Bob Reed

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 25 posts - 926 through 950 (of 1,093 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: 2019 closer/relievers thread – Miller + ? #78181
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    I don’t blame you for being skeptical, NJ.
    But with the Cards surrendering a first round draft pick for Holland, plus half a million in international bonus money, they effectively paid perhaps $25-30M for that single season of pestilence. So at least the risk with Miller is much less, on a per year basis.

    Per the Fangraphs form charts, the Cards just went from a rotten 24th in relief pitching to a mediocre 17th. With an additional arm, just a very-good-but-not-great acquisition — like Joakim Soria, for example — they can be on the cusp of the top 10. (Will Smith, if you’re curious and I’m sure you are, would vault the Cards all the way to 7th.)

    So get to it, Mo!

    in reply to: 2019 closer/relievers thread – Miller + ? #78099
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    I’d have preferred trading for someone younger or healthier or ideally both. Lefty or righty reliever, I don’t care.

    But hey, you never know what exactly teams are asking for in trade. And Miller was of course magnificent until 2018. From 2014-2017 his worst year was 2015 when he threw 61 innings with a 2.04 ERA.

    And there’s an argument that even his massively disappointing 2018 season wasn’t really as bad as the numbers initially make it look, as the 4.24 ERA was a distortion created by a couple of awful outings. Take away his best two games and his worst two, and his season ERA was 2.76, with a 41-to-13 K/BB in 29.1 IP.

    I’d rather have David Robertson at the same price, as he’s also murder on lefty hitters and has tossed at least 60 innings for 9 straight years. But maybe Robertson wants to play in the A.L., or likes the east coast. Who knows?

    But I must admit that nobody — not Robertson or Kimbrel or Britton or anyone available in trade — offers a greater potential upside than Andrew Miller.

    Now go get Yusei Kikuchi, Mo, plus one more excellent reliever. That would make the Cards division co-favorites. At least.

    in reply to: Winter Meetings – Boring Week #77302
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Man, I can still remember waiting for the Sporting News to come in the mail each week!”

    And each February, waiting for the monster Street And Smith annual. (Same with football and basketball.)
    When I was an adolescent it was an expectations battle royale between the Sports Illustrated swimsuit issue, and the early baseball stuff. If only Cheryl Tiegs had played for the Cardinals, then I could’ve scratched two itches at once. So to speak.

    Funny this topic should arise, because I saw a Dave Dombrowski interview just a few hours ago wherein he waxed rhapsodic about how, decades back, there was a winter deadline for all trades — and maybe for free agent signings too, I don’t know. I believe it was a pre-Christmas deadline, so that MLB execs could have some true “down time” built into their schedules, before ramping up again for Spring Training. But now, a cowboy’s work is never done.

    Hang in there, TexasCard. I have a feeling the Birds will do something on Thursday.

    in reply to: What is wrong with Dexter Fowler and what should be done? #77073
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    From the opening day, Fowler stunk it up. That made him sad.

    Then at long last, in mid-June he was finally benched. Because this is sports, and he was actively hurting his team by being on the field, and there was clearly someone much better to take his place. Being benched made him even sadder.

    He spent five days out of the entire season, with an OPS over .615. And of course he’s a lousy fielder as well. That’s not anyone who should be on the field.

    Show of faith? Show of commitment?! He stunk, he got benched. He’s a grown man, and he got benched. That’s sports. We don’t need a single scrap of inside information on Fowler to know that any bad player in any sport being benched is never an injustice. It’s the way that sports is supposed to work. It’s one of the main reasons we love sports. Because at its best it is a meritocracy.

    If Fowler had “mental issues” then that’s just too darn bad — go see a therapist. You can afford it.

    Maybe I’m insensitive, but maybe the club needs less sensitivity and more meritocracy for playing time. This isn’t T-ball and they don’t give participation ribbons. You play until there’s someone better to take your place.

    in reply to: Cooperstown Class of 2019 #77022
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Robert Reed- Sportsmanship, character and integrity means that Ty Cobb should be kicked out. What about the racists, drunkards, ones with criminal incidents that have been elected to the HOF?You want to have a baseball HOF combined with a Angelic perfect person HOF?

    There are six guidelines for Hall Of Fame voters. The following is lifted verbatim from the HOF website:

    Voting: Voting shall be based upon the player’s record, playing ability, integrity, sportsmanship, character, and contributions to the team(s) on which the player played.

    If anyone feels that Ty Cobb’s or anyone else’s personal behavior or views should have them removed from the Hall, I will be more than happy to listen to their arguments. But addressing some of your specific remarks: Baseball itself was a racist institution until Jackie Robinson broke through, and in my view it makes very little sense to retroactively apply our modern behavioral standards to ballplayers from before the color line was crossed. All of society was different, therefore so were ballplayers.

    Drunkards? Some of my best friends are drunkards. Excessive drinking has no bearing whatsoever on integrity or sportsmanship. Character, perhaps. And character is just one of the six guidelines, and for me it does not come anywhere near outweighing the other five. (This is why it’s such nonsense when people refer to the “character clause.” You may note that the PED apologists never refer to the “integrity clause” or the “sportsmanship clause.”)

    Criminal records? A more extreme version of the “drunkards” remark. You can certainly question a criminal’s character. But as for their baseball integrity and sportsmanship, it has zero bearing.

    Your wanting to apply your standards to everyone else reeks of censorship and suppression IMO. I might not agree with some writers opinions but I also don`t try and preach from the pulpit. Saying Greenies were not against the rules is your rationale …..yet is not greenie a drug which elevates body chemistry of the user? Hypocrisy IMHO.

    The first formal MLB drug policy was enacted in April of 1971. Anyone who took “greenies” AFTER commissioner Bowie Kuhn issued his Drug Policy Memo in April of 1971 was violating MLB rules. Conversely, anyone who took greenies BEFORE he issued his Memo in April of 1971 was NOT violating MLB rules. You can’t break a rule that did not exist.

    “Preach from the pulpit?” So we aren’t supposed to express opinions if they differ from those of sportswriters? You’ve lost me there. This is the internet, a wondrous marketplace of ideas.

    What I want is the exact opposite of hypocrisy: I want to apply the same standards to Keith Law that Keith Law himself wishes to apply to others. Here’s what I mean. This is excerpted from Law’s chat of November 11.

    Joe:
    I understand if a voter refuses to vote for pitchers for MVP because he sees it as a position player’s award. I don’t necessarily agree with it, but I understand it. But it really doesn’t make sense when a writer gives deGrom a 5th place vote. If you see him as eligible, how can you possibly justify having him 5th on the ballot?

    Keith Law:
    I agree with your second point, but as for the first one, it is definitively NOT a position player’s award. If you refuse to consider pitchers, that is your right… but DON’T F***ING VOTE. Give the ballot to someone who will follow the actual guidelines. (I edited his obscenity. I guess that would be censorship.)

    Law clearly (and profanely) wants everyone else to follow the guidelines for MVP voting. But when it comes to the illegal PED cheats, he wants to contemptuously disregard three of the six Hall Of Fame voting guidelines: integrity, sportsmanship, and character. That’s hypocrisy.

    in reply to: Cooperstown Class of 2019 #76930
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Thanks for the response, BHC.
    Tim Raines’ cocaine use was indeed contrary to MLB drug policy. However it’s hard to argue that it violated either the integrity or sportsmanship guidelines of the Hall Of Fame voting. Whether it showed a lack of character is in the beholder’s eye. It certainly showed stupidity.

    I would never have voted for the other three, as I’m convinced enough in my own mind that they were systematic users of illegal PEDs. Some voters on the other hand want proof with a capital P before withholding their vote from an otherwise obviously qualified candidate. To each their own.

    But then there’s the worst category of journalists and fans by far.

    There will always be ethically and intellectually lazy or indifferent people like Keith Law who would rather do zero rigorous thinking on the subject, and prefer to simply apply no standards whatsoever. (Law infamously said with a straight face several years ago that he would vote for a PED cheat for league MVP even if he were busted in-season.) People like him, via their vile rationalizing, would in the long run eventually ruin sport, all sports amateur and professsional, for those who choose NOT to cheat.

    People like Law and his ilk have no useful place even participating in Hall Of Fame discussions, much less ever casting a HOF vote, because they would choose to apply their own personal standards to the voting, and willfully ignore 3 of the 6 official voting guidelines — the aforementioned integrity, sportsmanship, and character of course.

    in reply to: 2019 LH hitting additions – Drew Robinson + ? #76929
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    I’ve always had a soft spot for Asdrubal. Defensively versatile, and invariably seems to hit better with men on base. Check these splits:

    Career bases empty .721 OPS
    Career men on base .798

    2018 bases empty .717
    2018 men on base .857

    As Bw52 said, he likely wouldn’t want a reserve role. Not after 8 straight years of 135+ games. But maybe more money would be a sufficient inducement. Who knows?

    Anyhow, I do still like Dietrich also. Say what you will about the below average glovework, his overall value at both B-Ref and Fangraphs has still graded well above replacement level. And I love, love, love those Dietrich career home/road splits (.696/.816).

    in reply to: Bryce Harper thread #76923
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Fair points all, Brian. And maybe the new hitting guru can fix Fowler enough to return most of the way to his best at the plate.

    But at 33 and already a poor defender, he just doesn’t represent enough upside to me for 2019, much less beyond. I say Mo should go Full Dombrowski and release him. If Fowler were much more professional, then I’d say keep him as a veteran leader at 4th or 5th outfielder — he’s shown a good work ethic, he has playoff experience. These are not completely inconsequential matters.

    But “professionalism” does not describe Dexter. He fussed and fumed about his benching, and still publicly griped about it in October after having months to reflect on his lost season. Through his eyes nothing was his fault. Stupid manager should have kept playing him every day despite his being perhaps the worst player in the Senior Circuit.

    The O.E.D. defines “mediocre” as “of only average quality.” That’s Fowler through and through. For his 10-year career, he’s 2.0 WAR player at Fangraphs and 1.8 at Baseball-Reference. The embodiment of mediocrity.

    And you know what? From Opening Day they’ll probably bat him 2nd (where the team’s best hitter should bat). Good hitters in front and in back. To try and “get him going.” To try and give precious Dexter Fowler every possible advantage. The heck with the rest of the roster. After all, wouldn’t be fair to Dex to bat him 8th where he belongs. He wouldn’t have any “protection” there.

    Oh, but this is a Harper thread. I don’t want Harper. Well, maybe a pint of Old Harper.

    in reply to: Bryce Harper thread #76914
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Wasn’t John Heyman discredited as a serious “journalist” more than half a decade ago, due to his incessant shilling for Boras clients? Always seems to be Heyman telling us about “mystery teams” and “mystery owners” — and only when it’s a Scott Boras client. Some coincidence.

    Don’t know why Mo or anyone would wish so fondly for Dexter Fowler’s 2017 season. Just 1.6 WAR per Baseball-Reference; and injury-riddled of course. When he plays, he’s mediocre. Then he gets hurt.

    Dexter is like the joke about the old women vacationing at a Catskills resort. “The food here is terrible,” says the first one. “Yes,” replies the second. “And such small portions.”

    in reply to: Bryce Harper thread #76891
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “…the FO is scared to go make the huge splash…sure fixing the pen will help a little but right now still a 3rd place team in division…and that is without Mil and Cubs doing ANYTHING yet.”

    Not that I trust the computer models as infallible gospel, but the Fangraphs projections have the Cards second to the cubs in the division right now, and trailing Chicago by a scant single game. I expect the Cards, cubs, and Brewers to all still make moves this offseason. I don’t expect any one of them to dramatically out-do the other two, going forward this winter.

    Also, I would argue that the Brewers will need to make several smart moves just to stay above 88-90 wins, because they (1)had almost every single thing go really, really right in 2018; and (2)already lost quite a few quality innings, assuming that Wade Miley and Gio Gonzalez and Dan Jennings and Xavier Cedeno sign elsewhere this winter.

    That quartet combined for 21 starts and 87 relief appearances, totaling 178.1 IP and a 2.67 ERA. So losing them is a lot like losing a Miles Mikolas off your roster. It’s gonna leave a mark.

    And don’t forget, the Cards played nearly .600 baseball after dumping Mabry/Mueller/Matheny in July. And that’s despite playing more than 70% of their second half games against teams with winning records. When you replace the worst hitting coach in baseball with someone competent, great things happen. (Despite facing markedly tougher pitching, the Cardinal team OPS jumped by nearly 40 points over the second half.)

    I see the Cards as currently right there, with the two division rivals. And due to their horrible bullpen the Cards have a painfully obvious weakness, while the others do not. So in a weird way, that gives the Birds an offseason advantage — better chance to improve an important facet of the team without breaking the bank.

    in reply to: Cooperstown Class of 2019 #76865
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Nobody likes players to have a advantage over other players. The facts are baseball has had a long history of players looking for a edge by whatever means possible-Gaylord Perry’s spitball, Elston Howard using his buckles on his shin guards to cut the baseball for Whitey Ford and other NYY pitchers, Amphetamines, corking bats, Pine tar (hello George Brett),etc.. Players are always looking for a advantage legal or otherwise.”

    I see this argument frequently, and my response would be threefold.

    One, the illegal drug use of McGwire, Bonds, Clemens and others was expressly forbidden in baseball beginning in April of 1971 with Commissioner Bowie Kuhn’s Drug Policy Memo. (Among other things, this means that all of the “greenies” taken by Mickey Mantle and others in the 1960’s were not a violation of MLB policy.)

    Two, in matters of criminal law, e.g., thievery, assault, it is a universally accepted principle that there are degrees of transgression. No one would remotely equate stealing a handful of jelly & jam packets from a diner, with a Pulp Fiction-style armed robbery of that same diner. Similarly, no one with any sense would equate scuffing a baseball with systematically altering one’s body via the repeated use of illegal PEDs. Another principle is that the punishment should be proportional to the transgression.

    But three, IF anyone wants to assert that Gaylord Perry should be removed from the Hall Of Fame due to spitball throwing, or Mickey Mantle because of greenies, or George Brett due to pine tar, then I’m more than happy to hear their argument. Maybe there are some guys in the Hall who should be removed, for whatever cause.

    But the key for me is that in a time when there were very specific, explicit rules against the use of any illegal drugs, some ballplayers chose to play it clean and some did not. By honoring the drug cheats we ourselves aid and abet their dishonesty, and therefore we mistreat the very players we should be praising. The players who could have cheated, but chose not to.

    Anyway I’m very glad for Big Lee and Silent Harold. I wouldn’t have voted for Harold, to be honest. But I am still thrilled that he made it. Class act all around, and the only “must see” hitter on some really rotten White Sox teams of the 1980’s. I mean, I’d have the TV on, I’d watch Harold’s AB, but then I’d immediately leave the room to do chores of some sort. Then I’d return when Harold was coming up again.

    in reply to: Cooperstown Class of 2019 #76755
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Fred McGriff has been cheated not so much by the voters, as by his prominent contemporaries at first base, who just happened to be illegal PED users. The Crime Dog’s prime lasted from 1987-2001, and as you may see from this link, over that 15-year stretch the top 3 first basemen in the majors were all drug cheats. (Well, two confirmed PED cheats and another highly likely one.) Then came Frank Thomas, then McGriff.

    https://www.fangraphs.com/leaders.aspx?pos=1b&stats=bat&lg=all&qual=y&type=8&season=2001&month=0&season1=1987&ind=0&team=0&rost=0&age=0&filter=&players=0

    The drug cheats raised the “average” performance of MLB first basemen, and thus artificially lowered all other first basemen’s WAR totals. It wouldn’t be a huge amount, but it wouldn’t be entirely negligible either. Not to mention any stolen All-Star game appearances, and other potential accolade theft.

    Drug cheats poison the well of sport in so many ways, and it doesn’t stop when they’re exposed, or even after they retire. If this weren’t a family website I’d really tell you what I think of them.

    in reply to: 2019 LH hitting additions – Drew Robinson + ? #76599
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Gyorko, right now, I believe is quality depth. Carpenter will need rest. He can platoon a bit with Wong.
    Really what we need to do is cut Fowler & Cecil (the only 2 players on the Cardinals with full NTC’s by the way).”

    I don’t always agree with C-2016, but I very enthusiastically second all of the above thoughts. And I also agree with him re Derek Dietrich for lefty bat off the bench. Dietrich is the same age and same general talent level/career track record as Marwin Gonzalez, but will cost a lot less than Marwin, I’m pretty sure, due to Marwin’s flukey 2017 monster year, and his national publicity arising from the Astros’ success of late.

    Moreover, DD might provide substantially more hitting value than it superficially appears, since his home/road split was so crazily skewed while playing for the Marlins. With 1,000 – 1,100 trips to the plate both home and away, here are the nutty numbers.

    Home .234/.319/.377
    Road .272/.351/.465

    That’s an .816 road OPS, versus .696 at home. I apologize if this has been mentioned on any other threads. But even if it has, it probably bears repeating anyway.

    I am STILL saying that the bullpen should be priority number one, and two, and three. But as long as people think that we need a versatile lefty bench bat, the Cards may as well get one with upside.

    in reply to: 2019 closer/relievers thread – Miller + ? #76489
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Oh, he (Jose Martinez) has value. But there are only about 3 teams that need a DH that don’t have one. And you can get a DH for a few million bucks.
    Good relievers > DH”

    Prior to the 2017 season the Indians gave 34-year-old DH Edwin Encarnacion a 3-year deal for $60M coming off a 134 OPS+ season. Jose Martinez has a lifetime 128 OPS+. And he’s a long way from 34, and he makes no dough.

    If an A.L. team doesn’t see him as a terrific opportunity, then they’re nuts. And maybe they are, I don’t know. But Jose at his current batting line as a 150 games DH is much more valuable than 95-99% of even the good MLB relievers.

    in reply to: Cubs thread #76488
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    The Cubs have a trio of $20M starters, plus Quintana and Hendricks. That’s their five, I would have to assume.

    If Darvish can’t go, then they default to Chatwood or Mike Montgomery — one of the highly underrated utility pitchers in all the majors.

    So I don’t see either the budget or compelling motivation for Kluber. And besides all that, I cannot imagine the smart Indian front office falling for a trade like that. Ian Happ is a very good bench piece, but that’s all; not enough bat to start. And Fat Boy is a platoon bat with no defensive position, which should hold very little appeal for a team with a $20M designated hitter already in the fold in Encarnacion.

    in reply to: 2019 closer/relievers thread – Miller + ? #76478
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Reyes
    Hicks
    Hudson
    Gant
    Brebbia
    Ponce
    Gomber (L)
    Leone
    Gallegos
    Shreve (L)
    Isn’t this enough to make a decent pen?”

    I’m partial to homegrown guys, but unfortunately I think it isn’t, cranny. I think it would very likely be a repeat of 2018, where the club scrambles all year to try and figure out who really belongs in what role — and in the meantime, games are being lost late. It’s okay to scramble a little, maybe for the first couple of months. But not all year.

    On top of which, they might need Gant, or Ponce, or Hudson, or Gomber, to make spot starts. In fact, we can be pretty sure that at least one or two of them will have to do so at some point. The potential needs of the rotation are definitely a factor in all this.

    But even if all of those swingman types stay in the bullpen all season, for me that hypothetical pen above reads like a list of guys who should battle for the 6th/7th inning role. It has nobody in it — except possibly Brebbia — who has pitched well in more than one MLB season. (And I’m frankly reluctant to count Brebbia, since his MLB single-season inning totals are relatively modest, at 52 and 51.)

    I like Brebbia, I like him for middle relief. He could be solid in that role going forward. But if there is any chance that John Brebbia is the best relief pitcher on your roster, you are in terrible trouble. And I believe that is where the Cards are right now.

    Sorry to be such a sourpuss, cranny. And on a Friday no less.

    in reply to: 2019 closer/relievers thread – Miller + ? #76477
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “I am curious why people think Taylor Rogers is available in any trade for JMart. Does anybody remember the Craig Kimbrel trade? Aroldis Chapman? Andrew Miller?”

    Speaking just for myself, I suggested taking a bad contract off of the Twins’ hands, and also including a prospect in the trade. And Jose Martinez has an MLB lifetime 130 wRC+, and makes no money. I am curious why so many people seem to think he has limited appeal as a DH.

    Also, Taylor Rogers has very nearly none of the prestige that Kimbrel or Chapman or Miller possessed when they were traded. Because he’s not a closer, because he doesn’t get a ton of strikeouts, because he lacks a lengthy track record of MLB dominance, because he was never a big prospect and isn’t young now, and finally, well, maybe he’s a little undervalued partly because he’s a Minnesota Twin. Hasn’t performed on the “big stage” so to speak.

    “Since Minnesota is trying to win a winnable division…”

    If Minnesota won’t trade, if they’re really trying to win their division (or at least take a shot at the wildcard) I think they’re making a big mistake, but that’s obviously their choice.

    As for the A.L. Central being “winnable,” I don’t know what to say to this. I can only assume that you’re kidding. Cleveland will win that division by 15-20 games, if not more. They would have done so in 2018, but were bad in extra innings/one-run games, where there’s a significant element of luck. The Injuns outscored their opponents by 170 runs in 2018, and they have a great multi-superstar core to fill in around. They will run roughshod over that division for at least the next two years.

    Minny might win 86-88 games if Buxton suddenly actualizes and a few other things go right. And almost nothing goes wrong.

    in reply to: Paul Goldschmidt Thread #76471
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Q: “C’mon, let’s be realistic. Yes, it looks like Fowler will open the season there, but if he doesn’t perform, he will be replaced at some point. Why are so many so gloomy?”

    A: “Residual damage from the Matheny era, must be.”

    Matheny was the one who benched Fowler beginning June 12, in favor of Bader. Fowler started just 11 games over the next 5 weeks.

    Shildt benched Bader for Fowler, as soon as he took over. Fowler then started 15 of the next 17 games. Then Fowler got injured, and the Cards went 32-20 the rest of the way.

    This is why I do not trust Shildt to be smart about Fowler. Because he wasn’t remotely smart in 2018.

    in reply to: Bryce Harper thread #76345
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “It’d be like you and I swapping DVDs and you give me three seasons of Two and a Half Men that you haven’t watched in several years, while I give you season 2 of The Office. Sure, maybe you only got one year, but *you* won’t regret the deal.”

    Is three years of Two and a Half Men worth the same as 7 1/2 years of one man? Like say, The Prisoner? (One man, but very high EAR — Entertainment Above Replacement.)

    I did like your analogy, Mr. Lankford. Very well done.

    in reply to: 2019 closer/relievers thread – Miller + ? #76337
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    No free agent relievers for me, please. Not unless it’s a Final Boss type of guy — someone relatively unknown, and cheap as the Dollar Store. I say go big for Kikuchi, though, as he could relieve or start in 2019, then slide into the rotation for the remaining years of his contract after Mikolas & Wacha depart.

    A 2020 rotation of Carlos Martinez, Jack Flaherty, Alex Reyes, Yusei Kikuchi, and Dakota Hudson sounds pretty good to me. Gant and Gomber for the safety net.

    Anyway, an alternative would be to package Jose Martinez and a good-not-great prospect to the Twins for overpaid backup backstop Castro (there’s your lefty bench bat, if you have to have one) plus solid southpaw Taylor Rogers for the pen. Twins get salary relief, a fun fun cheap cheap top 3 DH, and a prospect. Cards get a bench guy that Shildt might actually play 4 or 5 times a month, instead of burning Yadi out by mid-August.

    If not Rogers, maybe Andrew Chafin. If not him, perhaps Caleb Frare. I don’t even care of the bullpen is nothing but righties, as long as they can get both lefty and righty batters out. But whatever happens, let’s get relievers who are IN their primes this winter, and not multiple years past it. Let’s learn from the past.

    in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #76322
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Get Bumgarner and Britton.”

    Only if they come with a time machine.
    I don’t want anyone who is multiple years past his prime. Especially pitchers, and most especially pitchers who will cost a lot in terms of talent or shekels.

    Maybe I’m paranoid. Maybe the recent Redbird history with Cecil, Gregerson, and Holland has pretty much ruined me for future pitching acquisitions. But I’d much rather the Cards take on mid-sized unwanted contracts while trading for relievers in their mid-20’s, and in free agency pay for starters not already on the downslope — like young Mr. Kikuchi.

    in reply to: Bryce Harper thread #76320
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “2017- Fowler (5 years)
    2018- Ozuna (2 years)
    2019- Goldschmidt (1 year)
    That’s why.
    I love Goldschmidt…. but not for a 1 year rental.”

    “So you are saying you wanted another Fowler deal?”

    That’s so mean, Brian. Reminds me of this.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wvKPaIWz5xk

    in reply to: Paul Goldschmidt Thread #76168
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    If he leaves after one year, the Cards get a high draft pick, and simply re-install Carp back at first base. Then Gyorko takes over at third. Or maybe Elhuris Montero is such a phenom that he’s ready for the MLB hot corner at 21. Stranger things have happened. Goldy leaving would not gut the team, not at all.

    It would merely leave the Birds with the same personnel that just finished 4th in the N.L. in runs per game, and 2nd in road OPS behind only the pennant-winning Dodgers. Carp and Yadi would be old, of course. But Bader, O’Neill, and DeJong would be in their primes in 2020.

    So I don’t think the calculus changes much, depending on whether Goldy sticks around or not. If he goes after 2019, you probably got a great season for cheap money, and a draft pick afterwards. If he stays, you’ll be paying full market value for a player in his early 30’s already — sometimes a fair deal but very rarely a bargain for the buyer, folks.

    in reply to: Bryce Harper thread #76160
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    I don’t get the need for a lefty bench bat. If your righty bats can hit righty pitching okay, why go out of your way to add a lefty hitter?

    Jose Martinez has an .813 career OPS against righties, and Tyler O’Neill’s was .804 in the majors last year, after a 1.066 in AAA. (That’s pretty good, isn’t it? A 1.066 OPS? I mean, he was better against lefties, that’s true. But 1.066 is alright for your weaker side.)

    Gyorko and Munoz are both over .700 against rights, for their careers. I mean, unless you can find a true righty-mashing Adam Lind type, why bother? For that matter, just bring Adam Lind out of retirement! (Of course, then lefties will exploit the crap out of him. And he won’t help you one iota in the field or on the bases.)

    So, other than the nebulous (and perhaps valueless) virtue of “balance”, what is the selling point of the lefty bench bat?

    I love, love, love that they’re out of the Harper race. Wish I could get the same reassurance about Moustakas. (There are several markedly better players than Harper, who are quite possibly going to be free agents over the next couple of years. Mike Trout, Nolan Arenado, Mookie Betts, Kris Bryant. Probably more I can’t name off the top of my head. No need to cry over spilled Bryce.)

    in reply to: Paul Goldschmidt Thread #76151
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    v. LHP: Carp, Bader, Goldy, Ozuna, O’Neill, Yadi, DeJong, Wong, pitcher

    v. RHP: Carp, Wong, Goldy, Ozuna, DeJong, O’Neill, Yadi, Bader, pitcher

    Have to have Bader near the top v. lefties. Anywhere from 2nd to cleanup. And DeJong has hit righties better than southpaws for his career thus far. Notice also how a fast guy will hit 8th all the time. Good for the pitcher bunting guys over, and also more RBI chances for the top of the lineup.

    Now just trade a very good-but-not-great prospect to Minnesota for Taylor Rogers and Jason Castro. Cards get a quality backup backstop who makes too much money, plus a solid southpaw for the bullpen. (Might have to take Addison Reed’s contract as part of the bargain.)

Viewing 25 posts - 926 through 950 (of 1,093 total)

First-hand news and commentary on the St. Louis Cardinals™ and minor league system for over 25 years