Bob Reed

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 1,091 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: 2027 TCN Community Top Prospect Voting Thread #323140
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Bob, I entirely disagree with Ortiz offering either more base running or defensive value than Gurevitch. I’m not sure about vastly better batter either. I’ll give you ‘better batter’ without the vastly, similar speed, with Ortiz being worse defensively.”

    Thanks for the response. This was and remains my reasoning.
    First, baserunning. I assume Deniel Ortiz is either smarter or faster on the base paths than Jack Gurevitch, or both, since Ortiz has 53 steals in 66 attempts in the minors (175 games). Gurevitch on the other hand has a mere 12 pilferings in 19 tries across 141 pro games.

    As for defense, I should’ve clarified that I was referring primarily to their respective glovework at third base, where Ortiz grades out as much stronger per Clay Davenport’s metrics, as well as by their error/DP ratios. (Gurevitch more errors than DP’s, Ortiz 30% more DP’s than errors.) More specifically, again per Davenport, Ortiz during his peak years projects as a scratch defender at the hot corner, and Gurevitch as unplayable there at -16 runs per 150 games.

    Finally, the hitting. I said Ortiz was the “vastly better hitter” at AA this year. Here’s the breakdown:
    Gurevitch 95 wRC+ with a 39% strikeout rate and 4% walk rate.
    Deniel Ortiz 123 wRC+ with an 18% whiff rate and 15% BB ratio.

    Setting aside Ortiz’ profound plate discipline advantage, let’s just look at the 123-versus-95. For the Redbirds this year, Alec Burleson and Leo Bernal posted a wRC+ of 125 and 124, respectively. Mean time, Nelson Velasquez and Lars Nootbaar registered a 98 and 95, respectively. I would opine that in 2026 the former pair were “vastly better” at the plate than the latter twosome; but it’s each fan’s personal choice how to define “vastly.”

    Anyway, there’s at least one objective source that rates Ortiz’ bat as distinctly ahead of Gurvitch’s. The Steamer projection model already has next year’s MLB estimates (in case there’s actually an MLB season, right?) and it says that Jack Gurevitch figures to post a shaky 78 wRC+ in 2027. Deniel Ortiz on the other hand projects to a 92 wRC+. So Steamer clearly prefers the slightly younger Ortiz right now.

    ————————————————————-

    “Ixan Henderson if he recovers successfully and fully, he could come on fast.”

    I couldn’t agree more, muddy. Ix was one of my favorite arms prior to his injury, a real Mark Buehrle Lite if everything panned out. Just one of those southpaws who gets outs, again and again, without overwhelming velocity or movement. I mean, the guy has a professional career ERA of 2.56 for cryin’ out loud (253 IP). In the long, long run, I give Henderson roughly as good a chance to contribute meaningfully in the majors as Clarke, Roby, or Hjerpe.

    in reply to: 2027 TCN Community Top Prospect Voting Thread #323122
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    #29 Sammy Hernandez
    #30 Deniel Ortiz

    Sammy’s 2026 season taken in a vacuum makes him look like a future star, and his 2024 campaign in Low-A at age 19/20 was very good also. Ortiz was slightly younger than Gurevitch in Double-A, was a vastly better batter, and very likely offers more baserunning/defensive value. I don’t dislike Jack G., but Ortiz is the clearly superior prospect unless I’m missing something….

    in reply to: 2027 TCN Community Top Prospect Voting Thread #322970
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    #27 Sammy Hernandez
    #28 Deniel Ortiz

    in reply to: 2027 TCN Community Top Prospect Voting Thread #322854
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    #25 Daniel Eagen
    #26 Sammy Hernandez

    Last 8 starts in Double-A, Eagen posted a spectacular 65-to-9 strikeout/walk tally across 46 innings. His whiff totals are nearly the equal of Odle’s, and Eagen’s walk rates are vastly superior.

    Backstop Sammy Hernandez had a huge year in High-A, where he turned 22 in June. He had a terrific 140 OPS+, supported by a truly outstanding BB/K ratio of 43/47, and he even swiped 21 bases in 26 tries. He had more extra base hits than singles, and his defensive numbers on balance are sound — errors okay, CS% a bit low, passed balls blessedly few & far between.

    in reply to: 2027 TCN Community Top Prospect Voting Thread #322398
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    #19 Santana
    #20 Ragsdale

    I realize people are reluctant to vote for a reliever, I get it. But relative to starting pitchers, relievers are rapidly closing the gap in importance. Ten years ago, MLB starters threw 75% more innings than bullpenners. In 2026, it was just 33% more.

    If an outstanding reliever 10-15 years ago was roughly as valuable to a team as a #4 starter, I’d say he’s now equivalent in value to a solid #3 — if not #2/3, once you factor in the high leverage opportunities such a reliever regularly receives.

    in reply to: 2027 TCN Community Top Prospect Voting Thread #322290
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    #17 Santana
    #18 Ragsdale

    Rags got off to an awful start after being traumatically traded from baseball’s current best franchise to our mediocre Redbird organization; over his first couple of weeks he went 10-for-52, with 20 strikeouts and just 7 walks. After that, though, he settled in. The rest of the way he batted .277/.413/.477 with an excellent 12/16 BB/K ratio.

    Overall, his 2026 season looks like this: .295/.418/.536. With 37 steals in 40 tries for good measure. His time was divided equally between High-A and Double-A, and the results were pleasantly identical more or less.

    High-A .975 OPS and a 44/64 BB/K tally.
    Double-A .933 OPS and a 42/71 BB/K.

    The lefty swinger has a professional OPS nearly 400(!) points higher against righties than lefties. So he’s a platoon guy, period. Which isn’t preferable. But on the other hand, he may be an outstanding platoon guy who can start 110-120 games a year (all games versus righties and maybe 20-30 percent of games against the southpaws he matches up with best).

    in reply to: 2027 TCN Community Top Prospect Voting Thread #322134
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Santana has 33 innings above A+ level.”

    That’s basically true. (Including the AAA postseason, his grand total is 36.1 innings above A-Ball.)

    In those 36.1 innings across Double-A and triple-A, Sandro permitted only 4 runs, on 11 hits, and fanned 57 men. I’d like to say that minor league pitchers whose strikeouts are 5X their hits allowed over a solid sample size in the upper minors tend to go on to great MLB success. But I can’t say that. Because there’s no such thing as another pitcher who ever had 5X as many strikeouts as hits allowed over a solid sample size in the upper minors.

    in reply to: 2027 TCN Community Top Prospect Voting Thread #322092
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    15. Miguel Hernandez
    16. Sandro Santana

    Just a quick reminder. Hernandez was 17 years old for the first two months of the season, and finished the year dominating the Florida State League. Even over a small sample, that’s highly unusual in the best possible way.

    in reply to: 2027 TCN Community Top Prospect Voting Thread #321970
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Alexander Frias is a fine choice; when the Birds traded for the 18-year-old outfielder at the end of July he was ranked top 70 by Keith Law and top 50 at Fangraphs. He’ll probably be on all top 100 lists this offseason

    But the thing of it is, Frias played at Palm Beach with fellow 18-year-olds Sebastian Dos Santos and Miguel Hernandez. And simply put, he was not at their level offensively.

    Here’s the Palm Beach line for each, extrapolated to 150 games.

    Frias .247 with 12 homers, 24 doubles, 65 walks, and 36 steals in 42 tries.
    SDS .246 with 27 longballs, 22 doubles, 119 walks, and 49 of 60 stealing bases.
    Miggy .304 with 12 homers, 42 doubles, 120 walks, and 42 steals in 60 attempts.

    They each projected to fan between 150 and 163 times, which is admittedly a concern. But as you can see, both Miggy and SDS offset the whiffs with tons of walks, which Frias does not. Now, Frias will probably add power, given his age and frame — but he’ll have to add a chunk just to get to where Sebastian and Miguel are right now. (Their isolated slugging numbers were nearly 50% higher than Frias.) And of course, Dos Santos and Hernandez have each played primarily shortstop in their brief careers, so it’s not unfair to assume they’ll have at least as much defensive value as Alex Frias, if not more.

    Frias is very young and very promising, a top 100 talent, maybe top 50. But the other guys are better.

    #13 Sebastian Dos Santos
    #14 Miguel Hernandez

    in reply to: 2027 TCN Community Top Prospect Voting Thread #321813
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    #11 Sebastian Dos Santos
    #12 Miguel Hernandez

    In all of the full season minor leagues in 2026, across all 30 organizations, there were just 5 middle infielders who were 18 years old and posted at least a 125 OPS+. The two Birds above, and three other guys who have an average overall prospect ranking of #32 at Fangraphs and #35 at MLB.com.

    Dos Santos and Hernandez should both be consensus top 50-60 overall prospects, and top 5 or 6 for the Cardinals.

    in reply to: 2027 TCN Community Top Prospect Voting Thread #321778
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “He (Dos Santos) has split time between second base and shortstop and hasn’t been super sure-handed at either, and early reports of a fringy throwing arm make the former spot feel more likely long-term.”

    That cursory scouting report courtesy of the Fangraphs staff — whenever it came out — is simply not tethered to reality. I hate to do this, but the following is a straight copy/paste from earlier in this Top Prospect thread:

    Without getting too granular here, Sebastian Dos Santos has put up real solid numbers as a 17- and 18-year-old shortstop, while also spending some time at 2nd and 3rd, of course. In sum, SDS has in his brief career participated in 44 double plays while committing just 11 errors. That is an excellent ratio for one so young. Compare it to his fellow Cardinal farmhands.

    Jesus Baez career: 131 DP’s and 61 errors.
    Miguel Hernandez: 25 DP’s and 20 errors.
    Yairo Padilla: 24 DP’s and 27 errors.

    The excellent DP-to-error ratio of 4-1 by Dos Santos doesn’t happen by accident.
    If his arm were truly fringy, SDS would almost certainly have fewer double plays.
    If his hands were unreliable, SDS would almost certainly have committed more errors.

    —————————————————————-

    “Since Dos Santos’ defense has been discussed, how about Hernandez’ defense? He seemed to alternate second and shortstop with Dos Santos.”

    While the dreadful DP-to-error ratios above for Hernandez and Padilla aren’t conclusive of anything (a hard-working teenager can develop in any number of ways) they do align well with only publicly available defensive metrics for the lower minors, Clay Davenport’s.

    Davenport’s website has Miggy’s glovework as below average at both short and the keystone, at all three levels at which he’s competed. BUT he’s hit the crap out of the ball. I mean, at Palm Beach this year, Miguel Hernandez was half a year younger than Rainiel Rodriguez was last year for the same team, and posted an even higher OPS+ than Rai-Rod did! Very high BABIP over a pretty small sample, but he did it nevertheless.

    In other words what Miggy likely is, is a future outfielder. And I would say the same thing about him that I said about Jordan Walker a few years ago: his 90th percentile outcome is Matt Holliday with better defense.

    in reply to: 2027 TCN Community Top Prospect Voting Thread #321705
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    You got that right, Bling.

    in reply to: 2027 TCN Community Top Prospect Voting Thread #321675
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “He (Jurrangelo Cijntje) just needs to pitch like he did the last month and a half at Memphis.”

    No kidding. Last 9 starts in AAA: just 1 homer, a 48-to-14 strikeout/walk tally, a .556 OPS allowed, and a 2.95 ERA and tremendous 2.20 FIP. Absolutely fantastic, better than I thought before checking the details. I’ll stick with SDS for now, but Jurrangelo is a top 125 type prospect, if not higher.

    #10 Sebastian Dos Santos, please.

    • This reply was modified 3 weeks, 4 days ago by Bob Reed.
    in reply to: 2027 TCN Community Top Prospect Voting Thread #321630
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “I don’t see how you can’t like Jesus Baez’ low strikeout rate and 39 homers….And how about Baez’ improvement at Springfield? No one talks about that.”

    Yeah, I hear you, Cards27. It is indeed highly unusual — in the best possible way — for a guy to combine power & contact so well. Specifically, there were 76 minor leaguers this year with at least a .250 isolated slugging (min 300 PA’s) and Jesus Baez (iso. slg. of .305) fanned the least of any of them! I love love love that combination.

    But as has been mentioned by others, he also had the 2nd-lowest walk rate of all 76 power hitters; and historically in the upper minors a poor walk rate portends future failure in the majors. Anyway, when you add it all up, his BB/K ratio ranked just 58th among the aforementioned 76 sluggers. That’s a medium-sized red flag. Bright red.

    Then you have his weirdly low BABIPs, everywhere I mean everywhere he’s played. Guys who go on to be average-or-better MLB batsmen just don’t post such poor BABIPs in the minors. Maybe some have but none spring to mind. Again, it’s just *weird* how consistently low they’ve been. On the other hand, he HAS been young everywhere he’s played, and that can lead to BABIP suppression, and home runs don’t help your BABIP like doubles and triples do. Hit it over the fence, your BABIP just stagnates.

    On the other other hand, there was a longball rampage in 2026 across the minors, and we just don’t know if we’re looking in a one-season funhouse mirror when we see “39 homers” on Baez’ baseball card.

    ————————————————————

    He’s a combustible stew of extreme positives and negatives (Clay Davenport’s evaluation system likes his shortstop defense almost as much as Sebastian Dos Santos’ defense) which means his MLB chances will come down primarily to health and hard work in all likelihood — and the latter is a concern, I’d say.

    In any case, I have the young man in the 12-14 range among Redbird farmhands, or roughly top 120-130 overall. In his recent Athletic.com chat, Keith Law claimed Baez’ attitude is improved since coming to the Cards; but Nigel says otherwise and he’s an eyewitness. So I’m discarding Law’s second-hand reportage.

    Finally, thanks for the kind words, 27. And Gags and Nigel as well. Cardinal fans are the coolest.

    in reply to: 2027 TCN Community Top Prospect Voting Thread #321547
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    #9 Sebastian Dos Santos

    And if you all vote for him, I promise: no more long-winded posts overflowing with statistical minutiae. Probably.

    in reply to: 2027 TCN Community Top Prospect Voting Thread #321520
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Suppose I told you that we had a pitching prospect who, at 21, just plowed through 3 levels, was named reliever of the year by MLB Pipeline, noted as “best left handed slider” by Baseball America, 14.2 K/9 (39.6% K rate), allowed a total of 4 earned runs and 14 hits the last four months for a 0.91 ERA, allowed a very good .576 OPS against righties and an absurd .349 OPS against lefties?
    Other than his small size, Sandro Santana is a virtuoso on the mound. He’s got an excellent fastball and the killer slider, which makes him a potentially elite bullpen arm.”

    I’m glad you brought up Sandro Santana, stl25. He’s in my Redbird top 10, and overall top 100, which certainly wouldn’t have been possible for a reliever 15 or 20 years ago. But now with “workhorse” major league starters barely logging enough innings for the ERA title, bullpen arms are much more important than any time in MLB history. And becoming more so all the time.

    To expand a bit on 25’s statistical overview, here’s the kind of 2026 season Sandro had.

    There were 1,382 minor leaguers who tossed 50+ innings and Santana was the sole twirler ranked in the 99th percentile in every single one of the following categories: ERA (1.97), FIP (2.68), xFIP (2.90), K/9 (14.20), K% (39.6%), K-BB% (27.5%), batting average against (.153), and swinging strike rate (17.8%).

    Righties slugged .276, and lefty bats slugged .140. Slugged. And as stl25 alluded, the 21-year-old was just as effective versus AA and AAA as he was early in the year against A-ball batters. Santana allowed a double on May 15th, which is noteworthy because he allowed exactly one more extra base hit over the remainder of the season (190 hitters).

    Yes, 2026 was a big breakout. But SS was also very effective in 2025 with a 2.73 ERA. And he’s been healthy now for two years running — 64 innings this year, 59 frames last season.

    I’d prefer he were a little bigger, and didn’t throw quite so hard, as that combo probably makes him a bit more prone to physical breakdown over the long haul. But you can’t have everything. As is, with his spectacular 2026 campaign, it’s still likely the best bullpen prospect profile since Craig Kimbrel some 15+ years ago.

    • This reply was modified 3 weeks, 6 days ago by Bob Reed.
    in reply to: 2027 TCN Community Top Prospect Voting Thread #321449
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Bob, on Dos Santos, do you push back on MLB.com’s evaluation where they have him as a 45 grade fielder. I’ve always assumed the SS who was given a 45 grade and has played about 40% of his innings away from the shortstop position isn’t likely to stick at SS or would be a below average defender at the position. My dream for him was basically to follow Wetherholt’s path where he ends up an above average defender, just not at SS. But it seems like you are much higher on his defense and projection at SS, and I’d love to get there as well.”

    Fair question, Yoshi. I wouldn’t give too much credence to MLB.com’s infielder fielding grades. They assign 45’s and 50’s to all but the most dazzling defenders, at least when it comes to Cardinals. JJ Wetherholt was a mere 50, and so was outstanding defender Tommy Edman. Paul DeJong was just a 50, and Brendan Donovan a 45. Unless I’m mistaken, they also gave superior cubby gloveman Nico Hoerner a 50. Call it careful, cautious, or cowardly, whatever you want. But they pass out a lot of middling numbers, so I take their grades with grains of salt.

    I put much more trust in two other things: actual on-field defensive performance, and Clay Davenport’s defensive translations, both present and peak.

    Without getting too granular here, Sebastian Dos Santos has put up real solid numbers as a 17- and 18-year-old shortstop, while also spending some time at 2nd and 3rd, of course. In sum, SDS has in his brief career participated in 44 double plays while committing just 11 errors. That is an excellent ratio for one so young. Compare it to his fellow Cardinal farmhands.

    Jesus Baez career: 131 DP’s and 61 errors.
    Miguel Hernandez: 25 DP’s and 20 errors.
    Yairo Padilla: 24 DP’s and 27 errors.

    Obviously a fielder’s range is as vital as his hands and throwing arm. But when it comes to the latter two categories, Dos Santos is pretty clearly miles ahead of the other three — especially Miggy and Yairo. And Dos Santos is a good enough athlete (steals bags, doesn’t GIDP) that there’s no reason I can see to assume he’ll have a range problem.

    ————————————————————-

    And then there’s the Clay Davenport Translations. Davenport’s been doing this kinda stuff for 30 years, and his glovework prognostications have proven prescient more often than not, so when his forecasting system says SDS will be a +10 at shortstop in his prime, that carries quite a bit of weight with me. Much more than anyone’s fielding grades.

    Anyway, one last thing about errors. For his short career, Dos Santos has an milb fielding percentage of .954 at shortstop. That fits right in with the minor league career tallies of some other recent Redbirds. Chronologically, you have Brendan Ryan .958, Paul DeJong .971, Tommy Edman .965, Masyn Winn .960, and JJ Wetherholt .963. Yeah, SDS is a little bit lower than the others. But he’s close enough that once we adjust for his extreme youth — and also for the fact that he’s been playing on the less-manicured lawns of the lower minors — I feel comfortable calling them his defensive peer group. At least for now.

    Lastly, thanks JNevel for the gracious words.

    in reply to: 2027 TCN Community Top Prospect Voting Thread #321398
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    This list is fascinating so far. Talk about a farm system with depth! I have 10 Redbirds as top 100 overall prospects; 5 of them are already on the list, but the other 5 have received little or no support. I think Fajardo throws more than fahard enough to be a number 1/2 starter, but I still lean toward a position player at this point.

    In the most recent rankings, centerfielder Alexander Frias is top 50 at Fangraphs and top 70 for Keith Law — but he was decisively out-hit on his own Palm Beach team by fellow 18-year-olds Miguel Hernandez and Sebastian Dos Santos. Since the latter has the best defensive projection, I’ll take him here. And even if he has to move to the hot corner, then we’d have Two Santos at third base, and that couldn’t be bad. 😉

    Sebastian Dos Santos at #8, please.

    in reply to: 2027 TCN Community Top Prospect Voting Thread #321206
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Sebastian Dos Santos at #7, please.

    (For the record, I think Tanner Franklin was an excellent choice at #6. Just not my first choice. I have Franklin & Fajardo [sounds like a vaudeville act] right after the duo of Dos Santos and Miguel Hernandez.)

    I’ll stubbornly stick with SDS here, not just for his hitting exploits, but also his glovework and baserunning. Regarding the former, Clay Davenport’s projection system figures Sebastian to be worth about 10 runs above average at shortstop, in his prime. And as for the latter, the young man has been a pretty good basestealer over his two professional seasons. In fact, let’s extrapolate ALL of his minor league numbers to a 160-game total:

    Dos Santos over 160 would look like this: .271 with 27 homers, 8 triples, 36 doubles, 55 steals, only 3 double plays grounded into, and 128(!) walks drawn.

    in reply to: 2027 TCN Community Top Prospect Voting Thread #321117
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Bob: Padilla had a lost season yet the organization kept pushing, and Padilla kept appearing as a middle of the order bat at DH. How far below the two do you have Padilla?”

    Good question, I’m glad someone mentioned Padilla. Gracias, Nigel.
    I have Yairo in the 12-15 range among Redbird farmhands, which equates to somewhere in the 120-150 range among all prospects.

    Just to quibble a bit, it wasn’t a completely lost season for young Yairo. He did play, albeit mainly at DH, as you alluded to. But if we count him as a shortstop, well, I mentioned in a previous post that only nine middle infielders in all of the minors this year posted at least a 125 OPS+ while being multiple years young for their level of competition. Fact is, Yairo didn’t miss being the 10th member of that illustrious group by much. (He had a 118 OPS+ and was 1 year + 362 days young for the Florida State League.)

    Sadly, he missed much time in 2026 with that injury. But just for fun let’s take the six weeks he played for Palm Beach and extrapolate out to 160 games.

    That would be .281 with 50 doubles, 11 triples, and 17 homers. Also 55 steals. Also 72 bases on balls. (Umm, and an astonishing 39 GIDP’s. Unlike SDS, who did not ground into a single double play in 31 Palm Beach opportunities [thanks, Pugs, for reminding me of that pleasant eccentricity].)

    To put it another way, if Yairo had done what he did at Palm Beach for 80 or 90 games, he’d be a top 100 prospect for me. But 30 games? I think “top 100” is a level or two too aggressive.

    In other words, he’s still a very good prospect — thanks to the power boost an even better one when it comes to hitting, than he was a year ago. But now his long-term durability is called into question, which is no small matter.

    in reply to: 2027 TCN Community Top Prospect Voting Thread #321072
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Sebastian Dos Santos for #6, please.

    He’s posted an OBP of at least .400 at all three levels, including hitter’s graveyard Palm Beach. He hit much better at Palm Beach than his fellow 18-year-old, Alexander Frias — and Frias is an outfielder ranked in the overall top 50 by Fangraphs and top 70 by Keith Law.

    Dos Santos had a dandy 129 OPS+ at Palm Beach. But the cool part is, he got better and better as the season progressed. Overall, 129 OPS+ and an excellent BB/K ratio of 0.73. Real good, right?

    Well, from July 15 forward, he had a 155 OPS+. A bat like that is a star at any position.
    Best of all, over his final 100 plate appearances, SDS had an 1.109 OPS with more walks than strikeouts. (That was an OPS+ of roughly 180.)

    Finally for the cherry on top, he homered from each side of the plate in the season’s final game. And both homers were opposite field shots. This bird can HIT.

    • This reply was modified 1 month ago by Bob Reed.
    in reply to: 2027 TCN Community Top Prospect Voting Thread #321044
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “This is a little rich for me for Dos Santos….I like the bat but a lot of strong rookie ball bats don’t end up turning into major leaguers.”

    “This is all very interesting discussion on the DSL/FCL guys….guys like Dos Santos, Hernandez and Luna are part of that next wave of prospects who could easily be Top 5 next year if they dominate again.”

    ———————————————————–

    I agree that rookieball prospects are unusually volatile — but the thing of it is, Dos Santos and Hernandez played very well for Palm Beach in the Florida State League, which of course is full season A-Ball. That is a huge step up from rookieball, and they each handled it without a hitch.

    Just to put their 2026 Palm Beach hitting performances into a proper context, there were nine middle infielders in all of the full season minor leagues this year who posted at least a 125 OPS+, while also being multiple years young for their level of competition. Just nine guys. (Min. 100 PA’s.)

    Two of those nine are Sebastian Dos Santos and Miguel Hernandez. The other seven are all on MLB.com’s top 100 list, and all seven are also within the top 75 at Fangraphs. The average ranking for those seven is 33rd at Fangraphs and 25th at MLB.com. That is the peer group for SDS and Miggy. (The pair of Redbirds, by the way, averaged a 146 OPS+, while the other seven averaged 141, so no real difference to speak of.)

    But if we get even more granular re age and level of competition, there were just three fellow 18-year-old middle infielders in Low-A who posted at least a 125 OPS+ in 2026. Those three have an average rank of 32 at Fangraphs and 35 at MLB.com.

    Call me crazy, but all things considered I don’t think SDS & Miggy are any riskier than Joshua Baez, due to their substantial present advantage in both plate discipline and potential defensive contribution. In my opinion, both our 18-year-old shortstops rate an overall top 50 ranking, with Dos Santos around #40 or so. He looks like Lindor Lite to me.

    Forgive my long-windedness. And thanks, everyone, for the responses to my previous post!

    • This reply was modified 1 month ago by Bob Reed.
    in reply to: 2027 TCN Community Top Prospect Voting Thread #320953
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    I’ll go with Sebastian Dos Santos at #5, please.

    The 18-year-old switch-hitting shortstop has done nothing but hit. He batted .313/.452/.570 last year in the Dominican Summer League, then this season he posted an OPS of 1.015 in the Florida Complex League (3rd-highest OPS in the 6-year history of the FCL), before finishing up with a 129 OPS+ in full season A-ball for Palm Beach in the Florida State League.

    But here’s my favorite part, where Dos Santos’ Palm Beach performance mirrors that of someone you know, a certain Rainiel Rodriguez.
    In 2025, from mid-July to season’s end, Rai-Rod had a sweet 24/26 BB/K and an OPS 262 pts. above the FSL.
    In 2026, from late July to season’s end, Dos Santos posted a 24/27 BB/K and an OPS 263 pts. above the FSL.

    The two players were the same age, within a matter of weeks. Now, I’m not implying that SDS will kill the baseball like Rainiel Rodriguez going forward. I’m just saying that Dos Santos has been more spectacular at the plate so far than he’s been given credit for.

    • This reply was modified 1 month ago by Bob Reed.
    in reply to: 2027 TCN Community Top Prospect Voting Thread #320942
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Leonardo Bernal at #4 for me, please.

    As for Josh Baez’ defense, JNevel is absolutely correct that Josh didn’t play much left field at all in the minors, starting fewer than 50 games there in his entire farmhand tenure. But for me, I’m less concerned about Baez’ glovework than I am his plate discipline. I feel like one part Nolan Gorman & one part Tyler O’Neill is Josh Baez’ likeliest outcome as a hitter, and that’s not enough in an outfield corner to make me vote for him yet. Baez’ MLB debut at Wrigley was incredibly thrilling, but a 33-to-4 strikeout-to-walk ratio is scarifying.

    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Let’s take a concrete example.
    Liam Doyle’s last 10 starts in AA, he allowed 8 earned runs in 50.2 innings. To compute the ERA, take 8, divide the 8 by 50.667 (50 and 2/3 IP), then multiply by 9. That leaves the ERA as 1.42, I trust you’ll find.

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 1,091 total)

First-hand news and commentary on the St. Louis Cardinals™ and minor league system for over 25 years