Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
October 25, 2017 at 12:03 pm in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #36857
The Cubs will have 2018 as their last year to not worry about total payroll. They have Bryant, Hendricks, Russell and LaStella as first time arbitration eligibles this year. Next year, they have Baez, Montgomery, Schwarber and Edwards as first time arbitration eligible. Contreras and Wilson will be first time arbitration eligible in 2020.
When you throw in whoever they sign to complete their starting rotation and bullpen, they will start to raise payroll quickly over the next 2 years without some changes to their core. If Heyward opts out after 2018 or 2019, it would be one of the best things that could happen to the Cubs. If the Cubs chose to do whatever it takes, they could keep their core together until 2020 or 2021.
Brian, you must have posted your post as I was composing mine.
I would hope that the organization is ran so that the GM discusses with Matheny what Matheny needs. Then the GM identifies what fills that need internally or externally and makes a move after discussing minor league players with their managers and the teams’s scouts and minor league instructors. Once a move is made, I could see the GM providing Matheny with a complete scouting report on the player that is being added to the team. If Matheny needs more info, he would then contact the player’s minor league manager or whoever in the organization has that info.
I would hope that Matheny spends almost all of his time thinking about the team he has to work with and the opponents he has to face. It is not his job to keep track of minor leaguers, too.
bccran
Participant
Question. Do metrics measure leadership, counseling, compassion, toughness, endurance, teaching, patience,
resiliance, motivation, etc?Alternate question: Is it possible to have a manager who does all that AND provides great in-game management of players and situations?
BC, are you now saying that wins and losses are the only definitive way of measuring a manager, depending on who he has to work with? Yes or No?
If no, what are you saying is the way to measure the quality of a manager? I have lost track.
One last point of contention: I don’t blame Matheny for guys playing bad. I blame Matheny for CONTINUALLY playing players who are playing bad. Example, continuing to run Oh out there in save situations. Example, continuing to play Piscotty when Martinez was outperforming him. Example, continuing to play Fowler in center when Pham was clearly the better fielder.
Why would he post an article from 2012 on a current events thread? It would be posted in 2012. He doesn’t need to re-post it just to satisfy one person who feels he is biased. He has very clearly stated that he will post positive articles when they come up. None have recently unless you know of some. And, once again, you, like anyone else, can post the link to positive articles.
bccran
Participant
Matheny had little choice but to play DeJong at SS? Would suggest a look at both the Cardinals and Memphis rosters when that move was made and notice the players who had a heckuva lot more professional games at SS than DeJong’s total of 11 at the AA level and 17 in the AFL. Moving DeJong to the most critical defensive position on the field at the major league level with his paltry time having played there was a huge risk, and took a lot of intestinal fortitude.
There wasn’t as much risk in playing DeJong at SS as you make it out to be. He had played the position some in college, in the Arizona Fall League and in spring training. I am sure there was enough sample size to determine whether or not he could handle the position competently. He really wasn’t playing because of his fielding, anyway. He was playing because of his bat.
As far as the others to play the position, you had Breyvic Valera, Diaz, Wilfredo Tovar, Alex Mejia, Gyorko and Greg Garcia. Who am I missing? Who would you say would have been a better choice?
bccran
Participant
“Brebbia pitched well, but MM continued using less successful pitchers in high leverage situations”. Really? You want to put a minor leaguer who was called up at the end of May into high leverage situations? When he doesn’t have any major league experience in those situations?
He did with Sheriff in 2017, Bowman and Alex Reyes in 2016, Wacha and Siegrist in 2013, etc. There is actually a pattern of success doing this in the past.
bccran
Participant
2.) A 28 year old outfielder who had labored in the minors for over 10 years. He gets a chance and hits .309 with an OPS of .897 in over 300 plate appearances.
CariocaCardinal
Participant
I give MM little blame for bad play (except when he puts players in positions that lead to their failure). Consequently, he gets little credit for their success. Particularly the play of a 28 y.o. that Matheny ignored the past few years and didnt even see fit to keep on the roster at the start of the year.
bccran
Participant
He had a choice to play the 28 year old for the past “few years” and ignored him? Are we talking about the same player? Martinez came to the Cardinals organization about a third of the way through a 5 month minor league season in 2016, after being in the minors for 10 years. At Memphis in 2016 he hit .269 with a .742 OPS. Sheesh, even when the facts are there, posters will bend them to fit their agenda.
So maybe Matheny didn’t have him for 2 full seasons (he was acquired in late May 2016). He had the opportunity to start him all year long in 2017 but only gave him 63 starts. At least 1/3 of them were in September. This same 28 year old had hit over an .800 OPS in 2014 and 2015 so it is not like Matheny didn’t know he could hit that well. Starts by month: 8, 4, 12, 5, 12 and 22. How does Matheny gets credit for that?
bccran
Participant
I simply like Sooner’s positive, data laden posts and wanted to thank him and compliment him.
Posts like his are very informational and helpful.So my positive, data laden post was not very informational and helpful?
Do all the organizations have 7 teams or do all the teams have 5 OFs? That would affect your bottom line.
bccran
Participant
Terrific analysis, Sooner.
We just pump along with good players up and down the lineup, but no
true difference makers. It’s good enough to have a winning record, but not be a strong contender in the playoffs.Brian, going back to relievers.
How does it calculate when we’re tied going into the 8th and a reliever gives up a run or runs? Or if we’re only behind be one run going into the 8th and the same thing happens?Here are the ERAs per inning –
1st – 4.50
2nd – 3.11
3rd – 4.11
4th – 4.33
5th – 4.33
6th – 3.39
7th – 3.78
8th – 4.89
9th – 3.66
Extra – 3.41Sure looks like the 8th was our Achilles heel.
Just to clarify something that has been expressed at times by some posters. The Cardinals were 7th best in save percentage (70%) and tied for 7th best in blown saves (18). The ML averages were 66% and 21, respectively. From the 48th game through the end of the season, the ERA in the 8th inning was 3.68. There were 5 games in the first 47 that we allowed 4 or more runs in the 8th inning. Most of the problem was Socolovich, Broxton, Cecil, Bowman and Rosenthal.
This is a tough one. There are the NEEDS, WANTS and could stand to do.
I think we have to have either an elite middle of the order bat or an elite closer. I also think we are going to need an innings eater pitcher.
My ranking:
1. Middle of the order bat
2. Closer
3. Innings eater starter
4. Middle relief depth
5. Defensive upgrade
6. TOR starter
7. Leadoff hitterThe defensive upgrade can be accomplished simply by moving Fowler to LF. The only other thing to do is acquire an elite defensive SS.
October 9, 2017 at 8:08 am in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #35531CardsFanInChiTown
Participant
Correct, I do not see Pham having a year like he did this year. Trading him while his value is maxed out is what I’d do because of his history. The $43M was their income in 2016, with around a $150m payroll. With another $30-50 in the new TV deal, if they don’t have one over $175M it would be fair for all fans to be extremely disgruntled.
I don’t know why Pham couldn’t have another year like 2017. Since 2010, Pham has hit fairly well every year except 2012 and 2016. He has shown power in previous years as well as the ability to hit for average. He has an .890 OPS in AA for his career and an .840 OPS in AAA for his career.
I also looked over the Forbes article again. Once again, I don’t see where it lists their income in 2016 as $43M. The only figure that is anywhere close is their operating income at $40.5M. Is that the figure that you mean?
One point to consider is that impact trades would have been hard to do for the last several years (before 2017). We didn’t have enough in the minors to trade unless we depleted the farm system.
In the last year, we have finally achieved a surplus to trade from. We needed the prospects to progress through the system and put up the numbers like they did in 2017.
Your view that they are a good middle of the lineup is as much conjecture as Onyxgem’s view that having them will mean missing the playoffs for the 3rd straight year.
October 8, 2017 at 7:30 am in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #35439Also, CFICT, what’s the 43M? Where did you get that number? The Forbes website does not list anything that is 43M that I can see.
October 8, 2017 at 6:45 am in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #35438In other words, you think Pham is going to take a nose dive this year? If he performs anywhere near his 2017 numbers, he should be worth more next off-season.
October 7, 2017 at 10:11 pm in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #35434CFinChiTown, why do you want to get rid of Pham?
Also, how are they supposed to spend growing net worth?
Bruce is 4 years younger than Berkman or Beltran were when we signed them. I am pretty sure he will want to sign for more than 2 years.
gscottar
Participant
You don’t think Bruce is a big upgrade over Piscotty? I sure do.
How much and for how long do you think you have to sign him for? How long will he earn that contract?
We have some prospects that will be blocked if we sign Bruce and I think the prospects could outperform him in 2 years. Also, which Piscotty will we have next year? The one who hit 22 home runs and slashed .273/.343/.457/.800 or the 2017 version? If we get the 2016 version, that outperforms Bruce’s last 4 years average.
I would be fine with signing Bruce for 1 year. Anything more and it’s a mistake. Aim higher.
Bruce has averaged 28 home runs and 88 RBIs with a line of .237/.303/.457/.760 over the last 4 years. I don’t think he will be worth the money. I don’t think he upgrades us very much. Aim higher.
Now the negatives of a prospect can’t be discussed? What is the point of this exercise if you can’t?
October 4, 2017 at 8:33 pm in reply to: Cardinals OF roundup, who stays and who goes? (Grichuk) #35168bc, I think CC meant to say “I am NOT saying this to embarrass you but to educate”. I am struggling to recall a time that CC would say that he meant to embarrass someone or ridicule someone or belittle them.
Also, bc, have you ever considered that someone would read your way of putting up a player’s numbers and mistake OPS for SLG? What you are doing could lead to confusion since it doesn’t follow standard slash lines. Someone might reasonably misquote that player’s OPS based on your shortcut.
-
AuthorPosts
