Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
September 27, 2024 at 8:19 am in reply to: StL 2024 Game #160 thread – Friday, Sept. 27 at Giants #268020
The last ride of Scruffy Mikolas.
We can only hope he’s not wearing a Cardinal’s uniform next season.
September 26, 2024 at 7:59 am in reply to: StL 2024 Game #159 thread – Thursday, Sept. 26 at Rockies #267977Will this be Gibson’s last game as a Cardinal?
I don’t think staff changes will grab many fans’ attention – that is reserved for ‘name’ players.
No matter who they sign or what other changes they make the only real path I see to recapturing their fans is winning a lot more and then advancing in the playoffs.
If they make splashy changes and then sputter early again on the field the interest and attendance of fans will plummet very quickly as patience has already worn thin.
If the product on the field isn’t significantly improved next year I think this year’s attendance will look great by comparison. I’d bet the number of tickets sold during the off season will be much lower so it’s likely they will be chasing ticket sales all season – they really do have to win in 2025 to balance the books so to speak.
It was either Herzog or Weaver that said a good manager can only ‘steal’ about 4-5 games a year.
September 24, 2024 at 7:28 am in reply to: StL 2024 Game #157 thread – Tuesday, Sept. 24 at Rockies #267800I know they have to play the games but what is more depressing – especially in the age of 3 WCs – than a game between two eliminated teams?
You can’t know whether winning or losing means all that much as the player & lineup shuffling along with nothing to play for takes the edge off the game.
September 23, 2024 at 11:25 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #157 thread – Tuesday, Sept. 24 at Rockies #267793Cards missed a big opportunity to get a much better look at some younger players. They found a way to lose at losing, lol.
I really think 2025 will be a ‘reset’ year and the Cards should be transparent with us fans and call it what it is.
Gray makes $25M in 2025; is he scheduled to make that or more in 2026?
They completely blew the opportunity to get prospects for Goldschmidt in 2023. Now they will get nothing after paying him ‘star’ money for 2024.
Mikolas, lololololololol
It almost feels like whatever decision they make it will turn out to be the wrong one. Snake bit.
September 22, 2024 at 8:32 am in reply to: StL 2024 Game #156 thread – Sunday, Sept. 22 vs. Cleveland #267698No. Just, no.
September 21, 2024 at 9:15 am in reply to: StL 2024 Game #154 thread – Friday, Sept. 20 vs. Cleveland #267640I do not understand why Goldschmidt and to some extent Arenado are still taking at bats?
Baker and Burleson could be getting a look at first.
Who else can play third?
I guess maybe since Cleveland is technically still battling for their division the Cards feel compelled to but the best on paper lineup out there?
Dunno……
85-90 wins by 2027? I mean, sure I’d think you could take all but a couple of franchises (White Sox) and give a solid FO / staff three years to get there.
But based on the results since 2016 – who will be happy with that?
I truly do not believe much of any team’s record is due to the manager. A handful of games either way.
Now sure, if you lose the division by three games you might be able to blame your manager or credit the other guy.
I would think they know it’s coming but they haven’t even started marketing in earnest.
They will figure out a catchy slogan, and maybe put Bloom’s face on it
Winn, Contreras, and Gray (and maybe Helsley) will figure in.
Something like “The future is now! Come see your Cardinals compete for a playoff spot!”
Pretty sure it will be Marmol for ’25.
September 19, 2024 at 7:25 am in reply to: StL 2024 Game #153 thread – Thursday, Sept. 19 vs. Bucs #267506Fedde looks like a complete bust to me. Other than the first part of this year he hasn’t done all that much to get excited about as a #2 pitcher – maybe he’s ok as your #4/5.
Gray is actually a #2 – he’s pretty good but not great and now he’ll be another year older and making $25M next year?
I can’t find a whole lot to be excited about for StL in 2025. Maybe the light bulb comes on for about 1/2 the line up, 4 young pitchers appear from the farm and produce at a high level, 4-5 solid FAs are signed and they all perform well, and the injury bug stays away.
It could happen…
September 19, 2024 at 7:16 am in reply to: StL 2024 Game #152 thread – Wednesday, Sept. 18 vs. Bucs #267505The Buckos are in even worse shape than we are. It’s hard to read much if anything into a win against them.
White flag vs. White flag. It is what it is.
Based on JNevel’s analysis I DO think the Cardinals are a train wreck.
Take Goldy off 1B and Winn has a ton more throwing errors for sure.
The outfield is a complete disaster.
OBP as a team is only slightly above whale poop.
The starting pitching is average and unsettled moving forward at best and just plain bad at worst.
The bullpen was good this year but that is no guarantee moving forward as we all know about year to year relief pitching.
What about injuries next year? You know they are going to happen.
If quite a few of our starting players and pitchers are only borderline major leaguers you can be pretty sure whoever will replace them when injuries happen will be worse.
I’ve always said when projecting performance and you get to three, “If player x can just do….” then it’s too much.
Unless there are is a massive turnover of this roster with massive upgrades across the board I’m thinking 2025 is going to look a whole lot like 2024.
Sure, 3 starters and 3 bullpen assets could arrive via the farm to go with what’s coming back, and Walker, Nootbar, Gorman, Scott, Siani, Pages, and Saggasse could all turn into good hitters & fielders…..but, are you willing to bet on all of that or hell, even half of that happening?
Nobody’s on base percentage is going to fly. If there is just one thing I could magically fix it would be OBP for this lineup. You’ve got to have traffic on the base paths or you can’t score many runs.
Just look at OBP up and down this roster – it’s anemic team wide so that smells like an organizational approach issue to me.
Bikemike – your suggestion for next year feels a lot like a youth fueled rebuild.
I don’t think that team wins 75 games but I don’t dislike the plan as we would for sure find out who can play / develop among the youngsters.
So, we are certainly going to win more games this year than last year; maybe around 10 more.
On the surface that looks like an upward trend that could be projected to improve to really fighting for the division next year and certainly picking off a WC spot.
However, the roster optics don’t seem to support the building back to a winner projection. Most fans aren’t stupid and can see the mess the organization has gotten itself into – you can see THAT in all the empty seats in Busch.
There are a lot of different ways someone might go about fixing the Cardinals. At this point, I’m in favor of jettonsing anyone over the age of 30 for picks and prospects and spending the next 3 seasons rebuilding the Astro Way. (There are few like Mikolas that they probably can’t unload though.)
Question: Is there a way to do a ‘soft’ rebuild that can provide the same chance to end up with a young sustainable talented roster and a stocked up farm system?
September 14, 2024 at 5:45 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #149 thread – Sunday, Sept. 15 at Blue Jays #267279Good grief, is it Scruffy’s turn, again??
September 14, 2024 at 5:42 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #148 thread – Saturday, Sept. 14 at Blue Jays #267278I can hear the “we were in it until the end” and “not eliminated until September X” spin now.
In what? Barely withing shouting distance of the 3rd WC spot?
September 14, 2024 at 8:38 am in reply to: StL 2024 Game #147 thread – Friday, Sept. 13 at Blue Jays #267252Now, regarding the complete teardown method – it’s not without risk.
Young players and pitchers don’t always pan out so you better have a bunch of them – especially pitchers due to career ruining injuries.
It’s ok to have and you certainly need a few veterans but those guys have to understand – especially early in the process – there aren’t going to be many wins.
The current roster is just a disaster as evidenced by the annual dumpster diving excursion each off season and trade deadline.
The problem is now that the window to get a prospect bonanza for guys like Goldschmidt has closed making any sort of rebuild even harder than it already would have been.
September 14, 2024 at 8:31 am in reply to: StL 2024 Game #147 thread – Friday, Sept. 13 at Blue Jays #267250Starting the last game this year, the Cardinals need to decide what they are going to be – pick a lane and stay in it from a roster building perspective.
It seems like we have been heavy on both ends of the young, wet behind the ears rookie types and also the grizzled old past their prime wiley veterans.
I’d like to see a complete Astros style teardown / overhaul of the team and build it back with youth and a sustainable farm system.
The Cardinals have been stuck in the middle for far too long and it seems that it will take something fairly extreme to get the franchise out of the rut.
The Astros appeared in 7 straight ALCS and have two titles. The Cardinals just keep getting run over.
September 13, 2024 at 9:00 am in reply to: StL 2024 Game #147 thread – Friday, Sept. 13 at Blue Jays #267173Truthfully we are merely spectators in the WC race.
Will have missed the playoffs in ’16, ’17, ’18, ’23, and ’24 so, 5 of the past 9 years, and have made no noise in the post season since 2014 other than appearing in the ’19 NLCS and getting swept away there. A solid decade with only 1 decent result.
I seem to recall two separate 8 game losing streaks towards the end of 2006? We were really cruising and then just collapsed.
Hung on, recovered, and won a title. -
AuthorPosts
