Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Yankee fans are reeling.
and booing
What’s interesting is that Winn only played 1 game his senior year in high school.
I read a while back Winn broke team rules and was suspended for the season. I didn’t look further and don’t know what that was about. I figured the Cards did due diligence and it wasn’t something that was overly concerning.
It was challenged and was an obvious overturn. That’s why I said thankfully some of his mistakes can be corrected. He does his worst work behind the plate and hasn’t been there yet. I assume he’ll get the plate in Game 5 or 6. Lay some $$$$ on PHI that game, lol.
1td, an obvious dropped ball at 2B by Segura that Eddings said was an out due to the drop being on the transfer for the throw to complete a DP. It wasn’t even close. The reason I was sensitive to it is Eddings has a history with the Padres (google eddings padres bad umpire). Or to get a wider variety of his incompetence, just google eddings bad umpire, e.g., he really stuck it to the Blue Jays in maybe the worst umped game this year. A shame goons like him get this level of assignment.
Eddings also has a little history with the Cards. He tossed Carpenter one time when Carp was on the bench. Arenado was batting at the time. Another play that I’m sure you remember was against the cubs, on the wild play the umps screwed up an infield fly rule (Arenado didn’t make the catch). This was during the long winning streak. Shildt got ejected by Bill Miller, but it was Eddings who screwed the whole thing up by calling the runner out trying to advance to 2B, then allowing him to go back safely even though Edman (or somebody) tagged him out. He ruled the play dead, mostly because he screwed it up. It was asinine.
Doug Eddings doesn’t get talked up enough as a terrible umpire. What was he looking at? Just awful that he has an impact on a LCS. Thankfully the challenge system can correct some of his mistakes.
It’s how fast you get it there, not how fast you throw it. As you guys have said, that’s why Ozzie was able to be great without an elite arm. Same with catchers and pop time in cutting down runners. Mitt to bag is what it’s all about. Arm strength won’t overcome wasted energy in the other areas like foot and leg work, transfer, and release.
Looking at BW’s link to the data has me thinking of all kinds of time and distance calculations and statistical correlation analyses I could’ve given to my aerospace science cadets, but not doing that any more. I might’ve improved some students’ interest and grades if I’d used more baseball examples instead of aircraft all the time! The amount of live action data they capture now is enormous and the challenge is how to process and interpret it all, separate the wheat from the chaff, and use the meaningful stuff to help make decisions.
I couldn’t believe I forgot about our old friend Polanco
I don’t remember ever knowing he did that until a couple weeks ago when reading about the new utility award. I googled to find out if a player could win two awards in the same year and there it was. Obviously, this whole topic is too elusive for me. I need to become uninterested in it, lol.
EDIT: for my posts above addressing BW’s comment on voters where I said I read they were using a formula-only approach for the utility GG. I went back to look for the link, and now I’m not sure I’m right based on another thing I’ve read. It’s clear from what I read that they’ve devised a “special formula” unique to utility award, but I originally thought I saw a source that said that the formula would be the sole decider. Now I can’t find it, which probably means my old eyes were reading too quickly. Sorry about that, but please disregard those posts (#205034 & 205035). I would delete them if I could.
I’d like to see Tommy Edman win a GG, but I’d rather see him win one for the 2B position.
1td, see my post above. I think that makes it a realistic possibility Edman could win two GGs. Of if not him, then Varsho.
If these reflect the 75% manager/coaches vote, which they don’t and won’t, my conclusion is that Edman has the best chance to win among the four Cardinals, and it would be the utility award.
Of course, the voters can be unpredictable.
Evidently the voters don’t have a say on the utility award. It will be by a formula. Or so I read somewhere.
Otherwise, I was wondering the impact of Edman and Varsho being finalists for two “positions” (utility and their other one) and how that might help/hurt their chances with the voters. Many voters might think they’re deserving, but then their votes might get split across the two positions because a voter doesn’t think they deserve two awards. The formula-only approach for the utility position eliminates that possible issue.
I also wondered initially if they’d be eligible to win two gold gloves in a single year, and it looks like the answer is yes.
Ha, I just read GameCard’s link. It gives the answer to my trivia question!
I haven’t seen that yet Oliver, so thanks for posting. So if I can piece this info with what stlcard25 and I were discussing on another thread, it must be you are eligible for the one position where you have the most innings after the 141st game, not end of season. I said that might be the case, but as 25 and I were saying, the web site wasn’t clear on a couple of criteria. At the end of the season, Edman had more innings at SS. My guess now is that at the end of 141 games, evidently he had more innings at 2B and that’s what matters.
I also wondered if it is now possible for a player to win 2 gold gloves in the same year with the new utility gold glove. I think the information you posted shows it is possible.
Which by the way brings a trivia thought to mind — 1td are you listening? Name at least one of two players to have won a gold glove at different positions (but not in the same year like I was talking about above). One of those players is very familiar to many of us on this board.
No, Knizner didn’t capitalize. He looks more like a backup than a starter to me, however I still won’t say he’s been given a very good chance to show what he can do. Yadi missed a lot of action in 2022, yet still had more at bats than Knizner.
A good trade is when both teams benefit. Looks like that’s already happened with Monty-Bader.
A great trade is when the Cards fleece the cubs, like when they traded Doug Clemens for Jack Spring. You might recall Broglio and Brock were also thrown in on that trade.
very little offense….
In recent years, it seems like this is the nature of playoff baseball. This will likely continue to be true if the way to advance to the LCS is to have a 2 or 3 starters capable of dominating a game and a short series. Those teams will often advance and the dominant starters will keep dominating.
The TBS postgame panel discussion also discussed the new wrinkle to the dynamics this year. Rollins and Granderson said hitters need to be facing “real” pitching everyday this time of year since pitching machines and coaches don’t simulate very well. They felt the lack of that everyday exposure for several days contributed to the Braves, Dodgers, Astros & Yanks (bye teams) having low production in their division series.
My boy bader keeps this stuff up and he may get him some most valuable hardware if Yankees can win another round.
Hey, watch out willie, I called it first a few days ago. Bader staking a claim to Babe Ruth Postseason MVP Award is in progress.
I believe the thinking by some might be backwards on Knizner. For a long time the Cards haven’t seemed to emphasize offense from their backstop, Yadi or backups. Although modest with the bat, Yadi overachieved against their expectations. So I think it’ll depend on how they view Knizner’s framing, handling pitchers, and overall defense.
It seems like I kept hearing most of the broadcasters (including opposing broadcasters) say Kiz does a fairly good job behind the plate during the season. However, his defensive stats look subpar. My own eye test was kind of mixed — he made the occasional nice play, but made more mistakes than you want.
1td has a good point about his time being so fragmented working under Yadi. Hard to really get going with the bat or glove that way. I guess it depends on how Mo views the risk assessment with other guys like Gorman, Carlson, and O’Neill as to how much risk he wants to take on by going with just Kiz & Herrera.
No kidding! What if he signs Correa or Trea Turner? Then everyone would move!
You’re overthinking this with unnecessary constraints. Why not both? Then move Turner to 2B and trade Gorman, Winn & Edman for an elite catcher. That way you’re only moving Turner. He played 3B in college so this just another step around the horn for him. Yeah, that’s the ticket.
Agreed that Gorman at 2B wasn’t great this year. He’s still new enough that I think you’ve got to give him some time to sort it out.
This makes sense. To a point, that is, and for me it’s giving him maybe up to half a season next year. Hopefully he’ll get his plate issues sorted out so he can stay in the lineup somewhat regularly. After 2 to 4 months next season, if he hasn’t shown any improvement at 2B, he’s out of place since that would be two seasons to demonstrate his ability to handle it. Caring about the defense and trying not to lead the league in errors is exactly why you’d need to move him.
I just hope they find a place where Gorman can field adequately, wherever that may be. Absent Arenado opting out, it won’t be 3B for sure. If it’s OF, so be it. The 2B trial of 2022 was subpar. If they continue the trial into 2023 and there’s no noticeable improvement in the 1st half of the season, they need to quit kidding themselves.
Drew had a pretty good 14 year career.
Yes, but he didn’t touch that mysterious ceiling. Regardless of how good he was, the Cards certainly got an enormous return out of drafting him. It ended up being a very good thing for the Cards that TLR believed Drew lacked commitment.
So it doesn’t look like Edman would be qualified at either position, unless I’m misreading. Or are they saying 698 innings and you’re in at the most played position? It doesn’t look clear to me.
Yep 25, it could be clearer. Your second take is correct based on what I’ve read. However, I have read more than one recent article saying the criteria is now 713 innings after the 141st game. Inflation I guess. See the links below. Goold clarifies your question. If they are correct, seems strange the Rawlings site is not up to date.
Speaking of JD Drew, my son liked him a lot when he started playing in StL. We were going to a lot of games then. I bought him a Drew rookie card. I bet he still has it even though Drew didn’t turn out to be a great Cardinal.
Keith Law and every other preseason prediction had no idea what any club would do at the deadline.
Yep, jj, predicting team records for a whole season is kind of like the stock market, where you see disclaimers about past performance being no guarantee of future performance. But they do it anyway. Nature of the beast. If it was easy, it would not be interesting nor worthwhile to do. It would be silly to hang your hat on someone’s predictions. Having said that, they’re usually not terribly far off with most teams at the end of the season. Most of us serious fans are usually in the ball park too. I wonder what Law was seeing that others didn’t to predict the Cards to have a losing record? Maybe he thought the Cards were going to do a salary dump at the trade deadline.
What’s really difficult is to predict what kind of MLB performer a player will be when he’s never been higher than A or AA level. Or even AAA for that matter. That’s why those who make these projections, “professionals” included, miss the boat on so many prospects. Hanging your hat on prospect projections is far sillier than hanging your hat on pre-season predictions of team records.
Yep, 1td. I edited my post to add what the actual minimum is. It’s 698 total innings by the 138th game.
Now another question pops into my mind. The Rawlings site says you qualify for the position in which you played the most innings. I’m wondering if the “most innings” is based on the numbers at the 138th game, or at the end of the season. This shouldn’t be that hard.
-
AuthorPosts
