Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
January 28, 2024 at 10:07 am in reply to: Former Cardinals in the News – 2017 to Aug. 2024 (closed) #242166
Yeah, clocking in a approximately 10% of the population their relative scarcity gives them more rope for sure.
I hope Bloom’s position is not the baseball equivalent of a political liaison officer that was attached to military units in the old Soviet Union.
I see Carpenter as the Wilford Brimley of this team. The old guy full of wit and wisdom who is a really good listener.
Personally I don’t see why the clubhouse needed him and I know the 26 man roster doesn’t.
However, his presence is water under the bridge at this point and Mo didn’t check in with me before he did it.
As Brian has pointed out – the 26th roster spot provides very little on the field anyway.
With that, here is a question. What is the best use of the 26th roster spot for a team?
Third catcher? Extra bullpen arm? Utility man who can play all over the place but can’t hit a lick? Clubhouse grandpa? Surely not a young player with potential who would sit there and rot while getting an ab or two a week….
Wow. What a thing to say, lol.
It would have been really cool if his name was Frankenstein instead. The walk up music options would be epic.
Brian,
That is an interesting observation. Is WWU completely optional for players or could the club demand that they attend and be available to the media?
My opinion on leadership is that not everyone is a leader and that’s not something you can force.
The real issue is the 35 year old manager who simply does not command respect. It’s not his fault that he was hired to be the manager but (again my opinion) he simply hasn’t put in the time to earn that position – and it showed.
I’m a civil engineer / planner / real estate developer. One of the municipalities in my area hired a 32 year old to be their city engineer and it simply did not work. He was smart but simply wasn’t ready for the position. It was a massive cf on many levels. Sound familiar?
Matz flashed a little at the end of the season last year.
Was it fool’s gold or could that have been the beginning of a really nice run for him?
Ah, but that is the $64,000 question isn’t it?
As far as the starting rotation is concerned I think the die is cast for 2024 barring a system prospect blowing up and / or a deadline trade this summer.
I think 2024 will be better record wise than 2023; I just don’t know by how much.
If the Cards decide not to keep Carp I’m sure they will have a come to Jesus meeting with him first and let him announce his retirement or let him be ‘injured’.
I’m sure Buddy will give Matt his number back. Maybe 00 would be a better number for Carpenter though as it will be representative of his 2024 contributions.
If indeed this move is primarily to address clubhouse issues then shame on Wainwright, Goldschmidt, Arenado, Marmol, and McEwing.
We already had a 2nd year Contreras, Lynn, Gray, Gibson, + Goldschmidt and Arenado.
What is that smell in the air around Mo?
Was there seriously not a better use for $740,000?
Where is he going to play? We don’t need him to DH.
I honestly do not understand or see any upside to this move whatsoever….
So, did Naile have to approve a trade / sale to a foreign (non-MLB) team?
Winn in, Paul out
Muscles out, Edman to full time CF
Younger guys a year older
Goldschmidt and Arenado a year older
Motter gone – this could absolutely crush the spirit of this team – bears watching early on.
We shall see what happens with the pitching. More quality starts will lead to fewer early blowouts which should take pressure off the hitters and the bullpen.
Last year the Cardinals were out of it by the end of May and most everybody knew it.
As long as they can stay in the race until the end of the year that should help the revenue stream even if they ultimately miss the playoffs again.
To me, this looks like a 78-83 win team but who knows…if they are buyers at the trade DL and pick up a couple of key rentals anything can happen.
As has been discussed in multiple threads here, other than a select handful of franchises – do just enough to get into the playoffs, get a couple of good rentals, and hope to get hot in the tournament.
Fermin may not be the answer but he may be the answer.
Somebody call Motter and see what he’s doing, lol.
Well – reading through all of the above leads me to believe that the Cardinals are a few bricks shy of a load at SS and CF if Winn doesn’t come through at SS and / or if Winn, Carlson, or Edman are injured or don’t hit.
We appear to have 3 guys for 2 spots with Winn unproven, Edman coming off a surgery, and Carlson coming off an injury / underperforming season.
Yikes….
Could Victor Scott save the day, maybe?
This feels like a very Cardinal move. I’d have rather hung on to Palacios and traded Carlson for a better than a ‘coin flip he’ll turn out good pitcher’.
I’ve always thought that if you get to more than three – ‘if this guy turns out ok’ – on your team that things tend to fall apart more often than not.
Reading through the last couple of days of this thread is rather depressing.
It feels like the FO is rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic.
Brian if you are right that the Cardinals won’t have the pitching to really contend for 2-3 more seasons then they should have traded – if they could – both Arenado and Goldschmidt and loaded up on prospects.
Riding these two for ticket sales while burning up the rest of the productive portions of their careers seems selfish and short sighted and may actually work to keep the franchise mired in mediocrity.
The first thing Mo does every morning after grabbing his coffee is read this board. Guaranteed.
I think the pen as currently constructed would perform a little better this year than last year because the starters will provide more innings.
I also think a couple more bullpen arms are going to be added but we will have to see who they are.
I do not think this (current) team wins the division and will be pecking around the edges of the playoffs all year. I don’t expect another hideous start like 2023 that had us 14 games under in May at what 10-24 wasn’t it?
To me, this looks like a 78-83 win team without further additions or a couple of prospects busting onto the ML scene a year ahead of schedule.
I don’t know…. Don’t we already have enough octogenarians on the pitching staff?
Any given ‘star’ player acquisition may or may not work out but with multiple signings usually some of them will. The Padres last year are an example of big spending not working out but for franchises that have and are willing to keep spending big and paper over their mistakes with more dollar bills – yeah it’s pretty tough for teams like the Cardinals to truly compete.
Sure, sneak into the grossly expanded playoffs and fool yourself into thinking you have a chance at the brass ring…..but it’s becoming apparent that other than the very occasional outlier season – it ain’t happening. When it does the team that pulls it off is quicky disassembled and picked over by the vultures with all the money.
Yeah, starting the 10th inning with a runner on second is just little league.
Brian and Mud,
Statistics can be a funny thing depending on the point you are trying to make, eh?
Anyone paying attention knows that the last time the Cardinals had a truly contending team was the first half of the 2015 season – before injuries and age (and the Cubs) caught up with that group.
Since then there was 1 appearance in the NLCS (2019) and not much else and even that ended with a sweep.
Times do change and these days, for better or worse, the rate at which things change is accelerated due to ‘technology’.
We are sitting on 8 years of pretty much blah baseball by St. Louis standards and – it’s time for another run of truly contending baseball.
I don’t think they should but I think they will.
It might work out ok but more than likely it’ll lead to another ugly goodbye season…
-
AuthorPosts
