Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Roster stands at 38 after today’s moves.
Fermin, Pereira, Bruihl, and Soriano are the 4 more marginal players without options (even Gorman has an option year left) so to some extent, these 4 handcuff the team a bit.
Fermin had a solid season. He’s versatile and came through quite a bit in key situations. But, Torres and Saggese make him a bit redundant. We also have Jesus Baez getting close and Prieto is still available for emergencies (or Mendoza if we needed to add someone). I wouldn’t be surprised to see him traded for a low level Minor Leaguer.
Pereira was really good in limited time and is still fairly young. He can play CF. The question is whether he can hit well enough to deserve a bench role. I think they bring him to Spring Training to see his skillset and make a decision by the end of Spring. Most likely, we don’t really need one of Pereira or Scott given that Chase Davis is also in Memphis.
Bruihl was reliably average out of the pen from the left side. Unless they want to sign someone else, they might as well keep him until at least Santana is ready to usurp him.
Soriano seemed to have stretches where he was excellent and then go out and throw a complete clunker. He might have been overused a bit. He probably returns unless he doesn’t look great in ST. However, I’d love to see him replaced by a Veteran BP signing. I’d love a more reliable back-end reliever.
I always thought Ixan would end up as a lefty reliever. These injuries have even more cemented that likelihood. He was on a trajectory to potentially make it as a starter though with his numbers last season.
17. Kuhns
18. MolinaI understand the sentiment on Santana. However, Kuhns could throw 300 innings across a couple seasons. Same with Molina. It might take Santana 5 or 6 seasons to get there. Short relievers have value, but it’s hard to compare to a starter with similar pitching weapons. I do have Santana coming up at 22 though. He has been utterly dominant especially as of late, which is good because the Cards BP needs left handed help. He should be up there soon.
The releasing team would owe the full contract amount. However, if another team picks that player up as a free agent, that new team would pay the prorated minimum salary amount remaining for the year. This would ever so slightly lessen the burden on the team that originally released the player.
Yes he will. Strong potential to not offer Gorman a contract. May be 2-3 others DFA (possibly Pereira, Prieto, Bruihl, Fernandez, Svanson, Scott, or the new pitcher we just picked up). Those are all back of roster filler guys who could be replaced with an upgrade.
Stanek option was declined so that leaves at least one 40-man roster spot open.
For now, I’d do more revenue sharing and institute a floor of around $130 million and see where that leads you. Give teams until 2028 to get to the floor since they won’t get that revenue sharing until well into 2027. Keep the CBT. Maybe even strengthen the top line penalty a little. All these seem like sensible solutions towards a bit more parity, which I think would be better for baseball.
They can protect 38 on the “AAA” roster. Since 40-man players are already protected and I’ll assume Baez, Odle, and Davis get added to the 40-man for the purposes of this exercise, here’s how the “AAA” roster might look for the Rule 5 draft:
Cho, Levenson, Clemente, Hansen, Linn, Richardson, Ledbetter, Henderson, S Hernandez, Tarlow, Paige, Mendlinger, Harris, Moore, Encarnacion, Mejia, Suarez, Honeyman, Pino, Pena, Cornwell, Sequera, Moran, Love, Hales, Murphy, Worley, King, Ynfante, Menes, Batista
That’s only 31. Even if they don’t add Odle and Davis to the 40-Man, they could add them here and get us to 33. Everyone else is either protected by the 40-man, a minor league free agent, or not eligible to be taken in the Rule 5 draft. Therefore, zero worries with the Minor League phase.
I still believe there will be no Rule 5 draft, which benefits St Louis. If they do have it, Jesus Baez is the only sure add. The Cardinals have 6 or 7 guys that in theory could be added or taken if not, but I’m not sure any is super risky. I’d be the most worried about Odle even though he’s still a ways off. He has a fastball and could be hidden in a reliever role.
If there’s a draft:
Add: Jesus Baez
Strongly Consider: Odle, Cho, Chase Davis
Consider: Levenson, Clemente, Hansen, Linn, Richardson, Ledbetter, Henderson, Sammy Hernandez
Assuming a draft, I could see the Cardinals protecting just one (Baez) or up to 4 players.
15. Miguel Hernandez
16. KuhnsAfter Raniel, I think Miguel has the next best chance of our position player prospects to be a superstar. Tons of walks. Tons of doubles. Great batting average. Solid defense that could end up a plus. Good speed.
I don’t know as much about Kuhns. He starts with a great fastball and has a good shot to repeat what we saw out of Doyle this year. I could have picked Molina or Manicalco here. But I’m going with Kuhns for upside.
October 30, 2026 at 8:10 am in reply to: The Cardinal Nation’s Team Recaps and Top Players of 2026 #322065I support this pick. I love Fajardo. He does almost everything well.
I do think we should be careful with BABiP and assuming low means lucky and high means unlucky. That’s probably typically the case, but not always. Some pitchers are just easier or harder to square up against. For example, Mathews can make many hitters uncomfortable. Hjerpe is that to the extreme with lefties. Not as much for Fajardo. That probably is because his fastball is routine so hitters can sit on the changeup and catch up to the fastball. I know Brian knows all this, but not sure all readers understand it.
Yeah Bling, I almost added a disclaimer on Manicalco because we haven’t seen him. But every blurb I read about him mentions elite defense so I’m assuming he will start at the good level.
Bling – I’ll try to help with some generic ratings for prospects that might be in the next 20-30 spots):
Bad – Ortiz
Questionable – Cho, Gurevitch (for 3B), Mitchell (still very young), Ferraro, Ledbetter
Average-ish – M Hernandez, Frias, Ragsdale, Pena, dos Santos, S Hernandez
Good to Great – Maniscalco, Padilla, Davis, Campos
Not enough data for me to rate – Henne, Kennedy, Williamson
These are broad generalizations and it could depend on position, but hopefully this helps a little. Also, the younger they are, the more time they have to improve or potentially get worse due to size.
Tight race between Kuhns, Roby, dos Santos, Miguel Hernandez, and Frias. I’m a bit surprised Molina isn’t just as high up there with this group too. Also, no mention of Maniscalco yet. All of these guys might have been top 5 if they were around and we were doing this ranking 4 years ago.
October 29, 2026 at 7:49 am in reply to: The Cardinal Nation’s Team Recaps and Top Players of 2026 #3220253 years in a row is very impressive!
13. Miguel Hernandez
14. Sebastian dos SantosI had Tai Peete ranked between theses two on my list. Now that he’s in, SDS is next. Enough has been said about both. There’s risk here for sure because of age, but as far as on-field results go, these two deserve to be at least this high – especially considering age to level. I would not be surprised if they are both top 5 next year.
I completely support Kuhns and Molina around this level too as I have them up next. I then have a few others before we get to Santana, Frias, and Ragsdale. Santana solely because of size and the fact he’s a reliever. Otherwise, he’d be top 10.
Good post “667”
11 & 12 look to be solidly belonging to Condon and Peete. Peete had a wonderful finish to the season and has been the MVP so far of the AFL. I wonder if he fully replaces VSII next season in CF at Memphis? Probably so.
Bob, I assume you’ll finally get SDS across the line in the next round. 13 or 14 is still a very respectable place given all our depth. Heck, I have high hopes for most every player in my top 30.
October 27, 2026 at 11:38 am in reply to: The Cardinal Nation’s Team Recaps and Top Players of 2026 #321881It could have gone either way on Doyle vs Franklin. Stats are nearly equal with maybe the slightest edge going to Franklin. While I prefer Franklin as a prospect, I think I would have gone with Doyle here given they are the same age (just 9 days different) and Doyle pitched the whole season at AA. But Franklin is an incredible story given that he had been a relief-only guy prior to this season. I don’t think anyone could have ever expected him to be any better than he was.
I love that my top 10 is the Community’s top 10! Slightly different order, but not by much. I also love that we’re all voting for or talking about my next 7 guys (except Ragsdale who I have at 22 and Santana who I’m not quite sure what to do with yet – 23 for the moment but I may do a deeper dive and reconsider).
I’m going with Trevor Condon at 11 based on being a first rounder, his early success (in a teeny sample), and partially from hype. I don’t have any real opinions on him yet. But I trust the front office in choosing him where they did.
I’m ecstatic about number 12 though despite limited observations. I’m going with Miguel Hernandez. Much has been written above about him. He often gets lumped in with Dos Santos since both came through the DSL at the same time and both play mostly SS. I just like Hernandez’s swing and plate approach better. I truly don’t have any real opinions opinion on his fielding yet. These guys are still very young and everyone this young makes a lot more mistakes than we are used to seeing at the MLB level. Bob did a nice job on trying to give us some data on their defense although I might argue that there just isn’t enough data yet to make any kind of good speculation.
11. Condon
12. Miguel HernandezCorrelation isn’t necessarily causation but in this case, the evidence is fairly strong that lots of analytics combined with lots of scouts leads to success more often than not. The other element missing here is the number of coaches doing internal development. I would assume that has some sort of correlation to success as well. All three make sense to me as each would obviously lead to better results assuming they were being applied correctly.
I’m going to go Cijntje here at 10. It’s a toss-up between he and Condon, but having seen only a few at bats from Condon means Cijntje wins for me. Those last few starts at Memphis were pretty dominant. I do still have a lot of questions on him though. He’s probably my least favorite prospect I’ve voted for yet for all sorts of reasons. I worry about the 2-handed approach (even though he seems to have largely dropped that) and sometimes the way he attacks hitters. On the upside though, he might start the year in the MLB rotation.
10. Cijntje
9. Fajardo again
I like all these votes here except Ragsdale. All these others are close enough to go in any order including Hjerpe and Jesus Baez who we just voted in. I like Fajardo as more of a sure thing than the others. If he were guaranteed to stay healthy, Hjerpe is the most sure thing of them. But health is a big question mark for him. Peete is looking better and better every day. And Condon of course has gobs and gobs of upside. The only one who hasn’t been voted for yet that I also have in this group is Kuhns. I haven’t seen him pitch yet, but super excited based on everything I’ve read.
-
This reply was modified 3 weeks, 5 days ago by
Jnevel.
Nice post Bob. Enjoyed that.
8. Fajardo
-
This reply was modified 3 weeks, 5 days ago by
-
AuthorPosts
