Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Not saying Girsch couldn’t be skipped over, but he also might leave if that happened.
I’m not saying the Cards might want to fire Girsch, but if they ever decide to “fire” him by promoting somebody else (Flores mentioned) to POBO over him, I’m not sure it would work. Girsch doesn’t strike me as a guy who has a lot of leverage around the league.
Also for gscott, Brian or anybody, I missed the story where Mo might transition eventually to an advisor role, as gscott mentioned above. Any article you can point me to?
I do recall that when the POBO position was created, there was discussion of an evolution where Mo (as POBO) would be doing more and more strategic work on how to continuously modernize the organization and keep the Cards on the forefront of advanced technology, analytics, techniques, philosophies, etc., and how to implement all this. Focus was to keep Cards baseball ops on the leading edge to build/maintain a strategic edge over the rest of MLB.
Is that what you’re referring to, gscott? If so, I interpreted all that as something much more grandiose than “advisor.” Speaking of that, I haven’t perceived much evolution on the role of POBO. Mo still seems a lot closer to bean counter than strategic visionary and do-er. But again, I probably missed what you referred to on the advisor role.
How do you get ‘restructuring player development’ and ‘improving the Baseball Ops Dept’ out of adding a few guys?
Because the chunks and bits Mo spit out were vague. Mo is usually good at that, or maybe the reporters were bad at drawing out more specifics in this case.
It really doesn’t matter if you’re after good clues about the team’s prospect for progress, because things have devolved to the point that it’s important to pay attention only to the stuff that happens and not the stuff that’s said. Like last year on rehires/fires, Maddux, Albert and Holliday all said “I ain’t working here no more.” That was very disconcerting at the time, and even more so after it played out a bit. Looking back, that was about the most damning foreshadow for this season I can think of. Mo couldn’t cover that up very well and more stuff like that this year would not be good. And they just lost a coach to girls college softball. I wonder if the Cards stand alone as the only MLB team to have its staff poached by college softball?
September 12, 2023 at 8:28 pm in reply to: Former Cardinals in the News – 2017 to Aug. 2024 (closed) #233788I was trying to answer a specific question by explaining that a sac fly is the reason for DeJong’s lower OBP than BA
Yep, a high enough sac fly count is the only thing that will cause OBP < BA. And since PDJ has no BBs or HBPs since he left StL, 1 SF is enough to do it.
September 12, 2023 at 2:12 pm in reply to: Former Cardinals in the News – 2017 to Aug. 2024 (closed) #233746while OBP uses plate appearances.
Almost. Just a small point here, but it matters since it’s math. OBP includes just hits, ABs BBs, HBPs and SFs. A sacrifice (bunt type) is an example of a plate appearance that doesn’t factor into OBP.
September 10, 2023 at 2:35 pm in reply to: Former Cardinals in the News – 2017 to Aug. 2024 (closed) #233622A lot of baseball books were written by pitchers. Good pitchers too, e.g., Paige, Perry, Lyle, Mathewson. Maybe that’s Flaherty’s career path, something like The Art of Pitching. After this season, Ball Four might be more appropriate, but Bouton already took that one.
Also, the Brewers happen to be 3rd best in the NL in ERA so maybe there is something to this pitching thing.
You’ve got a lot to learn about the game of baseball, gscott. Run prevention is overrated. I remember Johnny giving a response early in the season to a question on why Burly and Walker kept getting so much corner OF time while looking so shaky. His answer was, “Slug matters.”
Haha forsch. I bet Girsch is the guy who needs to be fired. He probably keeps signing Motter behind Mo’s back, and then Mo has to clean up the mess. You gotta keep an eye on those guys whose names end with sch.
DFAing Motter 3 times in one season should be grounds for immediately firing the responsible party.
September 2, 2023 at 10:39 pm in reply to: 2023 StL Game #136: Saturday, September 2 vs. Pirates #233045Well, looks like we’re going to have to wait another day for that September surge.
Oli didn’t say September 1st, 2nd, or even 3rd. He just said “September.” I don’t think the heavy stuff is gonna come down for quite a while.
Come to think of it, Oli didn’t say 2023 either.
I assumed that both player and team each had a choice.
Both do…and…both must exercise the option for it to happen.
Vintage Red Schoendienst autograph glove. Red wouldn’t have gotten much help on the instant replay “sphere” interpretation, LOL.

You do know the probabilities in advance. If the Cards finish the season 5th worst, they will have a 10% chance of getting the 1st pick. They could also fall as low as the 11th pick, however there’s a greater than 96% chance they’d get a pick in the top 8.
When Cardinal baseball starts conjuring up images of Rosie O’Donnell, it’s time for a break!
Chris Welsh is not the only announcer who says the out at 1B is determined by when the ball “enters” or “is in” the glove and not when the ball “hits” the leather or “back of the glove.” This “in the glove” thing is only for interpretations by the replay umps, not by umps on the field. In real time on the field, the umps’ human senses are not precise enough to discern the difference between the two. The difference is discernible on a super slo-mo replay where the video advances at a rate of 1,500 frames per second. The caveat is the ball must then be controlled by the defender for it to be as an out. I guess you could say it’s an out before it’s an out if the player secures the ball, lol.
There is justification for Welsh and others who say this. It evidently isn’t stated as such in the MLB rulebook, but it was supposedly in some clarification provided by MLB for how the replay umps were to interpret catches by players on force outs.
All I can tell you is to google John Farrell and replay catches. He was in a dust up over this several years back and it got some attention at that time. Farrell talked about the “guidance” MLB provided on how the replay teams were to interpret when a ball was “caught.” Like it or not (and I think the logic is suspect), it’s easy to find some discussion on the internet about this, so it was “a thing.” On a quick search just now, I can’t find anything where MLB disputed, clarified or changed the guidance that Farrell brought to light.
Damn, I just took more time to talk about Chris Welsh than I have about the Cards in the last month…..such as this season is.
True Materialman, you must’ve started in the 60s like I did. True except the part about Oli. Maybe you didn’t hear, he has been amazing.
Small consolation, but don’t Bill and Johnny have some really nice clothes?
August 26, 2023 at 11:04 am in reply to: 2023 StL Game #130: Saturday, August 26 at Phillies #232509It’d be amazing, but you can only dream of an entire rotation of Hudsons, Matzes and Thompsons. Even shoot-for-the-moon Mo knows that.
John Daly said he never got injured because, while you can pull muscles, you can’t pull fat.
I think John Kruk also thought this was a sound approach.
Mo is a purveyor of waste. As noted above, his work has impacted the depths of the org — and player personnel is not the primary issue. It’s leadership, coaching, and admin. The 40-man is really just the symptom and is a misguided target for any meaningful cleansing.
August 16, 2023 at 8:00 pm in reply to: 2023 StL Game #121: Wednesday, August 16 vs. Oakland #231729Who had getting-thrown-out-at-home-with-one-out-and-down-7-to-0-by-the-slowest-runner-in-MLB on their list of accomplishments this team would nail by the end of the year?
But the guys getting more expensive may be the ones most likely to go.
True in a decision to non-tender one of two similar players, but not so much in a trade. Depends on the value they are seeking and what matches it in return. The cheaper guy might be what it takes to make the opposing trade values more equitable.
August 11, 2023 at 8:12 pm in reply to: 2023 StL Game #117: Friday, August 11 at KC (Waino start) #231221Anyone remember Zelmo Beaty, the former St Louis Hawk?
Don’t ask Shaq
August 11, 2023 at 8:02 pm in reply to: 2023 StL Game #117: Friday, August 11 at KC (Waino start) #231218Mo has quickly evolved this team from being bad to being a cruel joke to being a slap in the face to the fans. Pathetic.
I saw this yesterday. Seems strange and not a good look for the team. Thought there had to be something deeper they’re not telling us, but maybe not.
Pretty much all media seems to be not-so-transparently aligned with some viewpoint or agenda and this is why their trust ratings are so low. I guess trashing the Os on this one seems like a no-brainer for all of them.
Yep, 1td. That was no love tap by Odor. Pretty impressive that Bats didn’t go down. Anderson went down like the Cardinals’ 2023 stock on much less of a shot.
One more out to go, let’s see a little fight boys.
Speaking of fight, wonder how many games suspension this will get you, compared to what Mikolas did to get his five?

-
AuthorPosts
