Jnevel

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 25 posts - 4,651 through 4,675 (of 4,748 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Pitching #211635
    Jnevel
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    That is not a true statement Oliver. This 2023 team is very different than the one in 2019. And very different than 2020. It is a little closer to 2021, but still significantly different. It is very close to 2022 but that was just 2 playoff games- one of which we almost won. So really small sample size there. Plus, even compared to 2022, we are still quite different because each of our very young players will have another full year of experience under their belt, which can make a huge difference. And our aging veterans have another year under their belts which may make them older and slower. The team is very different. And the circumstances will be too. Is my faith in this team based on hope and gut feeling? Yes, unequivocally yes. But that’s part of being a fan. I certainly agree this team can get better and improve their chances. But I still like their chances as is now.

    in reply to: Pitching #211630
    Jnevel
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I want to reiterate my point above. If we had 4 1968 Bob Gibson’s on our playoff roster (probably each making $40 million per season) for the last 4 playoff years and they all threw complete games while allowing 1.12 runs in each game (I realize 1.12 is not a real number of runs), we would still have lost over half of those playoff games. So our problem is not as simple as just spending money. Sometimes things are far more complex without easy solutions. And there’s no sure thing. But I personally still really like the way the Cardinals have found a real nice balance going into 2023 and I like their odds, even if Vegas doesn’t.

    in reply to: Pitching #211625
    Jnevel
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    A lot is being made about how we need top of the rotation pitchers to be winners in a playoff series. And the evidence is mostly that the Cardinals have not been good in recent playoff series. And that means that if this team wants to win a World Series it either has to spend money on a top of the rotation guy or just get really hot (lucky) during the playoffs. After all, look at our recent performances. But something inherently has bothered me about this line of thinking. First, and most obvious, baseball is a team sport. Your job is to outscore your opponent. So if we can just have a better offense, then we can still win with average pitching. Heck, the difference between a top of the rotation guy with an ERA of 3.00 and our guy with an ERA of 4.00 is only one run per nine. But second, as I laid out earlier in a comment, I was thinking that it’s really been our hitting and not our pitching that has failed us in the moment. So I looked to see if what I remembered being true was actually true. Since 2019, the Cards have played in 15 postseason games. Our record is a dismal 4-11 in those games. But you know what, we scored 0 or 1 run in 8 of those games. So in those 8 games, it would not have mattered if we had Gibson with his 1.12 ERA pitching because we didn’t score more than the requisite 1.12 runs in over half of those playoff games. And, if we exclude the 13-1 shellacking of the Braves in our game 5 NlDS win, we scored just 39 runs over 14 other playoff games (and 9 of those runs came in one other game). On the pitching side, our pitchers mostly performed well. In 10 of the 15 games, our opponents got 4 runs or less.

    I’m not sure that I’m taking any side here. I just do think that for whatever reason, our offense tends to get very tentative in playoff games and I think that’s the reason that we’ve lost a lot of them lately. And I don’t really know why that is. Maybe it’s just in our head? Maybe we need the right leader to snap us out of that and get our hitters to be comfortable? Maybe we just need hitters who perform better in the clutch? I don’t know. But I do know that one pitcher doesn’t fix this. Not even 1968 Bob.

    in reply to: Pitching #211520
    Jnevel
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I’m not sure Wins matter much but I would have to think that Mikolas has the best chance to get to 15 of them. He generally pitches deepest into games.

    I think the Cardinals have 3 number 3 pitchers all with possibilities to be a number 2 or number 4. But there’s very little variance there (unless an injury occurs). Low ceiling, high floor. Then we have 2 others that are probably 4’s but could fall below that with not much ceiling above that. So that’s not great. Not even good really. But it’s probably passable because of our defense and half the games played at Busch. Plus, we should have a very good bullpen to bail us out of some jams. The other plus is that we have about 4 other guys backing our top 5 up who are all likely 5’s or 6’s. That gives us an extremely high floor that we haven’t really had the past few seasons. Overall, I think this makes our pitching fine. Not good, but not bad.

    I 100% agree that it isn’t always about talent. Some guys do very well under intense pressure and others don’t. This is a factor not really seen in most stats. For instance (small sample size clearly), Mikolas and Quintana both stepped up admirably under pressure. And also for instance, most of our hitters imploded. And I think that’s generally been a trend for us in the past few postseasons. So while I expect our offense to be great during the regular season, I do worry about it getting lost in the postseason. Someone needs to be the leader and set the tone there the way Pujols or Rolen or Berkman or Beltran or Craig did for us when we had success in the past.

    in reply to: Conservatism #211479
    Jnevel
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Of course there are concerns! There are always concerns. Always some tweak that could make the team a little bit better. All I’m saying is that the Cardinals brass has done a great job of developing and trading for players to make this team in 2023 a fantastic looking team that has a good shot at a World Series. Pretty much no team ever has a better than 50% shot at winning the WS. Even 25% would be incredible. But 50% or better seems to be the standard that fans want to hold the Cardinals to as they forget about the 20 other teams that are doing their best to also win a championship. We can’t just buy any player we want or trade for any player we want. Some of those players want to go to a certain city or be in a certain situation. Some players have good stats but aren’t good teammates and we don’t want them. Some teams value one team’s prospects better than ours. And sometimes it’s just not worth the trade ask because it makes the team worse in the long run. And the Cardinals truly are a team that cares about the long run. They want a chance to win every single year. And they never go all in to try to just win this year and say screw the future. And I love that about them. Consistency is a valuable trait. And I guess that’s what the topic of the thread is about. Except that I think consistently good is a better description that conservative. They weren’t conservative when they traded for Ozuna or Goldschmidt or Arenado (or extended Goldschmidt). They were trying to be consistently good in every case. Today, so many people want instant gratification. But I personally love the Cardinals approach of consistently good and I’m glad we’re not letting AJ Preller or Dave Dombrowski run our long-term prospects into the ground. This is the Cardinal Way. It’s what this team is about and has been about for at least the Dewitt era. This is the legacy that George Kissel instilled upon the organization while he shaped its culture for all those years in the minors. And I’m glad to be a fan. Especially in 2023.

    in reply to: Conservatism #211471
    Jnevel
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I think I’m with you 1toughdominican. While San Diego certainly has a great shot too, I’m going to say the Cardinals score the most runs in the NL this year. There are really only 2 scenarios that are really bad for St Louis. 1) Edman gets hurt. Ugh. We picked up a few guys that might be ok backups in a pinch and we still have Kramer Robertson, but this would be really bad both for our offense and defense. 2) Contreras gets hurt. Again with a big ugh. If it’s for a length of time, then I guess we bring up Herrera and he and Knizner do their best. But that is likely a hole in the lineup. Otherwise, we have so many backup combinations for everywhere else with good hitting backups. Like Bling said, quantity is not an issue. Many of the other teams listed above don’t have that at all. One injury could hurt some of those offenses and 2 injuries really de-rail them. We have 12 guys plus Walker and Gomez who likely will be average or above average MLB hitters. That’s crazy good depth. I can’t remember ever having anything close to that going into a season. Now if we could only have 5 above average starting pitchers. . .

    in reply to: Conservatism #211440
    Jnevel
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I am honestly ecstatic about our odds in 2023. I think the Cards have built one of the best Cards teams that I’ve seen in my lifetime. The offense is great. The defense is great. The bullpen should be pretty great. The starters are fine. And there is good depth at every position in case of injury except catcher and shortstop. I think it’s great that fans are sitting around complaining about Knizner being our biggest issue. If backup catcher is the only real thing that scares you, then you have an awesome team. Sure, we don’t have elite starting pitching. But no team is elite at everything (ok, the Dodgers were pretty close last year). If pitching becomes an issue, then we will upgrade it mid-season. But either way, I really think we are running away with the division and there’s a very, very good possibility that we finish with a top 3 record in baseball. I’m typically kind of a pessimist. But it’s so hard to find fault with the team we have. I think it’s going to be a lot of fun. And I’m thrilled that we have the owners and general manager that we do have. Other teams and fans admire the Cardinals organization so much and wish they had the leadership we have. And they would love to be in the position to complain that their backup catcher is likely a below average player.

    in reply to: Baseball America Cardinals prospect rankings #211126
    Jnevel
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    No Graceffo, Burleson, or Herrera? A little surprising. I guess being the best hitter at AAA isn’t worth what one might think.

    in reply to: Spring Training 2023 Roster #211101
    Jnevel
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Jeremy Rivas seems like a bit of a surprise. But I guess they want some depth at shortstop and there aren’t many other choices. The only other name that jumps out to me as at least a little surprising is Hence. I’m not shocked because he has such great stuff. He just hasn’t gotten to use it much against upper level competition.

    in reply to: Cubs thread #211062
    Jnevel
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    The Cubs will probably be better than last year. And, they likely closed the 19 game gap at least slightly. But they will not be good. They have a solid rotation that should be better than last year. And, they got a little better defensively. But I don’t think their hitting or bullpen is likely to be any better. They lost their best hitter and signed multiple bad hitters plus a perfectly average to slightly better than hitting shortstop. They are really just filling out a roster and hoping they will complete some Hail Mary passes. I doubt they will be a .500 team. I see them finishing in 4th a little ahead of the Reds and a couple games behind the Pirates.

    in reply to: Cardinals Winter Warm-Up 2023 #211060
    Jnevel
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Agree with BCCran. I appreciate all of the summarizing you did! It’s always interesting to hear what each of these players is working on or thinking.

    in reply to: Community 2023 Top 50 Prospect Voting #210521
    Jnevel
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    51. Rancel Rincon
    52. Osvaldo Tovalin
    53. Nelfy Ynfante
    54. Samil de la Rosa
    55. Chris Rotondo

    10 Honorable Mentions in no particular order: Scott Hurst, LJ Jones, Nick Trogic-Iverson, Andrew Marrero, Wilfredo Pereira, Anyelo Encarnacion, Yordelin Peña, Alfredo Ruiz, Logan Sawyer, and Zuniga

    in reply to: TCN’s 2023 Top 50 Prospect Countdown #210511
    Jnevel
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Brian,

    Since we’re on this line of thought, I’m really curious where Rancel Rincon ranks on the list. He’s definitely my favorite prospect that didn’t make the top 50 (safe to assume he’s not in the top 8 yet to be revealed!). He’s the one guy who didn’t make the list that I’m the most confident about making it in the future.

    Thanks for any input you might be willing to share!

    in reply to: TCN’s 2023 Top 50 Prospect Countdown #210507
    Jnevel
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    LJ Jones is very limited defensively so he has to hit well to be a valuable prospect and thus far he has been a good hitter, but not really a “very good” hitter. He is not young as he’s going into his age 24 season and hadn’t made AA yet. For perspective, he’s 6 months younger than Carlson who now has 2+ years of mlb service. He does have some serious power potential, but it’s pretty raw right now. He tends to strike out a lot. And, to my eye, he tends to be very streaky. So for me, he’s somewhere in the mid 50’s to maybe even low 60’s on the list. We’d all love for that entire 2020 draft class to be amazing (it still is either way) which I think artificially drives up LJ in our thoughts. Maybe he does make it as a 1b/DH some day. But if he does, I’m betting it won’t be with St Louis as there is just so much talent in front of him. He will be rule 5 eligible at the end of this season so we will know then what the Cardinals think of him long term.

    in reply to: TCN’s 2023 Top 50 Prospect Countdown #210429
    Jnevel
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I totally get the huge risk factor for Bernal and Mejia. Mejia is basically in the extreme risk category. But unless your team desperately needs a left-handed bullpen arm now, I’m thinking any team would still rather have Bernal or Mejia in a deal over Thompson. Wouldn’t you?There’s certainly some risk that Thompson isn’t very good either. But his floor is low leverage middle relief and I get that is still something vs a floor of nothing for Mejia and Bernal.

    And I think our community definitely rated him high at 9. They liked him for his limited good results in the Cardinals bullpen. It seemed like some had him as high as #6 or 7.

    I was just expecting to see him lower than top 10. Just my opinion. I accept that I may be wrong and hope Thompson proves me so.

    in reply to: TCN’s 2023 Top 50 Prospect Countdown #210422
    Jnevel
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I’m really surprised we haven’t seen Thompson yet on this list. I have him at 14 although basically he was a toss-up with Gomez at 13 on my list. I really have to think that if we offered another organization their choice of either taking Thompson from us in a trade or taking Bernal or Mejia, they’d choose Bernal or Mejia nearly every time. Therefore, those 2 guys are more valuable and likely are better prospects. Thompson is most likely bullpen only now and I’m not real confident that he’ll be better than average there. He may. He was in a small sample size last year with several low and high leverage inning mixed in together. Sure, he’s got the pedigree of a first rounder. But who would you rather have in your organization if you had to lose 2 of the following: Thompson, Bernal, or Mejia? I’d likely keep Bernal first and then Mejia next. And that would be a tough decision between those 2. But Thompson would definitely be out.

    I’m happy to have him. We struggle with bullpen lefties and have for many years. And there’s still some time to develop. But is he really top 10? Call me surprised.

    in reply to: Community 2023 Top 50 Prospect Voting #209723
    Jnevel
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    48. Sawyer
    49. Rincon
    50. Tovalin

    in reply to: Community 2023 Top 50 Prospect Voting #209530
    Jnevel
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    45 Sawyer
    46 Redmond
    47 Rancel Rincon

    in reply to: Cubs thread #209392
    Jnevel
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I like the Cubs starting rotation. Their bullpen is probably bad though. Although bullpens can be so difficult to guess at. But their lineup still looks terrible. Contreras was their best hitter last year. Maybe Swanson produces at that same level, but probably a little less. Otherwise, I don’t see where they are getting any help outside Hoerner and Haap both being around average. Maybe Merton comes up and hits some home runs? But I doubt he’ll be much better than replacement level. Maybe Bellinger gets to about average as a hitter? I doubt he can get better than that. Overall, I just don’t see them scoring runs. They may still finish in 4th behind a Pirates team that could quietly take a step forward. I for one would love to see the Cubs finish dead last, but it will be hard to finish behind the Reds.

    in reply to: Community 2023 Top 50 Prospect Voting #209391
    Jnevel
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    42. Ralston
    43. Sawyer
    44. Redmond

    I would vote for Wilking Rodriguez, but it just feels wrong since he doesn’t really fit as a prospect except by technicality.

    Rancel Rincon and Samil de la Rosa should both make our list. And, I think Nelfy Ynfante should too. These are all very young guys who have had some good seasons now. I also think Grant, Rotondo, and Marrero should get serious consideration from us. And then there’s still Pinder and Hurst that are probably not more than AAAA guys at this point, but at least they are almost sure things to get at least a handful of MLB at bats at some point. Also, Zuniga who we just gave a roster spot to. And finally, Gustavo Rodriguez had a good season and is also doing spectacular in the winter leagues so I guess I could see him as a fringe top 50 guy as well. I would probably put Heredia a little behind him so probably in the 55-60 range. And I’m just not a fan of Rivas because he can’t really hit. But I can see an argument for him around 50ish too. And I didn’t mention Anyelo Encarnacion who really had a great year with the bat. But he’s so young. I think that’s about everyone – at least everyone outside of some of our other newly drafted pitchers that’s we just haven’t seen enough of yet.

    in reply to: Community 2023 Top 50 Prospect Voting #209321
    Jnevel
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Desmetlax12 – Torres is gone.

    in reply to: Community 2023 Top 50 Prospect Voting #209281
    Jnevel
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    39 Scott
    40 Ralston
    41 Logan Sawyer

    Others we should consider:

    Rancel Rincon – He had lots of success in the Domican as a starter in 2021, then had several great outings this year in the Complex League and then made a few starts at Palm Beach. Last year I was disappointed to not see Paniagua in the top 50 of TCN list and challenged that one as the only miss. This year, while I don’t feel quite as strongly as I did about Paniagua, Rincon is that miss. I really like the way this guy goes about everything and how quickly he adapts. He’s definitely my favorite unrated prospect.

    Osvaldo Tovalin – since we somehow voted in Buchberger, Tovalin is extremely similar in a lot of ways but significantly younger. He’s a really good hitter and semi versatile. And, like Buchberger, he has a penchant for coming up with key RBIs.

    Chandler Redmond – Serious power. 4 homers in a game. And he can take a walk. He used to play all over. Now he’s pretty much 1B only. But he does it well.

    Scott Hurst – The problem with Hurst has always been that he couldn’t hit – not for average or power. Except that in 2022, he suddenly had an OpS over .800 for much of the season. Plus he’s an excellent defender in the outfield. I actually thought there was an outside chance he could get taken in the Rule 5 draft. He’s suddenly a little interesting again and I’m intrigued.

    Chris Rotondo – Drafted as an OF in the later rounds this year, he went out and had a very productive year. I actually really like him (for a late round pick).

    Chase Pinder – Always hurt. But when he’s not, he’s an excellent hitter. Plus, he plays all 3 outfield positions well.

    Samil de la Rosa – Our best hitter at Palm Beach. And he played all over the infield. Lots of errors, but very young.

    Luken Baker – He is like the hulk. Which is really fun when he connects with the baseball. And not so fun when he strikes out or runs the bases.

    Andrew Marrero – Did really well now that he’s no longer a starter. Very good reliever results. I’m not really a believer long-term, but the results were great this year.

    I’m also a fan of Yordelin Peña and Alfredo Ruiz, but the results aren’t there enough to put them in the top 50 yet. But look for them next year.

    in reply to: Community 2023 Top 50 Prospect Voting #209043
    Jnevel
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    36. Scott
    37. Luis Pino
    38. Ralston

    in reply to: Community 2023 Top 50 Prospect Voting #208905
    Jnevel
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    33 Granillo
    34 Scott
    35 Pages

    in reply to: Cards sign C Willson Contreras #208842
    Jnevel
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Very interesting indeed. That gives us $7.5 million more this year to spend plus the roughly $5 million that was already still in the budget. Not quite Rodon amounts, but perhaps someone else in a trade that helps consolidate our extra pitching?

Viewing 25 posts - 4,651 through 4,675 (of 4,748 total)

First-hand news and commentary on the St. Louis Cardinals™ and minor league system for over 25 years