Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
July 30, 2021 at 9:02 pm in reply to: 2021 Cardinals MLB Game 103 thread – Friday, July 30 vs. Twins #168350
Who is the other pitcher whose name ends in “x”? I can only think of “x-lax”?
I’m sure they’re talking about Danny Cox. 😉
July 30, 2021 at 8:58 pm in reply to: 2021 Cardinals MLB Game 103 thread – Friday, July 30 vs. Twins #168347Lucky goes just one out short of a quality start. That slow, sweeping curve is mesmerizing and tantalizing, but I’m not sure I’d want to be 60 feet away from a big league hitter when they swing at it.
I wonder if Lucky is the only pitcher in MLB history whose last name ends in “eBlanc”?
July 30, 2021 at 8:49 pm in reply to: 2021 Cardinals MLB Game 103 thread – Friday, July 30 vs. Twins #168344That too, willie. It’s a double whammy tonight.
July 30, 2021 at 8:41 pm in reply to: 2021 Cardinals MLB Game 103 thread – Friday, July 30 vs. Twins #168339Well so far an average pitcher is holding us down.
Bad matchup for the Redbirds. I think they have historically struggled against pitchers whose last names end in x.
July 30, 2021 at 8:37 pm in reply to: 2021 Cardinals MLB Game 103 thread – Friday, July 30 vs. Twins #168337Single, stolen base, advance to 3B on a fly out, score on a sac fly. That’s how St Louis does it.
Like everything else in the last year, dumpster dives ain’t as cheap as they used to be.
One of the mysteries of the universe. Evidently the latest spreadsheets, coaches, managers, etc., don’t recommend bunting. It’s not manly. Threading the needle through a shift feels better and just looks cooler.
Amazing that a guy, after a few years of huge success, felt compelled to significantly change his swing and hitting approach. Even more amazing that this same guy, after struggling in a big way after the change, does not feel compelled to un-change that failed swing and hitting approach. Carp is an old dog now and doesn’t need another pay day.
forsch, WAR (BR at least) does not get WAR by adding defensive and offensive WAR. At l east one factor (positional adjustment I believe) would get double counted by doing that. So, WAR is usually less than the sum of offensive and defensive WAR.
I think Ny’s question is a little more complex than who is providing more overall value to the team based on WAR. WAR is good for general discussions about who is having a better year (especially if the two players are of the same position). I believe Ny’s question would be better stated as who has provided the most net value specifically for the Cards, given how the Cards’ roster has been constructed this season.
Even if you believe WAR numbers are 100% accurate based on the stated definition, WAR is simply based on some calculated replacement value. Replacement value is not some constant we’re talking about with Ny’s question. Instead we’re talking about substituting specific players on the roster that might be above or below WAR’s “replacement” value for those positions. If Wainwright was not a Card, who would’ve pitched his 125 innings? Somebody less effective than Oviedo? So what is Wainwright’s value above that guy or those guys, whoever he or they are. Same with Arenado. He’s played in all but 3 games I think. I guess that would mean a lot more innings for Sosa/Carp/etc.
I wonder if forsch is talking about the lower certainty with the defensive side of WAR. Some have less faith in the accuracy of those numbers. Regardless of the accuracy, some debate that defensive position players get too much of the WAR pie for run prevention compared to pitchers, which would slight the pitchers.
I’m not making a case for either player, just think it was a particularly interesting question (the engineering geek coming out in me). I was curious and looked at the Cards’ record for games Wainwright has played in (11-9) compared to Arenado (49-50). Probably doesn’t mean much!
July 27, 2021 at 8:50 pm in reply to: 2021 Cardinals MLB Game 101 thread – Tuesday, July 27 at Indians #168010This umpire has been great. This is what umpiring looks like.
I haven’t watched until the last inning. Are you saying he doesn’t have a “his strike zone”?
July 27, 2021 at 8:46 pm in reply to: 2021 Cardinals MLB Game 101 thread – Tuesday, July 27 at Indians #168002This is the point in the season where Shildt looks for an outfielder with a .400 OPS so he can bench Bader for two weeks and cool him off.
Lane Thomas to the rescue.
July 27, 2021 at 8:44 pm in reply to: 2021 Cardinals MLB Game 101 thread – Tuesday, July 27 at Indians #167995And his slash line just gets better and better the later the innings.
Which seems a little strange because in past years the reason a lot of people give for PDJ’s slumps has been overwork/fatigue. You’d think that’d be worse in late innings, but maybe not. Or maybe that’s not the reason.
July 27, 2021 at 8:41 pm in reply to: 2021 Cardinals MLB Game 101 thread – Tuesday, July 27 at Indians #167988Folks, the Edman base running blunder is actually a blessing in disguise — the reason the Cards win tonight. Nothing ever plays out the same if you go back and change a piece of history. If Edman had stayed at 2B, Carp would get a different sequence of pitches and perhaps strike out. DeJong gets different pitches too and probably doesn’t go yard. Thank goodness Edman was thrown out! Which of us were smart enough to give a celebratory fist pump at that play?
July 27, 2021 at 8:30 pm in reply to: 2021 Cardinals MLB Game 101 thread – Tuesday, July 27 at Indians #167973Just seems like DeJong hits late inning home runs, for his career.
Innings 1-3: 26
Innings 4-6: 31
Innings 7-9: 34July 26, 2021 at 7:01 pm in reply to: 2021 Cardinals MLB Game 100 thread – Sunday, July 25 at Reds #167874That is correct bling. A couple years ago, Mo wanted to modernize/overhaul the analytics department and maybe double its size. There were bigger goals than just analytics, encompassing the broader domain of performance (things like development, training, rehab, staying healthy, etc.). I think this included things like a pitching lab. Mo wanted to find the next big thing in baseball (something along the lines of tech/analytics) and lead the Cards there first.
At least that was some of the talk after Mo moved to POBO.
July 26, 2021 at 12:46 am in reply to: 2021 Cardinals MLB Game 100 thread – Sunday, July 25 at Reds #167818Rat, please keep up. Nobody uses WIR, BAGIT, OZP, or DRV anymore. Those stats are so several years ago. Mo and the boys now go with WIR+, BAGIT+, OZP+, DRV+, etc.+, to normalize the stats across the league and eliminate distortion caused by external factors, such as adjusting for ball park differences.
July 25, 2021 at 3:57 pm in reply to: 2021 Cardinals MLB Game 100 thread – Sunday, July 25 at Reds #167790Yep, it might be more fitting for the widescreen. Fortunately, Gallegos lost his sense of humor after loading the bases with no outs and retired the next three without yielding a run.
These umps are awful.
And Arenado just hit another HR.
July 25, 2021 at 3:15 pm in reply to: 2021 Cardinals MLB Game 100 thread – Sunday, July 25 at Reds #167786You can just sense we’re on the verge of another bullpen comedy hour.
July 25, 2021 at 2:54 pm in reply to: 2021 Cardinals MLB Game 100 thread – Sunday, July 25 at Reds #167784Life’s not fair, but 6 walks and 5 hits in 4 1/3 innings doesn’t deserve a win.
Why did Helsley throw just 6 pitches?
July 24, 2021 at 8:43 pm in reply to: 2021 Cardinals MLB Game 99 thread – Saturday, July 24 at Reds #167696Making noise in the 8th, but DeJong gets doubled off on a Bader lineout to end it. His first move was toward 3B, making the play at 2B close. But wait, it’s overturned on replay, but a terrible day for DeJong regardless. Needs to get his head in the game or butt on the bench. Carp now up with 2 outs and bases loaded.
July 24, 2021 at 7:40 pm in reply to: 2021 Cardinals MLB Game 99 thread – Saturday, July 24 at Reds #167665Nothing bad this team does should be surprising at this point. I thought DeJong might score on Edman’s double, but he was just halfway between 2B and 3B when they finally showed him in the picture. I thought he would be rounding 3B. I guess he mis-read it badly or was carrying an invisible piano. Then the predictable happened with the Cards failing to score after having runners on 2B and 3B with one out.
If Mo’s successor has a good hire lined up to take over as manager, I’d be all for it. Anything else is just shuffling the deck.
July 23, 2021 at 10:11 pm in reply to: 2021 Cardinals MLB Game 98 thread – Friday, July 23 at Reds #167542Doesn’t help that we had a horrible umpire
I think the ump needs new glasses
Bucknor might be Exhibit A in the case for automated balls/strikes.
July 23, 2021 at 10:04 pm in reply to: 2021 Cardinals MLB Game 98 thread – Friday, July 23 at Reds #167540You might think the skipper managed himself into a pickle when he has a pitcher pinch hitting with 2 outs in the 9th, down by 1 run. But then again, Adam had the best looking at bat in the inning.
Speaking of O’Neill’s and Arenado’s ABs in the 9th, let that be a lesson to all you young boys. If you have to lean your body at a 45 degree angle toward the plate while swinging and you still don’t come close to reaching the ball, then it might be just a bit outside.
July 22, 2021 at 9:05 pm in reply to: 2021 Cardinals MLB Game 97 thread – Thursday, July 22 vs. Cubs #167465Reyes couldn’t resist giving at least one free pass, but otherwise a routine looking save.
-
AuthorPosts
