Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Baker did fizzle last year in 99 PA. Couldn’t hit the ball, couldn’t catch the ball. He probably had the opening night jitters for those 99 PA. He deserves another chance.
August 5, 2024 at 9:47 am in reply to: Do the Cardinals have the needed “hungry to win” mentality? #263108I think what this team lacks is the impact players that bb mentioned earlier. This team doesn’t have a Chris Carpenter or a Mark McGwire, Jim Edmunds, Albert Pujols, Scot Rolen, or even a young and healthy Adam Wainwright or Edgar Renteria. Both Arenado and Goldschmidt, like Manny Machado and Kris Bryant, seem to be over the hill in their early thirties for reasons unknown. This team needs a couple of impact players to give the team the confidence it needs to feel like a winner. It looked like Walker was going to be that kind of player, but not any more. Eventually Winn, Burleson, Wetherholt, Hence, Matthews could be impact guys, but none of them are there yet. Right now, there’s only one impact player on the whole team and he’s a reliever. I think we can forget about free agents solving the problem because of all the empty seats we are seeing at every game. Basically, the St. Louis Cardinals are now in the same boat as almost every other small market team, and the front office is going to have to work through it. IMO, if the fans would stop worrying about ‘dominating’ and just enjoy the game for what it is, and if ownership would stop issuing insane contracts to players, the whole of the game would be a better experience for everybody.
Pham has been with 8 different teams. Doesn’t that say something about the guy? The Cardinals drafted him in 2006 and futz around with him and his various physical impairments including his back and his eyes for
8 years. Then, when he finally started looking like he was ready to give something back, he jumped ship via free agency and badmouthed the organization on the way out. I’m inclined to agree that they got Pham to fill Carlson’s role. If Carlson is about to get traded, it must be a trade that they really like in order to be willing to take on a player like Pham.BTW, I wasn’t aware or the ‘tea cup’ metaphor, so for those who didn’t think to look it up, here it is.
If Edman is traded, that pretty much guarantees that Carlson will stay.
Siani is the biggest surprise for me. I never thought he would hit as well as he has. It took him a couple of months to find his groove. But since the start of June his BA is .280… and his OPS looks like it’s up about 100 points. He just recently turned 25 years old, so it’s too early to say whether he has reached his ceiling.
The only player from this draft that is in Brian’s and Blake’s Top 30 is Wetherholt. Wouldn’t it be crazy if there turned out to be two or more star players that emerged from this odd draft?!
I agree with bb 100%. Let the guys show what they’ve got.
A look at Michael Siani’s offense with respect to BA …..
Career BA – .218
2024 BA – .230BA
2024 (Mar/Apr) .128
2024 (May) .253
2024 (Jun) .291
2024 (thru Jul 21) .243Siani’s BA for May/June/July (Mar/Apr excluded) is .265
Siani had a birthday 5 days ago. He is now 25 year old. It’s still too early to tell what his ceiling is for BA and OBP.
O’Brien manages to survive his first outing since coming off the IL, and gets a save.
July 20, 2024 at 8:40 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #99 thread – Saturday, July 20 at Braves – Game 2 DH #261051Painful to see the venerable Paul Goldschmidt struggling.
Riley O’Brien pitching the ninth for Memphis tonight…. 4 pitches, 4 balls, 1 BB.
July 20, 2024 at 8:30 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #99 thread – Saturday, July 20 at Braves – Game 2 DH #261045Nothing like living on the edge. Good for Leahy (and Oli).
July 20, 2024 at 3:21 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #98 thread – Fri, July 19 at Braves, PPD to Sat Game 1 #261000Hernandez instead of Kittredge with a 2 run lead? Roycroft pitching in the 10th? Pages as the runner at second base in extra innings? Oli really had to dumb down in order to lose this one.
This talk about Wetherholt demanding above slot money is a rumor, and nothing more. Gronky, LACardFan, and bb summed it up well. I doubt that the Cardinals will pay him any more than his slot value of $6.82M. And if they do, it will be very little more. It’s possible that his agent went fishing for over slot money. But, so what?
July 19, 2024 at 3:33 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #98 thread – Fri, July 19 at Braves, PPD to Sat Game 1 #260874Rat and Pugs, thanks for telling about your experiences. I have health issues, too.
Jimmy Crooks is looking pretty good at Springfield. He might make make it up to Memphis this year, especially if Herrera gets traded. Also, Leonardo Bernal is doing pretty well at Peoria. It looks like both Crooks and Bernal will get to the major leagues at some point. Don’t know for how long. Sammy Hernandez was acquired from the Blue Jays for Genesis Cabrerra at the trade deadline last year. He’s at Palm Beach and he’s only 20 years old. Brian and Blake like him. I get the impression that Kross is viewed more as a hitter, not really as a catcher.
Not sure about this. But I think Oli put Edman behind the plate for a couple of innings when the Cards were getting blown out last year or the year before. They can always find somebody in a pinch. Obviously, nobody wants to see Edman or Donovan behind the plate in a meaningful game.
The Cardinals organization doesn’t look like it needs another catcher, especially one that is ‘offense first’ (per Brian). The scouts must like his bat a lot to give him $369K. It will be interesting to see if Kross winds up at first base or in the outfield.
If Edman comes all the way back, I’m okay with letting him play 2B in 2025, and trading Gorman for a high ceiling pitcher over the 2024-2025 offseason. Every now and then, Gorman finds his groove and shows his immense offensive potential. But all those strikeouts make me willing to trade him for the right pitcher. Also, his defense is impressive at times, but there are plays that a really good defensive second baseman, like Tommy Edman, would make that Gorman doesn’t make. Trade Gorman, but there’s a lot of risk because of his potential, so just make sure you get something back with the same potential.
FWIW, Pedro Martinez is listed at 5’11, and incidentally, Tink Hence is now listed at 6’1. I’m pretty sure that Hence was originally listed by Baseball Reference at 5’10.
This is one weird draft. It looks like they’re going to save as much money as they can in order to sign Wetherholt, Dutkanych, and Findlay. It will take extra money to sign Wetherholt, presumably, because Wetherholt knows he can get it if he waits. It will take extra money to sign Dutkanych because he knows that if he comes all the way back from TJ surgery, then pitches another year and shows he’s healthy, he knows he can get more money. The same goes for Jack Findlay who also had TJ surgery. We’ll have to wait and see what actually happens.
FWIW. Jose Altuve is 5’6.
If Edman comes all the way back, I could see shooing Gorman this coming offseason.
July 10, 2024 at 5:44 pm in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2024-2026 #259901I could see Carlson traded for a reliever and a prospect.
Makes sense. Just make sure that the prospect is a high ceiling guy who is already having success. Carlson is on the verge of breaking out.
July 8, 2024 at 10:21 pm in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2024-2026 #259647I don’t understand why Gallegos hasn’t been pitching well this year. In prior years he was good enough to deserve to be in a major league bullpen. It seems possible that there is a team that would take a chance on Gallegos based on his prior years’ performance, and then, the Cardinals could try to fill his spot with a reliable veteran upgrade from outside the system.
I don’t see how they could fit another starting pitcher into the current rotation. With the way Pallante has been pitching in the rotation, it would be a really tough call to send him to the bullpen. That’s not going to happen. There’s no place for a RH bat, either. They’re not going to release Carpenter or Crawford to open roster space for a RH bat.
I think Carlson looks much different at the plate this year than he did in prior years. I think the Carlson we saw at spring training is what he’s going to look like in the future.The Cardinals are going to have to open up a roster spot for Edman, and Carlson looks like the one who will be moved. I just hope they get a really good prospect, or two, for him. And, if Edman has a setback and can’t make ti back this year, then it wouldn’t make sense to trade Carlson.
There might not be much activity by the Cardinals at this year’s trading deadline.
AdM, I admire your intensity. But, the way you often find yourself in an altercation with Shady makes me laugh at times.
Arenado’s contract: 2025 – $32M ($5M paid by Rockies)
2026 – $27M ($5M paid by Rockies)
2027 – $15M
I think Arenado is tradeable.Next year’s infield: 1B Burleson
2B Gorman
SS Winn
3B Donovan
This may lack that ‘veteran’s presence’. But it sheds $53M of payroll ($27M, Arenado and $26M, Goldschmidt)Jose Fermin can play 2B, and he bats RH, and he’s already on the active roster. I’d just as soon see Fermin play regularly if Gorman needs to go down to Memphis and get straightened out.
-
AuthorPosts
