Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
It’s really the ‘Hall of Very Good’ and has been for a long time.
In ’85 the tarp monster ate rookie Vince Coleman.
There are probably more trades coming plus a dumpster dive or two if necessary.
Quantity over quality.
I guess this would be a good time to define ‘competitive team’
Outside of simply fielding a squad, what does that term mean to each of you.
For me – being ‘competitive’ means being a plus or minus .500 team and it is the least any franchise should try for – even during a rebuild.
With the bloated playoff system, hanging around .500 generally keeps you in the mix for WC3 up to or even into the last week or two of the season – at least on paper.
This is the space the Cardinals have lived in for most (not all) of the last decade and the ‘get in and get hot’ model of team building has worn might thin with a big chunk of the fan base.
I think they play Cricket in India? I suppose Pallante could make the switch from baseball…
Begining towards the end of 2021 through 2022 and into 2023 we all experienced double digit inflation combined with shrinkflation (less product for a smaller price increase)
We all go to the grocery store. The same trip today costs 25-35% more than it did in early 2021 – and prices will never go back. Our incomes will never catch back up at our (most of us) advanced ages
As far as a trip to StL goes, hotel room prices have skyrocketed as has the cost of eating out.
I’d bet Bill’s ballpark village gross income has suffered as prices for everything have reached the puke point for a lot of people.
The days of post covid revenge travel finally petered out in mid- 2024.
Baseball as a whole needs to rework its archaic regional broadcast system in order to maximize that revenue stream – and I think that is slowly happening.
Fan engagement and putting a good or even better a great product on the field and then providing your fans with multiple ways to give you their money has always been the formula but the specific ways to separate fans from their money is always evolving. Baseball in general and the Cardinals specifically are behind the curve.
The cost of attending a big league ballgame is ridiculous. The Cardinals have always been a regional draw meaning that many fans travel in for a series and food and hotel costs are also ridiculous.
It’s not just the cost of the tickets.
November 29, 2025 at 8:07 am in reply to: Something to discuss on Thanksgiving-Oli Extension #296680I don’t trust or distrust Bloom yet. I will give him a two year window to sort this crap out and put a playoff caliber team (WC 1 or better: ie top 4 in the league) on the field – so that’s ’26 and ’27 to get sorted and then arrive in style in ’28.
November 28, 2025 at 10:30 am in reply to: Something to discuss on Thanksgiving-Oli Extension #296645After spending an enormous amount of time asking AI to research the impact on the number of wins and losses a ML manager has on a teams record – ‘the computer says’ up to 4-5 wins and as many as 7-8 losses.
Taking the two extremes with +5 wins being a great manager and -8 wins being a putrid manager the spread is a maximum of 13 games – which is significant.
Stepping further out onto the AI limb it suggests that the vast majority of ML managers influence 2-3 games per year – either way.
So unless the manager is horrifically incompetent to the point of being silly – no matter who is in the dugout it’s plus or minus 2 to 3 games a season from a strictly procedural management point if view.
Now, if the manager creates / allows to fester a toxic clubhouse culture where the players are absolutely miserable and at each other’s throats then from a human resources standpoint I could see a massively negative impact. On the other hand a really good clubhouse chemistry where everyone gets along and has each other’s back – while pleasant – will not lead to a massive increase above talent level in wins.
Personally I think Marmol is a middle of the road, competent ML manager who probably learned a lot about keeping his mouth shut after the Tyler O’Neil base running drama.
In my opinion he was too young when he was promoted but after 4 years he’s now not.
If the Cardinals ever get back to at or near the top of ML baseball – say an actual NLCS contender – then those 4-5 games that a truly elite manager brings to the table will actually matter. Unfortunately, that’s not a likely discussion for at least a few years…
November 27, 2025 at 3:57 pm in reply to: Something to discuss on Thanksgiving-Oli Extension #296624In college, it really hurts recruiting if the HC doesn’t have a few years left on his contract; I don’t think it matters much if any in the pros.
At this point I’m ambivalent on Marmol as the manager; I can see plusses and minuses. Sounds like he’s going to get an extension of some kind – could be only 1 year tacked on. I guess we will see.
I don’t care if they fire him and I don’t care if they add a year to his contract. Now, my eyebrows will raise if Bloom adds 3 or 4 years to his deal.
Try not to gain more than a pound and a half…
Now the off-season can finally go full steam ahead. There are so many ways things can go with Bloom at the controls. Compared to the last two years we Cardinal fans should have a lot to talk about.
I’ve been to Montreal but not to Toronto. Vancouver is the big city on the west coast.
Pretty sure they have zero Canadian players though, lol
2 planes so the players get their own? Good grief at the excess and waste…
Yes, here is hoping for an entertaining WS with seven games decided by 1-run.
I think Goldschmidt falls a little short of the HoF. If he gets in it won’t be a travesty at all but, for me, nope.
We will have to see who the Cards sign out of the FA market or trade for but – barring Bloom going way off script OR about 6 of our developing players getting way better ahead of the curve I expect 78-83 wins and no playoffs BUT the big difference will be that the expectations for 2027 should be to make the playoffs.
Assuming that baseball gets played in 2027…
I’m not sure I see why so many teams are lining up to hire Pujols to manage. This isn’t college – there is very, very little recruiting and that’s limited to a few free agents.
I guess it’d be like hiring Ted Williams or Stan Musial to manage….You get a big name in the dugout – whatever that turns out to be worth.
Apparently, Schildt was not much a pleasure to work for or with. It seems Mo took a lot of unnecessary heat when he fired him for wrapping it all up in ‘philosophical differences’.
I wish there was a way both teams could lose.
I’m convinced that we really are finally entering a soft rebuild – or did enter it in 2025.
I expect 2026 to be another .500 +/- season with more and more younger players getting shots to prove they belong at the big league level.
2027 would be THE year the team starts to rise and turn the corner from a record standpoint.
Now, based on player development, if CBA issues kill a big chunk of 2027 I think that’s an absolute disaster for StL. So, we need to hope we don’t lose a lot of that season.
IF, and I say IF, Bloom is both good and lucky then 2028 feels like the year the Cardinals are true WS contenders again.
So, as far as the manager goes – 2027 feels like the year to make a change if Bloom wants to replace Marmol and get fresh faces and voices in the dugout. If Bloom likes what he’s seeing with how the young players are being handled he might very well stick with Marmol & company.
If Bloom hits everything out of the park – minor league development, drafts, trades, the manager – all of it; the the Cards are serious contenders in three years.
If he’s hit or miss then welcome to more plus or minus .500 baseball with the occasional playoff appearance that isn’t sustainable.
If he’s a bust then we’re the Pirates or the Rockies.
As we all know Bloom may be a bust. We have all watched organizations struggle for decades and never figure it out. Draft picks dont pan out. Injuries ruin and derail careers. Bad luck or bad calls cost key games. Trades go tits up and you watch what would have been your future win for another organization
Doing all the right things dues not guarantee success
Five years from now the Cardinals could still be stuck in a rut, going nowhere, and starting over with a new gm.
Bling – oof… Surely not, lol
That would be bad, irresponsible, and really dumb.
-
AuthorPosts
