Bob Reed

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 25 posts - 701 through 725 (of 1,093 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: ProspectsLive Cardinals prospect list #118024
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    You’re welcome, ChiTown. And thank you in turn, for the funny “short guys” anecdote. Tyler O’Neill & Harry Bader both are built like fire hydrants, adding to the ball boy resemblance.

    I meant to add something to the earlier Ivan Herrera comments. As it is the season for gluttony, I feel a heaping helping of Herrera hoopla is appropriate. This is from a couple months back:
    https://www.mlb.com/news/top-hitting-prospects-in-arizona-fall-league?t=mlb-pipeline-coverage

    This was my favorite part:
    “His batting practice before the Fall Stars Game, meanwhile, was among my favorites. He showed plus pull-side raw power, parking balls well over the fence with ease, and hitting them farther than most other hitters on the field that day.”

    A teenager is not supposed to be among the most impressive batting practice performers in the Arizona Fall League. (For a guy whose greatest weakness by far as a hitter is supposed to be a lack of power, that is one very reassuring scrap of scouting.)

    in reply to: ProspectsLive Cardinals prospect list #117972
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    First of all, thanks, Brian, for bringing this prospect list to everyone’s attention! Pretty good analyses, by and large uncontaminated by the typical typos and grammar gaffes. I’ve never been to that website before, but it’ll be a regular destination for me now.

    ———————–

    “A 19 y/o catcher, putting up great numbers in A+ AND the AFL….. and the catching seems to be above average.”
    “Just my opinion, but you’re all under rating him!!! Happy New Year Cards fans!”

    Happy New Year back at you, ChiTown, and I agree wholeheartedly that Ivan Herrera is wildly underrated. (I have him in roughly the 40-50 range among all prospects.) However, please forgive me if I do feel compelled to slightly amend a couple of your observations. Herrera did put up a great line for Low-A Peoria in 2019 (136 wRC+), but he was just league average at A+ Palm Beach. On the other hand he was only 18 years old for half the season, so the performance overall was indeed truly tremendous for a batter of his age. I share your well-founded enthusiasm for his season.

    And he did, just as you say, put up excellent numbers in the Double-A equivalent Arizona Fall League. The thing is, that was barely 40 trips to the plate. Encouraging, yes. But upon reflection maybe not as encouraging as the mere fact that the organization sent him there at all. That’s a lot of faith to show in a young kid catcher, and he did not disappoint.

    As for glovework, not so glowing. I don’t think the defense can be deemed acceptable yet, much less above average. The caught stealing was fine & dandy in 2019, at 31% across the two levels during the regular season, then 33% in Arizona. But the errors and passed balls were both a chunk too high for my comfort. And moreover, passed ball rates tend to strongly correlate for good or bad with pitch-blocking skills. So Ivan likely has multiple skills to hone.

    But I don’t mean to just throw cold water. Based on everything I’ve seen and read, Herrera is fairly nimble, quite intelligent, extremely determined, and very hard-working. I’m no sports psychologist, but he seems to possess that blend of humility and confidence necessary for pro sports development. So I would say that the potential is certainly there for “above averageness” behind the dish. But he’s not there yet.

    in reply to: Cooperstown Class of 2020 #117763
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “However, rather than blaming it on the writers – who have a very tough job to do to sort this all out and invariably 420 voters are not all going to see it the same way – why not point back at the Hall itself? For decades, they have purposely provided only vague guidelines to the voters instead of taking on the issues themselves.”

    —————————

    I agree 100%, Brian, that the writers have a quite difficult chore. And for far too long the Hall Of Fame wimped out re guidelines for voters. But it felt to me like the Hall finally provided the firm and explicit guidance you describe two years ago, when in November of 2017 vice chairman of the Hall Joe Morgan stated the following in a letter sent to all Hall Of Fame voting members:

    “We hope the day never comes when known steroid users are voted into the Hall of Fame,” Morgan wrote. “They cheated. Steroid users don’t belong here.’

    He continued, “Players who failed drug tests, admitted using steroids, or were identified as users in Major League Baseball’s investigation into steroid abuse, known as the Mitchell Report, should not get in. Those are the three criteria that many of the players and I think are right.”

    And finally, “By cheating, they put up huge numbers, and they made great players who didn’t cheat look smaller by comparison, taking away from their achievements and consideration for the Hall of Fame. That’s not right.”

    As respected baseball writer Joe Posnanski opined at the time, “Let’s not mistake this. The letter was sent from the Hall of Fame email address. This Joe Morgan letter is the Hall of Fame’s stance.”

    in reply to: Jose Martinez… #117549
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Girsch said this very thing on MLBN a week or two ago (with Vasgersian I think). He said in an ideal world, if everyone plays to form in ST and is healthy to start the season, then Edman will not have a starting “position” — but he will get starts at different positions depending on who needs rest, pitching matchups, etc.”

    And Mo also said something very similar when interviewed on the MLB network during the Winter Meetings. Specifically referred to Tommy Edman as filling a “Ben Zobrist” type role. Which is smart, in my opinion, even if Tommy E. projects as slightly more valuable overall than Carp as a third baseman, or even Wong at the keystone.

    Let’s accept at face value the projections I referenced earlier in the thread, with Carp hitting slightly better than Edman in 2020. If Tommy starts over Carp, the hot corner position would generate a little more value, e.g., half a win or perhaps one full win. But if Tommy does start, then the team gets less out of the two of them as a combo than they would if Carp started and Edman played the role of Swiss Army knife, spelling guys all over the diamond and accumulating 75-80% (or more) of a starter’s typical workload in plate appearances.

    Carp cannot start, or even fill in, at any other position anymore, other than first base — and that spot will be taken for 150+ games in all likelihood. He can’t pinch run either, but Edman sure can. There’s no flexibility there, no way to leverage Carp other than pinch-hitting.

    It may not be fair to Tommy, strictly speaking, to only get 100-120 starts rather than 140-150. But it is probably best for the team as currently constructed. Now, if Yairo Munoz had turned out to be the player they thought they’d traded for, i.e., a solid 1-2 WAR utilityman, things would be different. But from what we know now, Tommy certainly seems to be by far the best bench choice. Then, depending on several variables, maybe he takes over for Carp next year, or Kolten the year after that. Or heck, maybe he switches to outfielder if he retains most of 2019’s power surge.

    That power would be a sweet belated Christmas present for all of us.

    in reply to: Jose Martinez… #117538
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Tommy Edman will start somewhere…other than maybe Goldschmidt he is our most productive offensive player.”

    This certainly could be true, once we factor Tommy’s exceptional baserunning into the equation. But speaking strictly from a batting standpoint, here are some OPS forecasts for returning Redbirds — taking the average of the Steamer and Marcel projection models:

    Goldy .867 (46 points above 2019)
    Carpenter .798 (+72 v. 2019)
    DeJong .787 (+25)
    Edman .785 (-65)
    Jose M. .774 (+23)
    Wong .762 (-22)
    Fowler .736 (-18)
    Bader .732 (+52)
    Yadi .724 (+13)

    So we see that Jose and Dexter Fowler are expected to hit like middle infielders, while Goldschmidt, Bader, and Carpenter are all predicted to have big bounceback seasons, and Tommy E. will decline significantly but still be a terrific bench player who could start for at least 15-20 teams.

    (Tangent Alert!)

    Taking just the presumptive Opening Day seven starters, there’s a total OPS improvement of 168 points. Since 50-60 points of OPS for a fulltime batter equals approximately 10 runs or 1 win, those 168 represent an improvement of roughly three games in the standings. In other words, those within and without the Cardinal organization who are banking on a substantial collective improvement from returning Redbird batters are strongly supported by some objectively-generated data.

    Lastly, regarding Jose Martinez and playing time distribution. Just for kicks I checked the Clay Davenport 50th percentile 2020 WAR forecasts for ALL of the possible Cardinal outfielders. I prorated everyone to 600 plate appearances, and here are the results in inverse order:

    Adolis Garcia 1.2 WAR
    Justin Williams 1.7
    Jose Martinez 1.7
    Tyler O’Neill 1.8
    Dexter Fowler 2.0
    Rangel Ravelo 2.1
    Tommy Edman 2.2
    Dylan Carlson 2.3
    Marcell Ozuna 2.5
    Lane Thomas 3.1
    Randy Arozarena 3.1
    Harry Bader 4.1

    My immediate expectations aren’t quite that high for Arozarena, and certainly not for Lane Thomas, who was barely an average bat in AAA last year, before 40 or 50 terrific and terrifically meaningless MLB trips to the dish. (Don’t get sore, Lane. I swear I really DO appreciate your contribution to the division title. I just mean “meaningless” as a predictor of future MLB performance. Also, Merry Christmas young man.)

    Anyway, if the above numbers are even remotely close to prescient, there’s no reason to retain Ozuna at literally any price. Not for a buck a year. Because if you keep him, even for cheaper than dirt, you lose a draft pick. And the draft pick has real value, especially to a team that excels at Draft & Devel. Cleanup hitters or not, there certainly appear to be numerous other Cardinals who can match or very nearly match Ozuna’s total contribution to the team. Or maybe even exceed it.

    And just like 12 months ago, Jose Martinez should be traded to an A.L. team for whatever the Birds can get. In part because there are many others much younger with more upside both short and long term, and in part because his manager will overuse him if given any opportunity.

    in reply to: Vote here for 2020 top-50 Cardinal prospects #117533
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Where do you rank a guy, when he’s in his 30’s already and you’re only guaranteed to have him for two years? Pretty tricky. Well, one good thing is that the Korean Baseball Organization is equivalent to the American upper minors — like Triple-A, but a lowish Triple-A — so he’s effectively been effective in lowish Triple-A ball for more than a decade. (For those who don’t know, he was MVP of the league way back when he was just 20 years old.) Thus, there’s a huge body of work that should make his MLB projections more reliable.

    Naturally I’ve been looking at Kim’s forecast per the ZiPS projection model, the only one available for Kim so far. And I have to say I’m pretty darn impressed.

    ZiPS pegs him for 157 innings in 2020, with a 3.89 ERA and 106 ERA+. How good is a 106 ERA+ for a starting pitcher? At Fangraphs they are currently rolling out ZiPS projections one organization at a time, and have covered six teams so far (Mets, White Sox, and the entire N.L. West, save for Frisco). Here’s a list of all the starting pitchers projected to have an ERA+ between 102 and 110:

    Robbie Ray, Dustin May, Ross Stripling, Marcus Stroman, Chris Paddack, Kenta Maeda, and young phenom Luis Patino. Conveniently, those seven pitchers actually average a 106, same as Kim. That’s a peer group and a half, really very very nice. (For instance, Marcus Stroman is the Mets’ clear #3 starter, and they’re supposed to have one of the top 4 or 5 rotations in the sport.) And moreover, KK is forecast to be almost exactly as good in 2021 as well.

    I would rank him 4th in the system behind just Nolan Gorman, Dylan Carlson, and Ivan Herrera. He likely won’t give you as many wins above replacement in two years as I expect (or at least hope) to get from Knizner or Rondon or Arozarena in six years of team control — but given his recent consistent excellence, Kim has more certainty I think than any of them and could perhaps provide more wins above average in two years than they do in five or six seasons.

    in reply to: Houston Astros (and Red Sox) Stealing Signs #117346
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “If you steal money from a bank it’s still stealing whether you do it at gunpoint or embezzle it.”

    And the man who steals $1,000 from a bank at gunpoint will very likely get a rougher sentence than the man who steals $1,000,000 via embezzling. It is understood by one and all that those two activities are not morally or ethically or legally equivalent.

    Laws are what they are, and the Astros obviously knew exactly what they were doing, and moreover were warned loudly & clearly. They not only violated explicit MLB rules, but gave the commissioner the middle finger while doing so.

    in reply to: Houston Astros (and Red Sox) Stealing Signs #117340
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    I hear you, Minuteman. We’re trespassers in the postmodern age. Sometimes I feel like I’m Fred Flintstone transplanted to The Jetsons.

    But yeah, Apple Watches. Go figure.

    in reply to: Houston Astros (and Red Sox) Stealing Signs #117338
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Here’s the thing about the Astros.

    Late in the 2017 season the Red Sox were busted for using Apple brand watches to steal signs.
    Link: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/05/sports/baseball/boston-red-sox-stealing-signs-yankees.html

    So in mid-September of 2017, the Commissioner fined the Red Sox an undisclosed amount and issued a strong and quite explicit warning to all 30 clubs. This warning included the following:

    “…all 30 clubs have been notified that future violations of this type will be subject to more serious sanctions, including the possible loss of draft picks.”

    Full statement here: https://www.mlb.com/press-release/commissioner-s-statement-regarding-red-sox-yankees-violations-254435818

    So the Astros, in the 2017 postseason, used illegal means to steal signs less than three weeks after being quite expressly warned by Rob Manfred in the strongest terms NOT to do so.

    Who do they think they are, Bill Belichick?

    (Apologies to all, if these observations/links just rehash earlier statements in the thread.)

    in reply to: Kwang-Hyun Kim signed, Adolis Garcia DFAed #117047
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    I like it a lot.

    Yes, Keuchel & Ryu will both probably be better going forward. But there’s no telling how high you’d have to bid for those two, and more importantly whether they even want to pitch under the Arch. (For instance, we know now that Madison Bumgarner was practically pre-ordained to wind up with Arizona, if they wanted him. And of course they did, making less than half the dough per year of Strasburg and Cole.) And to bid and wait and lose out on those guys, those Scott Boras clients, could leave the Cards scrambling as February rolls around.

    Better to get someone now — and on a modest Classic Cardinal Deal that leaves the Redbird manager with the flexibility to use the Korean southpaw strictly according to how he performs rather than be unduly influenced by how massive the $$ commitment.

    ————————–

    And heck, maybe the Birds got a diamond in the rough. Recall that just 24 months ago the top two MLB free agents per MLB.com were Yu Darvish and Jake Arrieta. Not the top pitchers, or top righty pitchers, but the top free agents, period. And Miles Mikolas was a nobody, a low-hanging MLB reject trying to reclaim an MLB career, the #50 free agent at MLB Trade Rumors that offseason. And what’s happened in the two seasons since?

    Darvish 219 IP and a 4.16 ERA
    Arrieta 308 IP and a 4.26 ERA
    Mikolas 385 IP and a 3.46 ERA

    In case anyone’s curious, two years ago the other top free agent starting pitchers, per MLBTR, in descending order, were Masahiro Tanaka (335 IP, 4.14), Lance Lynn (358, 4.20), Alex Cobb (165, 5.36), and Mike Minor — the one guy who’s been roughly the Lizard King’s equal, with a 3.84 ERA over 365 innings.

    If the Birds are very fortunate, and everyone is healthy & effective in Spring Training, and Carlos Martinez is ready and rarin’ to return to the rotation, then Kim can be a sort of lefty Poncedeleon, a security blanket swingman from the left side. That’d be okay. But something tells me they’ll get quite a bit more than that from him.

    in reply to: Kwang-Hyun Kim signed, Adolis Garcia DFAed #116962
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    I like the idea, guys. The one thing the Cards have gotten really right in free agency over the past few years is their evaluations of Far East talent.

    Over the past two seasons, you know how many MLB starters have thrown as many innings as Lizard King Miles Mikolas, with as low an ERA? Here’s the entire list:

    Max Scherzer, Gerrit Cole, Justin Verlander, Jacob DeGrom, Zack Greinke, Aaron Nola, Patrick Corbin, and Trevor Bauer. Since arriving in St. Louis, Mikolas has thrown more innings, and posted a lower ERA, than Strasburg, Wheeler, Syndergaard, Bumgarner, and Hamels. Nice group to be better than.

    And for the two years that Final Boss Seunghwan Oh pitched out of the Redbird bullpen, here’s the list of all MLB relievers who posted a lower ERA with as many innings pitched: Brad Brach, Addison Reed, Chris Devenski, Brad Hand, and Hector Neris. That’s it. Five relievers across all of baseball.

    Over those same two seasons, here are some bullpenners who threw fewer innings than Final Boss, with a worse ERA: Dellin Betances, Roberto Osuna, Edwin Diaz, Ken Giles, Jeremy Jeffress, and Kelvin Herrera.

    ————————–

    If the Cardinals like Kim, then I like Kim. Only thing I don’t like? He lacks a cool nickname.

    in reply to: Winter Meetings #116496
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Cool Arenado stats:
    career bases empty .827 OPS
    career men on base .983
    career with RISP 1.024

    Over the past decade, MLB-wide (a sample size of well over a million trips to the plate) batterb as a whole have hit slightly better with men on base than with the bases empty. About 35 points of OPS better, but that’s all. Arenado appears to be the rare “RBI guy” who actually exists.

    Uncool Arenado stats:
    career home .995 OPS
    career road .799

    And Busch Stadium III is not kind to righty power hitters — Goldschmidt and Ozuna being recent glaring examples, along with Paul DeJong and Harry Bader, who have combined to homer 69 times on the road and just 32 times at home.

    But it’s all moot anyway, since Cardinal brass signed Matt Carpenter and Paul Goldschmidt both to multi-year extensions before the 2019 season. Ahh, if only no Carpenter extension. Then they could just trade Dylan Carlson plus a sweetener or two, and Nolan Arenado could hold down third base for the next half a decade. And likely be as disappointing as Goldy and Ozuna turned out to be.

    As it stands now, the trade would need to be Dylan Carlson plus Nolan Gorman plus Matt Carpenter. And I don’t think I’d do that if I were the Birds. Maybe, but I don’t think so. Perhaps if the Cards also included the salary and questionable shoulder of Carlos Martinez, and received Jon Gray. Man that would be some blockbuster, yes?

    in reply to: In honor of Strasburg’s new contract… #116438
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    As long as we’re speculating idly — on of all things a guy who’s no less than four seasons from free agency — I think Jack would sign tomorrow for 5 years and $50M, plus two team options at $25M each. His agent can call it a “$100M contract,” which would be the highest ever for a pitcher with so little MLB experience. I think.

    The only way that works out badly for Jack, is if he pitches at a star level nearly every year and stays unusually healthy. And even then, it’s $100M in the bank, and he’s a free agent at the same age Strasburg is now.

    And what would a free agent starter get on the open market in seven years, with the track record I just described? He’d get more than Strasburg just got, that’s for certain.

    In short, I agree with both Muddy and Brian. I believe Jack would absolutely consider a contract that extends beyond his arbitration years — but if and only if it well exceeds the similar length deals inked by Matt Carpenter, Kolten Wong, Carlos Martinez, and Paul DeJong. That’s just rational self-interest. (Especially for a twirler.)

    in reply to: Texas LHH outfielders #116433
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Both Baseball-Reference and Fangraphs have Mazara worth less than 1 WAR in every one of his four MLB campaigns. And he’s into his arbitration years now.

    Even in a straight platoon, his value is highly questionable due to poor defense. I guess as a platoon DH, he might make sense. But how many 24-year-olds cheerfully switch to DH? And don’t the Southsiders have an excess of no-glove types already? (And more on the way soon, with Collins & Vaughn?)

    Weird deal, to me.

    in reply to: Winter Meetings #116432
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    A third of a billion dollars? Hope that Craig Stammen doesn’t cost that much.

    in reply to: Texas LHH outfielders #116404
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    What, isn’t Drew Robinson available?

    This Handedness Preoccupation Syndrome never ceases to baffle me. Unless the club intends to go with a straight platoon — and I cannot recall the last time a Redbird manager did that — they should ignore handedness completely, in every single case, hitters and pitchers alike, and focus on talent, talent, talent. If every player on the 40-man roster is a righty, so be it. Just get the best guys and forget everything else. It’ll make for a stronger squad.

    Anyway, rather than rant my way through a few more paragraphs, let’s take a look at 24-year-old erstwhile top prospect Nomar Mazara.

    Entering 2016 Mazara was a consensus top 25 overall prospect (I thought so too). In fact, he was #5 at Baseball Prospectus. So stardom was clearly expected. But it just has not happened, in the least.

    2016 OPS+ 93
    2017 OPS+ 90
    2018 OPS+ 96
    2019 OPS+ 96 again

    Interesting split info:
    Career v. LHP .633 OPS
    Career v. RHP .799 OPS

    So, excellent platoon candidate. Except there’s another split that’s less encouraging.
    Home, career: .805 OPS
    Road, career: .705 OPS

    And Mazara’s defense is lacking, making him less than a 1-WAR player. So, basically, there’s no way I deal Arozarena or Tyler O’Neill for Nomar M.
    A couple years ago, sure. But not now. Not with the StL guys having dominated Triple-A pitchers, and Mazara having stagnated so thoroughly. And Mazara is starting to cost actual money, on top of everything else. Heck, why trade for a guy who could be non-tendered any day now?

    Choo would be intriguing as a platoon possibility, but he is old, old, old and cannot play the outfield any more.

    Left hand, shmeft hand. Talent. Talent. Talent.

    in reply to: Winter Meetings #116345
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    On the MLB Network Monday, John Mozeliak was interviewed at length from the Winter Meetings. Not surprisingly, he didn’t give away many state secrets. But he did say two things of interest, I thought. (All quotes are his.)

    1) There’s a “logjam of outfielders” and he feels that some “young players” should get a chance to see how good they are. In other words, if we take Mo at face value no big Ozuna contract will be forthcoming. So, big hurray for that.

    2) Yadi Molina can still play “a few more years.” I love Yadi, like we all love Yadi. Oh, oh, oh what a guy. But he isn’t the pitch framer or pitch blocker that he was just a few years ago, and this is reflected in the fact that — unlike the first dozen-plus campaigns of his career — the team ERA has actually been worse with Yadi behind the dish over the past two seasons. Whatever pitcher whisperer skills he once had, Yadi appears to no longer possess them to the same degree, if at all. Moreover, he’s only gunned runners at a very-slightly-better-than-average rate over the past four seasons. And finally, the bat just ain’t the same either.

    From 2007-2016, according to the Fangraphs calculations Yadi was the most valuable player in the Senior Circuit, just a whisker ahead of Chase Utley and Joey Votto. During that decade Molina was worth 46.7 WAR per Fangraphs, with a .348 OBP. And in 2016 the on-base was even better than that, at a sturdy .360. But since then, and despite pretty good health, he’s averaged exactly 2.0 WAR and posted shaky OBP’s between .312 and .314 each year. Not a pleasant trend.

    If the Birds pay Yadi $20M per year to stick around beyond 2020, then five old players will combine to make $100M in 2021. Matt Carpenter, Miles Mikolas, Dexter Fowler, Paul Goldschmidt, and Yadi will average 35 years of age in 2021, and average ~$20M in salary. That’s a little scary, folks.

    Scary not because the team will be up against the luxury tax, not that at all. But scary because when respected players make that much dough and are not good, they nevertheless are routinely permitted to block better younger “unproven” talent. This is a real organizational danger going forward — in my opinion probably the greatest impediment to StL success over the next two to three years.

    in reply to: Cooperstown Class of 2020 #116235
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    From Jay Jaffe’s article on Fangraphs:

    “The voting results will be announced that evening (Sunday, tonight) live on MLB Network’s MLB Tonight at 8 pm ET/5 pm PT, and any candidates elected will be inducted alongside those from this year’s BBWAA ballot cycle (whose results will be announced January 21) next July 21 in Cooperstown.”

    Good luck, Simba. Other than Brock & Gibson, you were the favorite from my childhood — and more importantly, a worthy candidate.

    in reply to: Madison Bumgarner Thread #116095
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Stepping back, does anyone really think the Cards would go five years/$120 MM or thereabouts for MadBum (or any pitcher in his 30’s)?”

    Well correct me if I’m wrong, Brian — and I so often am — but wasn’t there a 7-year, $190M offer from the Birds for David Price when he was the same age Bumgarner is now? Same age within a matter of days, in fact.

    Now, Price was maybe half a level better; a true ace versus a mere #1 starter. And Price was coming off perhaps his best season at the time. So it makes sense that he would get more years and a higher annual paycheck. But then, Bumgarner (1)destroys the Cubs & Brewers, (2)helps your team at the plate, and (3)has reportedly had some October success on the bump — a claim Price couldn’t make until very recently. So Bumgarner is not without his particular charms.

    Anyway I wouldn’t be shocked if they made an all-out play for M.B., even going as high as 6 years and ~$150M.

    The wisdom of such a move is another question altogether.

    in reply to: Outfield Dilemma … #115303
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Bob, I’ve been thinking about this quite a bit this morning. I generally agree that Bader should get every shot to start. I’d be curious to hear your thoughts on Thomas and Arozarena. I think a lot of people are seeing Lane and Randy as a step down with the glove but a potentially big step up with the bat.”

    And I agree with those people, stl25. But with some nuance. (Can’t resist the chance to ramble & rant.)

    I see Lane Thomas as a real wildcard at the plate, a guy whose bat could be anywhere from poor to very good. But for me Arozarena feels like a hitter who will definitely hit, if given steady at-bats. Year over year, he’s adjusted beautifully to each level in the minors.

    As for fielding, Randy lacks the instincts for center but should be fine in a corner, and perhaps above average — not unlike Dylan Carlson. Lane Thomas on the other hand can play a solid CF, I think. (Nothing like Bader, though.) And Lane’s feel for baserunning is better than Randy’s. The problems with Lane Thomas? Plate discipline and nagging injuries. And also it kind of seems like his bat stagnated at AAA in 2019. (As opposed to Arozarena.)

    To sum up: In a laboratory setting, where each guy got 600 fully healthy plate appearances per year, I think Bader would be worth ~3.5 WAR per year for the next half decade, and Randy Arozarena and Lane Thomas both in the 2 – 2.5 range. So, the latter two are plausible starters, but potentially excellent bench contributors. (But then, that’s what I thought about Jon Jay, Allen Craig, and Tommy Pham. So don’t listen to me.)

    ————————

    “Personally, I’d be a little surprised if Bader hits .240 with 15 HRs next year but I suppose it’s possible.”

    I can understand your skepticism. I know that a LOT of Redbird fans have already thrown in the towel on Bader. It is admittedly very hard to watch guys with low batting averages as they struggle day in, day out (regardless of whatever other skills they possess). But if a 33-year-old batter can bounce back from .180 to .238, is it such a stretch for a 25-year-old to go from .205 to .240?

    At any rate, the Marcel projection model used by Baseball-Reference may be rather rudimentary, but to the best of my knowledge it has a track record about as reliable as any of the more sophisticated and oft-cited forecast generators like ZiPS, Steamer and PECOTA. And speaking of Steamer, it predicts Bader will bat .238 and pop a dozen homers — but in barely over 300 AB’s. (B-Ref had him with just under 400 AB’s.)

    So the only two current publicly available forecast models see Bader pretty much exactly the same. And much, much more in line with his overall MLB numbers than his disappointing 2019 campaign.

    Keep the faith, stl25!

    in reply to: Outfield Dilemma … #115209
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Thanks, CC. The feeling’s mutual.

    Since there are Baseball-Reference projections up for the 2020 season, they might serve as a rough guideline. Bearing in mind of course that players with abbreviated MLB track records (like Randy Arozarena, Lane Thomas, et. al.) have a significantly wider performance delta, here are some 2020 forecasts in descending order of projected slugging percentage:

    Lane Thomas .503 slugging
    Tommy Edman .484
    Paul DeJong .466
    Tyler O’Neill .464
    Randy Arozarena .452
    Matt Carpenter .451
    Gap
    Yadi Molina .422
    Kolten Wong .419
    Harry Bader .414
    Delicate Dexter .411

    I excluded Goldy since he’ll almost surely anchor the lineup in the 3-hole. And also Jose Martinez, since he obviously has no business starting for a playoff contender. (Well, if he hits like 2017/18, I guess Martinez can start in RF when an extreme groundball pitcher like Dakota Hudson takes the bump.)

    For the sake of this exercise, if we just take all of the above numbers at face value, next year’s lineup should probably look something like:

    2B Wong
    LF Edman
    1B Goldschmidt
    RF Lane Thomas
    3B Carpenter
    SS DeJong
    C Molina
    CF Bader
    P

    Arozarena and O’Neill would be 4th and 5th outfielders in this scenario — but for me, I’d prefer one of them as the left field starter, and Tommy E. as a super-utility guy who starts four or five days a week all over the diamond depending on matchups and player health.

    And even though Lane Thomas is projected to slug .500+, I’d rather see a month or two of dominant Triple-A performance before anointing him as an MLB starter, much less cleanup hitter.

    So I guess the answer to “who replaces DeJong” in the lineup would be a new left fielder: either Arozarena or O’Neill or Edman. Or just maybe Dylan Carlson. Or Carp if he bounces halfway back to his previous borderline elite level as a batsman. But anyway, the broader point, the bigger point is that it just ain’t that difficult to replace the offense of a corner outfielder with a 106 OPS+ for his Redbird career. Marcell Ozuna was nothing special for the Cards, nothing like the player they thought they were acquiring. And he’ll only get slower and fatter from here.

    in reply to: Outfield Dilemma … #115206
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “You want DeJong in the cleanup spot?????
    Not in a million years. Unless he turns it around big time.”

    “DeJong in the 4th spot? I haven’t head anything that funny in months.”

    ———————————-

    Hmmm, let’s think about cleanup hitter. Derrick Goold and many others have suggested that it will be very difficult for the Cards to replace Marcell Ozuna at cleanup hitter.

    Marcell Ozuna as a Cardinal: .451 slugging percentage and a 106 OPS+.
    Paul DeJong for his MLB career: .467 slugging, and a 106 OPS+.

    Now, lemme be clear. I’m not advocating for DeJong as cleanup hitter. But rather I’m trying to throw cold water on the nonsense that “Ozuna’s bat will be tough to replace.”

    But neither do I mean to dismiss the idea of DeJong at cleanup. If he hits .260 with 30-35 homers, that’d be fine. And it wouldn’t surprise me much if he did just that.

    ————————————–

    But this is an outfielder thread, so let me suggest something about the outfield that is both radical and boringly obvious.

    Harrison Bader had a horrible year at the plate in 2019 and was STILL an above average ballplayer, thanks largely to his wondrous range in the outfield. We all know that great defense has a lot of value, especially up-the-middle defense. And Bader is indeed a great defender, which made him above average overall. He was above average whether we look at Baseball-Reference values, or Fangraphs. Even with the ugly bat.

    And for his (admittedly brief) career thus far, he has been worth an excellent 3.6 WAR per 600 plate appearances according to Fangraphs. And B-Ref likes him even more than that, at 3.8 WAR per 600.

    Therefore, based on both last year and his career, Harry Bader should be the starting centerfielder next season, period. If he maintains his superlative glovework and hits in 2020 as projected by the B-Ref Marcel forecasting system (.240 with 15 homers), he’ll be a 4-4.5 WAR player. And if he only hits like he did in 2019, he’s still worth keeping in the starting lineup. Just bat him near the bottom, and pinch hit late when tied or trailing.

    in reply to: Houston Astros (and Red Sox) Stealing Signs #114420
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Bob, they (amphetamines) were common place in baseball throughout the 90’s, and the nineties use was less than the 80’s. And the 80’s less than the 70’s. And if my elders are to be believed, the 70’s were their peak (into the early 80’s).”

    Ever hear the one about the guy who gets arrested for cheating on his taxes? He goes to court and the judge asks him how he wants to plead.

    “I plead only kind of guilty, your honor”

    “Kind of guilty?”

    “Yeah, I’m not really guilty, because lots of other people cheat on their taxes too.”

    in reply to: Houston Astros (and Red Sox) Stealing Signs #114409
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Is it really your understanding that amphetamine use mostly went away in 1971?”

    It does not matter what specific percentage of players stopped using in 1971.

    What matters is that any MLB player using amphetamines after Kuhn issued his Drug Policy Memo was violating MLB rules.

    And we know that Kuhn’s Drug Policy Memo was an enforceable and binding rule governing all MLB players, because the Memo was in fact enforced a couple dozen times while Peter Ueberroth was Commissioner in the 1980’s — most notoriously around the time of the Pittsburgh Drug Trials.

    The national coverage of the illegal PED users has been third rate from the start. Just to take one glaring example, national baseball writer Dan Szymborski of Fangraphs lies to his readers about these facts on a regular basis, when he loudly, repeatedly, and falsely claims that Kuhn’s Drug Policy was meaningless until there was drug testing. Kuhn’s Policy was NOT meaningless. It was enforced again and again in the 1980’s, and a variety of disciplinary actions were appealed and upheld — some were upheld in their entirety, some were reduced, and just one was fully overturned (the rather absurd one year suspension for Fergie Jenkins).

    Any players who used “greenies” or anabolic steroids or any other illegal PED’s after April, 1971, would not get my Hall Of Fame vote. Because of this, from the HOF website:

    5. Voting: Voting shall be based upon the player’s record, playing ability, integrity, sportsmanship, character, and contributions to the team(s) on which the player played.

    Integrity.
    Sportsmanship.
    Character.

    Those are three of the six yardsticks to be used, per the Hall itself. You flunk three out of six, and you don’t get my vote. That goes for anyone.

    So if Ozzie Smith or Cal Ripken, Jr. or some other star of the 1980’s admitted he used “greenies,” I’d be more than happy to sign a petition to have him removed from the Hall. Speaking of which, do you have a link to any stories, anecdotal or concrete, first hand or second, detailing “greenie” use in the 1980’s, tripleshy?

    in reply to: Houston Astros (and Red Sox) Stealing Signs #114405
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Why do the people who most strongly vilify steroid users also pretend that rampant amphetamine use in the early 80’s and before was no big deal?”

    I think maybe I can answer this one.

    All of the amphetamine stories I have read — like “greenies” on the clubhouse training tables — involved players like Mickey Mantle back in the days before illegal drug use in baseball was explicitly banned. (Violations of state and federal drug laws were banned in MLB by Commissioner Bowie Kuhn in April, 1971. That was MLB’s first binding drug policy.)

    Any major league ballplayers who used amphetamines after Kuhn issued his Drug Policy Memo in April, 1971, should absolutely be vilified. Because they were violating a binding drug policy.

    Any ballplayer who used “greenies” prior to Kuhn’s Drug Policy Memo was NOT violating MLB rules, and thus they get no criticism from me.

Viewing 25 posts - 701 through 725 (of 1,093 total)

First-hand news and commentary on the St. Louis Cardinals™ and minor league system for over 25 years