Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
December 20, 2025 at 9:45 am in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2024-2026 #297918
That sure sounds right to me. I want to say something related although not really on topic. And that is, as proven by decades of recurrent negotiations, the owners always lose. They can’t stand the pain of having to eat their overhead, which for the Cardinals is approximately 401 support staff, according to mudville’s last count.. So the owners always, ultimately, give in. The players, on the other hand, have zero overhead. Plus many of them are wealthy in their own right, and if not wealthy, their parents will gladly put them up for as long as necessary. When you think about it, that might be the very reason that it costs so much to go to a baseball game.
Really exciting write-ups on Lin. He signed in July, 2023, and 2025 was kind of a lost year in that Lin had health issues. And that’s not uncommon for a player to have a year like that. So, effectively, Lin has, so far, had one year, 2024, to concentrate on getting better, and he was lights out that year. (As Jack Buck would say on occasion ‘If ya’ wanna’ dance, ya’ gotta’ pay the fiddler’, which, in this case is Brian and Kyle.) What I’m trying to say is it would be nice if we could get some more conversation going on these write-ups.
If he’s hitting at Memphis, he could very well get some major league AB in 2026. I hope so.
stlcard25 – I’m thinking that the Cardinals need to open up 3B for Wetherholt, although I understand that many posters want to Wetherholt at 2B. I get that. But, I think that Arenado’s defense alone could give the Mariners 2 or 3 more wins than anybody else they could put on 3B. Add to that his veteran presence which would mean something, maybe a lot. Finally, Arenado has been my favorite player since he came to St. Louis. I want to see him get a ring. There’s some kind of deal possible that could send Arenado along with Donovan and, possibly, Romero to Seattle without diminishing the return for St. Louis. The two sides just need to get off being afraid to make a mistake and find a deal that’s fair to both sides.
I still think Arenado should be part of the package. The Cardinals could eat $15M and the Mariners could eat $5M this year and defer payment of the remaining $10M or so to the Cardinals over the next year or two. Arenado thrives on winning and fan adulation. That’s why he forced the Rockies to trade him to St. Louis. I remember reading at the time that Matt Holliday told him that playing in St. Louis was like playing in no other place. Holliday’s comment at the time was something like ‘A week night in the middle of August, and playing before a packed stadium of fans reacting to every pitch and every play.’ Hopefully, it will be that way again in St. Louis. I’m sure the smoldering passion for baseball will turn back into that raging fire again.
December 18, 2025 at 9:42 pm in reply to: 2026 Minor League Coaches and Player Development assignments #297856This impressive. The Cardinals appear to be building a player development team that may become the gold standard for player development. If this works out as intended, every prospect and every failing prospect with enough humility to accept guidance should want to tap into the Cardinals’ player development system. Bloom will get credit for this if it works out, but I’m guessing that Cerfolio, with help from others, is the one making it happen.I don’t know what could be more satisfying than salvaging a talented player who somehow got lost in the shuffle.
I get what you’re saying. It makes sense. But if Baez hits at Memphis like he did at Springfield, and if Walker is still striking out so much, and carrying a BA of .215 and an OPS of .584, it’s going to be hard to tolerate. But, then, business is business.
I’m thinking that Joshua Baez will be playing RF by the end of the 2026 season. All the rest that you named look like top 5 to me, also. Hopefully, Brandon Clarke will be up there despite the realistic pessimism about his health. If Ixan Henderson doesn’t reach the majors in 2026, I would expect him to be knocking at the door of the top 5.
I’m all for that idea, CFICT. A thread like that would keep all the reports, and the relevant comments, all in one place where people could easily keep track of ‘minors injury updates/progress’.
Chaim Bloom…So why should we expect anything smart from him?
Can’t argue with that, Bob. But I think most people like the changes he’s been making, particularly with regard to player development and drafting. I wanted to also name some of the personnel that he cherry picked from other organizations. But the only name I could remember was Rob Cerfolio from the Guardians. So I tried to look up the other ones he hired. I didn’t really find the names I was looking for. But, on the Cardinals website, I did find a list of all of the organization’s employees, and the ones I was looking for are, no doubt, on the list somewhere. I’m changing the subject of this post now because I think I made my point, and I want to mention my surprise at the list of employees. I counted 401 people that the Cardinals employ for the sole purpose of entertaining fans by fielding a team of athletes to play baseball. That’s is one heck of an overhead, and it doesn’t even include work done by outside contractors, etc.
https://www.mlb.com/cardinals/team/front-officeThank you. That’s something. But it’s not a very impressive group. I should have said ‘ got real traction for the Cardinals’. With that qualifier Carlos Martinez was the only player that really contributed for the Cardinals. It should be easy for Bloom to improve on that track record. Looking forward to seeing what Bernal, R. Rodriguez, Padilla, and yours and Kyle’s ranked international players, Dos Santos and Hernandez, can eventually contribute to winning for the Cardinals. Thanks for your write up on international. It was very informative and , for mudville, thought provoking.
Reading Brian!s piece on international signings made me wonder when was the last time the Cardinals signed and developed a Spanish speaking international prospect. They do have a few in the pipeline now that are still developing. But I can’t think of one that actually made it to the majors and got real traction.
Matthews will be at Memphis. But he needs to tick up a few MPH, also, and throw like he did in 2024. If he doesn’t, he could drop 10 spots in the Community ranking next offseason.
If Seattle wants to win now rather than be runner up forever, I think acquiring a future HOFer to fill their need at 3B, and a GG winner to fill their need at 2B, and possibly acquire a lock down closer on top of it all would give them a better chance to win now than waiting to see what a couple of their prospects might do. To each his own.
stlcard25 – Thanks for all the time and energy you put into this ranking. You handled it beautifully. Thanks again. It was interesting, fun, and it stimulated lots of us to think and learn more about Cardinals’ prospects. Merry Christmas!
It also makes sense for the Mariners to acquire Arenado. They’re not at all strong at 3B. Arenado could very well be the piece that puts the Mariners over the top. Maybe the Mariners can’t afford to take on as much of Arenado’s salary as the Cardinals are demanding. Or, maybe the Cardinals have a better offer from another team. It’s hard to believe that Dipoto is not jumping all over the prospect of acquiring both Donovan and Arenado. And even though the Mariners have already acquired a left-handed reliever, they could very possibly get Romero in the right deal. If ever there was a deal that was worth the cost for the Mariners, this would have to be it.
CFIC, I don’t see where we’re in any disagreement.
Nigel T – Thanks for posting. I have posted similarly about Arenado but not as thoughtful or as concisely. I’d hate to see him go even though it makes sense. I think if he were traded to a contender, we would see a resurgence in his offense. He could be the missing piece that pushes another team over the top. I don’t know what they will do with Wetherholt if Arenado isn’t traded. But if Arenado stays, I will be happy to see him retire as a Cardinal.
Good point, well said, ATM.
I hope Arenado gets to go some place where he can win a ring. I think he thrives on winning and he thrives on fan support. Wherever he goes he will be loved. And I wouldn’t be surprised to see his bat return. Seattle looks like the perfect fit for him. A package of Arenado and Donovan fills two of the Mariner’s needs, 2B and 3B. Maybe the Cardinals are asking for too much, or maybe the Mariners are asking for too much cash. Who knows? But if something doesn’t pop soon, Donovan will be in Kansas City.
net gain of $25,000 to Bill and the team
That cost has changed. It now costs $100K to sign a Rule 5 player and $50K to buy him back if he doesn’t work out for the acquiring team.
Something about the Rule 5 is weird. If the player is good enough to get drafted in the Rule 5, the fans want him back. But if he’s not good enough to stick with the acquiring team, it makes the player’s former team, and maybe the fans, too, wonder if it’s worth it to give back half of that $100K that they got for the player in the Rule 5.
I’m going to see if I can find the phone number for the Rays front office. I’m going to talk them into giving ME 15 millions bucks. I bet they’ll do it. These Winter Meetings have turned into a clown show. Now lets see what happens this afternoon with the Rule 5.
Fangraphs has Matz 25′ value at 8.9mil
Then the Rays must be thinking that they got a pretty good deal. I always admired the Rays for being a well run organization. In trying to understand, I can only say that ‘anyone can make a mistake’. This is a move that may actually cause attendance to go further down for the Rays.
I feel pretty much the same way about Arenado’s defense. I’d bet it’s worth 3 to 5 wins over the course of a season. That’s enough to make a difference. Seattle could probably make a deal with St. Louis to get both Arenado and Donovan for a fair price. But it seems like Seattle is always willing to settle for second or third place in their Division. So, even though a trade like that would solve their biggest problems, they don’t try to pull it off.
I figured that was going to come up, and I get your point. We don’t want to disrupt the kid’s progress. But we have at least three legitimate second baseman plus Wetherholt, and we have no heir apparent for third base, especially if Donovan is traded.
-
AuthorPosts
