Bob Reed

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 25 posts - 776 through 800 (of 1,093 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: StL 2019 Game 31 thread: Thu 5/2 at Nats #89677
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Paul Goldschmidt has been a monster with men on base over his career.

    Bases Empty: .869 OPS with an average BB/K ratio of 300/632
    Men On Base: .997 OPS with a solid BB/K ratio of 266/463

    But here’s the weird catch. He’s not good with the bases loaded. In fact he’s much worse with the bases loaded than he is in any other men-on-base situation.

    Bases Loaded: .854 OPS with a crap BB/K ratio of 6/28

    Well, make that 6/29 now. I’m not saying that Shildt shouldn’t have used him there. Not saying that at all. But it makes for an interesting study of psychology, in that Goldy certainly appears to simply place too much pressure on himself, or just gets impatient, when the sacks are jammed. He isn’t himself.

    in reply to: StL 2019 Game 31 thread: Thu 5/2 at Nats #89654
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Leone warming up. Cards are hell bent on not sweeping this series.”

    If you don’t let Leone pitch in the ninth inning or later, you’re usually okay. Career OPS allowed, very very late in games: over 1.140 in 151 plate appearances. (Not a typo. 1.140+ OPS.)

    6th inning: .657 OPS in 204 PA’s
    7th inning: .675 in 237 PA’s
    8th inning: .644 in 166 PA’s

    in reply to: Watching our Farm System #89649
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Here are a couple of names that caught my eye as possible exceptions.

    Nootbaar had five homers, but batted only .227 in April.
    Montero started slowly, but was playing well the last 10 days before he was injured.”

    Yeah, I can see an argument for Elehuris Montero as a grey area guy, as he’s come on strongly of (very) late. I suspect that your optimism is not misplaced, Brian.

    Lars Nootbaar is having an unusually promising start. I’m stickin’ to it.

    He doesn’t offer much in the way of glovework or baserunning value, but Nooty’s underlying numbers reflect positive hitting traits — low pro batting averages notwithstanding.

    This is a hitter with an outstanding 144 wRC+ for Peoria despite a BABIP of .235. How is he doing it? A very good walk rate of 13%, excellent power (isolated slugging of .256 vs. league average of .118) and most impressively an elite strikeout rate of just 9.6%.

    Roughly 1,200 minor leaguers have 50 or more plate appearances so far. Of the real prospects (those under 25 years of age), only four have an isolated slugging over .200 and a K rate under 10%:

    Lars Nootbaar (.256), Wander Franco (.235), Alejandro Kirk (.230), and Vlad Guerrero Jr (.244).

    This doesn’t make Nootbaar any sort of elite hitting prospect. Or even a good one. But it sure makes him interesting. Nooty’s a little old for his league, but I like him anyway. I’d probably put him above both Luken Baker and Genesis Cabrera on my prospect list, among others.

    My expectations for Lars were non-existent before the season. Now he’s a plausible 4th/5th outfielder long term. Maybe even more. It’s such an idiosyncratic profile, I don’t know what to expect. And that’s fun.

    in reply to: Watching our Farm System #89617
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Funny how with the big league team doing well the Nunez talk has almost totally died. I think there is a direct correlation.”

    Yeah, I confess I haven’t given much thought to Malcom N. over the first month of the minor league season. For me though, CC, it’s because there’ve been so many unexpected performances by prospects — both good and ill.

    Much worse than expected: Reyes, Hudson, Montero, Urias, Kruczynski, Hurst, and Cabrera.
    Much better: Gorman, Herrera, Sosa, Edman, Rondon, Oviedo, Toerner, Whalen, Nootbaar, Julio Rodriguez, and Woodford sort of. Oh, and Jesus Cruz. Absolutely Jesus Cruz.

    So there’s been a lot to take in, a lot to process for trends both positive and the other.

    (Apologies to any overachievers I forgot. And if I left out any underachievers, you’re welcome I guess.)

    in reply to: Less and less demand for traditional sports writers #89484
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    You’re just sayin’ that, So Cal, because you know I lived in Malibu. (Say hi to George and Michel at Colony House if you’re there. And Martha and Winston at the Artifac Tree. If they’re still around. “You know, Bob. The tallish bald guy with the beagle!”)

    I don’t write anywhere but here, as no one compensates me more than Brian does. To pay bills there’s part-time moneymakers dealing sports memorabilia and editing the scribblings of others. All brands of stuff, novels, corporate reports, all sorts of miscellaneous. Anything less sophisticated than White Papers.

    As with pretty much everyone ever, my life may have turned out quite differently if not for fate’s fickle finger, So Cal. When I’d been at Inside Sports a handful of months, I approached my managing editor Jim O’Conner with the idea of penning some magazine filler pieces here and there. And being a sober man of sound judgement, he agreed. I was on cloud ten, with all the cloud nine suckers looking up at me.

    Three days later we were bought out by Peterson Corp., publishers of Sport Magazine. And they fired us. Oh, I’m sorry — they downsized us. You bet I was downsized. Downsized like Rick Moranis’ kids by that shrink machine. And thus, a budding career began and ended the same week. Since then I’ve just had jobs. Jobs I liked and loved. But just jobs.

    So if you know anyone who wants a copy editor or mildly misanthropic ink-stained sportswriting wretch, I’m your guy.

    ——————————–

    “I subscribed to a Cardinals only baseball magazine in the early 80’s called ‘Redbird Review’. It had write-up and glossy photos of some Cardinals’ prospects. I want to say that Jim Lindeman was on one of the covers.”

    Jim Lindeman! Now there’s a name, muddy, that brings back Spring Training memories galore. Remember back in ’87 I think it was, when Lindeman destroyed Spring Training? He was a force of nature like Florida hadn’t seen since Hurricane Whosis back in the late 1960’s.

    I just looked up his career and was surprised to see than Jim acquitted himself very well in the dome-tainted 1987 postseason. He went 9-for-28, including 5-for-15 in the Series. Not too shabby.

    in reply to: Less and less demand for traditional sports writers #89435
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “For me they (ESPN The Magazine) were airplane reading during takeoff and landing.”

    I admit I read it a few times myself. In many ways a deeply underrated publication, for the bottom of a birdcage.

    I was working at Inside Sports magazine in ’98 when the ESPN bi-monthly hit the stands amid much fanfare. As we passed around the maiden copy of E.T.M., we couldn’t believe the breakthrough. Finally, a magazine for folks who enjoyed neither reading nor thinking. It honestly wasn’t like anything that had come before. The USA Today was The Economist by comparison.

    The late great journalist Frank Deford had faith in American sports fans when he founded The National, a glorious twin pillar of daily sports entertainment and enlightenment. It lasted 18 months. On the other hand, the cynical vile dreck-peddlers at ESPN got better than two decades from their hollow rag. How can these facts exist in any rational world? All I can figure is, I guess George Carlin was right when he said to imagine how stupid the average person is, and then realize that half of them are more stupid than that.

    in reply to: StL 2019 Game 29 thread: Tue 4/30 at Nats #89369
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    I do appreciate the P-B-P, Pugs. And I don’t want to play the killjoy.

    But I hate getting my hopes way, way up…and then dashed, all within a fingersnap. So anyway don’t listen too much to me — other people probably prefer the high-energy stylings.

    in reply to: StL 2019 Game 29 thread: Tue 4/30 at Nats #89362
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Goldy – Gives her a ride to deep left! Juan Soto back to the track and he’ll corral it on the track for the out.”

    Two rules to live by, Pugs:
    1) Coffee is for closers.
    2) Exclamation points are for homers.

    I recall one Mike Shannon call oh so very vividly. It was the eventual 20-inning loss to the Mets, back about a decade ago. Allen Craig I think it was, up in extra innings.

    “Long one down the line! If it’s fair it’s a game-winner! And that one is…caught up against the wall.”

    Calls like that one define Mike Shannon to me. And not in a good way. You could not pay me enough to ever again make me listen to Mike Shannon broadcast a Cardinal game. Yeah, the Hatfields and McCoys have got nothing on me, when it comes to holding grudges.

    in reply to: StL 2019 Game 29 thread: Tue 4/30 at Nats #89322
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Per Goold, Fowler has the flu. No indication when he caught it and how much longer he will be out.”

    Just glancing at the matchup possibilities for the next couple of days, it may have been smart to give Dexter a couple days off anyway. He hasn’t hit Sanchez well and has struggled badly versus Scherzer. As have so many. Like Paul Goldschmidt for example.

    Goldy is 1-18 lifetime against Mad Max, with 10 strikeouts. But Gyorko has hit him well. So maybe, Carp slides over to first base and Jedd gets a start at the hot corner against the St. Louis native. (Did you know that Scherzer is from St. Louis? It’s true.)

    Surprise stat of the day:
    Harry Bader, batting .222, has a higher on-base percentage than Jose Martinez, batting .351. Martinez has the edge in slugging, by 15 points. But Bader tops him in OBP by 25.

    Bader has a higher OPS than Martinez or Fowler. Barely, but still higher. Probably plays juuust a bit better defense, too. Gotta get the kid in the lineup whenever you can.

    in reply to: Minor league thread – Mon 4/29 #89181
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Hot Players = Sosa(very quietly .334 but only 3BBs) Toerner (mashing at Palm Beach… the tough league) and Gorman has been what we all hoped for and more.

    Sosa’s impatience is mildly troubling, it’s true Ny. But he’s hitting for avg./power, and we can’t ask for more than that from a shortstop in a bad hitting environment. (Road games only this year: .394 average, .636 slugging.)

    I’ve found the Cardinal catcher cache pretty exciting so far. At Palm Beach, 21-year-old Julio Rodriguez is hitting .339 with a 169 wRC+. Molina heir apparent Andrew Knizner is batting. 333 with a .400 OBP, is yet to commit a passed ball, and has gunned 46% of basestealers.

    And maybe most fun of all, 18-year-old Ivan Herrera has a 166 wRC+ for Peoria after a 155 and 160 at the lower pro levels in 2017 and 2018, respectively. (After his severe PB troubles last year, Herrera also has not permitted a passed ball, and like Knizner he’s showing solid plate discipline markers.) In fact, so far the three catchers cited here have combined for 20 walks and 31 strikeouts. Good sign for the future.

    in reply to: Alex Reyes Update #89119
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    I’m boringly ambivalent.

    I say trade him if you can get 75 cents on the dollar, because to me the chances that he’ll ever be more than a reliever seem pretty remote.

    Two major injuries in two years, and three self-destructive instances of fairly severe immaturity just that we know of (two drug busts, plus one wall-punching of course) do not bode well for the future, I don’t think. Has anyone with such a checkered health history, coupled with behavioral question marks, ever panned out as an above average MLB starting pitcher for any length of time?

    Again, I’m talking ~75 cents for a buck. I’m not advocating he be dumped for a borderline top 100 prospect type just to spare us the anxiety of waiting and hoping, hoping and waiting, over and over. But if the Cards could get a very good cost-controlled MLB bullpen arm, or a top 50-60 or so prospect at a position of relative organizational need, then I say cut the strings. Because if Reyes keeps up this Steve Dalkowski impersonation, he’ll have very little value a year from now.

    in reply to: 2019 draft #88941
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    I could see Kody Hoese lasting for awhile in the draft. Hoese has never done anything until this year.

    Hoese may be another Tulane optical illusion, not unlike Mike Ferris whom the Cards drafted instead of Dustin Pedroia back in 2004. That one left a mark. (On me anyway.)

    I want a guy with a less suspicious track record, whether it’s a hitter or pitcher. What can you tell us, 2016, about that Small guy?

    in reply to: Minor league thread – Thu 4/25 #88812
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    It’s the other way around, Minuteman. Edman’s a shortstop by trade.

    So far as a minor leaguer, 2,000 innings at short, 600 at second, 200 at the hot corner. Defensive rep is solid, probably not quite as good as Edmundo Sosa at shortstop. But he’s a better asset on the bases by far than Edmundo. Real good speed & instincts for Tommy.

    And of course Edman is a switch-hitter, which doesn’t hurt. Very nice prospect right now, edging close to Sosa for top 10 in the organization on my list.

    in reply to: Underrated John Gant #88753
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    You make some fine points, Pads, about the specifics of John Gant’s season thus far. To this point perhaps one could argue that Gant’s been hard-used, but not quite abused.

    But I don’t think I would use Walden to buttress my argument, were I you. (That is, if you’re arguing that Gant could be used frequently now, and be just fine later on.) Through the team’s first 15 games in 2015, Walden was on pace for 119(!) appearances and over 100 innings. He made one more appearance before breaking down, and he hasn’t thrown another MLB inning since.

    As for our current closer, young Howitzer Hicks at his most-used juncture last year was on pace for “only” 74 games and 96 IP through April 24, the first 22 games of the season. So never was he at the Gantian usage level we’ve seen this season. (Of course, we could adjust for Hicks’ age or number of pitches thrown relative to Gant, or the off days, etc.. Angels and devils are both in the details.)

    “Isn’t is funny that the only pitcher who seems to be able to make it 6 innings consistently is Waino – the old guy?”

    Well said, Minuteman. I admit I didn’t and don’t have much faith in Waino logging a quality season as an MLB starting pitcher. Over the winter I wanted Adam and the team to announce his plans to be nothing but a reliever from here on out. After all, he hasn’t thrown 30+ innings with a sub-4.40 ERA since 2014. But as you say, he deserves full marks for eating innings so far.

    in reply to: Underrated John Gant #88707
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Thanks very much for all the kind words, you guys.

    “I suppose another thing to consider for Shildt is that you’d presume you will have Carlos Martinez and/or Alex Reyes available for some of those later season innings if Gant starts to need more rest or becomes ineffective.”

    Agreed, 25. I think it’s not unreasonable to expect two or three eventual good bullpen contributions from among Martinez, Reyes, Ponce, Gomber, Woodford, Helsley, and maybe even fast riser Jesus Cruz. But the real problem right now is…

    “…our starting rotation just hasn’t eaten enough innings this year, whether that is poor execution on their part or a quick hook by Shildt or both. By my rough calculations the starting rotation has logged 57% of our innings and the bullpen 43%.”

    Yeah, I’d say “both,” gscott. Entering play Wednesday, the Cards were 21st in innings by starters, and 12th by relievers. They’re averaging almost exactly 5 innings per start, and really they need to get to 5.5 or a bit better. Or they’ll burn out more than just John Gant. Especially if they have an extra inning game or two during a protracted stretch without any off days.

    I think Shildt’s single greatest managerial strength so far — tactical strength anyway — has been removing his starting pitchers before they go too deep. To paraphrase a famous baseball axiom, it’s better to remove a starting pitcher one inning too soon than one batter too late.

    But if Shildt’s cautious approach is to work, you better have a deep pen, and you better get the periodic 7-inning start. I’m concerned that the latter feels unlikely, and the former I just don’t know. I think it’ll depend on the aforementioned potential reinforcements.

    Giving up lots of walks and homers at anything like the current rates(s), and NOT getting burned by them just isn’t a repeatable thang, I don’t think. Before today, across all MLB, Redbird relievers were a horrid 10th percentile in homer rate, and only a bit less horrid 20th percentile in walks. That’s a very scary combo. Makes that #4 ranking in bullpen ERA look awfully fragile.

    in reply to: StL 2019 Game 24 thread: Wed 4/24 vs. Brewers #88689
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Yelich with my favorite splits of the young season.

    Home: 13 HR, 29 RBI
    Road: 0 HR, 2 RBI

    Okay, it’s the second split that’s my favorite of the young season.

    Well done, Redbirds, on the sweep!

    in reply to: StL 2019 Game 24 thread: Wed 4/24 vs. Brewers #88684
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Not seeing the logic of letting an overworked Brebbia go 30 pitches with a 4 run lead.”

    Just a grey area decision to me, CC.

    Brebbia is on pace (before today) for 75 games and 90 innings, which are indeed a lot — but not crazy outlandish (like with Gant for example).

    And Brebbia had yesterday off, and won’t pitch tomorrow of course. But the other important thing, his recent pitch counts have been exceptionally modest. He only threw 11 pitches on Monday, and just 12 on Sunday, and only 3 on the Friday before that. So, fairly fresh for someone who’s been used a lot.

    If that makes any sense. 🙂

    in reply to: Minor league thread – Tue 4/23 #88609
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Small silver lining to the Peoria defeat: catcher Ivan Herrera made his 12th start behind the plate, and remained without a passed ball on the season.
    This isn’t completely inconsequential, as Ivan had a prohibitive 7 PB’s in just 20 games last year. Herrera was just 17, but still. That’s too many.

    Young backstops frequently have troubles with passed balls, but one every three games…well, Carlton Fisk had one every three games in the Midwest League over 50 years ago, and that’s the only other guy that bad off the top of my head. (For an eventual great catcher, I mean.)

    Mr. Bench was kind of notorious for struggling with PB’s as a youngster, and at age 18 in A-ball he had a PB once every six games. Yadi at 18 played in rookieball, and boxed a pitch once every five games.
    So I’m impressed with Ivan so far. And the .972 OPS doesn’t hurt either.

    Lastly, I loved the young man’s comments, quoted in the TCN Prospect Handbook, about growing as a player and a person. He sounds unusually mature, both emotionally and intellectually. Reminded me of the Carson Kelly quotes I used to read a few years back. Herrera has his head screwed on right.

    in reply to: Underrated John Gant #88608
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    With tonight’s two-inning stint, Gant is now on pace for 90 appearances and 120 innings — both wildly unacceptable. He likely won’t last through June. But that’s okay. (For the team, if not for John Gant.)

    I’m not complaining about Mike Shildt, just as I didn’t complain about Mike Matheny when he road the bullpen hard. It’s ten times smarter than a starter being overworked. Because there might be another good bullpen arm right around the corner in Triple-A. But there are no above average starting MLB pitchers sitting in Memphis.

    And the unpleasant truth is that someone on the staff is always going to be overworked by the manager, if every single game matters, from April through September, and the manager is trying his hardest to win every single time.

    That’s the difference between the Matheny/Shildt teams and the LaRussa years. There were several seasons when Tony’s Redbirds more or less routed the division by Labor Day. Four times they won the Central by ten games or more, and two other times the margin was six and eight games. And conversely there were also years when the club was nowhere near the playoff race. (Three times under LaRussa they won just 73-78 games.)

    So under Tony LaRussa there were many years without the incessant, season-long, vise-like pressure. Without the grinding, constant, day-in, day-out pressure to win every game, month after month after month, all the way to the very end.

    Unlike with Mike Matheny. Now, he won as many games per season as LaRussa. More in fact. But the Matheny margins in the standings were quite thin — not most years, but every single year. Even when Matheny’s Cardinals led the majors in wins in 2013 and 2015, the division title still came down to the final week — or weekend. When they won 100 games, the Pirates won 98 and the cubs 97. When the Cards won 97, Pittsburgh won 94. There were no chances to breathe.

    Every single year since LaRussa left town, the Cardinal season has hung in the balance right up until game 160 or so. Since Matheny’s tenure began it really has been a constant crucible unlike any in club history. Perhaps unlike any seven year stretch in the history of any team. Not because the Cardinals haven’t been as good as they were under LaRussa. (They’ve been better than under LaRussa. About two wins per year better.)

    But the opposition is also better now. So the Cardinals have had to win every single game that they could, over and over and over, for seven-plus seasons. And when you’re doing your darnedest to win every single game, someone (or two) on the pitching staff will be overused eventually. It’s inevitable.

    Tonight the Brewers didn’t use Josh Hader. And maybe that’s why they lost. But they know that Hader is a superlative talent — you know, like Andrew Miller used to be — that they must try to protect when they can, because he could be a big part of their team for years to come.

    That’s not John Gant. Gant has done a great job. But he is not ever going to be Josh Hader. And neither were Matt Bowman or Seth Maness or even Kevin Siegrist.

    in reply to: StL 2019 Game 23 thread: Tue 4/23 vs. Brewers #88605
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Great win, finally beating Milwaukee in a one-run game. Huzzah! All alone in first, thanks in no small part to an excellent performance by erstwhile Redbird Luke Weaver versus the Buccos. Thanks, Luke. (As has been said before, he and Greg Holland were clearly tipping pitches last year. It’s the only thing that makes sense. Why an internet crackpot can figure this out, and the Cardinals couldn’t is beyond me. [And it’s probably part of why Hudson has been lit up this year, as well.])

    Anyway, bragging/whining aside, Cards have been out-homered 11-to-3 over their past three games — and are undefeated. Extraordinary.

    But I’m fine with tons of singles and doubles, and of course the occasional tater. The .240 hitter with 35 homers is in fact less valuable than the .280 hitter with 20 homers…but it seems like every batter wants to be the former these days, rather than the latter.

    And speaking of which, here’s how power-centric hitters have become, just over the past handful of seasons. Entering play today, seven entire teams had an isolated slugging over .200.

    Just three years ago the highest ISO in the majors was .188 (Orioles).

    Three years before that, the highest team ISO was a mere .171 (also Orioles).

    I don’t mind 3 1/2 hour games (when the Cards are winning, anyway). Or even 4 hour games. But what I want is more plays, in the field, by players, and runners. But not Yadi running. Just other people.

    The ball is unquestionably juiced this year. Ryan Braun’s homer yesterday convinced me for sure. There was nothing special in that AB. A year ago he may have had a line-drive double, but just as likely the ball goes straight to the RF’er for a running grab. Instead it jumped for old man Braun like it was crushed by prime Pujols or Piazza.

    Deaden the ball back to normal. Lower the mound 2-3 inches to cut back slightly on strikeouts. And maybe even enforce the rulebook strikezone, to cut down on walks. (Though I suspect that fewer cheap Braun-like homers will indirectly lead to fewer walks, because pitchers won’t fear throwing strikes when behind in the count.) The aesthetics of the game would improve immeasurably.

    in reply to: StL 2019 Game 22 thread: Mon 4/22 vs. Brewers #88543
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Bobby will be wearing Fowler’s jersey around and have a large poster of Dexter on his bedroom wall, just like we did with Farrah’s poster back in the day, by season’s end.”

    Well, don’t bet the rent on that one, Pugs. And I wasn’t a Farrah guy either, red one-piece poster or not. Among the Angels it was either Jaclyn or Cheryl for me.

    Sorry if I was too acidic in my comment, Texas. I’ve read so much malarkey lately about what a “great guy” Fowler is, that I just got sick of it. Because there’s nothing great at all about someone who takes zero responsibility for their own actions. My remarks reflected that, as much as my modest expectations for his performance going forward.

    As my dear mother told me growing up, “If you can’t say something nice, just go on the internet and say something awful.”

    in reply to: StL 2019 Game 22 thread: Mon 4/22 vs. Brewers #88475
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Give Dexter a little love. He’s now hitting .313. Hopefully he can keep it up. It would be an amazing resurgence.”

    After he blamed his terrible 2018 on his teammates, his manager, and everybody but himself? No love from me. I don’t care if he hits .380 and wins the N.L. MVP. I have no respect for the man as a ballplayer. (If he were to loudly & publicly retract his statements about Matheny and his 2018 teammates, I’d certainly amend my low opinion of him. But not before.)

    Fowler’s blame-shifting began in October and continued all the way through Spring Training with his nonsensical “I wasn’t given the benefit of the doubt in right field.” He’s the standard-bearer for the modern self-absorbed professional athlete. Even with plenty of time to reflect on his lost 2018 season, months of time, he still pointed fingers everywhere but at the mirror.

    I want him to succeed because of the jersey he wears. But I dislike him personally, rather intensely, and I don’t see that ever changing. And for whatever it’s worth, I predicted he would have an OPS 156 points better than last year (on average that’s how much Wong, Piscotty, Voit, Aledmys Diaz, Ozuna, Grichuk, and Pham improved post-Mabry in 2018). That would mean a .732 this year. I’ll stick with that forecast.

    On a considerably lighter note, it sure is sweet being in first place — and thumping the Brewers to get there. Yes, they’re tied with the Buccos. But I don’t count Pittsburgh.

    in reply to: Minor league thread – Sun 4/21 #88392
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Indeed, Sosa is having a good season so far. He was solid in ’18…”

    A very good season so far, and maybe better even than it looks at first glance. Like last year, Edmundo’s numbers appear to be suppressed at least a bit by the pitcher’s park in Memphis.

    Sosa’s road game slashline in AAA, combining last year and this: .328/.375/.560

    It’s only 136 plate appearances, and I certainly don’t think that a .935 Triple-A OPS is Edmundo’s true talent level right now. But maybe .840 to .860, something of that nature. And that would make him an overall top 150 prospect and keep him ahead of Tommy Edman on my personal list. (Edmundo just turned 23 last month, making him nearly a full year younger than Tommy.)

    It’s that power increase that’s kind of exciting with Sosa — recall that he had more extra base hits than strikeouts + singles in Spring Training. Okay, it was a minimicro sample. But it may have foreshadowed a real step forward.

    in reply to: StL 2019 Game 20 thread: Sat 4/20 vs. Mets #88187
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Firstly, big kudos to Miles Mikolas. When you drive in as many runs as you allow, you’ve had a great day at the office. Research project: how many times did Gibson and Wainwright accomplish that feat? Or Forsch maybe?

    “When the team is at full strength, I don’t think Martinez should be in the starting lineup. On that triple to right center, he was barely in the picture. I would like to see Thomas get a start in center and move Fowler back to right. Hopefully that would work until Bader is back.”

    I also like the idea of Lane Thomas in center for now. His glovework reputation is good, and the metrics back it up. (And an outfield alignment of Ozuna/Fowler/Martinez is asking for trouble. Begging for it, actually.) And heaven knows, even the optimist in me has been pleasantly surprised by some Cardinal prospects in recent years. I never thought Tommy Pham would have a 5-WAR season, or Matt Carpenter a string of 4-WAR campaigns, or that Paul DeJong would do what he’s done over his first 1,000 plate appearances (7+ WAR).

    But I do like Martinez in RF when there’s a lefty starter. In Jose’s (admittedly brief) major league career, he’s beaten southpaws like rented mules: .333/.406/.569

    Even with the bad defense, that’s just too great a line to leave on the bench. Fowler can start versus righties, sure, while Bader & O’Neill are both suffering ouchies. But Martinez has to be in the lineup for lefties.

    Last season, they were .249 (overall) and .295 (runner on 3B, less than two outs). Why can’t hitters put up the same average no matter the situation? Aren’t they trying their hardest in every at-bat?

    I know you’re joshin’, Brian. Ya big josher. I would say that the man with the bat and the man on the bump are entered into an involuntary collaboration of sorts, and when the situation places too much pressure on the hurler, he over-cooperates with the batter. Probably what happens a lot is the twirler gets timid, starts to nibble, falls behind, and has to groove one.

    At any rate, here are the overall MLB splits for the past 5 years. First, batting average and OPS with bases empty. Then, the same for when there was a man on 3rd and fewer than two outs. (Each year, we’re talking about roughly 100,000 PAs with the bases empty, and 10,000 with a man on 3rd, less than 2 out. So there are no sample size distortions whatsoever here.)

    2018
    Empty: .241 & .710
    3rd/LT 2 out: .318 & .864

    2017
    .250 & .738
    .331 & .889

    2016
    .250 & .727
    .316 & .853

    2015
    .248 & .704
    .316 & .840

    2014
    .245 & .682
    .326 & .839

    So the difference is real, and it’s spectacular. It’s generally 70-75 points of batting, and 140-150 points of OPS. That’s the handicap. The Cards need to do better, for sure.

    in reply to: StL 2019 Game 20 thread: Sat 4/20 vs. Mets #88169
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “After last night’s game I was wondering does anyone know what our team batting average is with a runner on third and less than two outs? Asking for a friend.”

    The team is 9-36 with 15 strikeouts and just 3 sacrifice flies. So that’s a .250 average (and a ~.700 OPS).
    For context, this year the MLB average is .323 with a .905 OPS. And double the sac fly rate as well.

    So yes, the Cards have been horrific compared to their peers. (Last year the MLB average was .318 with an .864 OPS, and in 2017 it was .331 and .889.)

    Obviously an enormous advantage is to the hitter in that situation. But the Redbird batters (so far, over a very small sample) have been unable to understand/exploit that.

Viewing 25 posts - 776 through 800 (of 1,093 total)

First-hand news and commentary on the St. Louis Cardinals™ and minor league system for over 25 years