Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Many, many people / businesses are impacted by the MLB lock out well beyond owners & players.
The covid shutdowns / capacity restrictions impacted almost everyone but the service industries got hit the hardest.
Rampant inflation is pinching all of us right now as fuel prices coupled with supply chain issues are driving the price of almost everything up.
The general situation isn’t really great for most folks right now due to reasons far beyond their control.
I don’t have a lot of patience or sympathy for baseball’s ‘self inflicted wound’.
“Bill the pony nodded, as if he understood.”
– excerpt from Bored of the Rings.
(Parody of Lord of the Rings.)
What we need is a Fans Union.
Fans are the customers. Their interest (eyeballs) drives advertising dollars.
Their ticket and merch purchases impact the revenue stream.
Baseball, like any other sport, is simply one flavor of entertainment. Other forms include movies and music.
It’ll never happen because (a) it would be too hard to organize and (b) most fans would not follow a directive to ‘go on strike’ against their entertainment. They simply cannot live without their fix.
However, if fans across all of baseball were actually to organize themselves and hire good representation; then they could have a seat (and a strong one) at the negotiating table.
We are the idiots that keep throwing our money at these guys.
I don’t like the DH and I’m not ever going to.
I don’t like interleague play either. I think it has the potential to unbalance the schedule and give teams in a tight pennant race an unfair advantage / disadvantage.
I don’t like wild card playoff teams. If MLB goes to even more playoff teams then at least shorten the regular season. 154 / 162 games was used to separate teams. If 1/2 the league is getting into what amounts to an extended tournament then we don’t need a 6 month season to create separation.
In any negotiation, you have to know going into it what you HAVE to get vs. what you WANT to get.
Except in rare instances where one side has almost all the leverage there will be compromises so, your opening position cannot be your line in the sand. You almost never get what you started off asking for.
I really like the idea of not letting the hitters back in and out of the box. Your batting gloves are ok Skippy, just hit.
Unless you get brushed back or knocked down you keep you ass in there.
No calling time out either.
You step out of the box it’s a strike.
No DH – that removes a whole lot of strategy and tough managerial decisions.
Go back to whatever ball they used in the mid-80’s.
Shorten the games, whatever it takes. 2 1/2 hours is long enough to play a typical 9 inning game.
9 inning double headers.
Imagine if all employees acted like the MLBPA.
We are getting a small dose of that with the service industry, particularly restaurants right now.
Yes, I understand the pool of people who can hit a 95 mph pitch is much smaller than the pool of people who can drop an order of fries or sling a salad but there are also more short order cook / waiter positions available.
Other than giving yourself up at the plate to move a runner along and the sac bunt – what are other ‘stat’ things a player could do on the field that would help his team but hurt his WAR?
I’m asking because WAR seems like a pretty solid stat to base bonus pool distribution on to me?
Would certain players ‘call in sick’ against pitchers they don’t hit well to ‘protect’ their WAR?
We can argue tit for tat over MLB players-owners all day long but I don’t think any reasonable person would say that minor league players haven’t been horribly abused.
I hope these kids get some relief and a fair shake.
Some sort of performance based pay – especially for young players would be nice.
It’s a tough nut to crack but it seems like there has to be a better way to pay players than what is happening now.
Being paid for perceived potential or for past performance is a dangerous way to allocate resources.
If the players want to run baseball then they can buy the teams and work out the math for themselves.
Remember that the players get paid, whether they perform well or not, for the terms of their contracts with each club.
It’s about risk vs. reward. A business owner takes on almost all the financial risk.
Nobody is forcing anyone to play baseball for a living.
What you have to guard against is collusion between the owners to artificially suppress player market value.
Feb 6, 1958 – Ted Williams signed a contract with the Red Sox for $135,000 making him the highest paid player in MLB history.
$1 in 1958 = $9.65 today so lets round that to 10.
In today’s dollars the Splendid Splinter would be getting $1,350,000 as the highest paid player.
These guys can cry me a river.
I do think we end up with a full or very close to full regular season but with shortened spring training there will likely be more injuries and some poor baseball as they ‘play themselves back into shape.’
Maybe a completely lost year like Hockey had is what it will take to fix this for a while.
The Covid year in 2020 and the labor year in 2022 would certainly set the game back some.
1994 is a distant memory for most now and as I recall it took Sosa – McGwuire in 1998 to fully reengage the fans.
Due to Covid cancellations and political messaging turning me off – I learned that I could live without sports entertainment. I dove deep into the study of WW2 military and geopolitical history.
I’d rather have baseball than not have it but a certain part of me also wants to see all the major sports leagues knocked down a peg or two……
I feel the worst for the young crop of player that lost a year to Covid and now this.
Quite a few may never be able to overcome not being able to play and develop.
Egos get involved, lines are drawn, and it becomes too personal for these egos who just need to ‘win’ so they can add that feather to their cap.
No one is forcing any of the players to choose baseball as their career. I’d like to see more done for the younger players at ALL levels including MLB.
I understand the investment teams make in developing young talent and the need to have a certain time period to ‘control the asset’.
I understand the theory behind the draft order to give ‘bad’ teams a chance at getting the apparently better young players – BUT – I’d rather see the player acquisition system be more like college recruiting WITH a hard money cap (established by a mutually agreed upon formula based on the prior year’s net revenue) and I think there are already roster number limits in place.
Revenue sharing between all franchises of some kind should be a thing if it isn’t already.
Two salary caps (MLB and MiLB) should be hard – not soft with financial penalties for exceeding them – ultra rich owners will simply sneer at those.
Merry Christmas to all of you and yours!
Where are the most likely cities to get a team?
Normalizing stats takes care of most comparison issues across different years / eras.
(For example, the league batted .300 on average in 1930 and .301 was the AL batting champ mark in 1967.)
For any individual year you can simply look at how a player performed in this or that stat vs. the league \ mlb average for that year without worrying about normalizing anything.
As far as the HoF goes, I’m for making it for truly special players whose body of work truly sets them apart from their peers. So, I don’t know that ‘my’ Hall would be tiny but let’s just say there would be some cuts…..
If the Cardinals can avoid being decimated by injuries that would solve a lot.
You have to assume some injuries of course but its not practical to prepare for an apocalyptic level of decimation.
Yes, there is still work to do but I think the farm will produce better crops this season.
I think the bigger question here is: Does Rat need to be fired at this point?
Damn.
Brian I hope you grabbed your jacket before they locked you out, lol.
Are there any professional mediators / arbitrators involved at this point or is it just the two sides at this point?
Looks like everyone has gone to their corners for now……
Wow. Some heads are gonna roll in about a year…
The above obviously won’t work because then all the best players would end up with the Yankees, Dodgers, Cubs, other ‘big market’ teams.
Wasn’t there a split season in ’81 where the Cards had the over all best record in the NL but didn’t win the division in either half of the season and so did not make the playoffs?
Here is an idea. Each team splits the profit 50-50 with the players and all contracts are essentially performance based with some baseline mi nimum based on years of ML service with A, AA, and AAA counting as .25, .50, and .75 respectively.
The BL min = $100,000k plus $100,000k per year of ML service. Any money a player makes above that is earned by being above the current year’s league average in WAR with all above average WAR players on a particular team splitting 50% of that team’s profits on a pro rata basis.
Performing below average in WAR will not reduce a player’s base salary but if a team makes no money then there is nothing to split among the WAR+ players. Ownership and FO salaries are set and equal across all teams to reduce monkey business.
-
AuthorPosts
