mudville

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 25 posts - 1,001 through 1,025 (of 3,520 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Roster Matrix #241045
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    This is going to be a lot to handle for Midwest League batters….

    Springfield rotation: Hence
    Roby
    Bedell
    Panaigua
    Rajcic
    (Hjerpe, arriving in May)

    Bullpen: Nunez
    Svanson
    Cornwell
    Ralston
    ??

    in reply to: 25% of the bench #240946
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Dylan Carlson is still only 25 years old, just turned 25 last October. I’m not quite ready to give up on his hitting yet. He could still figure it out. My biggest complaint about Carlson is that he doesn’t seem to play with a lot of enthusiasm. i could say more, but what I’m saying is so subjective that I think it’s better to not to say more.

    in reply to: 25% of the bench #240908
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    My understanding is that Carlson injured his foot in May of 2023, and played through it the rest of the season. If Carlson is healthy and hitting well at spring training, then it’s easy to see Carlson in centerfield when a backup shortstop is needed, and Edman playing shortstop. They don’t need to carry Fermin as long as Edman is there. I’d like to find out if Baker’s power is real.

    in reply to: Palacios traded for Kittredge #240829
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    For what it’s worth… Burleson bats left and Baker bats right. Both have shown they can hit, but not yet proven as DH at the major league level. Baker’s power at Memphis in 2023 was intriguing.

    in reply to: Palacios traded for Kittredge #240815
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    (assuming Donovan is DH)

    Oli likes to use Donovan as a super utility guy that he can move around all over the field. I’m not sure what his rationale is for that, but that’s the way he managed last year. If Oli still wants to do that in 2024, that would open up a spot for Baker as DH. I’d like to find out if Baker’s power is for real, and if it is, Baker ought to be a regular right-handed DH…… unless I’m missing something.

    in reply to: The Cardinal Nation’s 2024 Top 50 Prospect Countdown #240802
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    When I watch those GIFs of Saggese going down and batting those breaking balls, I wonder why he isn’t more highly regarded. His bat control is unbelievable. And he’s only 21 years old, 22 years old on April 10. If he plays second base somewhere, maybe he misses a play once in awhile. So what? His bat makes up for it. The scout Brian quoted wondered why the Cardinals wanted him since there isn’t an apparent opening for him. Duh. They wanted him because he was the best available. Nothing wrong with that. If Saggese maintains his past minors hitting success at Memphis, I don’t see how they can keep him there very long.

    in reply to: Palacios traded for Kittredge #240800
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    With this acquisition there is probably only one bullpen spot available unless there’s an injury, two spots if they decide to take 13 pitchers north after spring training, which could very well happen because of the Palacios trade, and a third spot if they make Pallante’s spot competitive. So, the competition will be among John King, probably Andre Pallante, and Wilking Rodriguez, Ryan Fernandez, and Nick Robertson. It will be fascinating to watch how this plays out. King is the only lefty in the bunch. He had good success for the Cardinals in 2023 after the trade with the Rangers, but is not very highly regarded, it seems. Personally, I’d love to see Rodriguez make the cut although they do have flexibility with him. (For me, W-Rod is sort of a feel good story.) Ryan Fernandez has to be good enough to make the cut, or he goes back to Boston, and the Cardinals wasted $50K by picking him up in the Rule 5. I hope Pallante worked hard during the offseason. His spot is vulnerable, IMHO.

    I’m thinking that Pallante and King make the cut. And they keep Fernandez in the bullpen long enough to figure out if he deserves the spot. If Rodriguez pitches well at Memphis, he gets the first call up when needed. Robertson will get called up at some point in 2024, if he pitches well at Memphis.

    in reply to: Roster Matrix #240747
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    We still have two likely HOF players at the corner infield positions. Gorman OPS’d .805 with 27 HR in 2023, at the age of 23. Contreras posted a 3.4 WAR and an OPS of .826 in 2023. We’re not sure what we’ve got with Winn yet but most agree that he has the potential for a long and expensive career. If Walker’s defense improves, he will be a special player. Let’s keep in mind that Albert Pujols was an outfielder when he first came up. Everybody in the baseball world loves Nootbaar because of his talent and aggressive play. Same for Edman. Burleson has hit, and hit some more, wherever he has played. Donovan is a GG utility player. And
    Victor Scott is up and coming.

    Gray should be a decent TOR guy.
    Lynn will be fun regardless of how good he pitches, and he should be pretty good.
    Gibson should be fine, also, especially if our defense returns to form.
    Mikolas and Matz have a point to prove this year.

    Now if they can just get Kershaw to show up in a Cardinals uniform sometime around the middle of next summer…….

    It’s so much easier, and more fun, to be optimistic than pessimistic!

    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    He gave us some exciting plays in centerfield while he was here. I hope he can return to form and keep making those plays. Wish him the best.

    in reply to: Roster Matrix #240723
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I think Baker is a right-handed DH with power who can also give Goldschmidt a day off once in awhile. The seem to like Burleson. I can’t see him not making the cut. I’m thinking that Winn might have to go back to Memphis for some more AB’s. That puts Edman at SS and Carlson in CF, I think. Or, Nootbaar could play CF with Burleson in LF again. Then, Carlson is the left-handed DH. They could send Palacios down and keep Fermin instead, but there’s not much excitement with that move. Donovan can play outfield or 2B. It’s all fluid for now. I just hope that by June Oli is set on a lineup, but that might not be his style of managing. It’s hard to see how Arenado ever gets a day off. If Winn doesn’t make the cut, I do see where we need a defense minded infielder, probably Fermin. I think my point is that roster is pretty much set. It’s going to take an overwhelming breakout in spring training for a player to crack this roster.

    in reply to: Roster Matrix #240720
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    If Nick Robertson and Ryan Fernandez both make the cut out of spring training, then either Thompson or Liberatore get sent back to Memphis. I’m going to guess that Thompson goes to Memphis so he’s ready when they need another starter and Liberatore stays in the bullpen.

    Rom, King, Naile, and Zuniga are sent to Memphis where there’s no roster space, or they get cut or traded.

    Some of the pitchers at Memphis are going to have to be released.

    Starters – Mikolas, Gray, Lynn, Gibson, Matz.
    RH relief – Helsley, Gallegos, Pallante, Robertson(?),
    Fernandez(?)
    LH relief – Romero, Liberatore (and maybe King, but then,
    one of Robertson or Fernandez has to go.

    For the position players, the only opening looks like it’s going to be right-handed DH. Baker would seem to be the prime candidate for that with Carlson or Burleson being
    left-handed DH. After a few weeks Oli will probably go with 13 pitchers and somebody will have to be sent down, likely Baker or, possibly, Winn.

    C – Contreras, Herrera
    1B – Goldschmidt
    2B – Gorman, Edman
    SS – Winn
    3B – Arenado
    LF – Burleson
    CF – Nootbaar, Carlson
    RF – Walker, Palacios
    UT – Donovan
    DH – Baker

    It’s going to be really tough for a surprise this spring. Scott, Prieto, or Saggase?
    Graceffo, Granillo, Rom, or Robberse?
    All you can say is ‘anything’s possible’, until it isn’t.

    in reply to: Clayton Kershaw #240477
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Only pitched 131 innings due to injury. But, the rest of his pitching stats were CYA worthy.

    in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2021-2023 #239961
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Trevor Baur is radioactive. But does he deserve it? Take a listen to Baur’s video dated Oct. 2nd, 2023. He turns 33 years old on January 17, 2024.

    https://www.foxnews.com/sports/trevor-bauer-settles-legal-dispute-accuser-reveals-damning-messages

    in reply to: Should the Cards extend Goldschmidt? #239799
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I was exaggerating, sarcastically, to make the point that four years is not a long time and 39 years old is not old. Wainwright pitched 206 innings and posted an ERA of 3.05 at the age of 39. He even got some CYA votes and some MVP votes that year. Sure, Goldscmidt’s production is going to drop off, but when and how much is to be determined.

    in reply to: 2024 Bullpen #239798
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    The same holds true for Ryan Fernandez, except that Fernandez has to come north with the team or the Cardinals maybe wasted $50K by drafting him in the Rule 5 draft. I’d say that if Robertson and Fernandez are matching up pretty well at spring training, and if there’s only one RH bullpen spot remaining at the end of spring training, Fernandez gets the spot.

    One other thing…. Wilking Rodriguez is all healed up from his surgery. The Cardinals drafted him in the 2022 Rule 5 draft because he has a 100 MPH fastball and a nasty curveball. He could win a spot in the bullpen, too.

    It looks like what the bullpen really needs is another late inning reliever, preferably a lefty. They’ve got plenty of options for middle inning relief. The 5’9″, Yuki Matsui would seem to fit the bill. Just don’t give him more than 2 or 3 years.

    in reply to: Should the Cards extend Goldschmidt? #239793
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Goldschmidt was National League MVP in 2022. In 2023 his WAR was 3.4 and he hit 25 HR. I don’t think anyone should assume that in 4 years, at the ripe old age of 39, he will be no more than a beaten and tattered image of himself. The truth is that the guy hardly ever sees the IL, and he can still play. Add to that the intangibles that he brings to his team, and to the overall game, and it makes all kinds of sense to extend him.

    in reply to: The Cardinal Nation’s 2024 Top 50 Prospect Countdown #239717
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    His ranking by TCN is in alignment with the TCN community and the MLB Top 30. Pages defense is said to be the best in the Cardinals’ system. Bottom line….. I miss Yadi.

    in reply to: Should the Cards extend Goldschmidt? #239708
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Goldschmidt was league MVP one year ago. Having veterans on a roster has always been considered an important factor in building a roster. Goldschmidt hardly ever sits out with an injury. This move stabilizes the entire big league roster and brings clarity to what happens in the upper levels of the minors, IMO.

    in reply to: The Cardinal Nation’s 2024 Top 50 Prospect Countdown #239704
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    ‘Best defensive catcher in the system’. Added to 40 man roster, and likely to be called up if injury to Contreras or Herrera. Hits LH pitching well, hitting against RH pitching is improving. 16 HR in 2023. .805 OPS for 2023. Possibly the only position player in the system with a serious chance of being called up. Only 27 players ranked higher than Pages.

    in reply to: Should the Cards extend Goldschmidt? #239638
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    3 yrs/50mil

    I have to think that WDWII is behind this idea.

    This is not what I thought would happen. I thought Goldschmidt would leave after his contract ran out in order to loosen the budget, and I thought Arenado would get traded in the 2024-2025 offseason, also to loosen the budget. I thought Walker would move to 1B, and Gorman would move to 3B, and Saggese would take over 2B. With a Goldschmidt extension we would have 3 additional years to win the World Series with Goldschmidt at 1B. It also means that Walker is an outfielder for the foreseeable future and Saggesse is trade bait. With Goldschmidt around to stretch out and catch those hurried throws from Arenado, Arenado could very well win more Gold Gloves. This really stabilizes the outlook for the Cardinals for the next five years. I like this a lot.

    in reply to: Ohtani Dodgers 10 Years/$700M #239633
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    For what it’s worth, in the past 23 years the Cardinals have been in the World Series 4 times and have won it twice, and the Dodgers have been in the World Series 3 times and have won it once.

    in reply to: 2024 Rotation #239575
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Maybe a couple of grizzly veterans like Lynn and Gibson are just what Oli needs to set the record straight so that he can continue to develop as a big league manager.

    in reply to: Community 2024 Top 50 Prospect Voting #239517
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Fernandez has apparently made it into Brian’s and Blake’s top 30, but may not make it into the community’s top 40.

    in reply to: Tyler O’Neill Traded to Red Sox #239509
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Dave Parker was once asked why he wore a Star of David earring to which he replied: ‘Because my name’s David and I’m a star’. Parker had attitude. He was part of the legendary Pittsburgh Pirates ‘lumber company’ back in the 70’s.

    in reply to: Tyler O’Neill Traded to Red Sox #239446
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    That game where Templeton grabbed his crotch and screamed at a fan occurred on a Sunday which also happened to be Ladies Day at the ballpark. In those days such a gesture was considered highly offensive to ladies everywhere. Jack Buck was so aghast that he had a difficult time finding words to describe what happened. Following the incident Templeton was supposedly admitted to some kind of mental rehab facility which I thought was just a way to distract and keep Templeton from getting expelled from MLB.

Viewing 25 posts - 1,001 through 1,025 (of 3,520 total)

First-hand news and commentary on the St. Louis Cardinals™ and minor league system for over 25 years