Bob Reed

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 25 posts - 951 through 975 (of 1,091 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Paul Goldschmidt Thread #76114
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    I’m ambivalent. is it possible to be extremely ambivalent? Twelve months ago, it would have been a fine deal for the Cards. Two seasons of Goldy, great!

    But one year of Goldy — or worse, he gets signed to a massive albatross of a contract extension that runs into his late 30’s — for Carson Kelly plus Weaver plus multiple sweeteners? Definitely improves the team for 2019, of course. But for every single year beyond that, it makes things at least a little worse.

    Now maybe Knizner will really, really blossom for Memphis this year. And maybe I’m wrong that Luke Weaver was pitch-tipping, and will be a #1/2 starter once a team fixes that problem. We’ll see.

    Goldy’s great, and the Cards will still have Gyorko in case Carp blows his arm out playing 3rd base. So that’s a good thing.

    But I still say what I’ve always said. The 2018 lineup was objectively very good. So was the rotation. Therefore the place to invest both money and prospect talent was and is the bullpen. Let’s hope that Kikuchi is the next move, followed by a reliever or two.

    Also, Welcome Mr. Goldschmidt.

    in reply to: 2019 TCN top 50 prospect list countdown #76067
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Just not a lot to say about guys like Sosa and Schrock who are AAAA guys at best.”

    Yeah, I share your Schrock pessimism, Mr. Lankford. For me, Max had probably the most disappointing 2018 season of all Redbird minor league position players.

    Sosa though, I still like just fine as a future utility guy. At age 22 he had better health than in recent years, and it showed at the plate. In 450 AB’s split pretty evenly between Double-A and Triple-A, he hit .270 with 30 doubles and 12 homers, both career highs. Edmundo had some weird H/R splits this year. But if we want to be optimistic, check out his road numbers in AAA:

    30 games, .314/.361/.533, and an acceptable 8/20 BB/K. (Low walk rates have been his Achilles heel as a pro, in addition to injuries.) He doesn’t turn 23 until early March, so obviously he was young for the PCL.

    I have him 12th in the StL farm system, and roughly 220th overall. Like Arozarena & Urias & Lane Thomas, Sosa’s 2019 Memphis season should tell us a great deal about his future.

    in reply to: MLB announces pace of play changes #76063
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “You should be able to position your players as you see fit. Don’t like it, hit where they ain’t.”

    Amen, 315. Don’t like the shift? Learn to bunt. If pitchers can learn to bunt, regular hitters can. (The mistake that John Mabry made with Matt Adams, was that Mabry tried to train Adams to slap liners and hard grounders to the opposite field, and that is extremely difficult to do on command, unless you’re Rod Carew or Tony Gwynn. Bunting is much, much easier.)

    The whippersnappers out there, and I guess Rob Manfred is somehow one of them, do not seem to understand that the shift was always a possibility. It’s not like nobody was ever shifted on before — just ask Ted Williams’ chipped frozen head when he thaws out. Despite what you might read at Fangraphs, the “analytics generation” didn’t invent shifting because they’re just so much smarter than all those who came before them.

    The reason there was little or no shifting for decades, was that even the sluggers like Mike Schmidt and Steve Garvey most notably, possessed at least a rudimentary ability to drop a bunt down — if you played them waaay back at third base, or gave them the entire left side of the infield.

    Ban the shift? Learn to bunt, lazybones.

    in reply to: Bryce Harper thread #76060
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Bob, do you think there’s any chance that the bullpen can improve naturally? That is, without making a bunch of additions? With better health from the expected rotation, we could see Gant, Gomber, Poncedeleon and Reyes added to the pen. Better health from Leone (who has been very good at times), and a bit of maturity from Hicks and Hudson…it has to be at least within the realm of possibility that they could be average or better through some better luck, right?

    Good question, Mr. Lankford.
    I’m almost sure the bullpen would indeed improve naturally — just like 33-year-old Dexter Fowler will undoubtedly bounce part of the way back to his old self in 2019.

    But improve from worst or nearly worst in the league, all the way to average? I think that’s unreasonably optimistic. (For both the bullpen and Dexter.)

    The Cards had zero relievers in 2018 who posted a sub-3.00 ERA over at least 35 innings. Every other team in the N.L. Central had between 3 and 5 such pitchers. Heck, the last place Reds had 3 guys with a sub-2.60 and 60+ innings! The Cardinals do not have a single excellent reliever on their roster. None.

    On the other hand, there are non-competitive American League teams with excellent young relievers, and bad contracts the Cards could take off their hands. Baltimore has Mychal Givens and Paul Fry, and bad contracts in Mark Trumbo and especially Alex Cobb. Detroit has flamethrowing phenom Joe Jimenez who is just starting to mature as a major leaguer, and they also have Jordan Zimmermann’s really rotten contract. The Twins have southpaw bullpenner Taylor Rogers and the underwater contracts of Jason Castro and Addison Reed.

    I feel strongly that The Cards should sign Yusei Kikuchi (he’ll be rotation or bullpen, however things shake out in Spring Training), then leverage their remaining “Harper money” by taking on some portion of 2 or 3 of the aforementioned bad contracts, in order to acquire several years of control of multiple excellent relief pitchers. By taking on bad contracts, they theoretically wouldn’t have to give up much in the way of prospects either. (Or if the Cards were to surrender meaningful talent, then their trade partner would eat more of the bad contract dollars. Either way is fine.)

    They tried a patch-as-you-go approach last year, supplemented by some over-the-hill free agents. It was objectively an abject disaster. It’s time to go for relief talent that’s in or entering its prime. Not big names and big price tags on the wrong side of 30, like Miller or Britton or Kimbrel.

    in reply to: Bryce Harper thread #76050
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    After three straight years of the Cards missing the playoffs, why would anyone think they need to improve in just one area – whether right field or relief? Is there some reason to “put all their eggs in one basket”, to use BDW III’s term?

    Before the offseason began, I was in favor of adding Donaldson, Kikuchi, and 2 or 3 relievers via trade. But I was very much against Harper, Machado, Moustakas, and pretty much every other position player, because none of them offered the heft of plausible upgrade that Donaldson did, on such a short contract, to boot.

    But now that Donaldson is off the table, I do think the Cards should put all their eggs in the bullpen basket. Because of the principle I cited a few posts ago:

    Improving any aspect of a baseball team from very good to great is difficult and expensive. That’s what the Birds are trying to do if they focus on the lineup.

    Improving from rotten to merely average is much easier and much cheaper. That’s what the Cards need to do with the wretched bullpen.

    Any offense can be improved upon, at any time. But this team has one real *need*, and that’s the bullpen. Dead last in the N.L. in Win Probability Added in 2018. Third from last in ERA. Awful first half, awful second half, and a 5.09 September ERA. They NEED an overhaul in the bullpen, not a star bat.

    in reply to: Bryce Harper thread #75981
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Statements like these drive me nuts. When talking about $/Win, that is a load of ______. Assembling a baseball team is PORTFOLIO THEORY, it is not INDIVIDUAL ASSET PRICING.

    You’ve introduced some investment/economics jargon, which is fine. But if you would like to rebut anything I said, about the Cardinals, Bryce Harper, or how the St. Louis team needs to build their talent base, please do so with specifics. Thanks.

    The Cardinals can spend right up to the luxury tax and still be profitable.

    I don’t care how much profit the Cards make, not even a little. But I am certain that they operate within a payroll budget every single year. And thus, it is imperative that the club be efficient, in order to maximize wins. That’s all I care about, maximizing wins — but they cannot do that, unless they are generally efficient with their resources. Talent accrual only works when you don’t overpay.

    Here’s what I mean. Let’s say tomorrow’s Post-Dispatch headline reads: “Cards trade for Mike Trout! Contract extension of ten years included as part of deal!” Best of all possible news, right?

    But then you read the article and find out that the Cards traded Flaherty, Reyes, Hicks, Mikolas, Bader, O’Neill, and DeJong, to acquire Trout. And the contract extension is for 10 years and $900M.

    As exciting and great as Trout is, this would be a terribly self-destructive overpay by the Cards, in terms of both talent and money.

    Take your WORST positions, and try to upgrade them EVERY year. Last year, the WORST position was right field. DUMP DEXTER FOWLER.

    Couldn’t agree more, about dumping Fowler. But as mentioned in my earlier remarks, Harper does not upgrade RF by nearly enough, not when compared to either Tyler O’Neill or Jose Martinez, who both look to be worth at least 2 WAR this year, and in the case of O’Neill quite possibly much more than that.

    Then beyond this season, after Ozuna departs there’s more 2+ WAR outfield talent down on the farm. Dylan Carlson in particular.

    in reply to: Bryce Harper thread #75979
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    I do not want Harper, not at anything more than $25M per year. He’s been a 4.5 f-WAR player for his career, and 4 WAR at B-Ref. This means that if he is supplanting a 2 WAR player in the outfield, he is only going to be adding 2-2.5 wins per year. That’s a cost of $10-12M per win if you got him for just $25M per year — and we already know that no one is getting Harper for $25M a year.

    This is not a small point, about who Harper dislodges from the outfield. Harper might be “worth” the free agent price for some organizations, if he went to a place with a truly rotten MLB outfield and lousy farm system. But neither is remotely the case in St. Louis. (Heck, the Cards have so many average-or-better outfielders both now and for the future, they had to trade three of them away, in Piscotty, Pham, and Grichuk.)

    A team at St. Louis’ player payroll level cannot pay more than $10-12M per wins on the open market. It just doesn’t work. They need to be decidedly more efficient than that, as they were when they signed Final Boss and Miles Mikolas. And as they were when they traded Jon Jay for Jedd Gyorko. Those three moves have added victories to the team at a cost of roughly $3M per win upgrade.

    Of course, $3M per win upgrade is more of a best case scenario, rather than a realistic standard. Maybe $6-7M per win upgrade would be a plausible goal, on the free agent market. And a Harper contract has no chance whatever of meeting that goal. If the Birds want to go big, really big, they should wait for Trout in two years. Even at $55-60M per year, he might be a relative bargain.

    One other thing, is that I honestly don’t understand the premise in the first place, that St. Louis MUST add any offense at all. They were 4th in the N.L. in runs per game at 4.7, and the hitting was actually better than that, because they played in a nasty pitcher’s park.

    The St. Louis road OPS was 67 points higher than at home. They homered 47% more often on the road. They doubled/tripled 27% more often. In fact, in the National League only the Dodgers had a higher OPS on the road.

    Finally, they scored 5.1 runs per game over the second half, after dumping Mabry/Matheny/Mueller. (They scored just 4.4. per game with M/M/M.) So it’s already at least a very good offensive lineup.

    Improving any aspect of a baseball team from very good to great is difficult and expensive. That’s what the Birds are trying to do if they focus on the lineup.
    Improving from rotten to merely average is much easier and much cheaper. That’s what the Cards need to do with the wretched bullpen.

    in reply to: Yusei Kikuchi free agent thread #75964
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Thanks much, CC!

    in reply to: Yusei Kikuchi free agent thread #75853
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    I have a real good feeling about this young guy. And at 27 he is substantially younger than most MLB free agent pitchers ever are.

    In a very general sense, I see a lefty version of Jack Flaherty. Above average velocity for a southpaw, fine slider for a strikeout pitch, and a usable hook. Could be a #2/3 starter for less dough than Mike Leake received 3 years ago. With Boras it should be a pure bidding war — and with this guy you could win a winter bidding war and STILL call it a bargain. Go get him, Mo.

    Is there anyplace on the internet for Japanese park factors? If it weren’t for bad luck I’d have had no luck at all, in my searching. Anybody helps me out on this, they go straight to the Nice List, I’m sure of it. (I ask because Kikuchi’s team over the past 4 or 5 years always seems to score lots of runs, and be mediocre or worse in team ERA. So I’m thinking hitter’s park. And that could of course mean that Yusei might be even better than his stellar track record implies.)

    in reply to: Malcom Nunez #75852
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Thanks so much for the generous words, Pugs.
    When I re-read my posts, I feel they are like life itself. Lengthy and tedious, but punctuated by boredom.
    I do try not to sound too strident in my indictments of other so-called prospect evaluators, but I’d rather be blunt and thorough than just scratch surfaces.

    It would really be something if Malcom Nunez got to Peoria in 2019, but as the song says, one never knows. I get to a few Peoria games every year, and I’m very much looking forward to some of the Redbird talent on the way. Gorman to start the year, and maybe Jhon Torres, perhaps Ivan Herrera, almost certainly Leandro Cedeno. Not a lot of young pitching, I’m afraid. But bats galore.

    Take it easy, Pugs.

    in reply to: Malcom Nunez #75810
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Malcom Nunez hit more homers in 164 at-bats than 10 different DSL teams did.
    He hit more homers than the combined totals of the two DSL Royals teams in 4,399 AB’s.

    “Bottom line is there is a lot to be excited about.”

    Not according to Fangraphs. They don’t think there’s anything at all to be excited about. They rank Nunez 28th in what they consider a below average St. Louis farm system. Their writeup includes nothing about Nunez winning his league Triple Crown, much less the fact that he did so while missing nearly 40% of the season.

    Also nothing about how Nunez dominated the Cuban youth leagues, and also dominated competitions on behalf of Cuba against his international age peers. (You know, the kind of stuff that made Bryce Harper a Sports Illustrated cover boy in High School.) A guy who hits .415 and has a “cannon arm” or “huge arm” depending on who you read, gets a 55 grade from Fangraphs on his hit tool, and a 55 for throwing. Really odd. But here, you can read them in their own words:

    “Already to be taken with a healthy grain of salt, DSL numbers are often faulty when the prospect in question is more physically mature than his peers, and the hefty Nuñez is a classic case. He will likely need to move to first base, perhaps even while he’s still in the minors, putting a ton of pressure on his admittedly prodigious bat to fully actualize. There’s not much physical projection here, so the raw power Nuñez currently has is pretty close to what he’ll have at peak, meaning the bat-to-ball component is what will drive his stock going forward.”

    A lot of half-truths and nonsense to wade through there. First, DSL numbers are often faulty when the prospects are older than their peers. Age is the key, not the physique. It is actually a good thing to be strong. Always a good thing.

    Nunez is not “hefty.” Nunez is powerful for his age, not unlike Nolan Gorman, with a strong base.

    Shifting from 3rd base to first base would not put a ton of pressure on his bat. Over the past three years the average MLB 1st baseman posted an OPS just 26 points higher than the average 3rd baseman. Now, fifteen or twenty years ago there was indeed a much bigger gap between the two. Specifically, from 1997-2002 the gap was over 80 points per year of OPS, separating the hot and cold corners. But no more.

    There is no such thing as a 17-year-old who is “pretty close” to their power peak. There never has been and never will be. This baloney reminds me of Baseball America’s dismissive writings about Jack Flaherty, when they omitted him from their Midwest League top 20 list a few years back.

    They said Flaherty was “not projectable” because he grew up in California and played a lot of travel ball. Of course that was complete malarkey, as 99.9% of teenage pitchers who are 6′ 4″ and 195 pounds have plenty of time to grow, and room to grow. And no surprise whatsoever, Jack has filled out over the past three years and added 2 or 3 ticks to his fastball.

    Anyway, back to Nunez. Based on their rankings from last year, when 321 players were graded 45’s and above, and 739 guys were graded 40 and above, the estimated Fangraphs ranking for Malcom Nunez right now would be roughly 630th, as he’s in the bottom third of the Redbird grade 40 prospects.

    Well it could be worse. At least he’s not Joerlin De Los Santos. Per Fangraphs, Nunez is merely too strong. De Los Santos is both too strong AND too fast, so he’s graded much, much lower than Nunez. I’ll bet you never knew that strength and speed were such liabilities for ballplayers, huh?

    in reply to: Cooperstown Class of 2019 #75801
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Joe Posnanski sounds confused.

    The museum portion of the Hall Of Fame does indeed already tell the complete, sprawling, flawed, sometimes ugly story of baseball. I’m lucky enough to have been to Cooperstown, and they don’t hide the steroid era in the basement under lock and key.

    We needn’t bestow baseball’s highest honor on a handful of extremely successful drug cheats in order to acknowledge all of baseball’s complex history. I see it this way: No one in their right mind has suggested that Marion Jones be inducted in the Track and Field Hall of Fame, or Lance Armstrong be inducted in the Biking Hall Of Fame. (Yes, such places do exist.) These individuals are rightly viewed as a disgrace to their sport — and sports in general. There has never at any moment been a debate about this.

    And yet, plenty of otherwise reasonable people drape themselves in misplaced sentimentality and pine to see baseball’s most effective drug cheats honored alongside Mays and Mantle, Koufax and Gibson, Brock and Broglio. (Oops, that’s right. Broglio didn’t quite get there. Sorry, Cub fans.)

    in reply to: What is wrong with Dexter Fowler and what should be done? #75729
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “RR, Fowler’s hard contact % was actually up last season and his k% in ’18 was sitting right on his career avg. Doesn’t sound like a guy getting dominated.

    You showed OPS from your research to show “results”. I want to mention a .120 pt career BA drop, on balls in play in ’18, that I believe led to those OPS results. I doubt Fowler could repeat his 2018, even if he tried.”

    First, thanks for responding, JJ. And please call me Bob. (That’s goes for everybody here, please.)
    I’m glad you mentioned the very modern metric of “hard contact %” because I’ve been meaning to cite Dexter Fowler’s terrible underlying contact numbers in 2018, but then forgot and never got around to it. I apologize if I’m about to simply repeat something that’s already been said in this thread.

    Out of 332 qualified batters, Dexter Fowler ranked all the way down at 287th in average exit velocity, and 285th in frequency of barreling the baseball. So for me there’s no compelling reason to think he was particularly unlucky in 2018. Quite the contrary. Link to stats: https://baseballsavant.mlb.com/statcast_leaderboard

    Now, I do agree wholeheartedly that Dexter won’t be as awful in 2019 at the plate — in part because John Mabry has been let go and the new hitting coaches are bound to be better. Specifically, I would guess that Fowler will have an OPS in the low-mid .700’s, which would be a massive bounceback, and still leave him a liability as an everyday player due to his dismal defense.

    Somewhere between replacement level and a 1-win guy per 600 PA’s, is what I’d guess Dex will be. Again, a huge improvement over 2018, but nevertheless still unplayable when you’re trying to make the postseason. I have nothing against Fowler in absolute terms; if the Cards didn’t have a 23-year-old outfielder who slugged .700 in AAA last year, I’d be fine with giving the 33-year-old Fowler another 150-200 plate appearances to see what’s left in the tank. But the Cards actually DO have such an outfielder, and young guys need consistent playing time to thrive and grow.

    in reply to: The Front Office's place in all of this chaos. #75703
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Thanks for the response, but with all due respect C-2016, I think we are simply arguing at cross purposes.

    That’s because I am only contending that the Heyward trade worked out spectacularly well from the Cardinal point of view, and that therefore there’s absolutely no reason whatsoever for any fans here or anybody within the Redbird organization itself to regret said trade. And thus there’s no real reason to avoid a repeat in the future. I’m not arguing motives, intentions, or even front office acumen. Only arguing results.

    The Birds got a great year of production from Jason, a year they needed every single bit of, and they got it for cheap dollars, and afterwards they got a high draft pick who’s looking REAL good so far as a pro. And the Cubs lost a high draft pick, and overpaid by tens of millions for a player who has melted down from Frosty to a snowball.

    If you want to argue that the Braves did very well also, because they got an excellent season from Shelby before flipping him to Arizona, then I agree 100%, no question. The Braves did do very well. But to me that in no way undercuts how terrific the deal has turned out for St. Louis.

    The Cubs are the dumb front office in all of this Heyward talk. Just as the Cards are the dumb one when it comes to Dexter Fowler. (Also by the way, I think you’re going to like Dakota Hudson for a long time. Usual health provisos apply.)

    At any rate, even if the Cards can get Goldschmidt for a reasonable cost in prospects, I would not love the deal — because I don’t want Carp moving back to third base. But I do think it would probably upgrade the club by a couple of wins, for a year. And if you make the trade, then you should let Goldy go next winter, and take the high draft pick. Because you’ll pay through the nose for past production if you keep him into his late 30’s.

    The question is, exactly whom would you trade, for Goldy?

    in reply to: 2019 TCN top 50 prospect list countdown #75688
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “I would assume the Cardinals have limited Cabrera’s winter league innings, but he has been dynamite in relief so far.”

    I agree, C-27, about keeping a starter a starter when possible. And as a Genesis Cabrera skeptic, my curiosity is nevertheless piqued — but I only see a couple of AA/AAA relief appearances, other than maybe postseason. Did you mean that he’s been mowing them down out of the bullpen in winter ball? Thanks for any insights or stats!

    Also, and this comment is directed toward no one in particular, I want to belatedly mention a couple of facts about prospect #32 from a few days back, Leandro Cedeno.

    In 2018 there were 2,172 minor leaguers with at least 200 plate appearances. Just 25 of them posted an OPS over 1.000, and only 8 of those batters were NOT old for their leagues. One of those 8 was Leandro Cedeno, my #15 Cardinal prospect, and roughly the 250th best prospect in the game, for me.

    Fangraphs disagrees. They considering Cedeno entirely irrelevant, giving him no grade at all, which leaves him somewhere outside of their top 1,000 or so prospects. They do list a handful of the ungraded Cardinal farmhands, like Terry Fuller and Patrick Wisdom and Johan Mieses, as “power-only profiles.” But they inexplicably lump Cedeno in with those guys, despite Leandro’s exceptional batting line this year of .336/.419/.592.

    You can say that a .336 hitter is “power-only” if you want. It makes you look stupid, but you can say it. But if you wish to be taken seriously as a prospect evaluator, I believe you absolutely DO need to provide some rationale. The thing is, they have zero comments about Cedeno in their Cardinal overview. Nada. A teenager with a 1.000 OPS, and nothing to say. (I count 17 other similar examples of weirdness from Fangraphs re Redbird prospects. It would get pretty tedious to list them all, but in the future I’ll mention some of them as the situation calls for.)

    in reply to: What is wrong with Dexter Fowler and what should be done? #75596
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    First thing, let’s see Why Dexter can’t hit.

    Baseball-Reference has divided the batting records of all hitters into three categories of opposing pitcher: power, average, and finesse. Until he hit his early 30’s, Dexter Fowler did okay against all three types of pitcher. In fact, he was almost exactly the same against each category, with an OPS in the .760’s or .770’s versus each type.

    Then at age 31 in 2017 he struggled against the power pitchers, posting a .635 OPS.

    And at 32 in 2018 he collapsed completely v. power arms, with just a lowly .443 OPS.

    So what should we expect from him at age 33? It seems to me that the Cardinal front office must at least consider the possibility that Fowler is now un-usable at the MLB level, period. He’s not a defensive sub, and he gripes when he doesn’t start, so he can’t be your 4th outfielder. His so-called batting “improvements” after the firing of Matheny/Mabry included an OPS still well under .700, and that is unplayable at even 5th outfielder, since Fowler is already a defensive liability and getting slower every day.

    It’s great that Fowler was a good teammate toward Bader, full marks for that. But as of several weeks ago Dexter quite publicly continued to blame Matheny and not himself for his inability to hit his weight in 2018. In the well-worn modern parlance, Fowler has never “owned” his awful 2018 season. And to me, that is unprofessional. So because of the on-and-off field stuff, they can’t release him fast enough for my tastes.

    And it costs nothing to replace him! No need to spend a third of a billion dollars on Bryce Harper; just put Tyler O’Neill in right field. Problem solved. Jose Martinez, Jose Adoilis Garcia, maybe Yairo Munoz or even Lane Thomas. Some combination of those guys can likely cover the responsibilities of the 4th & 5th outfielder.

    in reply to: The Front Office's place in all of this chaos. #75592
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    I must be missing something.

    The Cards traded Shelby Miller for Heyward. Miller in the 4 years since has thrown a total of just 344 innings and compiled an 11-35 record with a 4.36 ERA, for 2.7 Baseball-Reference WAR (just over 4 WAR at Fangraphs). He has cost $14M.5 in salary. So that’s Miller. Nobody can seriously wish he’d been in St. Louis, accruing less than 1 WAR per year.

    On the other hand, in his one season for St. Louis, Jason Heyward had 6.6 WAR per B-Ref, or 5.6 at Fangraphs. In other words, irrefutably a great, great season. A good bat in right field, excellent baserunning, and, well, we all saw the Clemente range and Colavito arm.

    And for that truly outstanding Heyward season, the Cards paid less than 8 million bucks. So the trade was a freaking steal. (And furthermore, the Cards needed every one of those wins, as they finished just 2 games ahead of the Pirates, and 3 in front of the Cubs.)

    And then the Cards got Dakota Hudson with the draft pick! And what happened to Heyward? The despised rival Cubs threw away nearly $200M by signing him, and lost their own high draft pick in the bargain! This is the kind of thing a Cardinal fan asks Santa for.

    I submit that the Heyward trade merely in and of itself, and especially with all that came after — the draft picks gained and lost, Heyward’s collapse in Chicago — is one of the Redbird front office triumphs of the past thirty or forty years. And it’s supposed to be a source of regret?

    Did I want Heyward retained, after his exceptional 2015 season? Yup, you bet I did. And I sure HATED losing him to the Cubs. But I was wrong. Or maybe I was sorta right, and Heyward’s bat would not have collapsed had he remained in St. Louis. We’ll never know. But the actual, factual results of the trade have been spectacular in just about every possible way!

    (As much as I ridicule John Mabry, he absolutely gets credit for Jedd Gyorko’s blossoming in St. Louis, and at least partial credit for Heyward’s solid season at the plate. Heyward didn’t have a “breakout” in St. Louis, but Mabry certainly coaxed much much more out of the J-Hey Kid than the Cubs coaches have managed to do.)

    in reply to: 2019 TCN top 50 prospect list countdown #75495
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Bob, you dont see O’Neill has top 100?”

    Fair question, CC. I was using the MLB rookie guidelines, for both O’Neill and Carson Kelly. That’s why neither appeared on my list.

    Here are the Davenport 6-year mean MLB projections (per 600 plate appearances) for Tyler O’Neill, plus three of the most well-known young prospects:

    2019 O’Neill 3.6 WAR, Victor Robles 3.4, Vlad Guerrero Jr. 3.1, Eloy Jimenez 2.8

    2020 O’Neill 3.9, Robles 3.8, Vlad 3.3, Eloy 3.1

    2021 O’Neill 4.0, Robles 4.0, Vlad 3.7, Eloy 3.3

    2022 Robles 4.2, Vlad 3.9, O’Neill 3.7, Eloy 3.5

    2023 Robles 4.4, Vlad 4.2, O’Neill 3.7, Eloy 3.6

    2024 Vlad 4.6, Robles 3.8, Eloy 3.8, O’Neill 3.2

    You can see why I don’t want to wait, when it comes to O’Neill. The computer says play him right now. While Davenport’s algorithms obviously have a crush on Tiny Kingman, just like every other prospect ranker I would not consider O’Neill to be at the same level as the other three.

    But unlike the other sources, I do consider him fairly close, CC. I would have ranked Tyler somewhere in the 20-25 range probably. Definitely the #1 Cardinal prospect if eligible. His career track record is quite comparable to Eloy, a consensus top 5 prospect, once you include O’Neill’s defense & baserunning advantages. (For me Eloy is top 10, not top 5.)

    It’s really a fascinating foursome. Robles has the best balance of skills, but has been hurt, and appears to lack anything even approaching the power potential of the other three. Vlad is a crazy-talented hitter, maybe another Miguel Cabrera. But he also has Cabrera’s age 35 physique. At age 19. And Eloy is a big stick, might be a Triple Crown threat some day. But also might be genuinely, truly bad in the outfield, a liability so severe that he must be moved from even a corner slot by age 25. O’Neill could be Canadian Khris Davis, but with better baserunning and glovework.

    in reply to: 2019 TCN top 50 prospect list countdown #75481
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    You’re welcome, Brian. It’s baseball. Try and STOP me from rambling on about baseball! (Helsey got hurt, and I don’t like Cabrera’s command. I’m fond of Reyes and Hudson — Alex Reyes hadn’t shown such superior streikezone control like he did in his rehab starts, since way back in his final month of Low-A ball, when he posted a 38/6 K/BB in 25 innings — and I think Angel Rondon looked real good when I saw him, still throwing 93/94 in the 6th inning. But you’re right, I don’t generally like the StL pitching right now. In terms of raw upside, the farmhand hitters are the best in memory. But more organizational balance would be better.)

    “I suspect that if you went through the prospects in the other 29 systems at the depth in which you analyze Cardinals, you would find dozens more Uriases out there – overlooked gems (following your process).”

    Depending on how one chooses to define “overlooked,” there are indeed quite a few out there — but the important point is that they are NOT distributed evenly across all organizations. Not by a long shot.

    I know, because last winter I performed that very exercise, examining for the first time all position prospects grade C or better at John Sickels’ website. It was 949 batters. And I checked each one, their raw track records in terms of hitting and defense, and if available their Davenport computer model projections, and also KATOH when possible.

    Some teams had many such gems, while other organizations (sorry, Marlins and Angels) were virtually bereft. By the way, according to Clay Davenport’s computer back then, Elehuris Montero already projected as an excellent hitter, a 3-win first baseman in his prime, if he played scratch defense at the position.

    “To the best of my recollection, Garcia was never in a national top 100, nor should he have been. I hope Urias does better than that and he could. Scouting and projecting is about informed guesses. There is no right or wrong until the players reach their summit.”

    Actually, that’s the funny thing about Greg Garcia. He’s been worth about 3-3.5 WAR for his career, which is coincidentally precisely how productive the average grade 50 position prospect has been over his first 6 or 7 MLB seasons, according to the very recent Craig Edwards Fangraphs study. (A grade 50 is someone ranked anywhere between 50th and 150th or so, per Fangraphs. So the average grade 50 would thus be ranked as a borderline top 100. So it would appear that Greg should have been ranked as a borderline top 100 after all. Maybe right after his excellent AA season, when at age 22 he posted a .408 on base percentage and a 137 wRC+)

    Here’s a link to the Edwards study that contains the analysis: https://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/an-update-to-prospect-valuation/

    in reply to: 2019 TCN top 50 prospect list countdown #75394
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Thanks for the response, Brian.
    But I don’t think I said that the ceiling for Ramon Urias was MLB reserve. What I said (or meant to say anyway) was that I thought his likeliest MLB contribution would specifically be at the level of Greg Garcia, circa 2015-17. Sorry if I misled you. The internet: where misunderstandings go to flourish.

    At any rate, Greg Garcia for those 3 years was worth 3.3 WAR at BPro, 2.7 at Fangraphs, and 3.1 at B-Ref. Not a ton of raw WAR of course, but that was accumulated just one full season’s worth of plate appearances, or a little more. That’s an excellent bench guy or borderline starter on a playoff team. I think that’s what he’ll probably be.

    The ceiling for Urias on the other hand would be to maintain that level of 2.5-3.0 WAR performance over an entire season, for 3-5 years. In other words a nice solid Jon Jay/David Freese/Allen Craig level of starting major leaguer, someone who’ll potentially accrue 12-15 WAR in his career. Something of that nature. That level of reasonable potential indicates a top 100 type, or on the border.

    Or to put it another way, Keston Hiura is a second baseman and consensus top prospect. fangraphs just gave him a grade 60 yesterday, and last year they gave out only 23 grades of 60 or higher. Hiura’s pro career as a whole gives him a fine Davenport Peak projection of .275/.322/.462.

    Ramon Urias (mostly a 2B) has a Davenport Peak slash of .264/.336/.417, equivalent to .264/.322/.442. So Hiura is projected roughly half a win better on offense. But the thing of it is, per Davenport’s website Urias projects to be much the superior keystone defender.

    So much so that their 2019 projections for MLB are 2.6 WAR per 600 PA’s for Urias, and barely 1 WAR for Hiura. And remember, I’m not personally arguing in any way, shape, or form that Urias is remotely as good a prospect as Hiura. (Even though Davenport’s computer model obviously has Urias distinctly better than Hiura.)

    Nope. All I’m saying is that Urias is a borderline top 100. I am being extremely pessimistic, relative to Davenport’s projection for Ramon — a projection based on everything, Triple-A, Double-A, the Mexican League seasons.

    Remember in school when they said “show your math”? There’s my math, good sir.

    Here’s how I rank the top Redbird prospects, with (estimated) national rankings in parentheses. Oh, but before I do this, let’s briefly recap a few former Cardinal prospects who were never at any time on anyone’s top 100 list at BA, BPro, MLB.com, Keith Law, or Fangraphs. That would be Yadi Molina, Matt Carpenter, Lance Lynn, Dan Haren, Tommy Pham, Allen Craig, Jon Jay, Harrison Bader, David Freese, Jordan Hicks, Dakota Hudson (so far), and Paul DeJong. That’s top-of-my-head, so I apologize to anyone I’ve forgotten. In any case, Brian, you can see why a long time ago I ceased deferring to professional prospect “experts.” They are nearly valueless when it comes to Cardinal prospects. The track record for the experts stinks.

    Alex Reyes (35)
    Elehuris Montero (40)
    Dakota Hudson (50)
    Nolan Gorman (55)
    Andrew Knizner (65)
    Dylan Carlson (90)
    Ramon Urias (100)
    Malcom Nunez (100)

    For me the fun part is the articulating — or defending, if you prefer — of these rankings, and all other prospect rankings, Cardinals or otherwise. (Keston Hiura for me is top 40 for instance, not top 20.) So please feel free to inquire about any of the above, or any others who couldn’t crack the top 100 or thereabouts.

    in reply to: Sickels let go #75393
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    Most insightful, even-handed, and entertaining prospect coverage on the internet. (Except of course for Cardinal coverage, where the gold standard is right here.)

    Forget the high-profile places like MLB.com, BA, BPro, and Fangraphs. Rob Ozga for the amateur players and Sickels for the professionals — they’re the best around.

    in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #75380
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    If DeJong moves to third base, he just duplicates Gyorko. Here are their 2016-2018 numbers:

    DeJong .263/.319/.482 for a 111 wRC+
    Gyorko .259/.331/.463 for a 111 wRC+

    And here’s Brandon Crawford over those same 3 years: .261/.325/.409 and a paltry 94 wRC+

    For the hot corner, if you can’t get a guy with true star potential (like Donaldson would have been) then I say just go with Jedd Gyorko. Even with his HR’s declining, he’s still been a slightly above average bat every single year with the Cards. He’s fine, boring, solid. As good as or better than Mike Moustakas at the plate, and in the field, and on the bases. Better on the bases, in fact.

    If Jedd only plays 125-130 games, that’s hardly a scandal. Fowler has averaged 126 for his career, and Bryce Harper just 132. No one says they aren’t full-time players.

    When a team’s going great, the fans naturally tend to overvalue their individual players. Average guys seem good, good guys look great. And so it’s predictable, inevitable that the opposite happens when a team is disappointing their fans — like the Cards have done lately. Everyone from Matt Carpenter to Carlos Martinez now has very vocal internet critics, if not enemies. Everyone in the organization is a liability somehow, everyone’s to blame for the 3-year playoff drought. We’re fans, and we’re stupid.

    in reply to: 2019 TCN top 50 prospect list countdown #75375
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    I have Ramon Urias as a borderline top 100 overall prospect, and 7th/8th among Cardinals, neck and neck with Malcom Nunez. Struggled at AAA, but truly dominated AA — and in his first shot at American professional competition.

    I think he’s going to hit, and the defense & baserunning shouldn’t be a liability. Although his batting will take a much different shape from Greg Garcia’s, I think Ramon will provide overall value roughly equivalent to Greg’s excellent 2015-2017 self. And a future great bench player warrants a borderline top 100 slot.

    Nice extended blurb from the Commish today, about a Urias’ 3-homer game on Wednesday. Link: https://www.stltoday.com/sports/baseball/professional/cardinal-beat/cardinals-mighty-mite-ramon-urias-smacks-three-homers-in-mexican/article_3dc9926b-fcd7-572d-8db0-ee90166e3183.html

    in reply to: What is wrong with Dexter Fowler and what should be done? #75371
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    “Fowler is a negative influence and poor example for the younger players. The Cards need to find a way to trade him, even if they have to give up several mid level prospects in the deal.”

    I would partly concur, cranny. Certainly Fowler’s unprofessional whining about being benched last year sets a poor example. But the front office caving to him in a sense, while firing Matheny, might be a worse signal to the team in general. (Psst, Mabry was the problem, folks, not the manager. Well, Mabry plus the rotten free agents of the past two years. Even Miles Mikolas, Bud Norris, and Final Boss couldn’t counterbalance the horror of Fowler, Holland, Gregerson, and Cecil. That toxic quartet is very likely going to wind up collectively giving the team negative WAR at a total cost of about $140,000,000.)

    But Fowler, who was ridiculed repeatedly in the Post-Dispatch and elsewhere for being the “last to arrive, first to leave” the ballpark, was the last to arrive for a reason. He was last because he was taking extra time every single day working on his own with a personal trainer before coming to the ballpark. Ironic ain’t it, that it was his dedication that created the illusion that he didn’t work hard enough?

    No need to trade him, no need to give any prospects away. Just do what the Red Sox did with Fat Panda. Dump him and don’t look back. Put Tyler O’Neill in right field, take your 35-40 homers, and smile, smile, smile.

    in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #75307
    Bob Reed
    Participant

    Free

    JMartinez for Taylor Rogers for openers.

    Amen, C-27. A well above average DH who makes very little money, for an excellent non-closer bullpen arm who also makes no dough? That sounds just about right.

    Rogers had struggled v. righties before last year, but in 2018 he allowed them just a .643 OPS. And lefty bats had 110 plate appearances, and zero extra base hits.

Viewing 25 posts - 951 through 975 (of 1,091 total)

First-hand news and commentary on the St. Louis Cardinals™ and minor league system for over 25 years