mudville

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 25 posts - 1,176 through 1,200 (of 3,520 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Winn Called Up #231974
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Thanks, GameCard. You just moved Tommy Edman’s trade value up a few notches with that comment. I’ve been on the Hudson bandwagon for years, now. It’s been a bumpy road, and at times, I’ve had to hold onto that bandwagon for dear life. I still love Huddie because of all the gr0nds balls he throws when he’s really on his game, and the defense that follows. Edman has been a contributor to that defense on many occasions.

    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    There was a lot of optimism around DeJong at one time, and he’s set for life financially as a result of that optimism. It’s just sad for him and the Cardinals’ fan base that he didn’t do more to deserve all the money he got. Hopefully, Matt Svanson, the pitcher the Cardinals got back for DeJong will be able to contribute in the major league ball club, eventually. But, at the very least, moving DeJong, has given us a chance to have a look at Winn, and it saved the Cadinals about a million dollars in cash. According to Derick Goold, the Cardinals still have to hand over about million dollars to pay for half of DeJong’s salary for the remainder of the 2023 season, plus $2M for his 2024 buyout, and another $1M for his 2025 buyout. I think the total cost to the Cardinals, with the buyouts, is actually $4,000,065, if my math is correct. Are there any other profession where you get paid for being a failure? When you get into the big money, I guess there are. Something is definitely wrong with that picture. In a way it’s unfair to DeJong, also. He has to go through life knowing that he became a multimillionaire, not because he deserved it based on productivity, but because of a flawed system. Only the fans can change this flawed system.

    in reply to: Roster Matrix #231708
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Jnevel – Your comment that the Cardinals are a business is incorrect. Baseball (Cardinals included) is not, functionally, a business, rather it is America’s pastime. If you are inclined to disagree, please submit indisputable evidence.

    in reply to: 40 Man Roster at Season’s End #231705
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I had high hopes for Wilking Rodriguez, also. ‘Hidden gem?, mudville thought. But as it stands now, the only reason I see for bringing Rodriquez back is that, if they don’t, the front office has to admit that they pissed away $100,000 of the boss’s money for nothing. Now a hundred grand is a mere pittance by today’s MLB standards, unless of course, your the boss whose hundred grand was pissed away. And it’s my understanding that WDWJr does, in fact, pay attention to those minor details. So I’d say that there’s a better than even chance that Wilking Rodriguez is retained.

    in reply to: 2024 Rotation #231704
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    As i pointed out in another post, Herrera is not ranked, either. Maybe the ‘experts’ who made that Top 30 ranking were just having a bad day at the office?

    in reply to: 2023 StL Game #121: Wednesday, August 16 vs. Oakland #231703
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    ‘Lavatory’? Geez, Rat. I know Libby’s been disappointing most of the year. But, as one poster pointed out, he sure looked promising during spring training, and he was really good until about the middle of May. Regardless of it being the A’s that he’s pitching against this evening, if he wins he deserves some sort of validation…. maybe skip the jubilation. But if he wins, it’s a win for everybody.

    in reply to: 2023 StL Game #121: Wednesday, August 16 vs. Oakland #231702
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I’ve said before that, to me, Knizner is looking like a MLB caliber catcher now that he’s out of Yadi’s shadow.. He’s playing with confidence, and he’s hitting better than he ever has at the major league level. His Caught Stealing rate is only 8% this year. But that looks like an outlier because in 2022 his CS was 25% and in 2021 his CS rate was 23%. That CS rate is not too far off from where Contreras has been. And since it appears that Knizner has improved in other areas of catching, he might just improve that CS rate as well. I think Knizner is our everyday catcher until somebody shows up and proves that he is clearly more gifted than Knizner. That said, this has been a transition year for Contreras, so we might not have seen the best of him yet. It will be interesting to see what he looks like next year if the Cardinals don’t trade him.

    in reply to: 2023 International Class #231617
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Speaking of Ivan Herrera, the Cardinals do not list him in their Top 30. I wonder why that is?

    in reply to: 2023 International Class #231616
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Herrera and Bernal, both catching prospects, are from Panama. So the Cardinals apparently have a scout down there. I don’t know of any pitchers from Panama, though. Also, they have a connection in Venezuela. But it’s my understanding that they don’t actually send scouts there because it’s too dangerous.

    in reply to: What’s it gonna take to fix the Cardinals #231516
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Just a few comments…
    LACardsFan’s post about Stroman, Gray, and Snell, and Willianms being late round draft choices pretty much sunk my proposition that the Cardinals’ pitching woes were a result of picking ‘best available’ in the later rounds instead of going for pitchers. However, that’s a pretty small sample size and I think it’s still safe to say that the best pitchers are almost always gone by the later rounds. One thing I’ve wondered about is how it is the Cleveland and LA Dodgers, and Tampa Bay seem to be good at finding really good pitching prospects. Is it because they have more scouts than other teams? Is it blind luck? My best guess, and a guess it is, is that there are certain scouts who are just stars at evaluating pitching prospects. And if a ball club has one of those kinds of scouts in their organization, then that makes the difference. The problem is that, just like superstar players, superstar scouts are hard to find, and when an organization finds one, they don’t let him go.

    Second. Shane Bieber is still a possibility. Logan Gilbert is also a possibility, but less so, in my opinion, unless the Mariners come down from their ridiculous demand for Nootbaar in a trade for Gilbert.

    Third. I don’t see any really appealing free agents to throw money at this year with the possible exception of Aaron Nola.

    Fourth. The Cardinals surely knew what they were getting when they signed Contreras. They held out for a long time before putting the ink on the paper. They probably did it for fear of backlash from the fans if they didn’t do something. Herrera had a lousy year in 2022, and for the Cardinals to show up at spring training with Knizner and a low level free agent backup would have been grounds for rioting in the streets of St. Louis. The TCN website, for sure, would have had their computer hardware overheated.

    Fifthy (although I could probably rattle on about other things) I couldn’t care less about DeWitt making money on Ballpark Village. I see it as an asset to the City of St. Louis especially with the demise of the Washington Avenue entertainment district.

    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Shocking that Kelly got DFA’d. I thought he was going to be an All Star for a long time after Goldy retires.

    in reply to: What’s it gonna take to fix the Cardinals #231360
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Spend money, spend money, spend money…. Sure let’s just stand back and throw money at the problem. Outbid all comers. Sarcasm, of course.
    First of all, forget Ohtani because that isn’t happening. How about 34 year old Marcus Stroman? He’s having a fine year while he strives to earn his last big contract. Or, maybe 34 year old Sonny Gray. Yeah. Let’s give him everything he wants. Then, there’s the oft injured Blake Snell. Let’s lure him to St.Louis with a pot full of money. Aaron Nola. That’s it. Let’s break the bank on Aaron Nola. It will take breaking the bank to beat out the Phillies, Yankees, Dodgers, Padres, and some ‘sleeper’ team. And it’s debatable if he’s even worth what his asking price will be.

    Regarding MO…. He’s forever been drafting in the 18-22 slot. It would take blind luck to find a top of rotation pitcher that far down the board. So he took the best player available. Had he drafted mediocre pitchers instead of ‘best available’, we would be even worse off. I’m blaming this year on transitioning out of Yadi and Waino, and for not transitioning out of Flaherty sooner, not on MO.

    Regarding WDWJr…… I’m guessing that he took out a 30 year note for about a half a billion dollars to build us a new stadium back in ’06. Since loans are interest heavy during the first several years, I’m guessing that he still owes 350M or so on the loan. In comparison, the Brewers are trying to shake a couple of hundred million dollars free from the Milwaukee taxpayers by threatening to move if the taxpayers don’t fork it over.

    Finally, I’ll say that I am, at this point, clueless as to how the pitching problem will be improved over the offseason. But I don’t like the idea of throwing money around as the answer. Baseball revenue has to go down thanks to inflation. It now cost $40-$50 for two people to get out of even Applebees or Texas Roadhouse or Olive Garden nowadays. The money for baseball tickets is simply not going to be available because ‘the times, they are a changin’ as the lyric goes. The best thing that I can think to say is that we now have some fine young arms trying to break through their barriers to MLB.

    in reply to: 2023 StL Game #117: Friday, August 11 at KC (Waino start) #231174
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Here’s to Wainwright getting #199.

    in reply to: Middle Infield #231172
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Regarding catchers, I don’t know what Herrera’s defense is really like, or if he can hit major league pitching. I’m looking forward to seeing him perform next spring. The problem I have with Contreras is personal. I have this picture of him trying to throw out a runner stealing second base, and Contreras’ throw sailing at least six feet behind the runner and, obviously, nowhere near the second baseman. And I just can’t get that picture out of my mind when I see or hear his name.

    in reply to: Contreras #231170
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    It took a year for Goldschmidt to settle in with the Cardinals. It’s possible that Contreras is a lot better than what we’ve been getting so far this year. I would say, though, that in my opinion, Knizner has the look and the vibe of a honest to goodness major league catcher now that he is no longer living under the shadow of Yadi.

    in reply to: Middle Infield #231167
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I’m not willing to count on Saggese or Prieto for anything …..yet. Hold onto Edman for at least another year. He’s reliable and productive at many positions, and I agree that he has a special value that he contributes to the team.

    in reply to: Leonardo Bernal is still a top 100 prospect #231022
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Nice post, Bob Reed. Thanks.

    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Don’t forget that Gorman was looking like a possible bust for awhile. Just looking at Walker, and how he stands in at the plate, makes me think he’s going to be one of the ‘faces’ of the Cardinals one day.

    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I would tender O’Neill. He is truly a Gold Glove defender when he is going all in, and a premium slugger when healthy. I would, not only tender Hudson, but I would try to extend him for an extra year if he performs well for the next month and a half. (I already know most of the reasons why some people might disagree. I admit that I’m a bit of a ‘homer’. I’m still holding out hope for these Cardinnal players to overcome their struggles, and I believe it’s possible.)

    in reply to: Censorship or message management? #230914
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Absolutely agree! Independent media is truly our lifeline to freedom. We are so lucky to have given ourselves here in America the right to free speech.

    in reply to: Trade deadline #230913
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I’m not sure what to do or say about it, but I don’t like seeing Scott and Mautz drop down 2 slots in the ranking, or seeing Baker and Bedell dropping down 3 slots in the rankings. No doubt, if there are errors in current assessments, time will tell the tale.

    in reply to: What’s it gonna take to fix the Cardinals #230835
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Just want to mention that in a pregame interview yesterday,
    Michael Girsch, when asked about the coming offseason, stated that the Cardinals do have ‘dry powder’. We’ll just have to wait and see what develops from that.

    I’m thinking that 2023 has turned out to be what could be called a ‘transition year’. Almost everyone underestimated the impact of no more Yadier Molina behind the plate, and the impact of no more battery of Waino and Yadi every fifth day. Few thought that Wainwright couldn’t bring it for one last year. And few really contemplated that Oli Marmol might need more time to develop himself as a manager.

    in reply to: Have We Wasted Goldschmidt & Arenado’s Good Years? #230731
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I love Goldy’s defense. I hope they extend him for two more years, although I understand that that would present a problem as to what to do with Walker who I think is our future first baseman. Regardless, Goldschmidt will play somewhere after his contract is up in St. Louis.

    in reply to: Baker and Allen Craig #230620
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I’m really glad to see this thread on Baker. I’m hoping to get some understanding as to why this player isn’t getting much attention. Even in the Cardinals’ ranking, they bring him in at No.29. We’re paying Contreras 17M for his bat, and here we have a player at Memphis who is posting a BA of .332, and an OPS of 1.130 and leading AAA with 27 HR, and if he gets traded, he’s a throw in? I get that he’s a slow runner and, I assume, a liability defensively, but that bat of his appears to be have value, a lot of value.

    in reply to: Have We Wasted Goldschmidt & Arenado’s Good Years? #230400
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I hate the thought of Goldschmidt not playing first base for the Cardinals. But I don’t think the Cardinals will extend him after the 2024 season. I think Walker will be at first base in 2025. But with Goldschmidt’s level of play, I still think he’ll play somewhere in 2026 at age 37 and in 2027 at age 38.

Viewing 25 posts - 1,176 through 1,200 (of 3,520 total)

First-hand news and commentary on the St. Louis Cardinals™ and minor league system for over 25 years