Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
DC is by no means an exceptional outfielder. He’s pretty much average. TON has a gold glove and very good speed. He could very easily be a better CF. In fact, I was somewhat surprised when he didn’t move there following the Bader trade. Probably just because DC had more recent experience there and we were in the homestretch of the season. But TON could already be a better CF choice defensively. Ultimately,I think this is more about having interchangeable parts than anything. If DC can’t hit right handers again this year, then he can be taken out and TON can be moved to CF (or start the game there to begin with). But there is no universe where Gomez pushes DC out of CF. That’s just silly.
I see what you’re talking about. Yeah, that does seem weird. And it’s all happening over the last few days. My only guess would be that a minor leaguer needs to be assigned to St Louis to play in one of their Spring Training games. But I have no idea what other significance that might be beyond that. It is kind of weird to even list them out.
They are assigned to the St Louis club while on the 40-man roster. But then when the season starts, St Louis can only have 26 players on their “Active Roster” so the others have to be “Optioned” to the minor leagues (if those players still have options available).
This is a tough group. They all feel a bit fringe to me either due to really good but not great performance or limited years. I think Carlton and Renteria are the most deserving, but they both had better careers with other teams so that makes it hard to accept them to our HoF (We did finally get Hernandez there though!). Freese will be the likely choice due to recency, his postseason legend, being homegrown in St Louis, and the fact that St Louis was definitely his best career stop. But overall, his numbers are probably the worst amongst this group. I’m not really sure which to pick! I do kind of agree with Brian, George Hendrick may have been the best choice.
If he’s willing to take $18 million per year for 4 years right now, then I’m in. But I doubt he will do that. $72 million over 4 years is nice security. But if he has a good or great season, then he will make a lot more. Then again, if he is hurt for half of the season or looks mostly mediocre, he’s likely to make less. That’s always the gamble on these extensions. But I’d rather do that contract if I were the Cardinals than extending Mikolas for 3 or more years. 2 years for Mikolas would be good. But he is going to want longer.
I see autocorrect changed Wilking to Wilfredo in my above post!
Who does Rodriguez bump out? Gallegos, Helsley, and Hicks are probably locks. And so are 2 of the lefties (2 of the 4 candidates). So that leaves 3 other pitchers. Stratton and VerHagen are both going to make it if they look at least serviceable in ST due to their contracts. So if Wilking makes it too, then I guess he’s pushing out Pallante and Woodford and Hudson to all head to Memphis as starters. But that will be too many starters at the upper levels blocking other guys. So one of 3 things is going to have to happen:
Scenario 1) We will have injuries. This is always quite likely. This creates opportunities for those 3 I just mentioned.
Scenario 2). One of (or more than one of) VerHagan, Wilking Rodriguez, or Stratton will just look bad and be cut. I think Stratton is the least likely to be cut of the 3 and Rodriguez would be most likely. Rodriguez is easy to cut because he’s the least expensive since he just goes back to the Yankees and they give us $50,000 for him. VerHagan is the most expensive to cut, but I feel that since he was bad last year, if he looks bad again the Cardinals will just lose hope and move on.
Scenario 3) Someone will be traded. We really do have too many pitchers on the 40 man who are all in the “usable but not great” category (yes Packy and JoJo, I’m looking directly at both of you!). Perhaps we find a trade partner who could swap us for a young prospect not on the 40 man with some potential but a long ways out. We’ve seen that kind of trade a few times before.
Wilfredo Rodriguez
It’s possible and probably likely that the Brewers thought their offer was already an overpay by $500,000-$750,000. I think that’s usually the way it works in negotiations- both sides end up at a number they aren’t thrilled with but can live with. But sometimes the sides are just further apart. The Brewers may feel Burnes was asking for a $1.5 million overpay according to market and they were only willing to part with half that. I’m sure they don’t want hard feelings with their ace. But they also don’t want to unnecessarily drive up the cost of salaries because they are running a business. I believe the arbitration process is the fairest way to do this. I don’t feel sorry for either players or owners that “lose”. It’s a system that works pretty well.
I can live with the pitch clock, I like the extra innings rule, and I’m on board with the larger bases. But I hate the no shifts rule. To me, you get 9 defenders and other than the pitcher (and arguably the catcher) you should be able to start them wherever you want. If you want 7 guys standing in the right field foul territory because you’re sure that’s where the ball is about to be hit, then you should be able to do that (no matter how stupid that strategy may be). The only reason there is a standard defensive alignment is because that spaces guys out to the average places balls are generally hit – so it became tradition. Hitters just need to hit the ball where the defense isn’t. That’s the game. It’s the equivalent of forcing a football or basketball team to only be able to play zone defense. I hate it.
I’ve never seen Zuniga and know so little about him, but you’re right, he probably belongs here.
I hope you’re right about Bedell having a big year. And Hudson too, but I feel like Hudson’s absolute best would be average MLB pitcher (which is really good! Just not super exciting).
While I liked Blake’s final 6 far better than Brian’s final 6, I think I’d prefer Linarez’s potential to McKeithan. But in all likelihood, neither survive in St. Louis with the 4 more elite catching prospects ahead of them (Herrera, Pages, Bernal, and Crooks) and Contreras around for 5 more years.
Just for fun Blingboy, who would your final 5 plus one prospect who you think will be a surprise who is not in the top 55? Here are mine:
Logan Sawyer
Osvaldo Tovalin
Wilfredo Pereira
Chris Rotondo
Alfredo RuizAnd my surprise mover is Rancel Rincon. I am thinking he is moving well up this list over the next 2 seasons.
I’m least confident about Rotondo here and almost went LJ Jones, which would have made mine pretty close to the same as Blake. But I just don’t see a path for Jones to the Cardinals MLB level unless he just hits a ton and we’ve only seen him do that in shorter stints. Still, it’s a toss-up. I also like Trogic-Iverson in there too.
How about you?
I forgot about Kodi Whitley still being prospect eligible. I like Blake’s final 6 prospects quite a bit (except McKeithan really- he seems like organizational depth with maybe a hair of upside to be more).
I could see Whitley was broken last year but I didn’t know why so I just assumed injury. But the tweaks that Blake explains are helpful. I’m definitely pulling for him. It’s not often that a 27th round guy can make a major league impact.
I love that our bullpen has so many high upside potential guys this year. The depth is unbelievable. When you have 25 strong potentials competing, surely some of those will catch fire and be good. And with guys like Loutos and Sawyer and Zuniga and Whitley just behind all those on the 40 man who are competing, that just adds all that much more depth. There’s actually even more behind them as we get further into the season with Paniagua, Graceffo, Hjerpe, Ralston, and Granillo and maybe just maybe Hence by end of year.
While that is a good amount for a single year, I was expecting him to be holding out for a 3 year deal in the 15-20 million range. It seems like we could have met this ask and still had plenty in reserve for a future starter trade. Maybe the Cards see his skills diminishing or maybe they just want the roster flexibility of all the guys they have with options?
Could very well be Misiewicz who is #40. I think this is an ok move. Take on an ok lefty relief pitcher at a prime age with options that they can try to make better and replace a right hander who is less needed due to our depth who is likely to clear waivers anyway and still be on the team. Seems like an easy decision. It probably doesn’t make much difference but hey, it feels like there’s only potential upside to a move like this. Even if it probably is only a slight gain. If we can secure a better option, then we can just waive Misiewicz and it will have been a very small price to pay.
It’s difficult to say whether what Cohen is doing is good or bad for baseball long term. It could be and probably is both. Short term, it is certainly bad for competitive play. But to bring about needed change, you often need a catalyst. And I think most of us would agree that baseball needs to change and adapt. We just have different visions of how to get there. But Cohen’s moves may very well push some improvements along. Therefore, I’m content to watch how this all plays out. In the meantime, we get to do one of the most enjoyable American pastimes- root for our David to take down Goliath.
I think Seunghwan Oh also barely makes it over that threshold at around 3 WAR. And Edmundo Sosa around 4 WAR. But point taken. They really haven’t been too successful.
I agree gscottar. A really good bullpen might be able to hide the sins of our starters. Especially if our offense can score a lot of runs and we should be able to do so. And, he might give Thompson another shot to make it as a long term starter. Maybe. So I’m all for that move.
I agree that catcher was top priority as it should have been. And I’m still coming around to Contreras but he’s growing on me with all his positive comments. I just would have preferred Moreno or Murphy like probably most everyone else. And 5 years for a catcher in his 30’s is such a long time. Murphy or Moreno and a good starter would have been golden. But the price sounds like it was too high so now we’re at plan B or C. We should still be really good. FWIW, Zips thinks we’re the 2nd best team in the NL but quite a bit behind the Braves. That’s something I guess. But I also agree that at the moment we’re going into the season with a slew of 3/4 starters.
I’m sorry you feel that way Nathan. I personally feel that focusing on bringing in overpriced free agent superstars is typically an ever failing pursuit. You never have enough or it just never quite works out. The teams that win are the teams that build a good team from within with the help of some good trades and a few key signings and then a little luck in the playoffs. The team that “wins” the offseason has never won the World Series. At least not that I can remember. It didn’t do the Tigers and Rangers much good last year. It was the Phillies the year before that. Typically, it’s the Yankees. This year, it’s the Mets. We will get to see if history shines on them after shunning so manny. Great teams are more than a sum of their parts. There are so many immeasurable nuances that can’t be found on a stat sheet. Talent is extremely important. But it’s also about heart. It’s about character. It’s about confidence. It’s about positive emotional connection at just the right moment. And so many other possible synergies that define us as humans. Which is why we play the games. It’s why March Madness is so fun. I look forward to a fun season.
I’d probably give them a C+ too. They have a really good team and didn’t do anything to make it worse. But, they didn’t do a whole lot to make it better either. Contreras is a nice addition for now but may not look like that in 3 years. And the minor league signings and rule 5 draft look like depth or lottery tickets. I mean I like some of the lottery tickets we bought, but the odds of them paying off are pretty low.
I think someone may get cut or traded in Spring training. We have Hurst, Mercado, Toerner, Antico, and Pinder who really all play the same position (CF). Walker and Gomez need to play every day in the corners. My guess is that Toerner gets cut and Antico has to start the year at AA. Toerner may also just get moved to AA to make room. And then there’s still Koperniak who could also be in AAA.
Oliver,
That seems shortsighted. There are no absolutes. Quantity at times is certainly also greater than quality. It just depends on the situation. The Cardinals vast amount of “quantity“ this year helps them not fall far when an injury occurs. And because so much of that quantity is developing talent, it gives some future possibility for someone or someones to be “quality”. Having 5 pitchers that are “quality” and no “quantity” behind them runs a huge risk with injury. Neither is better. Ideally, we’d have both. But we don’t. We have 2 good pitchers in Mikolas and Montgomery who would start for pretty much any team in baseball. Not elite, but definitely reliably good. After that, we have 4 pitchers where we basically are hoping for the best with. Then we have close to ten others who aren’t far behind those 4. Is that a perfect scenario or great plan? No. One elite starter would really, really help assuming they stay healthy. And I wish we had gotten one instead of spending so much on Contreras. So I get the argument. We would definitely be a better team with better pitchers. But I don’t think that means we’re not going to the World Series. This team has a real definite chance. It’s the best Cardinal team I’ve seen in quite some time. But I admit that my faith may be misplaced.
For what it’s worth, Kyle Reid just listed Pinder at #34 and he watches a ton of MiLB baseball. I personally have him at #48. He has a good hit tool and can cover CF and is a good defender all over. He’s really a future 5th outfielder – a guy you call up to cover an injury or who maybe occupies the 25th spot on a MLB roster. But that’s something at least. But we also have Hurst and Antico competing for that same role and I might be inclined to choose Pinder 3rd out of the 3. Close between Hurst and Pinder but I definitely like Antico best purely because his speed is very useable. He will just have to prove that he can still hit at AAA.
This is Pinder’s final year before free agency I believe so he’ll have to put it all together or head out.
I agree Brian. Great to see Graceffo make this list and awesome to see how high they valued Walker. I still think they are missing Burleson. What more could Alec have done at the highest MiLB level? You would think best AAA hitter would be a near automatic lock unless the guy is 27 or more. At least automatic to be somewhere in the top 100 prospects.
Chafin would give the team an easier option to try to develop Thompson into a starter at AAA. Plus, he’s likely better as a reliever than Thompson so I think that’s a good idea as well. We’d lose someone off the 40-man, but there are several fringe reliever choices anyway sitting there now. We’d just have one less of them to try out in ST.
-
AuthorPosts
