forsch31

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 25 posts - 2,501 through 2,525 (of 2,639 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Cardinals OF roundup, who stays and who goes? (Grichuk) #35155
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    bccran

    Participant

    Carpenter
    Pham
    DeJong
    Martinez
    Fowler
    Gyorko
    Molina
    Wong

    Looks to me, as it stands, either Fowler or Gyorko is our 5th place hitter.

    If this is a response to my post about the fifth place hitter, neither Fowler or Gyorko was the 5th place hitter responsible for the poor wRC+. However, I think that IF (highly doubtful) Fowler or Gyorko were our 5th place hitter, that would be a big improvement on wRC+ by the end of 2018. I also don’t see us having the same lineup next year.

    in reply to: Cardinals OF roundup, who stays and who goes? (Grichuk) #35147
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    I think Fowler will be fine in LF. We have bigger problems to address before we need to address Fowler. However, Fowler HAS to be playing LF. We have much better CFs on the roster.

    Pads, your wRC+ by batting order position is quite telling that the Cardinals have problems. It is sad that our “best” hitters are in the first and second positions while the league average is in third and fourth.

    Also, our fifth place is pretty sad. Who is our fifth place hitter? ….. Oh yes. Enough said.

    in reply to: Cardinals OF roundup, who stays and who goes? (Grichuk) #35111
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    BTW, Fowler had injuries in 2016. He was on the DL with a hamstring issue in June 2016. Also, I remember some talk that he has had the heel issue for several years

    in reply to: Cardinals OF roundup, who stays and who goes? (Grichuk) #35110
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    But yet during this year of nagging injuries he hit better than he ever had for half the year. Since it wasn’t at leadoff, we should ignore the year.

    Explain that to me because it doesn’t make sense.

    in reply to: Cardinals OF roundup, who stays and who goes? (Grichuk) #35093
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    bccran

    Participant

    I just have to go by his last healthy year – 2016. When he had a set place in the lineup every day, all season. What were his
    numbers as a leadoff batter?

    I basically already told you: .205/308/.390/.698 in 227 plate appearances.

    If you want to point out his prior years, I will note that he outperformed ALL of his prior seasons when he batted anywhere but leadoff in 2017. Also, he batted leadoff from the start of the 2017 season until June 7.

    in reply to: Cardinals OF roundup, who stays and who goes? (Grichuk) #35088
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    I figured you would ignore it.

    in reply to: Cardinals OF roundup, who stays and who goes? (Grichuk) #35086
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    bccran

    Participant

    Maybe he was not the sparkplug he was supposed to be because of those nagging injuries. Plus being shifted around in the lineup which can change your role. Batting down in the lineup is sure different than leading off, which he was used to.

    Then how do you explain that his line was .223/.302/.408/.709 after 114 plate appearances to start the season while leading off? Or that he was .222/.317/.423/.740 after 218 plate appearances of which all but 4 were as lead off hitter? Or that he was .299/.399/.541/.940 in 273 plate appearances (only 10 as leadoff) after being removed from the leadoff position?

    I think Fowler can be valuable to us but he must play LF. I also think we should trade him after 2018. I would rather have O’Neill playing there in 2019 assuming he advances this year. If we can get an improvement somewhere by including Fowler in a trade, do it. If we need to free up salary to get an improvement like Freeman or Stanton, trade him.

    in reply to: Cardinals By Position – 1B #35078
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    I hope they give Martinez extensive instruction on 1B. He seemed stiff and uncomfortable there. In Wacha’s last start, he should have fielded 2 balls in the inning the Cubs scored their runs.

    in reply to: Matheny as manager – fired 7/14 #34998
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    BC, you state now that BDW and Mo have confidence in MM but have also recently stated that if the Cardinals miss the playoffs again, he will likely be gone. Obviously, their confidence is not too solid if he could be a casualty after the 2018 season.

    in reply to: Josh Donaldson thread #34981
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    BC, in the final 62 games, there were 28 games that Molina batted 5th and one of your decent #5 hitters hit lower in the order. There were only 3 games in the final 62 games that Molina batted lower than 5th.

    So there is some question as to whether MM will hit one of those 6 players in the #5 spot and Molina lower in the order.

    in reply to: 2017 MLB Game #162: Cards vs. Brewers Sun Oct 1 #34854
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    Nate (mspaid), do you have anything constructive to add to the discussion or are you just going to troll a lot of the topics all winter, AGAIN.

    in reply to: Cardinals OF roundup, who stays and who goes? (Grichuk) #34832
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    I think Pham CAN repeat 2017. He did it in the minors. Well, maybe not the same as 2017 but I would expect around .850 OPS. Carpenter should rebound SOME with his shoulder being healthy. Fowler, I have mixed feelings on. I could see him having a rough 2018.

    However, all that doesn’t change the fact that the team needs to make some major changes.

    in reply to: Cardinals OF roundup, who stays and who goes? (Grichuk) #34817
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    Pham – keep him for 2018 as CF. Trade him after 2018.
    Fowler – move to LF or trade, if we can get a difference making bat. Definitely trade after 2018.
    Piscotty – trade for a big bat. OK to keep if we upgrade elsewhere.
    Grichuk – trade. Strikes out too much to be a difference maker.
    Martinez – look to move him to an AL club or have him start less. He is a detriment as a fielder.
    Bader – make him the 4th or 5th OF. Include him in trade for upgrade to offense, if necessary.
    Sierra – start him in AAA. Look for him to be in St. Louis in 2019.
    Martini – don’t see him having a spot in St. Louis (maybe 5th OF if we need to trade enough others)
    JA Garcia – start him in AAA. Look for him to be in St. Louis in 2019.
    O’Neill – start him in AAA. Look for him to be in St. Louis in 2019. Protect him on 40-man.
    A Garcia – don’t see him having a spot in St. Louis
    Mercado – start him in AA. Needs to show end of year was due to injury before moving up. Protect him on 40-man.
    Arozarena – start him AA. Needs more seasoning. St. Louis in 2020.

    There are no untouchables for the right price.

    Summarize:
    Gone: Grichuk
    Trade 1 of Piscotty, Fowler, Martinez for an offensive upgrade.
    The youngsters to try to keep are O’Neill, JA Garcia and Aronzarena.

    in reply to: 2017 MLB Game #158: Cards vs. Cubs Wed Sep 27 #34483
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    Wacha was still doing his job until the home run. The Cubs were hitting the ball on the ground. Martinez didn’t field either ball hit his direction until then. A better fielding 1Bman should have had them.

    in reply to: 2017 MLB Game #158: Cards vs. Cubs Wed Sep 27 #34460
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    I have been critical of Matheny this year and I still think we need a better manager. However, I don’t see where the 7th inning was his fault unless you want to blame him for Martinez playing 1B. Wacha had thrown 60 pitches in 6 innings, allowed 2 hits and was cruising. Rizzo hit a ball that any normal 1Bman should have fielded except Martinez was playing about 6 foot from the foul line. The next batter, Zobrist, hit one that Martinez also could have fielded but he didn’t come off the base too much after holding Rizzo on. Russell followed and hit a decent pitch for a home run just inside the foul line. The Cubs’ announcers said that the bullpen was up stretching after the Zobrist hit.

    Everything happened fast. Like Pads said, Kelly should have slowed the game down in that inning. Wacha also needed to throw in a 3rd pitch. Only scoring 1 run would have made it hard to win no matter what.

    I know it is argued that he should have had someone up at the beginning of the inning. Wacha had only thrown 60 pitches and was rolling. He showed NO signs of the Cubs exploding. Prior to last night, Wacha had the roughly the same BA against the 2nd and 3rd times through the lineup.

    in reply to: Matheny as manager – fired 7/14 #34293
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    bccran

    Participant

    Ahead 6-3, but all eyes are on MM,
    just waiting for something to criticize?

    So, as fans, we should not make comments about observations we see during a game if they are negative?

    CC made a valid point. Matheny challenged a play that was so close that it was upheld very early in the game. Now, when he could use it to prevent a baserunner late in the game, he can’t. That could have the cost of 2 additional runs as the inning played on.

    Matheny is around 50% for his career and that would be about the middle of the pack. This year is his best year and he has the 10th best % of overturned calls. I will say that Matheny does have a MUCH better record on his early challenges. However, he has lost 10% of all his challenges on a challenge in the first 4 innings of a game. IMO, in the first 4 innings it should be a challenge on a clear cut missed call not a close play that could go either way.

    in reply to: Matheny as manager – fired 7/14 #34266
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    You are always welcome to post somewhere where you feel the moderator is the way you want him. I think Brian does a good job. I don’t see where there are articles being written in favor of Matheny.

    in reply to: Matheny as manager – fired 7/14 #34264
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    bc, you are able to put the link to positive articles, as well. If they are out there, you can find them, also.

    in reply to: 2017 MLB Game #157: Cards vs. Cubs Tue Sep 26 #34263
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    Even Cubs’ announcers said that Fowler looked casual on Happ’s fly ball that Contreras advanced to 2nd. That should not happen.

    in reply to: 2017 MLB Game #157: Cards vs. Cubs Tue Sep 26 #34237
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    I was watching the Cubs’ broadcast last night and they made a comment about Fowler playing CF that I hadn’t heard before. They said that it was talked about moving him to a corner OF position and he refused. I don’t remember exactly how they said it but I got the impression he strongly opposed a move.

    1. If that is the case, I am not sure I want him. He may be good in keeping the clubhouse loose but he still needs to do whats best for the team.

    2. If he doesn’t want to move off of CF, that could be the way to get him to waive his no-trade when it is time to trade him for an upgrade somewhere else or for him.

    in reply to: Matheny as manager – fired 7/14 #34134
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    bccran

    Participant

    Instead of opinions, let’s look at the changing face of the Cardinals roster over the past number of years and see what it tells us –

    2010 –
    2011 – Pujols/Holliday/Berkman/Rasmus/Molina/Freese/Theriot/Schumaker
    2012 – Holliday/Beltran/Craig/Molina/Freese/Descalso/Furcal/Jay
    2013 – Holliday/Beltran/Carpenter/Craig/Freese/Molina/Kozma/Jay
    2014 – Holliday/Peralta/Craig/Jay/Wong/Adams/Molina/Carpenter
    2015 – Holliday/Peralta/Carpenter/Reynolds/Wong/Bourjos/Heyward/Molina
    2016 – Holliday(injured)/Peralta(injured)/Adams/Wong/Molina/Diaz/Grichuk/Piscotty
    2017 – DeJong/Carpenter/Molina/Wong/Gyorko/Pham/Fowler/Piscotty

    In an objective way, please notice the shift. There’s simply no experienced big bat meat in the middle of the lineup anymore. The failures of Grichuk and Piscotty as well as Adams have been monumental. Risks that haven’t paid off. We’ve gone from Pujols/Holliday/Berkman to (last night) Fowler/Martinez/Molina.

    Matheny doesn’t have a top tier lineup like the Cubs, Nationals, Dodgers, Diamondbacks, Red Sox, Indians, Astros, etc. That’s why I tend to be less harsh than other posters.

    BA OPS HR Runs ERA RA Wins
    2010 0.263 0.733 150 736 3.57 641 86
    2011 0.273 0.766 162 762 3.74 692 90
    2012 0.271 0.759 159 765 3.71 648 88
    2013 0.269 0.733 125 783 3.42 596 97
    2014 0.253 0.689 105 619 3.50 603 90
    2015 0.253 0.716 137 647 2.94 525 100
    2016 0.255 0.767 225 779 4.08 712 86
    2017 0.260 0.767 186 737 3.95 660

    Notice our runs scored went up in 2012 and again in 2013 without Pujols.

    in reply to: Matheny as manager – fired 7/14 #33804
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    BC, what does Whitey’s background have to do with the FACT that it was his 7th full season, NOT his 11th season as you keep trying to say?

    Also, Matheny spent 2 years in the Cardinals’ system as a roving instructor. That has just as much relevance as Herzog’s jobs prior to managing.

    Third point, Herzog managed teams for 1194 games prior to winning his first WS. MM will have managed for 972 games at the end of this season. That is a little over 1 season difference.

    Herzog had a .543 career winning % at the time he won his first WS and that was after a 47-91 record in his first year as a manager. He had a .569 career winning % after that first year until he won a WS. Rangers winning % in the 2 years prior to Herzog was .374. The Royals winning % in the 2 years prior to Herzog was .509. The Cardinals winning % in the 2 years prior to Herzog was .478.

    The Cardinals winning % in the 2 years prior to Matheny was .543.

    in reply to: Matheny as manager – fired 7/14 #33767
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    bccran

    Participant

    Did MM inherit Pujols, BlackHills?
    The core player on the team? Did he inherit Descalso at 2B and Jay in CF? Let’s drop the discussion about what a great team he inherited. This year, do you really think he was handed a playoff teM?
    Peralta? Diaz? Grichuk? Piscotty?
    Broxton? Etc?

    Mike –

    Herzog finally won a WS in his 11th year of managing.

    LaRussa finally won a WS in his 13th year of managing.

    You have a great point about Southworth, but did it matter that his 2 WS wins were in 1942 and 1944?

    As far as the Redhead, here are some of the players he won the WS with in his 3rd year of managing –

    Brock
    Cepeda
    Shannon
    McCarver
    Flood
    Maris
    Gibson
    Carleton

    Case made.

    Once again, BC, you are incorrectly citing Herzog’s WS information. He won his first WS in his 7th season that he started the season as the team’s manager.

    He managed the Angels for 4 games in 1974. He took over the Royals with 66 games left in the 1975 season. He managed the Cardinals for 73 games in the middle of 1980. The 1981 season is usually listed on 2 separate lines because of the split season due to a players’ strike.

    in reply to: 2017 MLB Game #151: Cards at Reds Wed Sep 20 #33589
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    Tampa Bay beats the Cubs. Pittsburgh and Milwaukee tied going into the 9th.

    in reply to: Matheny as manager – fired 7/14 #33572
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    There will be changes to players ALSO. Matheny should not be exempt.

Viewing 25 posts - 2,501 through 2,525 (of 2,639 total)

First-hand news and commentary on the St. Louis Cardinals™ and minor league system for over 25 years