Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
I don’t know Yadi’s protocols well enough to have an opinion, BHC. Could be he does that in a lot of road games — and even some home games. I can’t put it into a meaningful context. Lot of help I am, huh?
Now for the rant.
We’re in an age where the Super Bowl MVP was a PED cheat, thrown passes by the Deflategate cheat, while being coached by the Spygate cheat. Cheaters never prosper? Sure they do. Lately they prosper more than anyone.
Alex Rodriguez gets to broadcast ESPN games every week, and even interview Hank Aaron. I nearly vomited, seeing them in the booth together the other night. Maybe Lance Armstrong can do a guest spot on ESPN this summer, covering the Tour De France.
There are no ethics in sports anymore, and maybe there never really were. But the difference is, now there is no shame. Ryan Braun, none. A-Rod, zero. ESPN, nada. If Bonds or Clemens or A-Rod or Big PEDi get into Cooperstown, I won’t be going back. I’m a relic, I guess. I actually thought that the Golden Rule was the foundation of all ethics. Confucius said it first, then Hillel, then Jesus, then finally Kant. It was THE rule to live by, if you forgot all the others. Now it seems just a minor inconvenience, something to be dodged on the pathway to professional athletic success.
Also, get off my lawn.
——————————————
I suppose I should add that many teams no doubt are trying to swipe signs in the “natural” way every game. That is, the players themselves looking for tells. That’s baseball. But once an outsider is introduced into the equation (e.g., Astros, Indians) then it is cheating. In my opinion.
2017 Brewers Home/Road team batting splits:
Home: .251/.322/.438
Road: .248/.322/.4192018 Brewers batting splits:
Home: .247/.322/.431
Road: .257/.323/.418So obviously the Brewers in 2017 and 2018 did not get much of an artificial hitting boost from their home park. Basically none, really. But how about 2019?
This year, before tonight:
Home: .300/.377/.584
Road: .227/.317/.365Now I’m not saying that Milwaukee has someone in centerfield with high-powered binoculars, stealing signs and relaying them to Brewer batters. But I’m saying that if they DID, then this is EXACTLY what their home/road hitting splits would look like.
Maybe it really is just the ballpark, though, somehow. So let’s check Brewer pitchers this year. Well, their pitchers are allowing a batting average just 14 points higher at home this year than on the road (as opposed to 73 points for their hitters), and a slugging percentage 97 points higher, compared to 219 points.
Yeah, the majors are difficult. I get it. But when Dakota Hudson allows 8 homers in nearly 300 career minor league innings, and zero home runs in 33 MLB innings in all other ballparks…but 5 homers in 8 innings at Miller Park this year, something looks more than a little bit fishy. (Hudson didn’t pitch in Miller last year. But then, there was nothing going on last year anyway, as evidenced by the previously-referenced season splits.)
Yes, I’m probably paranoid. And a “hater” when it comes to disgraced PED cheat Ryan Braun and his team. But as the saying goes, even paranoid people have enemies. And as a corollary, even the most hyper-suspicious and cynical baseball fan is right some of the time.
“I always like to see prospect’s better their numbers as they climb through the system. Johan Oviedo is doing just that early on…
By the end of ’18 he was the starter in the Chiefs opening round of the play-offs vs. Quad City. He pitched 6.0 innings of a 3-0 win…
At present Oviedo ranks at +/-#20 in most polls that I’ve seen including #20 on the latest TCN rating. His potential got him there and increasing his performance will no doubt boost him higher.”
Good info, Ny. With Reyes & Hudson graduating from the prospect list, it’ll be interesting to see who inherits the mantle of Top Pitching Prospect in the organization by season’s end. Johan certainly rates as a possibility.
Anyway, to supplement your insights I thought I’d include here some quotes from Kyle Glaser’s Baseball America Redbird prospect chat.
“Evaluators both internally and externally actually liked Oviedo quite a bit even when he wasn’t going so hot, and his second half turnaround really strengthened their belief that he could be a potential back-end starter someday.” (Emphasis mine.)
And better still, this:
“He’ll show you 96 and flash both a plus breaking ball and a plus changeup, but never at the same time.”
So clearly there is talent in the big man, however intermittently expressed. Glaser’s rather lengthy Oviedo remarks conclude with “His 2019 will be very, very interesting to watch, and I think he’s got a chance to really pop.”
I think the same could be said for both Angel Rondon and Jake Woodford, re “a chance to really pop” in 2019. But really, all we’re plausibly hoping for long term is a possible #4/5 starter from one of these guys (or Helsley, or someone else). Not that there’s anything wrong with that.
“Nolan Gorman just led off the Top of the 7th with a solo blast to centerfield. 1-0 Chiefs.”
…and that was indeed the final score, 1-0. Thanks, stormin’ Gorman! On a related note, here’s a fun early season micro-sample comparison.
Ivan Herrera and Nolan Gorman are Peoria Chiefs teammates.
Nolan Gorman is very young. Ivan Herrera is younger
Nolan is homering for 27% of his base hits. Ivan is homering for 33% of his hits.
Gorman is walking once every 13 AB’s, Herrera every 5 AB’s.
Gorman has struck out in 26% of his plate appearances. Herrera has whiffed in 32% of his.Conclusion: Ivan Herrera is more Gormanesque than Gorman himself.
This was not intended as serious analysis, of course. But Ivan — the only minor league backstop in any organization to post a 150 or better wRC+ in both 2017 and 2018 — is to my mind one of the overlooked potential gems of the Redbird system.
How overlooked? Fangraphs had Herrera 33rd in a Cardinal farm that they graded bottom five in baseball even when Reyes & Hudson still had eligibility. I rated the Panamanian 18-year-old roughly 140th among all prospects before the season began, and I feel at least 10% vindicated already due to the early evidence of a Herrera power increase. So far in his brief career he’s hit well enough for any position on the field. And if Ivan Herrera can remain at catcher, the Cards might really have something.
“This is what I call a ‘bench game’ being as the entire bench started the game. I gave them about a 10 percent chance of a win. That will teach me. Shildt figured out a way to get 4 guys two days rest before having to drink Mexican water.”
Yeah, the “bench game” theory. Tony LaRussa did it relatively often, once or twice a month loading the lineup with bench guys, usually on Sundays I believe. For the first 6 or 8 years that he managed the Cards, it drove me nuts. Why not spread the playing time around more, for the backups? Why seriously inhibit your chances to win this given game?!
But then I happened one day to be listening to the radio during a Redbird pre-game show, and TLR was asked by the interviewer about this very topic. And he said something that really resonated — and taught me about how I’m not always as smart as I think I am. Usually I am. Just, not always. 😉
Tony said that by playing all the bench guys together, it created a team esprit de corps that couldn’t be generated any other way. The thinking was, if the “bench team” won the game, it united the bench guys with one another more than before — and united them with the starters, too. But if the team lost the game, well that’s what they were supposed to do anyway. And at least a bunch of starting players got a day of rest.
I’ve probably simplified things a tiny bit, but that’s the gist. And it does make a lot of sense. Whaddayaknow, a first ballot Hall Of Fame manager knew something I didn’t know, about managing a baseball team.
April 12, 2019 at 3:10 am in reply to: What is wrong with Dexter Fowler and what should be done? #87041“Now Fowler should never see a lefty again and in many circumstances Martinez should play against righties.”
Couldn’t have said it better myself, booyah.
Starting Fowler against any lefties, while Jose Martinez is available, constitutes managerial negligence.Martinez, career, versus southpaws: .325/.400/.550
And as you insightfully opined, my fellow fan, Dexter should never see certain righties either, i.e., the ones who qualify as “power pitchers” per Baseball-Reference. Fowler’s OPS against such pitchers has plummeted from .806 in 2016 to .635 in 2017, then finally to .443 last year. (Martinez has a career OPS just over .700 when facing said moundsmen. Not world-beating, but vastly superior to Delicate Dexter.)
Obviously the best thing for the organization would simply be to release Fowler and platoon Martinez and Tyler O’Neill in right field for the remainder of the season. Per Fangraphs, since the start of last year Dex is tied for the 4th-worst position player in the majors with a total “value” of minus 1.4 WAR, from a .569 OPS and negative nine runs on defense. Rotten in 2018, rotten in Spring Training, rotten so far in 2019.
Playing him doesn’t save any money. Not a nickel. And releasing him doesn’t cost any meaningful money of course, since he’d promptly be replaced by dirt cheap internal options — but oh the public humiliation for all involved, if Dexter were given those walking papers.
“Then Irving Lopez sends home the hometown fans with a walk-off 2 run blast to right field. Springfield wins their first game, breakout the champagne.”
Even better, Lopez with the rare golden sombrero/walkoff homer exacta. Very glad for him, and the team.
Dylan Carlson with a very Carlson night: 2-4 with a single, double, and base on balls. I’ve personally moved him up from roughly #90 overall prospect to borderline top 50, after seeing his surprising athleticism in Spring Training, coupled with his blistering start to the season. (And of course a handful of guys above him have graduated or been injured.)“I very much doubt that Andrew Miller will run 13%/17.4% K/BB rates for the entire season, nor will Alex Reyes be at the astronomically terrible 5.9%/35.3% K/BB. So even with some BABIP regression, I expect the bullpen overall to be better.”
That’s well put, 25. I’ll somewhat reluctantly accept the proposition that perhaps this year’s and last year’s bullpens are NOT created equal. We’ll see.
In any case, even a bullpen fault-finder like myself can’t complain about today’s dynamite reliever performance. Eight K’s in 5 1/3 innings when the club needed it badly — with no walks and a measly pair of singles. Okay, plus a hit batter that I’ll choose to imagine was for some reason in honor of Bob Gibson.The homestand may have begun with a whimper but it ended with a lovely double comeback bang. How often do you get to win a game wherein you trailed by 3 runs twice?!
“I get the BABIP point, but I am less concerned.
Brebbia is one with a very low .111 BABIP so far. Last season, it was a normal .297 and he still had a good season (0.7 fWAR).
Gant is also at .111 now. Last season, he was at .253. He also had a solid 2018 (1.2 fWAR).”Pretty persuasive rebuttal, Brian.
I’m still right, of course. But I’m grudgingly entertaining the possibility that you are right as well. I’ll endeavor to follow your lead and fret far less.The Cards now have a +15 run differential on the season despite having played one of the toughest schedules around. Redbird opponents are a terrific 25-12 in their non-StL tilts, with an excellent collective +30 run differential of their own. (The Trolleydodgers are 8-2 when not playing Cards, the Pirates 6-2, Pads 6-4, and the Milwaukee Yeliches 5-4.)
That Sobieck dame’s got panache. Nice arm, too.
The StL bullpen 2018: 22nd in MLB in K/9 rate, and 29th in BB/9.
This year’s bullpen: 23rd in MLB in K/9 rate, and 28th in BB/9.So why is the bullpen ERA so much improved? Simple. This year’s relief corps has allowed a .159 average on balls in play. In other words, they’ve so far been by far the luckiest bullpen in the history of the sport.
Last year, the lowest bullpen BABIP was the Athletics at .265; in 2017 the leader was the Yankees at .272; the year before that it was the cubs with a .262 BABIP allowed. You get the idea.
This year’s pitching staff will rise or fall based in large part on AAA callups and July trade acquisitions. And they better get something pretty big from Carlos Martinez, too. Because the current bullpen is built on sand.
Lighter note: great, great rally today. Way to fight back, boys, whatever the eventual outcome.
“Grichuk: He was given many many opportunities to start here and could never seize the opportunity because of his poor OBP. I’m glad we aren’t paying him $52M.”
The following career numbers are from Fangraphs, a couple days back. See if you can guess which one is Cub star Javier Baez and which one is underachieving & undisciplined hitter Randal Grichuk.
Player A is 27 years old and has accrued 9.3 WAR in 1,877 MLB plate appearances.
Player B is 26 and has accumulated a total of 9.9 WAR in 1,940 PA’s.Player A has a lifetime wRC+ of 110, strikes out 29% of the time, and walks 6% of the time.
Player B has a lifetime wRC+ of 103, whiffs 28% of the time, and walks just 5% of the time.The answer of course is that it doesn’t matter much at all which is which, since they’re more or less identical in terms of age and production at the MLB level. (Not saying I wouldn’t rather have Baez — middle infielders are tougher to find than outfielders. But the point is that Grichuk has had a good career so far, and should be good going forward. I think Toronto got a relative bargain.)
“The organization must have the resources to do this, and they are rewarding their tenured players with nice deals as the ride into the sunset in their careers.”
I think we’re debating at cross purposes, BikeMike.
I’m not concerned about whether ownership has sufficient resources to cover the tab. The hazard here isn’t that the club will get a poor return on its investment. That’s not what worries me.
The profound hazard is that there’ll be a yet another repeat of what we’ve seen over the past few years with Fowler, Holland, Cecil, Gregerson, and to a certain extent Wainwright — that a contract commitment dictates who plays and who doesn’t, who starts and who sits on the bench, who remains on the 40-man roster and who gets rightfully released.
If Fowler for example were making $6M a year instead of $16M, not only would he not be starting, he likely wouldn’t even be on the team anymore. He’d have been released last year before Mike Shildt had a chance to inexplicably re-insert him in the starting lineup. Which of course would make this year’s outfield Ozuna, Bader, and Pham, with O’Neill waiting in the wings to take over for Ozuna in 2020. (In other words, with Fowler gone there would’ve been no need to trade Pham last year. Pham was traded to get Bader back into the starting lineup where he belonged, but from which he was pulled by Shildt in deference to Delicate Dexter.)
The terrible hazard with a contract extension like this is that at some point in the future — and for an extended period of time — the team actively hurts itself by using players who are markedly inferior to other available options.
I’ll say it once more. For the first 7-8 years of his tenure, Mo was as shrewd as any GM in the sport. I would not have exchanged him straight-up for anyone. But over the past 2-3 years he’s been a C- or D+ general manager. Maybe straight D, really, if you give him a meaningful demerit for the bizarre and highly idiosyncratic mishandling of Jordan Hicks’ formerly promising career. Of course Mozeliak has gotten some things right in recent years; even a .150 batter gets a hit now and then. But on balance Mo has declined precipitously as a decisionmaker, and this wholly unnecessary and potentially very counterproductive Carpenter contract is the latest in a long line of gaffes.
Okay, I do not get this one, at all.
The Cards already have first base locked up for half a decade. Now the same for 3rd base — with (perhaps) the system’s top 3 position players all 3rd-sackers.
Carp is off to a relatively poor start this year, and he can’t possibly move to the outfield in the future. He’ll be 36 years old for the 2022 season. I love the guy, but there’s an 80-90% chance that he will NOT be the best choice for 3rd base in 2022. And probably not 2021 either, in my unhumble opinion. (Yes the DH might be coming to the Senior Circuit, and then again it might not. But either way, do you want an old, $20M designated hitter? I don’t think I do.)
This continues a trend that began with Waino’s $97M extension several years ago. Since then there’s been Yadi, Fowler, Goldy, now Carp. You can kinda throw Cecil, Holland, and Miller in there, too. It’s a bad trend, paying big bucks for guys on the wrong side of 30. In fact I think it may be a terrible trend.
To put it most simply: when any given MLB team exceeds reasonable expectations, is it usually because young emerging players/pitchers provide a significant unanticipated boost to the organization? Or is it usually because some old players or pitchers have surprisingly big seasons? I would guess the former happens about ten times more often than the latter.
>>> Bob Reed… thanks for posting the info on Gorman’s glove yesterday. Its a little more concrete than what I’ve read.
You’re very welcome, Ny! I don’t know how helpful this will be, but here’s the “report” I filed on Gorman’s glovework last August when I saw him in Peoria:
“In the field, Gorman had one tough chance. He had to charge and throw on the run, and he showed fine footwork and a strong accurate arm. Not a howitzer, but he didn’t need one on that chance. In fact, he had three plays while I was in attendance (first 7 innings) and Gorman showed that ‘internal clock’ that people talk about, usually in regards to shortstops. Didn’t dawdle, didn’t rush, throws were spot on.
Looks like a player.”“Minuteman. Get one of your grandkids, or neighborhood kids to show you how to do Uber or Lyft. It’s a lot easier than you think, and Uber/Lyft will drop you off right in front of the stadium.”
Or there are cabs, I would think, in a city the size of Springfield. People who drive a taxi for a living, and have maybe done so for many years. You know, rather than scab cabs. Um, I mean “ride-sharing” apps.
Thanks very much, UConn! I hope to be a useful team member this season.
As for Gorman’s defense, GScott, I only saw him in person once last year, but he moved fine laterally, and charged well the only ball in front of him. So I would say that his “actions” were solid for the hot corner. It’s all about consistency. (I haven’t heard anyone say Tiny Thome was a “bad defender,” and given the extremely high number of double plays he turned last year, I don’t think such a characterization could reasonably be justified.)
Quoting from the prospect handbook, 18U National Team Director for USA Baseball Matt Blood says of Gorman: “Defensively, he can make all the plays there…solid-average to plus arm, solid-average to plus hands…in my opinion, I think he is going to be a solid-average to plus third baseman.”
I share Mr. Blood’s optimism, if that’s worth anything. Anyway his complete quote offers more detail, so get that handbook if you haven’t!
“Brian, you stated that Gorman leads the minor leagues in xbase hits. Is that the entire minor leagues or just our system?”
It was actually my aside, CC, about Gorman. And yes, he leads all of the minor leagues. Well, he’s tied with three Pacific Coast League guys who play in hitter’s parks.
No Midwest League hitter has more doubles than Gorman, no MWL hitter has more homers, and only one hitter has more triples. Here’s how well the kid is hitting so far: if you took each of Gorman’s singles and turned them all into groundouts, he’d still be batting .286/.375/.810.
“Goldy swung at ball 4 that was 2 feet off the plate.”
Given how nightmarishly poor the Cardinal front office has been lately at evaluating MLB talent — both their own and that of other teams, as well as free agents — I fully expect Redbird fans to regret the Goldschmidt extension before it even begins.
I realize this is well-trod ground but it really is an astonishing record of futility over the past couple of years. Fowler, Ozuna, Pham, Voit, Piscotty, Grichuk, Andrew Miller, Holland, Gregerson, Cecil, and Marco Gonzales. Each radically mis-evaluated.
Mozeliak and/or his scouts were among baseball’s best for 7 or 8 years. But they’ve been so horrible lately that I’m forced to concur with those calling for Mo’s head. The Andrew Miller fiasco is the final tipping point. (It doesn’t help that intellectual cipher Mike Shildt makes Mike Matheny look like a cross between Earl Weaver and Casey Stengel.) The front office is so terrible now that it wouldn’t shock me if they signed Craig Kimbrel tomorrow for 50-60 million bucks (and the lost draft pick of course), only to watch him post a 6+ ERA with the birds on the bat.
It’s a testament to the draft and development people that the personnel looks okay going forward. But the club probably does need a front office overhaul at this point, as Mo can apparently no longer be trusted to make any decision involving pitching or free agency or staffing (see Shildt/Maddux/Lilliqist/Mabry/Albert). The only one worth his salt among that quintet was Lilly, the guy Mo fired. Okay, it’s way too soon to tell with Jeff Albert — but like Andrew Miller the results are far from what was expected.
Tyler O’Neill with 4 hits today, and none of them homers? Must have the flu.
Star of the day was Dakota Hudson, though. Bailed out Bambino Mikolas with 6 shutout innings. The Nationals lineup that rocked Miles for 5 XBH’s in 3 innings couldn’t managed a single extra base hit versus Hudson.
I’ll say it again. If Hudson can learn to elevate a 4-seamer just 10-12 times a game, and upgrade his command a bit, he can be something like the 2014-17 version of Jake Arrieta. That is, plenty of groundouts but strikeouts too, and 190 innings per year, 2.67 ERA, 3.04 FIP, 3.25 x-FIP. That’s the plausible Cy ceiling. Dakota’s stuff is that hard to square up.
Sounds real good. Thanks, Brian!
“Dexter was only three extra base hits away from the cycle!” gushed Redbird manager Mike Shildt.
In truth there were a couple of positives. Mayers was sharp, Reyes allowed one runner and whiffed two in his inning of work, and Drew Robinson had 2 of the 3 team knocks. So the marginal guys on talent who are more or less default roster locks did okay.
Did those minor league games get played, Brian?
Good guessing, gentlemen. The winner is indeed Moises Castillo, CC. Well done!
And you’re right to mention the difficulty factor, Pugs. I wanted the answer not easy to divine via cursory research.Anyway, Castillo played in the DSL at 16, the GCL at 17, and the Appy League at 18. (I expect he’ll return there in 2019.) So the organization has shown some confidence in his ability to compete against older players.
Moises was a slightly above average batter in both 2016 and 2017. He struggled for most of the 2018 season, but then flipped a switch at season’s end. Specifically, over his first 135 plate appearances he homered just once, while posting a crummy 7/31 BB/K ratio. Then over the final two weeks (58 PA’s) he homered three more times while drawing 11 walks and striking out on just 7 occasions — and posting that aforementioned OPS of nearly 1.000.
Could just be a blip, for sure. Probably was. But IF half of that radical improvement was real then Castillo becomes an interesting guy. And if 2/3 of it was real he’s a top 20 Cardinal prospect, assuming he can stick in the middle infield.
If Mike Trout enjoys just average health over the remainder of his career, this new contract will generate more surplus value for the Angels than any contract has generated for any team in MLB history.
In short they’re paying for a 4-5 win player, and getting someone twice that good. This is an astonishingly fantastic bargain for the Angels, almost impossible to overstate. Like Brian, I’m glad that the Millville Meteor will spend his entire career with one team. But I think I just heard Marvin Miller flipping over in his grave.
“And that makes an 8-12-3 record for St. Louis on the spring.”
Well, I said back in January that I’d be happy if the Cards just posted a better record than the Red Sox in 2019. So far, so good!
Seriously though, it was a whale of a nice rally, scoring all 5 ninth-inning runs after two were out. Great two-strike approach exhibited by both Max Schrock and Elehuris Montero to keep the line moving.
One thing. With Urias, Edman, Edmundo, and Schrock, something’s gotta give. Not nearly enough regular playing time in Triple-A for the entire middle infield quartet, especially once Drew Robinson is sent down, and moreover if/when Evan Mendoza arrives at Memphis to play 3rd base. (They can’t possibly take Robinson north over Munoz, right? Not when Munoz is the one with an actual MLB track record of batting success, and he’s outhitting Robinson by 200 OPS points this spring, and he’s years younger than the erstwhile Ranger.)
This team needs relief pitching so badly, and it has upper minors middle infielders (and outfielders) coming out of its ears. There must be a trade to make, somehow, for an honest-to-goodness bullpen arm. Get it done, Mo!
“Suggestion for surprise bullpen stud this season – Mayers.”
I think he’ll be better than last year, cranny. But I’m not sure there’ll be any bullpen studs twirling in the shadow of the Arch this year.
Last year the Cards had zero relievers pitch 35+ innings with a sub-3.00 ERA. For context, every other team in the N.L. Central had between 3 and 5 such relievers. Heck, the lousy 2018 Reds, playing in a hitter’s park mind you, had 3 relievers with 65 innings and a sub 2.70 ERA. (I wouldn’t take 3-1 odds on even one Redbird reliever doing that this season.)
I don’t see anything changing this year. I mean, I’ve got a pretty good imagination and based on what we know right now I can’t envisage how anything changes re the StL bullpen. The three theoretical “shutdown arms” at the back of the bullpen all pitched last night, and the results were gruesome across the board.
Maybe I’ve just got a hangover from that debacle, but Miller especially was horribly disheartening. And his explanation didn’t help things. “Distracted” by the baserunners? A 13-year MLB vet, in a Spring Training game, was distracted by baserunners? C’mon, gimme a break. Either he’s (1)completely full of crap, or (2)the most easily distracted pitcher since Cueto dropped the ball because Pirate fans cheered too loudly. Anyway, when 60-70% of your pitches miss the strikezone by a foot or more, something is dreadfully wrong with you — whatever the reason.
I believe the Cards can win 90+ games and the N.L. Central even with a distinctly below average bullpen. But they can’t win it with a truly terrible one. They need to package a couple of prospects pronto, to trade for a very good reliever from a very bad team.
The 18-year-old Nolan Gorman — misidentified as 19 on multiple occasions by the Nationals broadcast team — is almost certainly the youngest Cardinal to homer in an official Spring Training game in a long, long, long time. Perhaps ever.
On the other hand, the fistful of strikeouts and errors show just how very far he is from MLB-ready. The day could not have summed him up better. A true gem is this kid, but with much cutting and polishing to come. I expect we’ll see him in the majors for keeps beginning sometime in 2021, when he himself is 21.
-
AuthorPosts
