Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
This team has no identity.
We don’t hit home runs.
We don’t steal bases.
We don’t play scintillating defense.
We don’t have dominant pitching.
We don’t have a HOF Manager.No identity. Who would want to be the Face of this franchise?
August 26, 2024 at 7:54 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #131 thread – Monday, August 26 vs. Padres #265609This team is boring.
Winn has had a marvelous rookie campaign. Much better hitting than most expected. Exceptional defense. Team leader in WAR.
But….
He has a ways to go to become the “face” of the franchise. I think one of his problems is he has been so consistent. We kinda take him for granted.
^^^^^
Great points. Marmol doesn’t appear to have garnered much respect in the baseball world.
A great manager brings out the very best in his players and team. I’ve yet to see Marmol do this.
Gray is tied with Winn for the team lead in fWAR. Nado is next.
I agree the Cards need better players. But Marmol is a joke. A Yes-Man.
August 25, 2024 at 9:43 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #130 thread – Sunday, August 25 at Twins #265525^^^^^^
Someone should write a book!
August 25, 2024 at 9:19 pm in reply to: 23 year old Quinn Matthews is likely better than Gray #265521Probably my fault, Brian.
I sometimes feel that if I use data and facts to show a poster the flaw(s) in his thinking, he will understand and walk away a little wiser. And then BANG!!! Before I know it I’m down into a “Who is the better hitter, Judge, Ohtani, or Burleson?” discussion.
^^^^^^
I think 2.1 bWAR & 2.7 fWAR so far in 2024.I don’t think he’s tradeable, so I’d love to see him get back to 20-25 HR next season. He still gets a lot of base hits.
August 25, 2024 at 5:17 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #130 thread – Sunday, August 25 at Twins #265489^^^^^
Not sure it was gifted to us.
Noot with a timely, clutch hit in the 8th against a very good reliever. Haven’t had enough of these type of key hits this season.
We earned this one.
August 25, 2024 at 4:39 pm in reply to: 23 year old Quinn Matthews is likely better than Gray #265481Your take on Burleson is not correct and was never correct.
At times you compared him to Joey Votto, Tony Gwynn, and Ted Simmons (to name a few).
He is not close to these players and never will be.
Additionally, you touted him for a couple of years as a “Doubles Machine” (your exact words). His 16 doubles on the season hardly qualifies him as a doubles machine.
He is exactly what I thought he was…a decent, not great hitter, who can’t run, can’t play defense, and can’t hit left-handed pitching. These facts are indisputable as of today.
FYI…with 32 games left his fWAR of 1.0 is currently tied for 13th on the Cardinals (with Ivan Herrera).
Now, please don’t respond unless you have a few facts or points of data to back up your silliness.
August 25, 2024 at 4:11 pm in reply to: 23 year old Quinn Matthews is likely better than Gray #265476Yes, it’s par for the course that I use actual data to make a point while you make wild statements which have no basis in reality and cannot be backed up by any evidence to support your latest silliness.
August 25, 2024 at 4:04 pm in reply to: 23 year old Quinn Matthews is likely better than Gray #265474Sonny Gray has a 2.9 fWAR with 32 games to go. This is second on the team to only Masyn Winn.
While I agree with many that Gray is not a #1 pitcher and while I agree with the author of this thread that Mathews appears to have a bright future in MLB, I find it ludicrous to suggest Mathews is better than Sonny Gray at this particular moment in time.
I think he deserves a shot…
Certainly can’t hurt the way this offense is going…
August 20, 2024 at 9:10 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #125 thread – Tuesday, August 20 vs. Brewers #265019Do our coaches teach players to take two strike fastballs right down central?
Sure looks like it.
Better late than never, although I doubt Oli will give him a legitimate look….
Well heck, boys & girls….here’s my take for what it’s worth…
Sure, Cards have a tremendous history! But that’s all it is at this point…history.
We are no longer an elite franchise. We hold no fascination for the baseball universe or the national media.
Baseball, like most pro sports, is a “What have you done for me lately” type of deal. And there’s no way to spin it…lately stinks!
This franchise needs a refresh…bold leadership…new ideas & new voices. Will the DeWitt’s do what so desperately needs to be done? Stay Tuned…
^^^^^^
Sounds like a good way to get a butt-whipping!
Right!
It needs to be bulldozed! And when re-built, let’s forget about legacy Cardinals!! We need baseball people who have a track record of success!
I love Pujols, Yadi, Carpenter, Waino, etc…but they are not the answer!
Go outside the organization ! Start by finding the best hitting coach on the planet who can work with and hopefully fix Walker, Gorman, Scott, and yes…even Nado! If the can be fixed, get ’em out of here! Bring in winners!!!
Similar to the arrival of The White Rat in
1980, The Cardinals are in crisis. The organization no longer has an identity and ownership appears to be in denial of how bad it has gotten.The DeWitt’s refuse to do it, but they need to blow the whole thing up and start from scratch. New Management, new Coaches, New Scouting, New players! If it ain’t broke don’t fix it…well boys & girls, it’s BROKE!
We have to look outside the organization for a manager. Find hitting & pitching coaches with a track record of success…I do not care if they have a Cardinal background or connections with this organization!
Make trades. Lots of them. Sign free agents. Screw sentimentality…b like Ole Red and figure out who can play at a high level and who can’t. Figure out who can be fixed and who can’t. DO NOT ACCEPT MEDIOCRITY!
It’s a big job. It’s a difficult job. It may not always be popular or pretty. But this organization is not only a mess, it seems to lack a direction. Ownership
MUST figure out what type of team the want and find someone to build that team.Whitey wanted speed, switch-hitters, defense. He wanted men on base with speed so teams could never relax.
TLR liked power and sound fundamentals. He wanted guys who gave 100% on every pitch no matter the situation.
I have no idea what this team is?
Here’s what I do know…
1. Nado is too young to lose his power completely.
2. Scouts raved about Carlson & Gorman & Walker. They get here and regress. Significantly. And no one seems to have a clue how to help them!
3. We’ve traded away some darn good players and received little in return in many cases.
4. This team is no longer an attractive destination for free agents.
5. Resigning a 37 year old Goldy would be yet another mistake.
6. Stop signing washed up vets like Carpenter & Crawford.
End of rant. Enjoy your weekend.
August 16, 2024 at 10:40 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #122 thread – Friday, August 16 vs. Dodgers #264566Mark Harmon has had a long career as a TV & Movie actor. Very successful.
But….did you know….
He was a two year starter at QB with UCLA and led them to an historical upset over Nebraska!
August 16, 2024 at 4:06 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #122 thread – Friday, August 16 vs. Dodgers #264495^^^^^^
You would need to define “good” actor.
Fred Dryer was a Pro Bowl D-End who had his own successful TV show for many years.
Uh…Johnny Weissmuller won Olympic Gold and became synonymous with Tarzan.
Arnold was a big star in both Hollywood and the sport of Bodybuilding.
^^^^^^^
I don’t jump on bandwagons and I don’t root for other teams.
I’ve been a fan since the early 60’s and the bad times (like now) simply make the good times that much more enjoyable & special.
August 15, 2024 at 12:35 pm in reply to: Could Stubby Clapp as interim manger help the Cardinals? #264395Exactly my thoughts…
We need new ideas and a new direction. A new voice. Similar to when we brought in Whitey and then later with TLR.
August 14, 2024 at 6:50 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #121 thread – Wednesday, August 14 at Reds #264300^^^^^^
And for the first time in decades, I’m not convinced we’ll be back on top anytime
soon.August 14, 2024 at 6:36 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #121 thread – Wednesday, August 14 at Reds #264298This is embarrassing….
-
AuthorPosts
