Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
“…reading y’all’s thoughts and comments on this forum and various thumbsuckers from elsewhere, I’m just not finding much to make me feel optimistic.”
Speaking for myself, Parisian Redbird, there’s the usual Generic March Anxiety. But objectively, the Cards have about as good a chance as anyone to win the division. I’ll be specific.
If you take the average W-L predictions of the well known 538 website, the Fangraphs website (uses Steamer and ZiPS computer modeling), the PECOTA forecasts, Clay Davenport’s computer, and the Vegas over/under lines, and average all of that stuff together, here is how the N.L. Central would shake out in 2019:
Cards 87-75
Cubs 85-77
Brewers 85-77
Reds 80-82
Bucs 79-83Other than much of the bullpen, I really like the StL personnel. If the Birds were to release Cecil, Gregerson, and Fowler tomorrow, I’d bet on them straight-up to win the division. In 2018 the lineup went from a below average 4.4 runs per game with Mabry and Fowler, to an elite 5.2 runs per game once they were both out of the picture. So I have pretty much zero concerns about run scoring. And the rotation should be well above average.
It’s a very good roster, Frenchy. It just needs to be leveraged properly. If Fowler is one of baseball’s worst players again, he gets released at the end of April. If Shildt starts Yadi behind the plate more than 14 or 15 games in a row, he gets called into the GM’s office for a dressing down. If last year’s Fowler/Molina insanity isn’t repeated, the club has a good chance to win 90+ games, in spite of the below average bullpen.
Very good pitching today, and it was nice to see Bader on base three times — and three steals!
Fowler meanwhile went 0-3 with a groundout, strikeout, and popout. Although I understand that Mike Shildt enthusiastically described the popout as a “perpendicular line drive.”
“Of course Hudson should be in the rotation. It’s about options and contacts unfortunately.”
“With all due respect to the esteemed H.M. Petrakis, I have to side with MsPaid here.”
Help me out here, gents. I guess I’m dumb or something.
Someone, anyone, please, I’m begging you, explain to me why John Gant’s lack of options means he should have a leg up specifically as a Redbird STARTING pitcher, rather than reliever?Gant needs to be on the MLB roster, absolutely. And he’s earned it, based on his solid 2018 — and of course there’s the lack of remaining options. So have him pitch out of the bullpen. Gant is your multi-inning man. Problem solved. Hudson in the rotation, Gant in the pen. Best starter starts, and the journeyman relieves.
In the last week I’ve read — about 117 different times, all over the internet — that John Gant will likely be the 5th starter due to his lack of options. Please, will someone explain to this baseball ignoramus why John Gant needs to start rather than relieve?
Thank you in advance for giving sight to this poor blind man.
“Hudson walked three and needed 69 pitches in three innings.”
First walks of the spring. Allowed his first extra base hit, too. For the entirety of Spring Training, Hudson has now permitted an extraordinary slashline of .200/.273/.225.
To paraphrase the great Harry Mark Petrakis, anyone who thinks that John Gant should be in the rotation instead of Dakota Hudson is either drunk or they aren’t paying attention.
Unfortunately I overlooked the guy who was already the most overlooked in the organization, Dominican Summer League keystone/hot corner combo infielder Ramon Mendoza.
Mendoza’s NAPS number of .455 compares quite favorably with many of the better Redbird prospects, and his road OPS was 158 points above his home tally so he might actually be even more promising than he seems at a glance. (If you get a chance, check his batted ball heat map at MLB Farm. Highly unusual, in a good way I think.)
As a righty bat he absolutely mauled righty arms (.370/.470/.590), which I also like a lot. First half, batted .347 but with an isolated slugging of just .102. Second half, hit just .292 but slugged a robust .520.
Listed at a modest 5’11” and 174, Mendoza was a conservative 75th in the community rankings. But I have him solidly inside the team top 40, perhaps as high as the 28-32 range. Wish I knew more about the glovework, but you can’t have everything.
“Do you know if the model (the Davenport Translations) has any built in biases, such as weighing performances against higher levels of competition as more important, or if it gives more importance to guys who both perform well and are young for their league, like Carlson and Gorman?”
Good questions, dac. Through his website I have reached out to Davenport a few times over the past decade, but to no avail. So I’m afraid I’m not versed enough in his methodology to comment.
However, speaking strictly of Lane Thomas, it certainly seems that more weight was given to his 2018 season than to his distant past. Rightly so, of course. Players change.Since that answer was so useless, I should at least offer you a scrap of new information, dac. So here are some more NAPS numbers for Cardinal farmhands. Again, keep in mind that these are Peaks, not career averages. And they are based on a normalized on-base percentage of .320. Therefore, a NAPS of .500 is good enough to start for almost any team, at any position, in any season. And a .400 NAPS makes you roughly a league-average batter (in your very best seasons).
Ramon Urias .481
Ivan Herrera .462
Carlos Soto .458
Justin Williams .455
Andrew Knizner .452
Randy Arozarena .447
Evan Mendoza .415 (Yairo Munoz was also .415 before his 2018 breakthrough in the majors)
Victor Garcia .409
Tommy Edman .387
Edmundo Sosa .354For further context, Paul DeJong was .473 and Harry Bader was .477.
“Rob, I find your work very interesting and thought provoking. Looking back over your list, I was surprised not to see Lane Thomas. I was wondering what factor or factors led to him missing the cut? Age, obp, or something else I’m not thinking about?”
No track record of success before 2018. That’s pretty much it.
In 2014 he slugged .382 in the Gulf Coast League.
In 2015 he slugged .391 in the Northwest League.
In 2016 he slugged .348 in the Midwest League.
In 2017 he slugged .383 in the Florida State League.That’s not enough pop for any outfielder, in any league, unless he runs like Vince Coleman. The batting averages weren’t much better either, ranging from .216 to .260. Basically Lane Thomas didn’t have diddly to recommend him until last year — when he was fully healthy for the first time, it must be said. And by the way, his NAPS number is .441, which isn’t bad at all. Functionally identical to fellow outfielder and consensus uber-prospect Taylor Trammell (.444).
He’s clearly a guy worth watching now. And we couldn’t even say that twelve months ago. (And please, call me Bob. And gracias for the kind words, dac.)
“Andy Young homered in DBacks game yesterday. He’s the one we should have kept.”
I like Andy Young okay, Ny, but not as much as some other utility types who were headed to Memphis this year. Talking Tommy Edman, Ramon Urias, Edmundo Sosa. Maybe Drew Robinson. (Probably not Robinson, though. Don’t care about him much. What’s the point of swinging left-handed when you can’t hit MLB pitching?)
You can even throw in Maximus Schrock, and eventually Evan Mendoza by summer I suppose, and Triple-A is going to be pretty crowded pretty quickly, from second base leftward.
Comparing Young to Urias for example, here’s an edited version of a comment from a Fangraphs thread:
“Andy Young is interesting, but…probably there’s more defensive versatility for Urias. And Urias also had fewer strikeouts than Andy Young, and double the walk rate for the same Springfield team at the same exact age. Urias posted a 170 wRC+ in the Texas League this year, after a hefty 164 in the Mexican League last season.”
The Clay Davenport projections like them both, but not equally. Per Davenport’s computer, Andy is a 2-2.5 win guy at his peak, and Ramon a bit above 3, mostly due to defense. And personally I would give Urias a small additional bump because he was stuck in Mexico for several years, when he might have been advancing & improving through the conventional minors; don’t know whether or not he would have received better coaching than he got south of the border, but I do know he would have been facing a higher level of competition at an earlier age. And that helps anyone improve — if they have it in them to improve in the first place.
“I saw on the Cardinals website that they are projecting Shreve, Mayers and Cecil to make the opening day roster.”
Yeah, I saw that too, Willie. The Redbird bullpen looks scary bad right now, especially with the bloom entirely off the Genesis Cabrera winterball rose. All thorns and no nice aroma right now. The Cards simply cannot go north with the current bullpen. It’s a recipe for heartache.
I say the club should trade for Detroit’s Joe Jimenez, even if it means taking 75-80% of Jordan Zimmermann’s contract ($50M total for the next two years). Heck, the way Z has thrown this spring, he’d be in the mix for the Cardinal rotation right now. Joe Jimenez looks like the next Edwin Diaz, to me.
The relief corps needed an offseason overhaul, and instead it was almost entirely overlooked. This needs to be remedied and real soon.
My name is Bob Reed and I endorse this publication.
Just got my copy in the mail and both the statistical insights and photography are first rate. Nothing wrong with the writing, either. Thanks for getting that to me so promptly, Brian.
Dexter Fowler with a double today, unfortunately ruining the lovely slot machine symmetry of .125/.125/.125.
Wacha was pretty good I suppose. Two homers is bad, but both with two outs and the bases empty. Nice to see Wieters gun a baserunner. Miller better, since his poor command first game.
“I want to say that back in 2014 Rowan Wick with his gaudy 1.290 OPS at State College was looking like the best hitting prospect in the game, a future star for sure. Then, in 2015 he went to Palm Beach and couldn’t hit a lick.”
Yeah muddy, Rowan Wick could be the poster boy for not falling in love with rookieball/short season guys who are old for their leagues. Wick was 19 in the GCL, 20 in the Appy, and 21 when, as you mentioned, he thrashed the NY-Penn League — but that’s a year too old for each level of competition. The projection models adored him after his thundering 2014 season, I’m sure. But age was a red flag all along. (Note that of the eight Redbirds on the list, two were age-appropriate in 2018, four were young, and two were very young for their leagues. There are some flags, but age isn’t one of them this time.)
Also, thanks for the kind words, muddy. And you as well, Nigel, for your generous remarks in another thread. It may seem like a fair bit of work is being done. But it’s not really work. It’s a time outlay, yes. But time spent scratching an itch that demands scratching anyway.
“Is it fair to assume there is substantially more projection inherent in career expectations for a current DSL player vs. one who has shown success at Triple-A, for example? Seems like there should be a greater swing of possible career outcomes the less experienced the player who is being projected is.
For example, we don’t know yet if Malcom Nunez can handle advanced breaking pitches, yet he is being labeled the third-best power threat in all of minor league baseball.”Absolutely, Brian. The Peak projections represent what I would describe as the “quite plausible upside” for each hitter. But further away almost surely means more variance — because guys get hurt of course, because defensive projections are so imprecise so far from the majors, and mostly because plate discipline can collapse at a moment’s notice. Which is why Malcom Nunez is borderline top 100 for me rather than a top 10 or 15 overall prospect.
Heck, for that matter it’s also why Nolan Gorman is a top 50-55 guy for me, rather than top 6 or 8. In each case we don’t know whether he’ll hit .210, .240, or .270. Or better. Or worse! The overarching revelation is that the Birds have a wealth of very high-upside hitting talent throughout the minors right now, and especially at the lower levels. Easily more than any other organization.
On the other hand Wander Franco is already a top 5 prospect for multiple highly respected prospect pundits despite his not playing a game above rookieball. That’s an aggressive placement. And I don’t necessarily disagree with them. Franco’s nearly impossible combination of high power/extremely low strikeouts is probably the best since Albert Pujols tormented Midwest League pitchers nearly 20 years back. And Wander might stick on the left side of the infield.
And speaking of low strikeouts, just for kicks I stitched together Malcom Nunez’ age-15 season back in 2016 against other young Cuban stars, and in international competition. In 188 total trips to the plate he drew 55 walks while fanning just 10 times. You read that right, 55 and 10. This was against most of the best of his peers. Kids against kids, yes. But pretty amazing anyway. (Funny thing is, he didn’t hit for much power at all, with an isolated slugging under .150. But he’s got power now, boy howdy.)
How much power does 17-year-old Malcom Nunez have? In the massive Dominican Summer league 3,946 batters have accrude at least 100 plate appearances since 2006. The top 3 slugging percentages are:
1) Malcom Nunez .774
2) Heriberto Hernandez .635
3) Miguel Rosario .605
No one else exceeded .600.But as far as power goes, I think I need to clarify something I’ve made more confusing that necessary. The “slugging percentages” on the list aren’t projected slugging percentages per se. Rather, they represent an overall hitting projection, but expressed as a slugging percentage once everyone’s OBP is normalized to .320.
And then there’s the minor birthdate adjustments when necessary. In other words the numbers represent a Normalized Adjusted Peak Slugging (NAPS).
Thus, a 15-homer hitter might well have a higher NAPS number than a 30-homer slugger because the 15-HR guy’s OBP is so high. The batter with the higher NAPS number may or may not hit for more power. He may or may not hit for higher average, or draw more walks, or strikeout less. But however the hitters’ specific batting talents are parsed, the one with the higher NAPS number is always the better batter.
1) Nolan Gorman .644
2) Vlad Guerrero Jr. .631
3) Malcom Nunez .603
4) Eloy Jimenez .600
5) Peter Alonso .597
6) Nick Senzel .572
7) Jhon Torres .571
8) Tyler O’Neill .565
9) Fernando Tatis Jr. .559
10) Austin Riley .557
11) Bobby Bradley .557
12) Kyle Tucker .544
13) Elehuris Montero .541
14) Wander Franco .539
15) Nate Lowe .539
16) Alex Kirillof .537
17) Bo Bichette .536
18) Leandro Cedeno .531
19) Christin Stewart .529
20) Mark Vientos .528
21) Yordan Alvarez .525
22) Isaac Paredes .523
23) Victor Robles .522
24) Nolan Jones .521
25) Brandon Lowe .519
26) Antonio Cabello .516
27) Jo Adell .515
28) Darick Hall .515
29) Royce Lewis .514
30) Carter Kieboom .511
31) Joerlin De Los Santos .511
32) Bryce Bush .508
33) Dylan Carlson .503
34) Danny Jansen .501
35) Carlos Rincon .501Too lazy to go back and incorporate the missing six guys. Just wanted to make the Redbird batters stand out better.
Decided to break it up into two posts, so the thing didn’t time-out on me. Well, I wouldn’t be paranoid if the computers weren’t all out to get me. Continuing:
11) Bobby Bradley .557
12) Kyle Tucker .544
13) Elehuris Montero .541
14) Wander Franco .539
15) Nate Lowe .539
16) Alex Kirillof .537
17) Bo Bichette .536
18) Leandro Cedeno .531
19) Christin Stewart .529
20) Mark Vientos .528
21) Yordan Alvarez .525
22) Isaac Paredes .523
23) Victor Robles .522
24) Nolan Jones .521
25) Brandon Lowe .519
26) Antonio Cabello .516
27) Jo Adell .515
28) Darick Hall .515
29) Royce Lewis .514
30) Carter Kieboom .511
31) Joerlin De Los Santos .511
32) Bryce Bush .508
33) Dylan Carlson .503
34) Danny Jansen .501
35) Carlos Rincon .501By team: StL 8, Tampa and Toronto 3, Mets, Astros, White Sox, Indians, Twins, Tigers, Nationals 2, and one each for the Reds, Pads, Braves, Angels, Phils, Dodgers, and Yankees. Fun fact: the five teams most disliked by Cardinal fans combined for zero uber-elite hitters: Cubs, Brewers, Red Sox, Royals, and Giants.
Near misses (.480-.499): Brendan Rodgers, Keibert Ruiz, Joey Bart, Tristen Lutz, and Jesus Sanchez.
Nearly near misses (.475-.479): Yunior Severino, Yusniel Diaz, and Ronaldo Hernandez.
Others of note: Keston Hiura .466, Taylor Trammell .444, Luis Urias .470, Ke’Bryan Hayes .442.
EDIT: Now, even as I type this, I see that I failed to integrate half a dozen hitters onto the list. Apologies for my sloppiness. The original 35 should have been 41, and included:
Nick Egnatuk .542, Grant Lavigne .537, Jordan Groshans .534, Sherten Apostel .531 (I swear I am not making these names up), Kristian Robinson .516, and catcher Alejandro Kirk .509.Egnatuk is a Brewer, so there goes that shutout, darn it. The other five include two more Blue Jays, plus a Ranger, Rocky, and Diamondback.
So the Cards are still the clear number one, and Toronto an equally clear number two. I look forward to your responses, folks!
“Is it better to be a bigger strikeout guy, or continue to get grounders with that heavy 95mph sinker, and keep the pitch count down?”
Start every AB by going for the groundout — as you say, cranny, it gets quick outs, keeps the pitch count down. But once you get to 0-2 or 1-2, 80-90% of the time you go for the whiff with the high cheese. If it’s 2-2, sometimes go high heat, sometimes the sinker/slider for a groundball.
At least, I’d say that’s the way to do it if you have a 97 MPH fourseamer. If you get way ahead in the count, and then just pound the bottom of the strikezone like it’s the start of the at-bat, you’re letting the hitter off the hook.
I think Hudson can be a solid #3/4 starter for the Cards doing exactly what he’s been doing, that’s how good he already is. But with either improved command or a meaningful increase in high fourseamers, he can be a #1/2 kind of guy. I know some people have misgivings about his delivery, his ability to stay off the disabled* list, but he’s been healthy & durable for three years running, so I think he’s 100% starter until proven otherwise.
* I’m insensitive, so I’m going to keep saying this for a few years. I despise outrage culture and hate language fascism. I’m so mean, I know.
“I don’t why some people choose to ignore the possibility that 2018 was indeed an accident. But what gets me the most is being told this: ‘It was a signing nobody should be faulting, in my opinion.’ Well I beg to differ.”
That was my quote about the Mikolas signing, of course. And that’s why I try and add tiny softening caveats to my strongest baseball opinions, NJ. Things like “in my opinion” or “for me.” Feels less like intellectual internet bullying that way.
I mean, I don’t ever want anyone to dread exchanging ideas with me online for fear that I’ll ridicule their views. I would hate that. Instead, I want my ridicule to always be a horrible and emotionally crippling surprise.
“The Allen Craig trade was a great trade for the Cardinals but it was still a bad extension. We should make that distinction.”
I still need persuading, on that last point. Based on what the Cardinal brass knew at the time Allen received the extension, it was a good extension as I recall. (Did anyone publicly criticize it at the time? It felt a lot like the one that Carp got a few years back. Some risk, but potential reward.) And the final outcome for the Cards and Allen Craig, his being traded to Boston for John Lackey, was also a good outcome for St. Louis. (More like a great outcome, as it wound up. We got a lot from Lackey, then got a high draft pick as well, I think, when he left. Although I could be mistaken about the latter.)
Or I should probably put it this way: For me, the mere fact that the Red Sox were willing to take Allen and his contract — and give something of real value in return — is the strongest possible evidence that Allen’s was not an onerous contract at all. In this case perception = reality. If the BoSox perceived Craig’s contract as okay, then be definition it was okay.
“The attempt to give Heyward a huge contract was a bad attempt. He didn’t want our money. Again, sometimes it is better to be lucky than good.”
Lucky is better, I agree. But bear in mind that the Cards could always have come over the top in their bidding for Heyward — like the Red Sox did against the Redbirds, when the Cards wanted to pay David Price nearly $200M for 7 years, or like the Cards themselves did with Dexter Fowler (blechh). But the Cards showed enough discipline to back away from Heyward, just as they did with Price. And Pujols for that matter. I’m disinclined to criticize a team very much for a contract never signed. Maybe a bit, but not much.
“As for Ben Cherington he did win a World Series in 2013 unfortunately so his tenure in Boston wasn’t all bad for them.”
Nope, not all bad. He was terrible, though. The conspicuous success the Carmines enjoyed in the years immediately before his arrival, and immediately after his departure, tells us all we need to know. To me there’s a healthy chunk of luck involved in a playoff run. But there’s no randomness involved when finishing last 3 of 4 years after inheriting a bloated budget and all-star roster. Just a bad GM, and he brought in two bad managers, and made bad signings. Good thing for him the club didn’t release David Ortiz before he returned to the illegal PED’s. That age 34-40 Ted Williams/Stan Musial impersonation really came in handy.
Not that I’m bitter.
Thanks for the feedback, cranny and dac.
“Or are you suggesting that as the pitching coach, Mike Maddux should have made that suggestion (Dakota Hudson throwing fourseam fastballs up in the zone periodically) by now?”
Absolutely, dac. And more broadly, not just Maddux but the entire organization from the day Hudson was drafted. It makes perfect sense to avoid the top of the zone if you’re a soft-tossing sinkerballer like Seth Maness, or even a mid-velocity Matt Bowman. But with Hudson’s blistering heater, it’s a clear waste of talent to keep the ball exclusively down, down, and down some more. And if they won’t work on an occasional fourseamer up above the hands now, in Spring Training, then when?
Hudson could eventually be that rare pitcher who combines very high groundball totals with good strikeout rates. As you said, cranny, it would be devastating. (It would be prime Arrieta — the pitcher Hudson was coincidentally likened to by Rob Ozga before Dakota was drafted.) But…well dac summed it all up very effectively in the comments re Hudson, Hicks, and Jack Flaherty.
Avoiding the top 1/4 of the zone (and above) means pitching scared. And to paraphrase a poker axiom, scared pitchers don’t win.
I can understand why you guys would be leery of large Cardinal contracts, given recent history. I’m always a bit skeptical of lengthy or pricey pitcher contracts. But a detailed side-by-side comparison of two MLB starters should show why in this particular instance I’m real happy with the Mikolas deal for the Birds.
Pitcher A threw 200 innings in 2018 with an ERA of 3.15, which was a ballpark-adjusted ERA+ of 137.
Pitcher B threw 200 innings in 2018 with an ERA of 2.83, which coincidentally was also an ERA+ of 137.Pitcher A turned 29 last summer, and Pitcher B turned 30. Pitcher A has a solid average fastball and an elite slider. And so does Pitcher B. Pitcher A has a career ERA+ of 109, and Pitcher B has a 108.
Pitcher A threw 189 innings in 2017, and Pitcher B threw 188. Both pitchers are sturdy and rather tall, but not too tall, at 6’3″ for A and 6’5″ for B.
So to this point we have two starting pitchers with astonishingly similar, in fact virtually identical track records and personal profiles for all intents and purposes. But let’s see how they project, going forward.
If we average together the four publicly available 2019 projections for the two pitchers — ZiPS, Steamer, Clay Davenport, and the Marcels forecast at Baseball-Reference — we get 181 innings with a 3.64 ERA for Pitcher A, and 175 innings and a 3.66 ERA for Pitcher B. Again, very nearly identical.
Pitcher A just signed a 6-year and $140M in free agency. (As you’ve probably guessed, Patrick Corbin.)
Pitcher B, well you already know about Pitcher B because he’s Miles Mikolas.Am I arguing that Mikolas would have gotten $140M or six years on the open market? Naaah. But he would have gotten much more than what he got from the Cards, I have zero doubt of that. All in all, it’s a good contract for the Lizard King, and a superb one for the Cards. In my opinion.
Good baseball players are expensive, and every contract is a gamble, but according to the available information the Birds got an excellent pitcher for the price of a merely very good one. In fact, Miles Mikolas at $17M per year? At that rate I kinda wish they’d signed him for another season. Or maybe even two. The price is that nice.
“I was listening to the Front Office show on MLB radio today and Jim Bowden trashed the Cardinals pretty good for the Mikolas extension.”
Did he think Mikolas might sign with someone for fewer years? Because I disagree with that. Or did he just want the Cards to wait until the All-Star break? I’m quite curious as to what — specifically — he thought the Redbird front office should have done differently.
“He also cited the Cards as being pretty bad at long term extensions as he mentioned Fowler, Wong, Craig, and the offer to Heyward. The only long term deal he liked was Holliday.”
Well, we could go right down the line. First off, Fowler was dumb at the time, and the Cards are reaping what the stupidly sowed. But that of course was not an extension, it was a misguided free agent inking. The Wong extension has been fine. Neither good nor bad so far, all things considered. Allen Craig got a weird injury, and the Cards dumped that salary anyway! If there’s an organization to criticize for mis-valuing Allen Craig it’s the Red Sox and their incompetent then-GM, Ben Cherington. (Three last place finishes in four years, folks.)
Heyward? As with Allen Craig, the Cards are not the team to criticize. That would be the Cubs, when it comes to Heyward.
The Cards also signed a few other guys to extensions over the past several years. Matt carpenter has worked out spectacularly well. And has Mr. Bowden checked Paul DeJong’s deal? Over the next five seasons Paul will make less than $23M total. (Per Fangraphs he was worth $26M in 2018, and $24M in 2017.) Oh, and then there are also two cheap club options at the end. So the Cards have control through his age 31 season. It’s almost certainly one of the best 4 or 5 deals in baseball, if he continues as is.
“I generally like Jim Bowden although I know some on here do not. I usually find him insightful and entertaining but I think he is off base on Mikolas. Sure there is some risk involved but if Mikolas had another good season in 2019 he would have cost much more than $68M to bring back.”
I agree, gscott, in large part. I don’t think too terribly much of Bowden’s baseball acumen, but I don’t generally dislike him. (He should know the Cards are not interested in a massive reliever contract like Kimbrel will receive. Besides, Kimbrel was very shaky in October. Could be tipping, could be health, could just be getting older.)
The Mikolas signing was smart and timely. The rotation is fairly well set for 3-4 years into the future, with decent health. The following 6 guys are under team control through the 2022 season: Mikolas, Flaherty, Martinez, Reyes, Hudson, and Gant. And that’s a solid foundation, with Lizard King as the veteran leader of the group. It was a signing nobody should be faulting, in my opinion.
“Gallegos didn’t help his case today.”
Yeah, I’m generally skeptical of castoffs from smart organizations like the Yankees. Better probably to poach from the stupid franchises that can’t identify talent as well. Like when the Cards got Kiko Calero from K.C. years ago, or Mujica from the Marlins, etc..
For me Gallegos wasn’t the most frustrating guy, though. That title goes to Dakota Hudson, clear cut. Two out, two strikes, nobody on base. And five minutes later 2 runs were in and Hudson was knocked out of the game, with 2 runners still on board after 4 straight singles. Yes, two hits never left the infield. But that’s not really the point.
Here’s a hint, Mr. Maddux. When Dakota Hudson has two strikes on a batter, for the love of common sense let him throw some 97 MPH high heat once in a while. When the opposing batter knows for a fact that every single pitch is going to be in the bottom half of the zone or below — regardless of the count, regardless of whether a grounder is needed or not — it makes his very difficult job sooo much easier.
I understand the groundball preoccupation. Quick outs. Double plays when necessary. But when you’ve got a hitter in the hole, and the bases are empty, what on earth is the catcher doing setting up the same target, the same darn bottom-of-the-zone, middle-of-the-plate target that he does on a 2-1 count with a man on first and one out?
Don’t listen to Kevin Costner. Strikeouts are good. And Hudson’s refusal to use the top of the zone (and above) to overpower hitters bit him twice today on 2-strike base hits. Yeesh, if only because of game theory, it’s a smart idea to at least present the possibility that a Dakota Hudson pitch might be thrown at the top of the zone once a month.
Before going outside to yell at a cloud, I’ll end my rant with a quote from Dakota Hudson’s Brooks Baseball page:
“His fourseam fastball (take this with a grain of salt because he’s only thrown 10 of them in 2018) generates an extremely high number of swings & misses compared to other pitchers’ fourseamers, is an extreme flyball pitch compared to other pitchers’ fourseamers, is blazing fast (98 MPH), has less armside movement than typical and has some natural sinking action.”
Sounds pretty good to me. How about using it, Mr. Maddux?
Here’s an overview of Paul DeJong’s injury track record, going back to his sophomore year at Illinois State:
2014 college…perfect health (played all 54 games)
2015 college…perfect health (51 of 54)
2015 pro…perfect health
2016…perfect health
2017…perfect health
2018…missed 7 weeks with fractured hand after being hit by a pitch. Besides that, perfect health.I’m not always an optimist about such things, but I wouldn’t worry one bit about DeJong’s backup. It would shock me if he has to miss significant playing time in 2019. As we can see, he’s been exceptionally durable for five years running, barring unavoidable traumatic injury.
For me the chief Cardinal concern is the same now as it was when the offseason started. The bullpen is possibly terrible, in there is no chance on earth that it will be an asset. In fact right now it looks potentially worse than last year, if such a thing is possible.
But! But there’s still three-weeks-plus before opening Day. Maybe the Birds will take my advice and leverage some of their fallow extra money, turning it into an excellent reliever (or two) like Joe Jimenez or Mychal Givens by accepting bad contracts from the Tigers and Orioles. Exchanging a pair of bad relievers for very good ones could add 3-5 wins to this year’s Redbird victory total. But it will take meaningful money, and probably a couple of mid-level prospects.
Roughly 40% of Cardinal innings will go to relievers this year, and the relief corps is frankly a mess. Not as atrocious as they looked today, but not good at all. Why the front office thought that ONE addition would fix the problem is beyond me. A band-aid for a bullet hole is bad enough, but a single band-aid for 4 or 5 bullet holes is pretty much inexcusable.
Bright side, that Tyler O’Neill kid is something special, huh?! Can’t wait to see the speedy slugger make those 150 starts in right field this year….
“…they must convince the Goldschmidts to stay,” writes Ben Fred.
This BenFred premise is worth pondering, I think.
So the Cardinals must convince 31-year-old superstar first baseman Paul Goldschmidt to stay? We can test that theory pretty easily, because some folks (myself included) thought they had to convince 31-year-old superstar first baseman Albert Pujols to stay, after the 2011 season.
But Pujols of course wanted too much money for too many years, and painful as it was, the Cards parted company with the future 1st ballot Hall Of Famer. In general we all of course know what’s happened after Albert was NOT signed by the Birds. But let’s check the particulars, both before and after Albert’s departure.
Cards with reputed lunkhead Matheny and no Pujols: 7 seasons, averaged 90 wins, 3rd best in MLB.
Cards with certain Hall Of Famers LaRussa & Pujols: 11 seasons, averaged 90 wins, also 3rd best in MLB.So I’d say we are forced to conclude that there is no such thing as a player who MUST be signed. Period.
If Goldy’s very gentle decline of the past few years continues in 2019, and he wants more than 5 years or more than $30M per year, then the Cards probably need to let him go. Because there would be better ways to invest the club’s dough over the long haul — just as there were when Pujols painfully left.
“There seem to be plenty of guys who could be future first basemen, if you believe all the prospect gurus.”
Yes, there are indeed big bats in the minors, some arriving in the next 2-3 years. There very likely aren’t any future 5-WAR first basemen…but then, Goldy probably isn’t a 5-WAR first baseman either in another year or two. Maybe not even in 2019. (But I sure hope so.)
“Having never made a typo ever, I can wonder how much Martinez has to sing to get a quarter of a million dollars.”
Not too much, as long as he’s better than Ditka, Roseanne, and Cuba Gooding, Jr..
Also, you know how the g and the t are adjacent on the keyboard? Well, never sign a letter “Best Retards.”
Worst. Typo. Ever.February 26, 2019 at 3:13 am in reply to: What is wrong with Dexter Fowler and what should be done? #82789“From 2014 – 2017, Dex had 15.0 oWAR total. For comparison,Christian Yelich had 16.6 oWAR.
Cardinal Nation is delusional when it comes to Dexter Fowler.
2014: 3.9 oWAR
2015: 3.7
2016: 4.0
2017: 3.4
Dex has the same career oWAR as Matt Carpenter (27) and has far more value defensively.”Belated welcome, Squishy. Sorry I didn’t notice your post until today.
I don’t know whether oWAR numbers alone make a very persuasive argument that Dexter Fowler is as good or better than Matt Carpenter, all things considered. To see how Fowler and Carpenter compare, let’s take a look at the three publicly available systems of player valuation.Bearing in mind that Fowler has 10 full years in the majors and Carpenter just under 7, here are the career WAR numbers — hitting, baserunning, defense all included of course — at Baseball Prospectus, Baseball-Reference, and Fangraphs.
BPro…Fowler 14.0 WAR and Carpenter 23.5 WAR
B-Ref…Fowler 17.9 and Carpenter 25.9
Fangraphs…Fowler 19.6 and Carpenter 28.6So we see that roughly speaking, Dexter Fowler has averaged between 1 1/2 and 2 WAR per season, and Matt Carpenter has averaged between 3.5 and 4 WAR per MLB campaign. Clearly they have not been remotely comparable.
In fact, according to Fangraphs over the past 7 seasons Matt Carpenter has been approximately as valuable as Bryce Harper and Manny Machado, while Dexter Fowler during the past decade has been about as valuable as Colby Rasmus and Yunel Escobar. (No offense, Colby, but you ain’t Bryce Harper.)
But that’s all in the past. So how do the two 33-year-olds project, going forward? The ZiPS forecast for 2019, prorated to 550 at-bats, has Carpenter worth a terrific 4.6 WAR, and Fowler a fairly dismal 1.6 WAR. In other words, according to ZiPS one player is a star and the other belongs on the bench. No real reason to look further than that, I don’t think.
One thing we can agree upon 100%, Squishy. When it comes to Dexter Fowler, there is certainly some delusional thought going around. As for Fowler’s contract, I suppose the readers can decide for themselves what a 33-year-old good bench player with a narcissism problem is worth on the open market.
“…I lost as much respect of them as a result of their ‘statement’ as I did in the irresponsible words they put in print in the first place.
Short and sweet, ‘We screwed up,’ should have been the path taken. They could have saved 997 words of nothingness.”Seconded. Very weak tea from BPro. When you know you’ve done wrong, just say it and be done. Don’t take an hour to do the minute waltz.
“Bob, could Luken Baker be added to this list? Dude looks like a Luke Voit clone. Must be the first name.”
Fair question, gscott. If we swap out Urias for Baker, the HR average would indeed go up. But the trouble is, I don’t consider Baker to be a real prospect, having seen him play for Peoria last year. (And when I say “play” I mean stand around and be huge.) So I admit I didn’t give him much of a thought. Perhaps I’m pessimistic but he’s not in my top 40 Redbird prospects, and I wanted the six to all be among the better StL minor leaguers. Many guys on the Cardinal farm could have raised the overall HR average if I’d traded out Ramon Urias.
“Aren’t Gorman and Baker the only serious power threats at this time? Maybe Thomas too now after last season. I guess several others could develop it as they mature and get stronger.”
The mountainous Baker projects by Clay Davenport’s system as a 20-25 HR guy in his prime, cranny. Not one of the best in the Redbird system. On the other hand, Jhon Torres received the same Game Power grade at Fangraphs as Nolan Gorman. And in his Cardinal prospect chat, Baseball America’s Kyke Glaser said of Leandro Cedeno: “…he has as much raw power as anyone in the system, Gorman included.” When you have two other players in your system whose power is considered comparable in any way to Nolan Gorman’s, you’ve got something to look forward to.
And both Dylan Carlson and Elehuris Montero are projected by Clay Davenport as 25-30 homer talents in their primes. We could quibble over terminology, but I consider 25+ homers to be a serious power threat. Also, you were right to mention Lane Thomas, as he projects to be a 25-homer bat at his best. (Very interesting guy, Lane Thomas. I look at him much like I looked at Tommy Pham 5 or 6 years ago. Clear talent, both at bat and afield, but can he stay healthy enough to self-actualize?)
“Bob, your interest in Cedeno is encouraging. #15 is aggressive for him… but he has yet to show his best. I’d like to see a list of your prospect ranking. I might learn a thing or two.”
Your wish, my command, Ny. (Approximate overall ranking in parentheses.)
1) Reyes…(35)
2) Montero…(40)
3) Hudson…(50)
4) Gorman…(55)
5) Knizner…(65)
6) Carlson…(90)
7) Urias…(100)
8) Nunez…(100)
9) Helsley…(130)
10) Herrera…(140)
11) Lane Thomas…(210)
12) Edmundo Sosa…(220)
13) Arozarena…(230)
14) Jhon Torres…(240)
15) Leandro Cedeno…(250)
16) Joerlin De Los Santos…(280)After that I have 28 other guys who matter, at this point. Those do not include either X-Large Luken Baker or Steven Gingery, due to injury. Bearing in mind that I only saw Baker one time, to me he didn’t move as well as Matt Adams either in the field or on the bases.
Now maybe Baker’s a real hitter, but right now he looks to me like a guy who’ll need to be a REAL hitter — because at the MLB level even the bench bats usually need to offer some kind of defensive value. And REAL hitters, like Jose Martinez for instance, are few & far between.
“I don’t like to rain on the parade, as I ranked Cedeno as a prospect this year, too. However, he is not invited to STEP Camp, which I do not consider a good sign. The reason that matters is that he is going to be Rule 5 eligible this coming winter. I don’t think he can move fast enough to make it before either being lost in the minor league Rule 5 draft or leaving via free agency.”
Yeah, I can’t disagree, Brian. Leandro Cedeno losing his age 18 season to injury may have thrown off his timetable too much to be kept long term. It’s a risk incurred by signing those international kids at 16. If they move a little slowly through the system, they can get caught in a numbers crunch.
But his bat forces me to rate him pretty highly within the organization. I really believe that in a different season, any teenager — who already has a track record of hitting success — batting .336 with a 1.001 OPS would have been much more highly publicized. (As opposed to not publicized one scintilla, ever, all year, by anyone, anywhere.) But the Birds had Gorman, and Nunez, and so many other interesting bats in 2018, esp. at the lower levels, that Cedeno went unnoticed.
As a first basemen only in all probability, there’s no real defensive or baserunning value to speak of; but the publicly available metrics at Baseball Prospectus imply that he’s not some hulking oaf either. Anyway he’ll really need to hit…but that’s exactly what he’s done so far in his career. And he’ll need to regularly overcome a rather shaky BB/K combo…but that’s exactly what he’s also done so far.
If he kicks Peoria’s butt at age 20 this year, I think the club finds a way to keep him. If on the other hand he’s merely a good-to-very-good hitter in Low-A, then the Cards likely lose Cedeno. Anyhoo, I look forward to watching him once or twice in 2019. Go Chiefs!
-
AuthorPosts
