization will place Herrera above the Appy League. I don’t think I would.
But let’s see. I have him roughly 140th right now. So if he were to keep killing the ball at a 150 wRC+ clip while moving up three levels to the Midwest League at age 18/19, I’d say he’d be top 20-30 overall, depending on defense. He’d immediately be one of baseball’s best 15-20 hitting prospects, and a plausible future catcher to boot. (But believe me, Ivan isn’t going to post a 150 wRC+ in the MWL. Not in 2019.)
For context, fellow catcher Miguel Amaya was a few months older when he played in the Midwest League in 2018, and posted a 114 wRC+. That quite rightly made him a consensus top 100 overall prospect. Amaya’s defensive numbers mirror Herrera’s in both caught stealing and errors, with Amaya holding the edge in passed balls. So I’d say that to rank where Amaya ranks now, top 60-80, Ivan would need a 120-125 wRC+ for Peoria while looking viable as a long term backstop.
What I expect though is that Herrera will go to the Appy League and mash in much the same way he always has. That would make him a top 100 possibility for me. Again, depending on defense.
“There aren’t many prospects out there I would choose over Reyes, Hudson, Gorman, Montero, Nunez, and Knizner. There just aren’t.”
Agreed, gscott. Cards are in an unusual spot, since so many high-upside guys are also high risk, e.g., Reyes, Gorman, Nunez, and all of the kid position players who have yet to taste full season ball. Plus the Card farm is overloaded with position players — worst imbalance in memory. But also most teenage talent.
The Twins, Rays, and Pads are almost surely the strongest systems, with Toronto up there as well, led of course by the two Legacy Guys. Birds are in a tier with the Reds, Braves, and a few others. Maybe the White Sox, though their depth stinks. St. Louis looks to be somewhere in the 5-10 range. But that’s rather vague, so I’ll opine 6th-8th. (I do not include O’Neill, as MLB officially excludes him from R.O.Y. eligibility due to days on the 25-man roster.)
I say 6th-8th, having not carefully examined every single team yet. But after doing this sort of thing for 15-20 years or more, a person develops a sense of what an average farm, a top 10, or a top 5 look like. Cards are top 10 for sure, but NOT top 5 right now. Redbird hitters are like Padre pitchers — lotsa guys with lotsa high ceilings. Could be fun to watch them grow over the next 4-6 years. (Both teams, I mean.)
“…the Cards score well for depth, but lower on top-end talent.”
Ivan Herrera is the only minor leaguer at his position to post at least a 150 wRC+ in both 2017 and 2018.
Nolan Gorman was the youngest Cardinal to play in the Midwest League in 50 years.
Malcom Nunez was easily the best hitter in the DSL for as far as the records go back.
Elehuris Montero when he was promoted was on pace to be the first teenager in Midwest League history (founded 1963) to win the batting title while leading the league in extra base hits.
Tyler O’Neill was the first AAA batter (23 or younger) since Willie McCovey 59 years ago to post an isolated slugging of .380 or better — despite playing more than half his games in pitcher’s parks. (He homered 8 times in the only 10 games he played in PCL hitter’s parks.)
And Joey De Los Santos was the only minor leaguer at any level to hit at least .310 while stealing lots of bases and walking more than he whiffed. No one else did so in 2017, either.
So whatever you may read, there is LOTS of top-end talent. The question is, how much of it will self-actualize.
“Our enthusiasm may cause us to overrate all the Cardinal prospects when they are compared with prospects on other teams.”
Well said, Ny. This is indeed the permanent danger. Our biases may color our comparisons.
Which is why I use 80-90% on-field performance when evaluating any prospect from any team. The same yardstick for Cardinals as for prospects from every other organization. Generally makes things very simple, objective, and fair.It’s obviously quite a bit harder to do with pitchers, since the “stat line” omits so many details of velocity, movement, mental toughness, etc.. Pitchers require more research, to be sure. But position players aren’t so tough, not really. I’ll show you what I mean.
As a prospect, Yadi Molina was never on a top 100 list. Neither were Paul Goldschmidt or Jose Altuve or Harrison Bader or Jose Ramirez. Also Matt Carpenter, Justin Turner, Robby Cano, A.J. Pollock, Kyle Seager, Lorenzo Cain, Matt Holliday, Kevin Kiermaier, Paul DeJong, Brett Gardner, Russell Martin, Brian Dozier, and Ben Zobrist. Never top 75 for anyone: Chase Utley, Ian Kinsler, and Dustin Pedroia. Never top 60: Mookie Betts, Andrelton Simmons, Chuck Knoblauch. And never top 40, Albert Pujols.
That’s 25 stars and superstars, maybe a half dozen Hall Of Famers, all radically underrated as prospects. Not underrated by a notch or two. Waaay off. Just goes to show how incredibly difficult it is to properly grade baseball prospects, right?
Not on your life. Of the 25, all but 3 or 4 could easily have been evaluated much more accurately, if only their publicly available track records of hitting & defense had been shrewdly scrutinized and given proper weight. In short, if only the stat lines had been fully scouted.
So that’s what I do, with Redbirds and everyone else.Scout the stat lines, both hitting and defense. Then after that, fold in the other lesser factors. (And those “other factors” do NOT include signing bonuses or draft slots. Those are little more than distractions, lazy comfortable data points that people inadvertently use to play tricks on themselves, to talk themselves into untrue things. To lobby for example for allegedly self-evident future MLB star Ian Happ over the supposedly inferior future bench player, Harrison Bader.)
“Bob, I wouldn’t worry too much about Fangraphs. They also predict the Brewers to finish last in the NLC. In my opinion they have very little credibility.”
Well, gscott, like every other source, they certainly have their (intellectual) virtues and vices. To be fair, the “standings” that show the Brewers behind the Reds & Pirates are generated by computer models, and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of individual Fangraphs writers. But I agree, any computer model that shows the Brewers in last, needs to be re-evaluated. Just like several seasons ago the ZiPS model was annually too low on the Cardinals, year after year, because St. Louis had a team of actual high BABIP hitters and the ZiPS model invariably over-regressed for that.
But I think it’s important to discredit intellectually dishonest and incompetent evaluators, which in the context of St. Louis prospects described Baseball America for 15-20 years, and now describes Fangraphs to a T.
I want Cardinal fans to be better informed. And I want them to feel good about good prospects, great about great ones, and bad about the distorted, dismissive and in my opinion dishonest work by McDaniel and Longenhagen at Fangraphs. The rankings are not only third rate, but they’re riddled with omissions and nonsense. Think I exaggerate? Okay, here’s one quick example.
In 2018 Atlanta outfielder Drew Waters and Cardinal third baseman Elehuris Montero each played in Low-A ball at age 19. Drew Waters posted a terrific 145 wRC+ and Montero was even better at 157. Very exciting season for each player.
About Waters, Fangraphs said:
“His full season debut in 2018 was a smashing success; he demolished the Low-A Sally League and posted a 98 wRC+ in High-A as a teenager.”As for Montero:
“Montero’s strong initial foray into full-season ball — .322/.381/.529 with 46 extra-base hits in 103 games — was his second straight year of on-paper success…”So Waters was a smashing success who demolished his league. Montero, however, was merely strong. On paper. Whatever that’s supposed to mean. I thought on-paper success was for potty-training your puppy. So that’s what I mean by “nonsense.” (Small matter, but note also that they mention Waters’ solid High-A performance. Nothing about Montero’s 110 wRC+ in his High-A time, however.)
Fangraphs went on to cite Montero’s “approach” as a potential problem, even though Waters actually walked less and struck out more than Montero in Low-A. Thus, more nonsense.
One other not entirely meaningless nitpick: when a player wins his league batting title and his league MVP, those achievements should be mentioned in any review of his season, in my opinion. That’s what I mean by “omissions.” Casual fans of the minor leagues might not know that Montero had done those things, and that knowledge helps to paint a richer more complete picture of his season. It gives an idea of what he accomplished, and maybe more importantly how he was perceived by MVP voters — which I believe was the league managers, but I don’t know for sure.
And it’s not just 6 or 8 or 12 guys. There were roughly 20-25 such weird examples of misleading writing within their Cardinal capsules. It was like a concerted relentless salespitch for a very specific idea. And that idea is “St. Louis’ prospects, almost to a man, are not nearly as good as they played on the field in 2018.”
Thanks, Brian, for posting these interviews. I still have a lot left to listen to, but what I’ve heard has been informative and even entertaining at times. Thanks again.
“If I were managing the Cardinals, I would want all of the players to be well versed on the history of the storied rivalry with the cubs.”
Agreed, Pugs. And you know what’s funny? I initially read “storied rivalry” remark as “steroid rivalry.” As in, a rivalry on steroids. (Which it is, since the cubs finished tanking.) Or maybe a jab at the PED-tainted McGwire/Sosa battle of 1998.
“…one would think the City of Brotherly Love’s baseball team would have at least one heated rivalry brewing.”
I think the overheated rivalry in Philly is between the team and their own fans, Pugs. Or between the fans and Santa, not sure which.
“Cub lover” – the ultimate insult!
You got it, CC! So much worse than even the hurtful “cub fan.”
Anyway, regarding the business of a cubbienetwork in the near future…I’m not concerned. With the MLB luxury tax thresholds being relatively low, and the punishments now including draft pick penalties, the $$ playing field (relative to revenues only) is probably more level than it’s ever been. The Dodgers and Red Sox and cubs have been winning lately because they got smart guys Friedman and Dombrowski and Epstein, moreso than their fat wallets. Smart guys hire smart underlings, and more importantly they hire smart managers for the dugout.
We see the tiny-market Brewers with a player payroll at 70% of the first tax penalty level, and also see multiple high revenue teams apparently unwilling to even enter the bidding for Harper/Machado. With this new network the Ricketts family will make more money than ever, but I don’t expect it to influence the cub player payroll much, if at all — and thus it should have miniscule bearing on cubbie team quality going forward.
First, thanks so much for the gracious words, Pugs! I’m twice as happy as I deserve to be, probably. Family and friends are in good health, and pitchers & catchers are less than a month away. It’s frozen outside but I’m warm and dry. So what else is there to wish for?
“I guess that one could blame anything on Mabry because there is no way of telling.”
It’s true that there is no way of telling, Ny. But it’s imcumbent on us to use our common sense.
It is absolutely true that there can never be definitive cause-and-effect proof that any hitting coach ever helped or hindered any player. And for the longest time the tobacco companies claimed there was no cause-and-effect proof that cigarettes gave you cancer. But again, common sense.I cited seven anti-Mabry examples. I could go into granular specifics yet again about how at-bats were routinely given away on a nightly basis by the terrible overaggressive & counterproductive plate approach that was instilled in developing Cardinal hitters over the past 4-5 years by the Mabry-led MLB staff — but I’ve done that on multiple occasions before, so I won’t. Simply put, it’s just a real bad track record, and it’s a pretty lengthy one, at 6 1/2 years. If anyone wants to believe that it’s all a big coincidence, that’s their choice.
I can think of only two hitters who looked better after Mabry got them (Gyorko) or worse after leaving (Heyward). With Mabry around, veteran batters went into unusually deep horrific slumps for many weeks (Moss, Peralta) or even months on end (Fowler) while younger Cards regularly failed to develop, and not infrequently literally got worse the longer Mabry was around them (Grichuk, Diaz, Piscotty). Hitters are supposed to be improving in their mid-twenties, not annually declining.
But hey, young hitters fail all the time. Some succeed, some do not. So we should put Mabry’s record into an appropriate context. Under Mabry’s immediate predecessors, there were five Cardinal minor league hitters with a decent chance to contribute at the MLB level (Freese, Jay, Craig, Carpenter, Rasmus). All but one reached at least his projected 50th percentile outcome at the plate, and a couple were substantially better. On the other hand, under Mabry the majority of young Redbird batters had to be traded away due to poor performance.
If anyone wants to defend Mabry, that’s obviously their prerogative. But I’ve said all I’m going to on the subject. So forgive me for bowing out of any future debate. At least within this thread.
“Bob, I think everyone was thinking along these lines as the offseason began, including the FO. Apparently these AL teams in question don’t think as highly of JMart as we do so a deal hasn’t been consummated and there doesn’t appear to be one on the horizon either. I think the FO is being smart this time by not giving away a .300 hitter making the minimum. He should only be traded for an impact reliever, not a prospect we hope develops in a few years.”
I think you’ve summarized things pretty perfectly, gscott. What I’ve found frustrating over the winter, is that we don’t have any inkling of what specific trade offers have been made and turned down for Jose. But I agree wholeheartedly that the Birds should NOT trade Martinez for prospects. Only current help, and only impact help, will do.
“I think that some clubs look at Martinez and realize we got him off the junk heap and they don’t want to overpay for a bargain player. After saying that, I want JoMartinez on the team… but preferably off the field. I love watching his at-bats, the glove part… not so much.”
Agreed 100%, Ny. MLB-wide perception has probably still not caught up with reality, when it comes to Jose’s outstanding hitting skills. I’d rather have an excellent cost-controlled reliever, but barring that, I’m happy to have an excellent bench bat and DH for interleague tilts.
What gscott said. Every word is hereby seconded.
“Bob,
Doesn’t your sureness that Fowler will fail, be a reason to keep (rather than trade) Jose?
I understand that you want the trade so that O’Neill will be the ‘Next Man Up’ in RF. But if it is inevitable that Fowler will fail then Jose will inevitably be needed as the fourth outfielder.
I know you have confidence in the minor leaguers, but you have to agree that as least for the first half of 2019, Jose would be a much better option as the fourth outfielder.”Thanks for the kind words, Ny, and for the response, Mr. O!
I’m not sure of Fowler’s failure, but I am 90% sure he’ll get hurt. Dexter has been in the majors for a decade and played 145 games once. He misses 35 games a year, and has averaged just 104 games since coming to St. Louis. And like the rest of us, he’s older every year. He’ll get hurt. But when he’s playing, Fowler will unquestionably hit much better than last year, now that John Mabry’s gone.To estimate how much better Dex will hit, let’s average the 2018 post-Mabry hitting improvements of Grichuk, Wong, Pham, Ozuna, Voit, Piscotty, and Aledmys Diaz. Some of those batters will of course be compared to their 2017 St. Louis performances, and some to their 2018 half-seasons with Mabry.
Voit improved by 333 points of OPS
Pham by 291 points
Ozuna +164
Wong +158
Piscotty +113
Diaz +74
Grichuk +45So let’s see. That’s 1,178 points of OPS, divided by 7. That’d be a boost of 168 on average. So add 168 to Dexter’s .576 and you get .744. Sounds about right to me. With good baserunning and bad defense, that would be roughly a replacement level right fielder, I believe. In other words not nearly good enough to stay in the lineup more than 6 or 7 weeks for a contending team with multiple distinctly better alternatives.
As for Jose Martinez, I’m not determined to get him off the team, nothing like that. But the club still needs a very good relief pitcher (if not two) and Martinez is the most logical and theoretically valuable trade chip if we’re dealing with an A.L. team. And Jose’s value will only decline year-to-year from here on out, as he makes more dough and gets fewer plate appearances. The outfield is deep, Tyler O’Neil has to get every possible at-bat, and Goldy’s at first base: that combo makes it unlikely that Jose will ever get more than 200-250 AB’s in a Redbird uni again.
Maybe I’m guilty of fixating a bit on Tyler O’Neill, but to me Tyler O’Neill is a lot like Dakota Hudson. They’ve both enjoyed tremendous minor league success, and in the pressure of a playoff race they both succeeded in their initial MLB foray. But I believe we are in an age of overthinking things sometimes, of occasionally being preoccupied with “process” and therefore staring far too microscopically at some selected peripherals of Hudson and O’Neill, while excessively downplaying the actual outcomes, which have been nothing but excellent.
O’Neill is not a bench player and Hudson is not a future reliever. In fact they could both be stars by 2021 if not much sooner, that’s the upside — fully supported by their professional track records. So I can’t agree that Jose is the better option for 4th outfielder. O’Neill’s defense + baserunning counterbalance Jose’s current edge with the bat. And Tyler, many years the younger player, may be a huge part of the club’s future, and for me that breaks all ties. Tiny Kingman has got to get maximum playing time, and he obviously has nothing to learn in Triple-A where he batted .310 and slugged .693 last year.
I wish the poll would’ve allowed us to place the analysts in order, 1-5. But you can’t have everything. At least they’re finally putting Al into situations more aligned with his skillset. He’s an almost ideal team ambassador. Personable and amiable and enthusiastic guy, but not efficient enough at verbalizing his observations for impromptu in-game analysis.
McCarver and Danny Mac have an easy and entertaining rapport that can’t be faked. Perhaps I’d get tired of them if they worked together for 100+ games a year, but I don’t think so. Edmonds and Horton are very good, while Brad Thompson needs to let the game tell the story once in a while. Two times too chatty for television.
Maybe I’m overly nostalgic, but I still feel that the Buck & Shannon radio team was the best. Well, them or Vin Scully alone. (I lived in LA for the end of Scully’s career and he was STILL great at the job. Not great for his age. Just plain great. The worst? Ed Farmer & Anyone. Farmer exudes all the joy of a man waiting for a tooth extraction while being audited. A pox on the Sox for his continued employment.)
Irrelevant sidebar. I wish the radio/TV coverage could have incorporated more of the stars from the championship 60’s and 80’s teams over the past few decades. Would have liked to hear more from Brock or Gibson or the speedsters of the Herzog years. If not regularly, at least with more frequent guest spots. But again, you can’t have everything.
-
AuthorPosts
