Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Thanks for posting those clips, Brian. I know those two competed against each other quite a bit in high school, including the summer showcase stuff. Obviously buddies.
Since this thread has been rejuvenated, I figured I’d take the opportunity to articulate a bit better why I have Redbird 3rd base prospect Elehuris Montero so highly ranked among all prospects.
“Top 40 overall for Montero? That’s aggressive.”
Pads was quite correct when he made this observation back in August. Top 40 will certainly seem aggressive, compared to other outlets. So it demands explaining on my part. Here goes.
Hitting performance is all relative, and what Montero did at age 19 in the Midwest League was pretty rare stuff. Specifically, he posted a wRC+ of 156 this year. For proper context, here’s a chronological list of every other Midwest League teenager who’s registered a 150 wRC+ or better this decade (min. 200 plate appearances):
Mike Trout, Wil Myers, Oscar Taveras, Javy Baez, Corey Seager, Byron Buxton, Bobby Bradley, Eloy Jimenez, Fernando Tatis Jr., Bo Bichette, and Vlad Guerrero Jr.. Nice roll call, huh?
So Elehuris Montero was just the 12th teenage batter this decade to meet that lofty 150 wRC+ standard. After their Midwest League seasons, the other 11 prospects were ranked 24th on average at Baseball America, and unsurprisingly all of them were top 100 prospects. Throw out the high and low (Buxton #1, Bradley #93) and the average ranking rises to 19th.
But that’s admittedly misleading, since some of the above 11, like Byron Buxton for instance, were already considered top prospects before they played a game in the Midwest League. To find Montero’s true peer group, we must compare him to the players who were unranked prior to their MWL seasons. That would be these seven: Bichette, Tatis, Myers, Jimenez, Bradley, Taveras, and Seager.
Like Montero, the non-top 100 guys all had positives and negatives before their triumphant MWL performances. (Montero was a modest bonus baby when he signed at 16 — no great scouting pedigree. But on the other hand, the year before thrashing the MWL he was an all-star in the Gulf Coast League. So he didn’t come from nowhere. Not by a long shot.)
So if we use the seven other prospects as a frame of reference, what do we get? Their average rank at Baseball America following their MWL seasons was 35th. If you want to argue that those seven offer more in the way of defense/baserunning than Montero, and therefore aren’t his true peers, well, the numbers don’t back that assertion up.
The Baseball Prospectus WAR numbers, which include baserunning and glovework, place Montero’s MWL season slightly above the other seven on average, with Montero at 6.4 WAR per 600 PA’s, and the others just a hair under 6.0. So I consider it only reasonable to place him in that peer group, and rank him in the top 35-40 overall prospects. But I can offer a bit more support — for both Montero’s bat and glove.
Montero as a pro has committed too many errors, and his error/DP ratio is marginal. But his range appears to be above average, as his annual defensive runs saved are in fact very solid, every year, per the Baseball Prospectus site:
2015 +7 runs in 57 games
2016 +3 runs in 61 games
2017 +3 runs in 52 games
2018 +3 runs in 103 Peoria games
2018 +1 in just 24 Palm Beach tiltsFive stops, five positive run values. So, error totals notwithstanding, when confronted with the above numbers it’s pretty hard to argue that he’s been a poor defender. And maybe he’s actually good!
And if all that weren’t enough, here’s another positive marker for success. Ele’s plate discipline at Peoria was markedly stronger down the stretch, as was his power.
First half: .307/.359/.483 with a 16/56 BB/K, excellent for a teen in the MWL, but blah strikezone control.
Second half: .347/.416/.604 with a 17/25 BB/K, great numbers for anyone of any age at any level or league.And finally, he played in a Midwest League pitcher’s park this season. Montero’s road OPS was 55 points higher than home at Peoria, so even his outstanding numbers may be underestimating his current true talent.
So top 40, absolutely. Good chance to be an above average regular. Stardom not impossible.
Bob, I disagree about Holland. He only signed for 1 year so his signing was not a risk.
One year certainly made it less of a risk, Forschy. But I feel like history shows that when someone is signed for a substantial amount of dough — let’s say, anything over 5-6% of player payroll for the season — there are always two risks.
One, the club will feel the need to keep using him past the point of good sense, because of the contract commitment. The time to cut Holland was late May, somewhere within his streak of four straight terrible appearances. (Or of course they could have just fixed him. Like Washington and Lilliquist did, immediately.) After late May I think Holland allowed something like 15 runs, 10 earned, in 13 innings. That contract-driven patience cost the Cards roughly one game in the standings.
And two, due to the dough, the club will be limited in the range of moves they can make later in the season, if the need arises. Let’s say for the sake of discussion that the Cards never signed Holland. That theoretically would have left a Holland-sized chunk of money to invest at the trade deadline, on someone like Cole Hamels for example, if the Cards thought they saw something fixable. Or any other hitter or pitcher who seemed like he could help, obviously.
The Bud Norris contract came with no risk. Final Boss, very little risk. Even Miles Mikolas had only a modicum of risk, despite being a multi-year deal for a starting pitcher — because the AAV money was modest. But Holland had meaningful risk. (And the next 3 or 4 times Derrick Goold says “There’s no such thing as a bad one-year contract” in one of his chats, someone please remind him of Greg Holland. Oh, and the high draft pick flushed away. And the half a million in international amateur bonus money. Arrrgh.
Is it really so bleeping difficult to trade for a relief pitcher or two? Find another Mujica, Mo. (And make room for him by cutting Gregerson and Cecil already, for heaven’s sake.)
Yeah, I guess I should have said intact at the top. I’d like to know the overall numbers, C.C.. But at any rate, Redbird drafting, their trades, and their international amateur acquisitions over the past few years are still each very strong, maybe even elite. And the recent free agents out of Japan (I know, it’s just a couple of guys) have worked out tremendously.
As for youth and the future, the Cards led the National League this year in rookie hitter WAR and they also led in rookie pitcher WAR. (Fangrphs WAR.) I doubt that such a combo happens very often. Specifically, they had 8.6 WAR from rooks, and the rest of the N.L. Central combined for 4.1. The N.L. average was just 2.8 per team, so the Birds more than tripled it.
And despite those graduations, they still have a lot left — very likely more teenage position player talent in the minors than any organization. In fact, I guarantee it’s more than any other organization, if we count all the guys who were 19 for the 2018 season, like Elehuris Montero, Dylan Carlson, and supersleeper prospect bat Leandro Cedeno. The pitching is down, perhaps way down, but in total the farm is in excellent shape, albeit oddly shaped.
Internal talent, majors & minors, is not the trouble. It just feels to me that the front office has lost its self-discipline of the recent past, and a fraction of good judgement. And that’s resulted in some self-immolation. They’ve been “hole-patching” instead of acquiring whole players. Imagine that you need more speed? Trade for Bourjos, who can’t hit. Oops, now you need power? Trade for Brandon Moss, who can’t do anything else. Need relief help? Sign a slew of free agents who are too old, too expensive, or require far too many years of contract.
Think you need a leadoff hitter, because Carpenter has too much power? Spend lavishly on career mediocrity Dexter Fowler, on the wrong side of 30, coming off a fluke year — maybe he’ll let you look at his World Series ring! And he’ll play centerfield for 3 or 4 years, because obviously that kid Bader can’t be trusted. Sure he’s been dominating the minors ever since he was drafted, but everybody knows you shouldn’t scout those darn statlines.
With both Kyle Lohse and Lance Lynn, the team was disciplined, smart. (They still understood some first principles, by not re-signing Lance Lynn. So all is not lost.) They did not used to give a 2-3 WAR performer a star-length contract after turning 30 years old. With Fowler and Cecil, they lost their minds, and more than a little. If you’re the Cardinals you cannot pay mere regulars as though they were stars. Some teams can. The Cards cannot.
(Which is why the cockeyed Hosmer/Moustakas rumors were so maddening a year ago, and why they’re STILL insane now, when it comes to Moose. He’s Gyorko. Or maybe Gyorko-lite. Let him go somewhere else. I don’t care if he hits righty, lefty, or standing on his head. You don’t get extra credit for having so-called “balance” in your lineup. By OPS+ the Red Sox best 4 hitters were all righty this year, the Yankees 5 best were all righty, and the Astros’ best were Bregman, Altuve, Springer, Tyler White, and Yuri Gurriel. All 5 of them righties. And that doesn’t even include Carlos Correa. You think those monster lineups’ front offices are losing sleep over a lack of “balance” in their offense? Don’t bet on it.)
Twelve months ago the StL front office fired the good coach (Lilliquist) and kept the crap one (Mabry). One half of that error was rectified in July, and, no surprise at all, the team played much, much better. Scored a LOT more runs per game (5.1 runs per game without Mabry, versus 4.4 with him). And the bats of Pham and Voit sure seemed glad to get out of town, didn’t they? Also, get off my lawn.
But really, the talent is already here to win 94-96 games, if a couple of excellent relievers are added. That’s it. Well, maybe three relievers. Of course, they can’t add three or even two relievers because of the dead roster spots being so graciously preserved for Malcontent Fowler, Washed Up Cecil, and No Velocity Gregerson. So as long as the front office is stubborn, they’re trapped.
Okay so that wasn’t the most eloquent screed I ever wrote. But it felt pretty good anyway.
“Heyward, Leake, Fowler, Cecil, Gregerson, Ozuna are an indictment of this organization. If they were trying to suck they couldn’t do a better job. Whoever is in charge in the Front Office is lousy at what they do. I think we’ll have to get used to third place for many years.”
Grading the above moves, I’d give Leake and Ozuna a C- or D+, because who would have thought that Leake would be stupid and stubborn enough to not let Yadi call his pitches for him? I liked the Leake signing in general, because of Yadi, the move from Great American Bandbox to Busch Stadium, and Leake’s relative youthfulness, solid velocity, and good health history. I hated the Ozuna signing because they were buying a guy coming off of a huge career year that was unlike anything that had come before. (Just like with Fowler.)
I’ve beaten the Fowler signing to death repeatedly. It’s an F- for Fowler and I wish there were a lower grade.
Cecil I was ambivalent, but it was clearly too many years from the start. And both Gregerson and Holland were very, very risky given their ages and significant evidence of decline already — esp. velocity. All three relievers get a straight D.
But Heyward? The Cards got a great year from him, for almost no burden on the payroll (less than 10 million bucks for a 6-win season), and then afterwards they got a high draft pick as compensation when he left via free agency…after which his hitting declined immediately, and now his bloated contract is hurting the hated Cubs! What more do you want than that?! That’s like Ralphie’s essay grade in A Christmas Story: A+++++++ for Heyward.
The front office has done a terrible job with free agency over the past 2-3 years. But they did get Mikolas and Final Boss from Japan, and did trade Jon Jay for three good years of Gyorko and counting. And the Tyler O’Neill/Marco Gonzales trade could pay large dividends if Tiny Kingman gets the chance to start 20+ times a month.
The brilliant Redbird front office of 2008-2015 is still largely intact. They just need to get back to the disciplined ways of those years. No long contracts for relievers, or players on the wrong side of 30 unless they have value to the organization off the field, and you know them very well. (Waino, Yadi of course.) No big four- or five-year deals for 2-3 WAR free agents, especially older ones. Be smart, not splashy. Be the Brewers of the last twelve months. You know, when the Brewers were emulating the Cardinals.
“Machado and Harper are generational talents.”
If they improve, they certainly might be. But now, I don’t see the supporting evidence as persuasive.
Since Matt Carpenter became a fulltime major leaguer in 2013, here are the top 10 MLB position players according to Fangraphs:1) Trout…54.0 WAR
2) Donaldson…35.6
3) Goldy…32.9
4) Betts…30.5
5) Billy Barty…29.4
6) Votto…29.0
7) Generational Talent Machado…29.0
8) McCutchen…28.8
9) Freeman…28.5
10) Matt Carpenter…27.2
GAP
13) Generational Talent Harper…26.3Mildly interesting to see more “corner guys” than up-the-middle types. If there’s a lesson here, it’s apparently Hitting Trumps Fielding. Also, four of the ten were never on a top 100 prospect list, and two more were never in Baseball America’s top 40. In other words, 60% of the greatest players of the last six years were never considered elite prospects by the presumptive experts at Baseball America. (To be fair, the other prospect graders didn’t perform much better than BA.)
If Mookie’s total feels too low, bear in mind that he only had a couple hundred trips to the plate prior to 2015. Pro-rate his numbers and he’s neck-and-neck with Donaldson for 2nd best player of the past six seasons. In any case, regardless of what Scott Boras or other hyperbolists say, for me Bryce Harper and Manny Machado are not yet particularly close to generational talents.
Are they both great players, and on a Hall Of Fame path? Absolutely, in no small part because they started so freaking young. But Hall Of Famer alone doesn’t cut it — a dozen or so Hall Of Famers emerge from every “baseball generation,” i.e., each 5-7 year period. Mike Trout is a generational talent. So is Kershaw. Betts might be already. Maybe Maximus Scherzer, if he can keep excelling for 4 or 5 more seasons. But Harper & Machado need to be better than they’ve been, to gain that label. For me.
“P.S. I will acknowledge that I found several of his (Hummel’s) other answers a bit unusual. For example, he said he only cares about 2019 and not beyond. Seems very narrow-minded and could easily lead to some sub-optimal conclusions.”
Yeah, that was weird. A recall a famous GM, John Schuerholz maybe, saying once that a good GM during decision making is usually weighting the seasons: 50% next year, 30% the year after that, 10% the year after that, and another 10% for all subsequent seasons combined, beyond the next three. Of course that’s just a rough estimate.
But far worse than that, The Commish conflated his comedians! Everyone knows that “Take my wife, please” was Henny Youngman, not Rodney Dangerfield. Dangerfield was “When I was born, I was so ugly the doctor slapped my mother.”
“At this time last year, he looked to be even with Bader. Before camp, I even projected O’Neill would make the team. Then O’Neill was twice injured in Jupiter and hardly played. Bader seized the opening and off he went.
Then during the season, O’Neill went on St. Louis’ DL twice – separate stints in July and August. How can he be trusted to start if he cannot stay on the field?”It is too bad that Tyler wasn’t healthier in 2018. Like yourself, Brian, it felt to me like he was prohibitively injury-prone. But then I checked the numbers, and between AAA and MLB he did play 125 games in 2018. For context, Dexter Fowler has averaged 126 for his career, and Bryce Harper 132. They’re certainly considered full-time players — if somewhat brittle ones.
And I would also add that Tyler played nearly 95% of his team’s games in both 2016 and 2017, in Double-A and Triple-A. So I would argue that while there’s some recent evidence of fragility, there’s at least equal evidence of very good durability as well. So I’m not worried. Yet.
Speaking of frail outfielders, Larry Walker, Reggie Sanders, and Jim Edmonds all arrived in St. Louis with track records of breaking down physically. (Edmonds had averaged just 119 games over his previous 5 years, Walker 127, and Sanders 126.) But of course they were all obviously talented enough that it was clearly worthwhile making a commitment to them, playing them 25 times a month as long as they stayed healthy. While they’re highly unlikely to ever be as outstanding as that trio, I’d like the Cards to play Bader and O’Neill as long as they’re healthy too. Bader’s glove and O’Neill’s bat make for tantalizing upsides.
I’m not sure exactly how damning the Hummel chat remarks were. Here are the quotes, lifted straight from his chat (emphases mine):
“Have I missed something? When is $23 million low risk? You’re not paying anybody but Bryce Harper more than Yadier Molina for one season and certainly not Donaldson.”
“The Atlanta Braves have jumped the shark and signed former Blue Jays third baseman Josh Donaldson to a one-year, $23 million contract.
Many will ask why the Cardinals didn’t do this.
Some answers:
He is going to be 33 next season and missed two-thirds of this season with calf and shoulder injuries.
He is not a lefthanded hitter.
Nobody on the Cardinals should make more money than Yadier Molina, unless Bryce Harper is signed. Donaldson never has played in the National League. There is an adjustment period.
Donaldson had one single and one walk for Cleveland in three playoff games. That is why the Indians acquired him — the playoffs.”Now, I could be way off base. But to me, those bolded comments above look much more like statements of personal opinion from the Commish, rather than insider-knowledge echoes of club policy/strategy. I’d say that Rick just hates the idea of an injured outsider from another organization coming in and being better paid than the Hall Of Fame bound face of the franchise. Which makes sense from a staunchly traditional baseball man’s point of view.
(That rather “traditional” point of view also prompted Rick to call the Cardinal defense “the worst in the league” during his chat. No team is worst in the league, if they’re perhaps the single strongest defense in baseball up the middle. Molina, Wong, and Bader could each have rightly won Gold Gloves. And DeJong has been average or better defensively at short.)
Rick has repeatedly and enthusiastically expressed his scorn for Donaldson’s playoff performance with Cleveland. (What was it, ten at-bats?) And if he believes the Braves have “jumped the shark” with the Donaldson deal, he probably doesn’t agree about precisely how great Donaldson was until very recently. From 2013-2017 Donaldson registered a 5-year stretch more valuable than any active player has had, over any half decade, except for Trout & Kershaw. And maybe Mookie’s past 5 seasons. Much better than Harper’s best 5-year stretch.
Please don’t anybody construe my observations as belittling of the Commish. He is a treasure, and I hope he works for another 20 years. He’s a fine writer, a more than patient chat host, and he possesses a wealth of hardball knowledge very few can match. When he retires we’ll all be the poorer for it.
We had Mark Reynolds once. Do we need him again? lol
He (O’Neill) needs to make more contact regardless and quit whiffing as much.I’m glad you mentioned Mark Reynolds, Booyah. Reynolds has only had one year where his strikeouts were counterbalanced enough by his power, to where he was actually a very good hitter. That was way back in 2009, when he posted an excellent 127 OPS+. Most years, in fact every other year, I would NOT want Reynolds in my starting lineup. Okay for thunder off the bench, but that’s it.
Tyler O’Neill doesn’t figure to be Mark Reynolds, though. Tyler was doing in AA at age 20 what Reynolds didn’t do until he was 22 and 23 years old. And O’Neill has more defensive and baserunning talent as well. There are no mediocre major leaguers with a track record like O’Neill’s. Not that I know of.
You can’t lump all the high-strikeout guys together, all the guys who ever led the league in whiffs. If you did, then Mark Reynolds and Pedro Avarez would be lumped in with Jim Thome and Kris Bryant and Jay Buhner and Gorman Thomas and Duke Snider and Jimmy Foxx and Babe Ruth.
I hate strikeouts, too. Swear it. But it’s counterproductive to fixate on them to the exclusion of other more important aspects of a player.
Bob,
He has also struck out 168 times in those 514 at-bats. That is actually better than what I thought. That is, however, a strikeout percentage of 33%. If he plays everyday and gets 600 at-bats he is going to strikeout around 200 times. That isn’t good. It wasn’t too long ago it was embarrassing to strikeout.Strikeouts for hitters are like errors for fielders. They are ugly. They frustrate. We watch millionaire athletes do things we didn’t do as high school ballplayers — or not very much anyway — and it confounds us. Strikeouts and errors undermine the pleasure we take from watching baseball, the aesthetics of the sport. But that’s not the same as saying that they are of primary importance. A factor, no doubt. But not a primary one, when evaluating a hitter or fielder.
Or to put it another way, Rat. Would you want O’Neill starting in your outfield if he fanned 220 times a year, but batted .250 with 45 homers, solid defense, and good baserunning? I would without a moment’s hesitation, because of the production. Look at the doughnut, not the hole.
Or to put it yet another way, there’s a guy who was a lot like O’Neill, I’ll bet you remember him quite well. I’ll withhold the name momentarily and just describe the production, the shape of it.
For the five years 1978-1982, he struck out 106 more times than any other hitter in the sport, he batted only .245, and was okay but nothing special as an outfielder. Sounds kind of useless, right? And yet he was worth 4 WAR per year, the 20th best total in the majors over those 5 years. Because he slugged over .500 and had the 2nd-most homers behind Michael Jack Schmidt (Who did indeed “jack” a few over the years).
For those five years Gorman Thomas was a terrific player, even though he struck out A LOT. The doughnut was delicious & nutritious, despite a larger than average hole. O’Neill could be that kind of talent. It’s what he was throughout the minors.
“O’Neill is the last Cardinal prospect that I would trade. He had some ups and downs as a Cardinal in 18 but was better than last year. He also proved to be a good late inning defensive alternative. The potential upside for him is far to important to risk losing unless there is a deal we can not refuse. I hold out quite a bit of hope for one who improves their game at high levels.
But most important he improved his plate discipline, his average and his power output at Memphis. We have to put him out there and let him either grow or go.”
You summed it up well, Sooner. (Also, go Sooners. Been a fan since the Greg Pruitt/Johnny Rodgers ’71 game.) Tyler might be special. Which is why I’m paranoid that (1)Shildt won’t play him due to strikeouts, therefore (2)Mo is going to include him in a trade for Goldschmidt. With the Lovie Smith contract extension, I have re-learned once again that stupidity has no limit. Heck, maybe O’Neill will be traded straight-up for Greinke and his $105M contract.
Anyway, enough of my whining. Here’s a summary of how good Tyler O’Neill’s minor league track record is, according to the Baseball Prospectus minor league WAR values. All WAR totals are prorated to 600 plate appearances.
Rookieball at 17 5.7 WAR
Low-A at 18 3.2
High-A at 19 4.7
Double-A at 20 4.8
Triple-A at 21+22 5.1
Triple-A just 22 10.3Across all levels, all games, 38 homers and 5.1 WAR per 150 games. And always young for his leagues.
The only level where he did NOT play at a star level, was when he was an 18-year-old kid in Low-A full season ball. Basically a high schooler against college grads.Here’s a cool stat. Combining AAA and the majors, Tyler O’Neill has now played exactly 162 games for the Cardinal organization. He has hit 47 homers in 514 at-bats.
I could see the Cards getting Harper for $37M per year. And then in two years the Brewers or Cubs sign Trout for $55M a year, which would be a much, much, much, much smarter deal. That’s how things are going.
That’s how the last couple of years have gone.
Cards sign 2-2.5 WAR Fowler for 5 years and $80M.
Brewers sign 4-5 WAR Lorenzo Cain one year later for the exact same contract.
Cards trade for 2-3 WAR Marcel Ozuna.
Brewers get 4-5 WAR Christian Yelich.We should learn from the Brewers. Be opportunistic, not impatient. We do not want Bryce Harper, not for 10+ years, and not for $35-40M a year at any length. He is not that special. He just isn’t.
Per fangraphs Harper has been a 4.5 win player for his career. At B-Ref it’s just 4 WAR per year. He’s not anything like Mookie or Mike. Those are generational talents. This is not a generational talent. He’s injury-prone, inconsistent, and is already declining on defense. Probably be washed up by age 32 or 33.
“I don’t mind missing out on him. His health issues are red flags to me. Would much rather have Goldy.”
But wouldn’t you agree that it depends on what the Cards have to give up in talent for Goldy? And I’m guessing the cost would be (will be) prohibitive. Like, they give up so much that the team is barely even improved in the short run, and is possibly much weakened going forward.
I see it like this: say you get Goldy. That means Carp MUST move to third base. Which makes Gyorko a likely trade chip. (For public relations, the Arizona fans need to see at least one productive MLB player come back to the Diamondbacks in the trade.)
So the Cards deal Gyorko plus someone very very good like Dakota Hudson, plus an underpublicized, high-upside, low-minors sweetener like Leandro Cedeno or Jhon Torres. Maybe even another sweetener, too, like Carlos Soto or Julio Rodriguez. Now, Carpenter at 3rd base is a liability in the field — and an injury risk, I would say.
Anyway the upgrade from Gyorko to Carp in total value is 1 to 1/5 wins. At first base, the upgrade from Carp to Goldy is another win. (Of course, Carp was as good as Goldy in 2018. But from 2013-2018, he’s been worth one win less per season, according to Fangraphs. So one win seems a fair estimate.)
So the total upgrade stands at 2-2.5 wins. That might be worth the trade. But in this scenario you also lose Dakota Hudson. And he stood to be one of your 2 or 3 best relievers. Or maybe even a rotation pitcher. With so few reliable relievers currently on hand, Hudson was worth roughly 1-2 wins to the Cards. So the total upgrade from the trade would be somewhere between zero and 1.5 wins.
And then Goldy is gone after 2019, and you don’t have Dakota Hudson for the next 5 years, or Cedeno/Torres ever. (Yes, I’m just spitballing with these names, but I guarantee this is what the trade is going to look like. Maybe not these specific players. But equivalent talents, certainly.)
Love Goldy, hate the idea of overpaying for one year of him. And hate the idea of giving him a massive contract extension into his mid-late 30’s.
I’m with you, Muddy. I’m very gratified to see the smart, civil responses here. Thanks, everyone. As far as I’m concerned this website is the majors and the P-D and VEB are AAA and AA for fan commentary. Fewer ideologues here, and less free-floating rancor.
However, there’s one thing bugging me. I’d intended to tack on an observation to the end of my initial essay, a postscript of sorts; but as my posts are wont to do, it went on much longer than anticipated. So I chose to wait. Then I forgot about it for several days. Blame it on excessive tryptophan intake. Anyway I remembered just now, so here goes.
Recapping, these are the projected major league OPS performances for current Cardinal minor leaguers. Not their projected career MLB numbers mind you, just the OPS estimate for the very best 3-year stretch, based on the 20-year major league track record of 25 Cardinal prospects. Some of these forecasts are pretty sexy. But even if these gaudy OPS numbers here prove 100% accurate, that does not necessarily imply stardom. (Bear in mind, Ryan Ludwick for example posted an excellent .862 during his 2007-09 years, and he was certainly not a star. Okay, he was. But only for one season.)
Nolan Gorman .931
Elehuris Montero .859
Leandro Cedeno .851
Randy Arozarena .836
Carson Kelly .824
Dylan Carlson .819
Lane Thomas .790
Ramon Urias .785
Andy Young .783
Andrew Knizner .776
Evan Mendoza .776
John Nogowski .751
Tommy Edman .730
Edmundo Sosa .723Those numbers are quite impressive, I’d say. (Apologies to Leandro Cedeno, who was inadvertently omitted from the initial list. How do you forget a guy who hits .336/.419/.592?) The Cards could definitely use a lot more pitching prospects, but they’re pretty rich in hitters.
What I wanted to add earlier, though, was that numerous teenage Redbird prospects not listed above might have every bit as bright a batting future as the ones who are there. I’ll just note the best.
Here are the most dominant 2018 hitting performances of some 17 and 18-year-old Cardinal farmhands, expressed in wRC+. (Sorry, Rat. Had to use wRC+ because (1)there’s no such thing as OPS+ for the minors, (2)raw OPS can mislead because some minor leagues have much more offense than others, and (3)believe me, no one here wants to see anyone’s offense described by wOBA. I don’t. You don’t. Everyone don’t.)
Malcom Nunez 238 wRC+
Joerlin De Los Santos 174
Jhon Torres 163
Ramon Mendoza 162
Ivan Herrera 160
Adanson Cruz 145To be blunt I’m not crazy about Adanson Cruz’s bat, though. Cruz struck out too much for the DSL, and as you can see he wasn’t quite as outstanding in general at the dish — not compared to the others. But I felt compelled to mention that Cruz, per Baseball Prospectus, put up some tremendous defensive numbers in 2018. Micro-sample, yes. Lowest rung of the minors, you bet. But good numbers are always better than bad numbers. And his glovework numbers were (your overwrought superlative here).
“Case in point. No one could convince me the 2018 Cardinals would have won anywhere near 88 games without veteran additions Miles Mikolas and Bud Norris, two guys that before the season none of us expected much of anything from.”
Agreed 100%, Brian, those were excellent signings. But the key is, they did not just “turn out” to be excellent signings. They were excellent signings before the season even began — because the dollars/years were controlled, shrewd, nothing like the Leake/Cecil/Holland/Gregerson signings. There was upside with both Mikolas & Norris, and more importantly virtually zero risk of their blocking better guys, if they failed.
Bad signings involve so much money, and so many years in some cases, that the player is almost guaranteed to keep playing regardless of how terrible he becomes. THAT’S the primary hazard with bigger contracts. It’s not the cost in dollars that kills the team. It’s the excessive emotional commitment, the deranged need to play the awful player/pitcher even when they stink.
This is why Bader was benched for Fowler when Mike Shildt took over. Think about that. The team’s overall best outfielder at the time, benched for maybe the league’s worst player. The front office had to trade Tommy Pham just to get Bader back on the field. (And of course the trouble goes even deeper than that. Right now the Cards would have much more room on their 40-man roster if they just cleared the dreck that they’ve signed in free agency over the past 2 years.)
“O’Neill seems like a far from a sure thing to me and the stakes are too high to miss the playoffs for a fourth year in a row.”
Tyler O’Neill is indeed far from a sure thing. No argument there. But so is almost anyone you could name, including Bryce Harper, who’s had three sub-2 WAR seasons in his last five, per Baseball-Reference. But one is going to cost 500 thousand, and one of them is going to cost 350 million. Embrace the bargains, GScott, because they leave much more dough for other needs.
And maybe even leave enough dough to bid on Mike Trout in a couple of years. If you’re gonna dream, dream big. Trout is exactly twice the player Harper is, and will likely cost only 40-60% more than Harper. Trout could become the highest-paid player in history, and STILL be a great deal for the buyer. That’s how much of a generational talent he is. (By the way, I don’t know why the stakes are any higher this year than other years. The stakes are always high for the Cards. The fans always expect a contender.)
“Dave Duncan is no longer our pitching coach, so we have to start acquiring relievers who can actually pitch.”
Ain’t that the truth. I don’t know exactly why Lilliquist was fired 12 months ago after six years of conspicuous success with both starters and relievers, but Mike Maddux certainly failed with the bullpen, especially Greg Holland, while Lilly turned Holland immediately back into the dominant guy he was with Kansas City. It was maddening to see. Here’s a painful refresher!
Holland with Maddux: 25 innings, 56 baserunners, 28 runs, and a 22/22 strikeout/walk ratio.
Holland with Lilly: 21 innings, 19 baserunners, 2 runs, and a 25/10 strikeout/walk tally.I suspect Holland was tipping in St. Louis. (Just like Luke Weaver.) It certainly wasn’t improved health or velocity in Washington that accounted for Holland’s transformation. Heck, his velocity was slightly higher in St. Louis, for both the slider and fastball. Man I miss Lilliquist.
Finally, I want to say I agree with every word of yours, BW52.
“I don’t think this is the time to roll the dice and see what happens. That is what we have done the last three years and it didn’t work. We need more certainty which means going with proven players.”
I must beg to differ, GScott. I think it’s the other way around. I would argue that the Cardinals have failed over the past few years because they have tried too hard to get certainty, have acquired far too many “proven players” who in fact had little upside, were too long in the tooth, or both — THAT’S what stopped the team in 2018. They failed to make the playoffs because they failed to trust their own players and pitchers, and mistakenly sought certainty from without.
Dexter Fowler. Luke Gregerson. Brett Cecil. Greg Holland. Those four by themselves destroyed the 2018 Cards.
Replace their at-bats and innings with Bader/O’Neill/Hudson/Poncedeleon and the team wins 8-10 more games. So-called veteran certainty is never remotely certain, so I say instead go for the upside. Even if it costs a lot less money, and provides less glamor. Fans want big free agent signings. I get it. But the smartest moves aren’t always headline-grabbers.
I said loud and long two years ago in these very web-pages that Fowler was a HUGE mistake, said it over and over, and I specified that Harrison Bader was going to be every bit as good as Fowler during Fowler’s 5-year contract. But Bader was not a proven major leaguer then. He was just a guy who’d dominated college and A-ball and Double-A. So nobody listened, right here at this website. No one believed in Bader.
Oh, a few other folks weren’t completely in love with the Fowler signing, but nobody believed in Bader. Nope, gotta have that guy with the World Series ring, gotta have that certainty, that proven-ness. You know what’s gallows funny, and terrible, and an indictment of the American public education system? Over at Fangraphs there are still numerous fans rationalizing the idiotic and self-destructive Fowler signing. I kid you not. Let us hope the Cards never ever make a mistake like that again. No more Fowlers, or Tino Martinezes, or Mike Leakes, or Juan Encarnacions. Only pay big bucks for big talent.
I’m imploring you now, my fellow Redbird fan (and you guys too, Mo and Girsch and Shildt if you’re out there), please listen to BikeMike. Tyler O’Neill is a ballplayer who needs to play, every day. He is a talent.
Let’s say you are Mozeliak, and you are told you can spend $35 million per year to improve the team. You are staring at three options:
1. Sign Bryce Harper. Make Dexter Fowler a $16.5 million backup
2. Sign Josh Donaldson for $20 million (3 years/$60 million). Sign Michael Brantley for $15 million (3 years/$45 million). Make Dexter Fowler a backup
3. Trade Dexter Fowler + Dakota Hudson + Austin Gomber + Jose Adolis Garcia to the Diamondbacks for Greinke + Goldschmidt. You will likely slap a QO on Goldschmidt next year and recover a draft pick.
Which option do you choose and why?I really like the $35M premise, but I’m going to cheat and say #4, none of the above. Don’t want Harper for a decade, waaay too much risk. Don’t want Brantley to block Tyler O’Neill, esp. since Brantley is old and breaks too often. Don’t want to trade Dakota Hudson; if he meaningfully improves his command OR learns to use a 4-seamer up in the zone for strikeouts, he’ll be a #2/3 starter. If he does both, he’ll be an ace. Mucho upside with Hudson. Also, don’t want to acquire Grienke with $105M still left on his contract over the next 3 years.
The rotation was 5th in all of MLB for earned run average. The starters ain’t the problem. Relative to his extraordinary salary commitment, Grienke has very little upside. And Fowler should just be released. That’s the Fowler option I choose. You can’t use him as a bench player. That’s absolutely not how he views himself; even with months to reflect on the matter, he still gripes about being benched last year, when he was perhaps the worst player in the National League. Crap player, crap attitude. Addition by subtraction.
I’d get Donaldson for the 3 years/$60M, Yusei Kikuchi for $10-12M per year for anywhere from 3-6 years. Both could be bargains. (No one can realistically say that about the Harper/Machado/Corbin/ type marquee guys.) I have no idea whether Boras/Kikuchi are seeking a big BIG deal, or a more tactical, modest Mikolasesque deal that will allow Kikuchi to prove himself in the majors for a couple of years. If Kikuchi can’t make the Redbird rotation out of Spring Training this year, he slides over into the bullpen for a season. Then in 2020 he replaces Wacha/Mikolas when they depart.
Save the remaining $3-5M for a bullpen upgrade at the trade deadline, or maybe rotation. And then trade Jose Martinez plus either Knizner or Kelly, plus perhaps a sweetener like Gomber or Gant or Adolis Garcia or Ryan Helsley to the DH league for bullpen help in the form of Taylor Rogers or Mychal Givens or Joe Jimenez, or Colome or Diaz from Seattle. If Arizona is the trade partner, get Andrew Chafin or Yoan Lopez. Triage principles demand you prioritize the worst wound first. That’s the bullpen.
Thanks for the additional feedback, Brian and C-27.
“I would hope that he tuned his formulas by comparing them to real results. As several have mentioned, some of these numbers seem overly optimistic. But time will tell.”
Well, Davenport’s been doing it for more than 20 years. And I can report that I’ve found his projections quite useful. I know there was a lot to wade through in my initial lengthy “methodology” post, a thicket of thoughts to whack through. But I think it illustrated the historical accuracy of Davenport’s Peak Projections in general — if we agree that the “Peak” can be defined by a player’s best 3-year OPS stretch in the majors.
Again, quick summary for those who didn’t choose to do battle with my sometimes dense writing. Over the past 20 years or so, of the 25 Cardinal prospects who later had any sort of remotely meaningful MLB career, their composite OPS for their best consecutive 3 seasons almost exactly splits the difference between the Davenport Career Peak and Davenport Best Single Season Peak. That’s 20 years of real results, for 25 Redbird prospects.
“The most extraordinary of exceptions do not make the rule. I very sincerely hope that Kelly earns the right to one day be mentioned in the same sentence with Albert and Yadi. However, I will not be holding my breath, as that is a Hall of Fame tall order.”
I agree, sir. I agree in every respect, with no caveats or conditions. Which is why I did not in any way argue that “the most extraordinary of exceptions make the rule.” At least that wasn’t my intent.
But maybe my meaning wasn’t as clear as it could have been, in the previous post. What I said or meant to say was that both Yadi and Albert had 3-year career MLB peaks that far outdistanced in terms of OPS any given single season they had in the minors. They are two outliers, and their mere existence indirectly implies that anyone who falls far short of them is therefore NOT such an outlier himself.
More specifically, Yadi’s best minor league single season OPS was .759. His MLB 3-year prime was 83 points higher at a collective .842. Big outlier, and that’s not what we’re asking of Carson Kelly. Albert had a .953 OPS in the minors and a best MLB 3-year stretch 129 points higher, at 1.084. Bigger outlier. Those are extremes, of course. But I didn’t say then or now that I expected Carson Kelly to be like them, to be markedly better in the majors than he was during his best minor league season.
Carson Kelly does not even have to exceed his best minor league OPS at all, much less clobber it by 83 or 129 points. As you pointed out, his best minor league OPS was in AAA at age 22, when he posted an .834. His Davenport Midpoint is 10 points below that. No best-case scenario required, not even close.
Now. With all of that said, like yourself I actually feel that Kelly will fall short of that .824 prime. Not by a ton, perhaps 20-25 points of OPS. And I think Knizner will surpass the .776 of his forecast. My gut tells me that Arozarena is too high, Tommy Edman too low, and that Nolan Gorman and Lane Thomas will fall short of their Midpoint by 15 or 20 points. Of course, the effect would be radically different; 20 points of OPS could keep Thomas from being an MLB starter, but it won’t keep Gorman from stardom. (Yes, Gorman committed too many errors in his pro debut, but he also turned double plays at a rate that would make Graig Nettles and the Boyer boys blush.)
Some guys will exceed their Davenport Midpoints, and some will of course fall short. Some by a little, some by a lot, in both directions. But the broader point, the important point to me, is that based on everything we know, everything that has happened over the past two decades, there is no reason to think that the Cardinal prospects like Gorman and Montero, and young MLB players like Bader, DeJong, and O’Neill will collectively over-or-underperform those OPS numbers by any meaningful amount.
Those numbers are the best guess. Carson Kelly’s .824 is his best guess. Because the past is the best predictor of the future.
All of these bapigs and wr+c and udr and opi numbers, etc, etc, just make me shake my head.
I was gonna do bapigs, udr and odi in the next post, but now I just won’t bother. 😉
Don’t fret over strikeouts, Rat. Lou Brock fanned a lot, and so did Reggie Jackson and many, many other Hall Of Famers. In fact, Reggie might roughly be Tyler’s best case scenario. Tiny Reggie, we’ll be calling him in 4 or 5 years. We can even create a candy bar for him. And YOU can name it!
When it comes to hitters, focus on the production, not the other stuff. Or as my mom likes to say, concentrate on the doughnut, not the hole.
A mister Brian Walton remarked:
I have no idea how Davenport’s projections are created, but if he is doing thousands of minor leaguers, it is likely formula-based, rather than scouting-based.
In his entire career to date at any level, Kelly had an OPS higher than the .824 “best three-year projection” shown above just once. At Memphis in 2017, he came in at .834 before backsliding this season. Maybe the formula weighted his 2017 strongest, because prior to that, his best showing was just .740 (at Double-A in 2016).
My question is if a player hasn’t done it for a prolonged period in the minors, why should he be projected to do it in the majors for a sustained period? Maybe if the player was young without a longer time playing and/or was rushed, but Kelly is 24 years old now.
I am 99.9% sure that there are zero scouting reports involved in Davenport’s projections. I think he would say that, as with all projection models for minor or major leaguers, his numbers exist to provide a wholly objective and emotionally indifferent complement to conventional scouting reports.
As for Carson Kelly’s MLB numbers exceeding his minor league ones, I would again cite his extreme youthfulness at many of his minor league stops. (I believe there’s an argument that he was in fact rushed, at least a little, in the lower levels, and that this may have hindered his hitting development.) Also, and I think this might be quite consequential, I would note that Carson was learning the craft of catching for his first few minor league campaigns. He himself has said in interviews that he did not work much on hitting until he reached the AA level, and felt comfortable spending less than 90% of his time on framing/pitch-blocking/game-calling/pitcher whispering.
In any case I can think of a couple other players whose 3-year MLB peaks far outdid their minor league best season. Yadi and Albert each surpassed their best single season minor league OPS by more than 80 points of OPS over their 3-year major league prime. To meet his Davenport Midpoint, Carson Kelly on the other hand merely needs to come close to an OPS he’s already posted in AAA, at age 22. I don’t think that unreasonable — although as with Yadi, it may not happen until his late 20’s.
Lastly, GScott graciously said:
That is a lot of research Bob. Kudos to you for taking the time to do it.
But based on the eye test and some rudimentary stats I am going to remain in the camp that Tyler is Grichuk 2.0 until proven otherwise. I hope your projections are accurate though because if they are then Tyler could be our starting LF in 2020.
If he is Grichuk 2.0 then he will just be a 4th OF.Well first off, why can’t everyone on the internet say such nice things to me, or send money? And second, I am glad you mentioned Grichuk alongside O’Neill, GScott, because I’ve seen that comparison a LOT lately, especially within the e-pages of the Post-Dispatch. So you’ve presented a needed opportunity for a side-by-side. (They were born in late June and mid-August, so the comparisons are even more convenient than they’d otherwise be. It’s a bit harder when guys are born half a year apart, and you’re comparing age-relative-to-league. But no such complication with these two outfielders.)
They each posted pretty gaudy numbers at a young age in the lower minors, but there’s not much reason to get into that, as we have large sample sizes for both in AA/AAA to look at.
Randal played in AA at 21 and was solid, batting .256 with a 116 wRC+ and a 3-1 strikeout/walk ratio.
Tyler toiled in AA at age 20 and was fantastic, at .293 with a 152 wRC+ and a 2.5-1 K/BB ratio.Randal was in Memphis at 22, where he hit .259 and slugged .493, with a nearly 4-1 K/BB tally.
Tyler was also there at 22, but he batted .311 and slugged .693. His K/BB remained roughly 2.5-1.Here’s a pretty cool fact. Grichuk had that 116 wRC+ in AA, and his AAA number was 102. Average those together and what do you get? A wRC+ of 109, which just happens to be exactly what he has posted at the MLB level through his first 4 seasons. I don’t even dare to do the math for O’Neill. It’d give me goosebumps.
It’s worth mentioning that this huge year for Memphis didn’t come out of nowhere. Tyler O’Neill was a consensus top prospect when the Cards traded for him from Seattle in 2017 — #36 at MLB.com, #38 for BA, and #53 at BPro. Then he was better than ever in 2018. But specifically, how great was O’Neill in 2018?
When it comes to Triple-A baseball, the Pacific Coast League has been around since 1946, as has the International League. The now-defunct American Association existed from 1946 to 1997. If you add it all up, well, that’s a lot of AAA seasons. Nearly 200 all told. And in all of those AAA seasons, only two batters age 23 or under have ever posted an isolated slugging of .380 or better.
1959 Willie McCovey .387
2018 Tyler O’Neill .382This doesn’t mean that he will BE the next Willie McCovey. In fact I’m sure he won’t be. But it means without a doubt, without room for reasonable debate, that Tyler O’Neill possesses a very rare gift for regularly hitting baseballs very, very hard. This is not a guy whom you block with Dexter Fowler or Jose Martinez. Far as I’m concerned anyway.
Thanks for all of the comments and questions, gentlemen! It might be a bit tedious but I’d like to address each piece of feedback in turn.
Forschy opined:
“It would be interesting to see the projections of players like Mather, Cox, Jones and Anderson just to see how he rated some of the more highly regarded prospects that didn’t make a difference. That might be even more telling about how to regard his projections.”Not a bad idea. Let’s look at the Davenport Midpoint projections for that prospect quartet.
Zack Cox was projected at a fairly dismal .715 OPS, lower than every current prospect cited above, including shortstops Tommy Edman and Edmundo Sosa. No smart team is going to play a third baseman whose best years are below average at the plate. So no surprise that he never made it.Bryan Anderson was forecast for a .767 Midpoint, or slightly behind where Andrew Knizner is now. But Anderson as a Cardinal minor leaguer was a poor defender with a net of -22 runs defensively per Clay Davenport, and even worse at -31 runs at Baseball Prospectus. So it’s not hard to see why Anderson didn’t get much opportunity in the majors. (Andrew Knizner, oddly, is -11 runs at BPro for his career, but a fine +8 at Clay Davenport’s website. Definitely far ahead of Anderson with the glove…the question is, how much.)
Joe Mather’s was the strongest projection by far, with a Midpoint of .860. His MLB debut was fine, with a .780 OPS at age 25 over a third of a season. But nagging injuries over the next several years generally hit him pretty hard, and I don’t think that being used as relief pitcher in the April, 2010 marathon game versus the Mets helped him either. We know for a fact that it injured Felipe Lopez, the other position player who pitched in that debacle. Thanks, LaRussa! (Tony allowed his relief pitchers to bat for themselves in extra innings with the bases loaded and two outs. Twice. Why didn’t he pinch-hit, with the game on the line? Because he “didn’t want to run out of pitchers.” Of course, by not pinch-hitting, not trying to score and end the game, LaRussa’s idiotic strategy eventually led to the very thing he was trying so much to avoid: position players pitching.)
So I would attribute Joe’s disappointing career to injuries as much as than anything else. I do have a theory that unusually tall batters might lose their swing mechanics or bat speed more easily than other hitters, or at a younger age, but I haven’t researched it systematically at all. Joe was around 6′ 5″ or so I think. Anyway it’s just a theory, based on underperformers like Ben Grieve, Jeremy Hermida, Hee Seop Choi, Jason Heyward, and a few others.
Finally we come to Daryl Jones, whose Davenport Midpoint was a solid-but-unspectacular .780 OPS. I liked Jones a lot back when he put up a great partial AA season. But I should have paid much more attention to his defensive numbers, which were quite poor at Clay Davenport (-19 runs) and an outright disaster per BPro (-41). With glovework like that, mostly in an outfield corner rather than centerfield, it’s hard to envision a lineup spot or bench role. (In my defense, I’m not sure that BPro had minor league defensive values on their website a decade ago. Maybe they did, but I don’t know.)
I would say that IF there is a lesson to be learned, Forschy, it’s to scout the defensive statline as well as the batting numbers. (Don’t listen to Keith Law, kids. Always scout the statline.)
Moving along,
jj-cf-stl stated:
The Carson Kelly / Paul DeJong rankings simply confuse me.
I have Carson as the next Tony Cruz, and evaluations like this make me wonder what glaring, obvious skill set I’m missing.Carson Kelly has been a huge disappointment in his limited MLB stints, no one can deny. But “limited” is the operative term here. Let’s check what he’s done over meaningful sample sizes in the upper minors, compared to Tony Cruz.
Tony Cruz got his first shot at AA at age 22, and batted .220 with a smelly 72 wRC+.
Carson Kelly played at Double-A at age 21, and posted a quite solid wRC+ of 115.Tony Cruz was in Memphis at ages 23 & 24, and managed a combined 73 wRC+.
Carson Kelly played for Memphis at age 22 and posted a wRC+ of 120. Again, I won’t praise in any way Carson’s pitiful MLB performance. But the evidence is strongly in his favor that he won’t turn out like Tony Cruz, if given ample opportunity.As for the straight-up comparison with Paul DeJong, Carson was competing at a younger age at every single level of the minors, much younger in some cases. For instance, Carson was initially at Peoria at age 18, while DeJong debuted there at 21. Overall, Kelly’s previously cited AA and AAA wRC+ numbers were very close to DeJong’s at the same levels, and Carson had the better plate discipline markers, to boot. So I’m not too surprised that he projects as well as DeJong does.
ROB COBB and ROB REED…. I didn’t get a chance to see your #76 – #100 selections. Any chance of a reposting? PADS? These lists are very interesting.
There’s no way I’m typing it all in again, brother Nyquist, if Pads can save me the work. I think he’s got it from when I posted the other day. C’mon Pads, I’m lazy!
And please, Nyq, call me Bob. Pugs prefers Bobby and that’s fine too. Screen name is Robert now only by necessity not choice.
November 20, 2018 at 4:38 pm in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #74739“Just say no to Cano. He has no place to play here.
I feel good about trading with Arizona. It seems like a good fit.”I could not agree more, GScott. No to the aging drug cheat Cano, and trade for the two Arizona relievers, Andrew Chafin from the left side, and Yoan Lopez from the right.
Then trade Jose Martinez and other stuff to Seattle for Colome or preferably Edwin Diaz, sign Donaldson and Kikuchi with most of the “Bryce Harper money,” and you’re set for Spring Training.
Oh, I nearly forgot. Release Fowler & Cecil & Gregerson, too. Their rotting carcasses are clogging the 40-man roster.
November 19, 2018 at 5:14 pm in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #74634So maybe a catcher (Kelly or Knizner) a starting pitcher (Gant or Gomber or other) and a DH to replace Nelson Cruz (Jose Martinez) would get the Cards superreliever Edwin Diaz. Seems like a healthy offer to me.
November 19, 2018 at 4:36 pm in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #74627Thanks for the responses, Guys.
I actually agree with you wholeheartedly that re closers there is a psychological component, gscott. I maybe should have said “closers can be found anywhere, just look at infielders Trevor Rosenthal & Trevor Hoffman or catchers Kenley Jansen and Jason Motte. So no smart team takes a potential #1/2 starting pitcher and moves him to relief pitching without giving him a chance to succeed in a rotation role first.)
Last 7 starts of 2017 for Hicks, at age 20, across Low and High-A:
Posted a 1.21 ERA and sub-2.00 FIP, with a 40/9 K/BB, and better than a 4-1 GO/FO ratio, and zero home runs, and just 12.8 pitches per inning.
For that brief shining period of time, Jordan Hicks and his blistering fastball possessed the Perfect Pitcher Profile™. And you don’t move a perfect pitcher to the bullpen. I cannot imagine a reason why I will ever relent in my belief that he should have stayed a starter until he showed he couldn’t be. Not with those numbers cited above.
See, here’s the thing. Even if the long term organizational expectation was the bullpen, you still owe it to both yourself and the kid to see if he can stick as a starter. Because even a #2/3 starter is more valuable (and likelier to stay healthy & effective over a period of many years) than an ace reliever.
The only way the St. Louis front office looks non-crazy in this matter, is if Hicks becomes as effective and durable as Kimbrel or Kenley. And that’s about a 100-1 shot, because those are 2 of the 4 or 5 best relievers in MLB history. What’s really going to happen, is Hicks will maybe be Trevor Rosenthal II, i.e., a sometimes great reliever who breaks down off and on over the next 3-5 years, because that’s what happens to 95-99% of relievers.
-
AuthorPosts
