Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
October 30, 2026 at 8:10 am in reply to: The Cardinal Nation’s Team Recaps and Top Players of 2026 #322065
I support this pick. I love Fajardo. He does almost everything well.
I do think we should be careful with BABiP and assuming low means lucky and high means unlucky. That’s probably typically the case, but not always. Some pitchers are just easier or harder to square up against. For example, Mathews can make many hitters uncomfortable. Hjerpe is that to the extreme with lefties. Not as much for Fajardo. That probably is because his fastball is routine so hitters can sit on the changeup and catch up to the fastball. I know Brian knows all this, but not sure all readers understand it.
Yeah Bling, I almost added a disclaimer on Manicalco because we haven’t seen him. But every blurb I read about him mentions elite defense so I’m assuming he will start at the good level.
Bling – I’ll try to help with some generic ratings for prospects that might be in the next 20-30 spots):
Bad – Ortiz
Questionable – Cho, Gurevitch (for 3B), Mitchell (still very young), Ferraro, Ledbetter
Average-ish – M Hernandez, Frias, Ragsdale, Pena, dos Santos, S Hernandez
Good to Great – Maniscalco, Padilla, Davis, Campos
Not enough data for me to rate – Henne, Kennedy, Williamson
These are broad generalizations and it could depend on position, but hopefully this helps a little. Also, the younger they are, the more time they have to improve or potentially get worse due to size.
Tight race between Kuhns, Roby, dos Santos, Miguel Hernandez, and Frias. I’m a bit surprised Molina isn’t just as high up there with this group too. Also, no mention of Maniscalco yet. All of these guys might have been top 5 if they were around and we were doing this ranking 4 years ago.
October 29, 2026 at 7:49 am in reply to: The Cardinal Nation’s Team Recaps and Top Players of 2026 #3220253 years in a row is very impressive!
13. Miguel Hernandez
14. Sebastian dos SantosI had Tai Peete ranked between theses two on my list. Now that he’s in, SDS is next. Enough has been said about both. There’s risk here for sure because of age, but as far as on-field results go, these two deserve to be at least this high – especially considering age to level. I would not be surprised if they are both top 5 next year.
I completely support Kuhns and Molina around this level too as I have them up next. I then have a few others before we get to Santana, Frias, and Ragsdale. Santana solely because of size and the fact he’s a reliever. Otherwise, he’d be top 10.
Good post “667”
11 & 12 look to be solidly belonging to Condon and Peete. Peete had a wonderful finish to the season and has been the MVP so far of the AFL. I wonder if he fully replaces VSII next season in CF at Memphis? Probably so.
Bob, I assume you’ll finally get SDS across the line in the next round. 13 or 14 is still a very respectable place given all our depth. Heck, I have high hopes for most every player in my top 30.
October 27, 2026 at 11:38 am in reply to: The Cardinal Nation’s Team Recaps and Top Players of 2026 #321881It could have gone either way on Doyle vs Franklin. Stats are nearly equal with maybe the slightest edge going to Franklin. While I prefer Franklin as a prospect, I think I would have gone with Doyle here given they are the same age (just 9 days different) and Doyle pitched the whole season at AA. But Franklin is an incredible story given that he had been a relief-only guy prior to this season. I don’t think anyone could have ever expected him to be any better than he was.
I love that my top 10 is the Community’s top 10! Slightly different order, but not by much. I also love that we’re all voting for or talking about my next 7 guys (except Ragsdale who I have at 22 and Santana who I’m not quite sure what to do with yet – 23 for the moment but I may do a deeper dive and reconsider).
I’m going with Trevor Condon at 11 based on being a first rounder, his early success (in a teeny sample), and partially from hype. I don’t have any real opinions on him yet. But I trust the front office in choosing him where they did.
I’m ecstatic about number 12 though despite limited observations. I’m going with Miguel Hernandez. Much has been written above about him. He often gets lumped in with Dos Santos since both came through the DSL at the same time and both play mostly SS. I just like Hernandez’s swing and plate approach better. I truly don’t have any real opinions opinion on his fielding yet. These guys are still very young and everyone this young makes a lot more mistakes than we are used to seeing at the MLB level. Bob did a nice job on trying to give us some data on their defense although I might argue that there just isn’t enough data yet to make any kind of good speculation.
11. Condon
12. Miguel HernandezCorrelation isn’t necessarily causation but in this case, the evidence is fairly strong that lots of analytics combined with lots of scouts leads to success more often than not. The other element missing here is the number of coaches doing internal development. I would assume that has some sort of correlation to success as well. All three make sense to me as each would obviously lead to better results assuming they were being applied correctly.
I’m going to go Cijntje here at 10. It’s a toss-up between he and Condon, but having seen only a few at bats from Condon means Cijntje wins for me. Those last few starts at Memphis were pretty dominant. I do still have a lot of questions on him though. He’s probably my least favorite prospect I’ve voted for yet for all sorts of reasons. I worry about the 2-handed approach (even though he seems to have largely dropped that) and sometimes the way he attacks hitters. On the upside though, he might start the year in the MLB rotation.
10. Cijntje
9. Fajardo again
I like all these votes here except Ragsdale. All these others are close enough to go in any order including Hjerpe and Jesus Baez who we just voted in. I like Fajardo as more of a sure thing than the others. If he were guaranteed to stay healthy, Hjerpe is the most sure thing of them. But health is a big question mark for him. Peete is looking better and better every day. And Condon of course has gobs and gobs of upside. The only one who hasn’t been voted for yet that I also have in this group is Kuhns. I haven’t seen him pitch yet, but super excited based on everything I’ve read.
-
This reply was modified 1 month ago by
Jnevel.
Nice post Bob. Enjoyed that.
8. Fajardo
Yes Bling. I mean for the season. Hjerpe, Fitts, and Roby may all be limited to somewhere between 100 and 130 innings. Roby could even be lower than that. I would imagine Graceffo could go 120-150 innings.
Sooner, I think there’s a zero percent chance that Franklin is in the Cardinals rotation at the onset of ‘27. Even if 5 starters were injured, he isn’t going to make it. He hasn’t pitched an inning at AAA, he’s only had 1 season as a starting pitcher, and he’s not Rule 5 eligible by the end of ‘27 so no reason to push him at all. Doyle is in the same boat except he has been a starter for much longer.
Assuming they aren’t traded or hurt, Pallante, McGreevey, Leahy, and Mathews all have positions locked down. They’d have to be terrible in Spring Training not to earn one. That leaves one open slot to start the year. There is lots of competition for that one. Liberatore, Hjerpe, Cijntje, and Fitts would be the front runners. Graceffo and Roby are the dark horses. Four of these guys have the same problem though. Hjerpe, Fitts, Graceffo, and Roby would all be on an extreme innings limit (maybe a little less extreme for Graceffo). That all leads me to a few possible conclusions:
Option 1: They choose whomever looks best in the Spring with Liberatore or Fitts likely getting a leg up based on MLB experience. This is the basic straightforward approach.
Option 2: Piggybacks will be the answer. I could see 2 of the above getting the last spot and one more getting a regular piggyback start with McGreevey or whoever happened to struggle that week.
Option 3: There will be trades. The Cardinals will look at their logjam of #3/4/5 pitchers and decide to trade them off in the hopes to upgrade internally to a #3 or eventually a #1 or #2 pitcher. They clearly need a starting third baseman so this is a way to get there. Trading either Pallante or McGreevey might be a good way to get there (I’d include Fitts here too, but he needs to reclaim some value first before they trade him).
I liked all these picks until Ragsdale. I have him as most likely to end up as a 4th or 5th outfielder on a good team so maybe a couple year starter on a bad one. That’s still valuable, but not top 10 with how deep our system is. I may be low, but I have him at 22. Even if I look at him with rose colored glasses I just can’t put him above 15. Maybe it’s just that he left a bad taste in my mouth because he was pretty average at Springfield after coming over from the Brewers and I don’t see him being able to handle CF. We have a later round pick who is almost 23 and is a corner outfielder with modest power and good speed who played inconsistently at AA. That’s what I see anyway. I’d love to hear why I have him too low if someone wants to talk him up.
I’m glad to get through that group of 5 after Raniel. While they didn’t come out in the exact order I had them, those were the clear group of next 5 prospects.
My next level of grouped prospects includes 7 guys. I don’t currently have dos Santos or Miguel Hernandez in this group but Bob’s arguments are causing me to consider them here. Condon, Hjerpe, and Cijntje as mentioned above are all in this range for me so I was happy to see them thrown out above.
First up in this group for me is Yhoiker Fajardo. He is very young (just turned 20 a couple weeks ago) and had very good success in the upper levels of the Minors at AA this season after graduating Peoria. He gets a lot of ground balls, limits home runs, and strikes out a respectable amount of hitters, especially given his age. His changeup may be the best in the system. He also pitches with a lot of poise, which I love to see. The knock on him is his mediocre fastball. That all sounds like McGreevey is many ways and I think that’s likely where Fajardo lands – a solid number 3 or 4 pitcher who is durable and provides innings because he induces lots of grounders and stays composed on the mound even when he gets into some trouble. There’s some potential for a bit more upside than McGreevey due to the quality of Fajardo’s offerings. A very high floor for him as he is mostly ready now and just needs a bit more experience under his belt to make the final refinements to be a MLB pitcher.
7. Fajardo
-
This reply was modified 1 month ago by
Jnevel.
Gscottar – I agree Milwaukee is a “small market” team. That’s just not how I have defined the haves and have nots specifically. For me, it’s more about revenue. Over the past 5 years or so, because of their success, Milwaukee went from a borderline mid-low revenue team to a mid revenue team. I think that while Milwaukee is in and of itself “small” compared to most other cities, they have the advantage that Wisconsonites support their teams and are willing to travel and tune in even when teams have tough years but especially when they are good. That isn’t the case in Tampa for example. I’m sure Pugs can attest to the fervor at which those who are from Wisconsin support their teams.
I’m glad to see the Dodgers ousted. Their advantages were mighty but that isn’t any kind of guarantee, especially in baseball. Milwaukee showed all season long why they are a formidable opponent. It would be great to see a “have-not” (as I’ve termed them) win it all. While the Brewers don’t qualify there (they are in the middle of the pack in revenue and payroll), both the Rays and Guardians would certainly qualify. They are the kind of team that seems to never win it anymore.
Bunting is usually bad. All teams know this. Trading a base for an out is a bad trade. Bunting slightly increases the odds of scoring 1 run but dramatically decreases the odds of scoring multiple runs in an inning.
There are a few situations where it is definitely good:
1) Good bunter who is a fast runner
2) Bottom of the inning in a tie game where 1 run wins the game.
3) Runners on first and second with no one out and an average or below hitter coming up (because here you’re trading 2 bases for one out).
4) Your name is Jake Taylor and you just tried calling your shot against a guy called the Duke who once threw at his son in a father/son game (at least according to Harry Doyle).A few other situations where it might be good:
1) Elite pitcher on the mound where getting 2 hits will be difficult.
2) Poor hitter at the plate who strikes out a lot and is competent at bunting.#6 Tanner Franklin again.
He’s my #4. I’m highly confident he’s going to be a good one for a long time to come if he avoids major injuries (which is a caveat we could put on every pitcher). At this point in time, Tanner is probably my favorite prospect to watch.
I believe Randal Clemente will also be a free agent. The rest of your list looks correct I think although Lopez wasn’t on my radar so I’m not sure on him. There also may be a few additional guys who signed Minor League contracts who could be gone. There is rarely ever information about those contracts so you never know if they are one year or multiple years.
As for Thompson, I’m almost sure he will be a free agent – assuming he doesn’t retire young.
Clemente is probably the most interesting name assuming he is indeed eligible to be a free agent. Davila had a good year as well, but he’s more likely to be an organizational soldier than ever make the Majors. And speaking of organizational soldiers, it’s sad to see Mendoza likely depart. He’s been in the organization for what seems like forever now.
-
This reply was modified 1 month, 1 week ago by
Jnevel.
Bob – Very interesting points with Dos Santos. He gets a bit lost with all the prospects we have running around these days. He’s just not a guy I’ve personally seen much of yet. I have him currently at 19, but maybe I need to reconsider him. Those are some pretty incredible numbers, albeit a small sample size when you only look at July forward. He could be the most under-the-radar big time prospect in our system. I’ll stick with Franklin (and then Jo Baez after that) here for me, but then I’ll take another look at the next group after that.
-
This reply was modified 1 month ago by
-
AuthorPosts
