Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Maybe they are constantly trading them to add that piece to win now?
They are in a position where they can paper over mistakes by just eating a contract and writing another check…
Why would this year be any different than the first three he was here?
I mean, not re-signing, Lynn and Gibson does open up a couple of rotation spots.
They did let Goldschmidt walk without so much as a by your leave…
We are still saddled with Matz and Mikolas.
Arenado is still here although he could be an Astro.
I’m not at all happy with Siani as a starting outfielder – but maybe he won’t be.
Truthfully I’d rather have Gorman at third so Donovan can play 2nd so we can see what we’ve got.
Obviously Walker and Gorman and to some extent Nootbar are in their put up or shut up year.
It’s not just the last two years. There were no playoffs in ’16, ’17, or ’18 either.
The last time the Cards were really good was the first half of 2015.
Yes they won 100 games and the division that year but they rode in on their first half record and were easily dismissed 4 games to 1 by the Cubs in the Divisional Series.
Great news!
So, let’s say the Cardinals do work out a trade for Arenado before the season begins.
Who do we think will play 3b? Gorman with Donovan settling in over at 2b?
Now, let’s say the Cardinals do NOT work out a trade involving Arenado and he’s still on the 40 man.
I understand they are still paying his full salary at that point but – if they are truely committed to the reset – then why can’t or won’t they do it anyway? Sure if you play Arenado and he’s hot that might help you move him at the deadline but what if he stinks?
As Roy Hobbs manager once said, “I’ve got to pay him but I don’t have to play him.”
He could hit Koufax.
A ‘mere’ $5 million dollar nest egg invested risk free at 3% will yield $150,000 annual income literally forever.
At 4% that goes up to $200,000 per year forever.
If you assume 40% gone to federal and state income taxes and agent fees then spend $500,000 per year to live, a pro athlete through salary, investments, and endorsements would (theoretically) need career earnings of 25 million over a 10 year period to stash a $5M nest egg.
So – average 2.5M for 10 years and dont blow a lot on wine, women, and song.
Sure, in order to boost the SS check you may need to work a career post baseball. Boo effin hoo.
Sure there are many guys who have 2-5 year athletic careers but they still made a lot more than the average Joe for a few years – and yes, they are clearly very special athletes but even league minimums are a dream salary for most people.
January 5, 2025 at 10:34 am in reply to: Top Cardinals Stories of 2024 and Look Ahead to 2025 #274387Hypothetically, if the ‘perfect storm’ of bad things happen that hamstrings the finances (TV money, ticket sales / attendance), do we think BDW might put the team up for sale in a couple of years?
With Gorman at third, Contreras at first, and Walker in RF – that seems like at least 2 to 3 extra base runners per game.
I don’t think any of our pitchers are going to like that. They won’t say anything publicly of course – but you have think they are groaning on the inside.
Throw Burleson into the OF on top of those three and – wow, that might be (on paper) the worst defense the Cardinals have ever fielded.
Is the above as bad as I’m making it out to be or am I overblowing it?
January 2, 2025 at 8:46 pm in reply to: FOX selling regional sports networks to Disney to Sinclair to MLB??? #274230I hope I can just buy the Cardinals games but KNOW I am buying and can watch all of them and not get cut out of Apple games and maybe some others.
Extra Innings was ok when you could actually see all the games but that changed a few years ago. I never used it to watch other teams games so I won’t miss that at all.
Well, to be fair, based on most of the past decade it’s actually a better look for BDW if he doesn’t understand.
Data is just data. It’s what you do with it that affects the end result of a game like baseball.
Baseball is and always has been a statistically driven game. R/L splits for batting average, on base percentage, slugging average, ERA, and WHIP are for me the most useful stats. The home ballpark effect is a real thing.
You can dive deeper but you have the be careful about drawing conclusions based on very limited data points. Case in point would be specific batter-pitcher matchups. I mean, how many times does a batter face a pitcher in any given season? Only a handful really so what conclusion can you really draw from Bob Uecker’s lifetime batting average vs. Sandy Koufax? He hit Sandy really well but are you actually going to make an in game managerial decision based on that stat?
Certain stats are very useful but many are just merely interesting talking points for the announcers. I think that a manager has to know his guys on the human level and gauge certain moves (both hitting and pitching) based on a myriad of things from yes – certain statistics – but also things as esoteric as; ‘How is my guy feeling today’?
I really believe managing a baseball team is equal parts statistics and ‘feel’.
You reap what you sow.
Smarmy condescending comments to ‘the idiots’ are damned disingenuous coupled with the product on the field – which has not been great since the first half of 2015 – is how the team and its finances unraveled to this point.
The Bally bankruptcy didn’t help but when you add up the new TV deal with other thing they are doing (can’t recall it atm) will likely keep that piece of the pie close to whole.
Would be interesting to see a breakdown of which teams pay (and how much) the luxury tax and which teams receive money (and how much) then couple that with how much money each receiving team spent on acquiring talent vs. retained dollars.
I wonder how much of each receiving team’s luxury tax revenue went straight to the bottom line?
So do some teams actually lose money forcing it’s owner(s) to ‘feed the monkey and watch him <defecate>’?
Merry Christmas to all!
At this point I think Arenado will (eventually) get traded before spring training.
If that somehow doesn’t happen then certainly before the trade deadline.
If he ends up hanging around StL I’d bet the locker room dynamic will be a bit funky but I also bet he’d be laser focused on producing so that outside interest will be as high as possible.
Moment of silence……
If Arenado wants out and if he really wants to play for the Dodgers then he will have to consider a salary reduction.
He can’t expect the Cardinals to eat a big chunk of his money and get very little back just to accommodate his wishes.
If I were the Cardinals I’d play hardball with him. Ok Nolan – you want to play for the Dodgers? Here’s how that will work – we’ll eat a little, you eat a little, and they will write you a (relatively) little check. If that doesn’t work then you can just stay here and take Carpenter’s place on our bench.
He may have a no trade clause but the Cardinals don’t have to make a horrible deal just to move his ass.
Maybe the ‘Greg Maddox’ style of pitching is the way forward?
Hmmmmmmmm.
With the NL now having the DH it allows for a guy like Walker to hang around. IMO, the Cardinals have too many defensive liabilities on the roster and they can’t ALL be the DH.
Again, the OF is just weak offensively AND defensively. It takes a really special POBO to pull that off.
2025 seems to offer a wide range of outcomes from a 65 win trip to the cellar to an 85 win wild card slot.
I agree with Bling in that most of the team’s positions are unsettled as to how the players will perform, which players will hold down the positions – or both.
I think his analogy of this season being used to ‘clear away the rubble’ is accurate and I would add that it will also be used to find out what we have in the younger guys we’re keeping.
This is the year for Nootbar, Walker, Gorman, Siani, Burleson, Pages, Herrera, Saggesse, and to some extent Scott to earn spots moving forward.
I think we know what we have with Contreras, Donovan and Winn. (I also think we desperately need an outfielder that can hit. The guys slotted to play are as weak a bunch collectively as I can recall.)
The starting pitching is a disaster in my opinion with only McGreevey and Pallante as possible future pieces. All the others are either too old or not good enough to build around.
We know that Mikolas and Matz are only here another year due to their contracts.
The pen will probably be solid against but if Helsley is dealt then Romero is your closer? Lol.
For me, 2025 could go in almost any direction.
If guys like Walker and Gorman break out, if Burleson, Winn and Donovan continue on and don’t regress, if a couple of young starters blossom – this could actually be a wild card team.
On the other hand if the struggles continue for Walker and Gorman, if a couple of others regress, if the injury bug hits hard, if the young starters are still a year away – then yeah it could be a real long season in StL.
I am as unsure about this team for next year as I ever recall being.
November 19, 2024 at 7:40 am in reply to: What Went Right/Wrong & Where Does that Leave the Cardinals #271981So, we think Nootbar in LF, Siani in CF, and Walker in RF?
On paper that might be the worst OF in MLB both at the plate and defensively. (Siani is fine with the leather but a gaping hole with the bat )
I am really hoping they trade for a CF that can hit and let Siani be a back up.
-
AuthorPosts
