Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Look it at like a minor free agent signing who we can always cut if he stinks it up again. It will give Oli every chance to succeed, but it will not stop change if that becomes the course. It is a vital investment that the organization had to make.
We all want a winner, but some question winning moves like Mo just forced Oli on us longer than we could possibly be expected to endure. What we can’t endure is losing, and Oli and losing are not simply synonymous.Expecting young starters to develop without learning from mistakes, and more importantly, changing and growing after reflecting on continuous errors inhibiting their success is not a practical use of time. You either have to experience failure and set backs with young starters or trade them at their minor league peak.
If the model includes developing cost-controlled starters, you have to give your top kids opportunities, and we have to understand dealing with failure is part of the process for all of us who are concerned.Brian already explained that we statistically could expect to experience an injury to the rotation. His historical perspective delivered a mild injury to the starter with the greatest margin for error and a personal history of overcoming that particular injury.
One could declare this enevitible outcome as the lesser of many potential evils. Happiness hinges on perspective, and I think having Sonny Gray chomping at the bit during those first couple inclement games where injuries and strains are always an issue is a fine hand to be dealt.It isn’t a serious injury; it is that Edman is the starting CF.
The most essential element to this deal is that Donovan and Burly weren’t getting it done on their own. Crawford should raise the mullettude level quite a bit. Teams just don’t win consistently without boasting superior mullets…especially in close games decided by a hair.
If this ends the Matt Carpenter era for good. then it is totally worth it. For what it’s worth, Crawford’s rep is playing the party boy clubhouse DJ role. Perhaps a new organization where he plays a smaller, more silent role will rekindle his bat and focus.
I thought the same thing. I assume step players fill the open innings. Perhaps a Rajic sighting is on tap.
If Edman is healthy, this is much ado about nothing. They designed the roster to have Winn and Edman take ALL the reps all season. The team with the best third string shortstop rarely wins with that being the determining factor.
Oh crap Bling! Did the season start? I was looking forward to six or seven weeks of spring, and I missed the whole thing.
Gamboa pronounces his name Ar-kim-e-dez, not like the Greek inventor.
We don’t need another shortstop right now. If Masyn gets injured (as opposed to some expected and reasonable muscle soreness and tightness at the beginning), then things change. If you want to exchange Fermin for an upgrade, ok, but Gamboa is MLB-ready. His swing has holes, but he can hit. He has some thump and is a pure shortstop.
The roster is wonky, and AAA ss is weaker than the MLB level. We have about 11 2nd basemen and two shortstops at the top levels.Scott is interesting because he doesn’t walk much. I have heard that his bunting evens things out, but the real issue is he needs development in a number of areas.
My eye test is that his bat could become Milt Thompson-esque with Alex Cole’s speed. If you add Rod Carew’s bunting (intended hyperbole), and Curt Flood’s glove, we are golden.
Mike Antico is waaay undervalued in this conversation. He is the version of Victor Scott who is actually ready.You have to provide starts for your young starters. They have to overcome struggles to be great, and you can’t do that if you take those opportunities and hand them to outsiders. When those outsiders are less talented and have no organizational equity, you breed ill will amongst your most prized humans.
Pitchers who start spring late seem to struggle; those who were ridden deep into the playoffs may benefit from a late start. It seems like Monty will end up making enough that the Cardinals will never even make an offer. Rightfully so.
I loved Oscar Gambles’ hair and Charlie Spikes’ power, but Silent George patrolling center field made Cleveland my red team in the American league. Too bad they got rid of those deep red uniforms.
All hail the silent one
Throwing big money at shoulder injuries is a terrible move, unless the shoulder belongs to Chris Carpenter.
Part of being a good leader is not burying people and blaming people when things go badly. If any player or Oli for that matter brought adversarial language into the clubhouse while it was burning, he would be a negative force, not a leader. There was never a point I can remember when an under-performing old guy was going to save the team by claiming these damn kids are bringing too much energy.
Leaders kick people’s asses when they are too full of themselves, not when they struggle.The Ponce release emphasized his unbelievable movement in three directions of 20 inches or more. The problem here is he had trouble locating pitches and had too many walks. They didn’t fix that. His handlers boasted he was now hitting 95 with ease. Interesting how they frame a reduction in velocity as growth.
Bob Reed is spot on in his analysis of Marmol’s handling of Liberatore. Building up arm strength and psyches are both vital to starters and Oliver fouled up Liberatore’s season.
I am anticipating great improvement from Liberatore this spring, and I hope it is in a rotation. I can’t imagine Marmol masterfully leading Liberatore to reach his massive potential out of the pen.Matz simply has to repeat the progression he was on last season.
I think the pace of game rules negate some of the irritation of pitching changes. I record all the games so I can fast-forward through commercials, pitching changes, and innings where Gallegos pitches. I root for Giovanni, but he is hard on my nervous system.
We have an interesting staff. We have a complete staff with every box checked. The assumption that not one of Mikolas, Lynn, Matz, Gibson, Liberatore, Thompson, Pallante, or Graceffo, will step up and pitch like a number two starter is far from assured. Excessive negativity is not the same thing as reasonable expectations. I suspect that four of the above-mentioned players will perform above his career norms while four will suffer injury or regression.
Pick any four of those names, and insert his apex season and we look pretty good(unless you pick Pallante, Graceffo, Liberatore, and Thompson; this would mean things went horribly wrong or unbelievably well).Projections are a fool’s errand. Too many variables to predict. To say we know how a player will perform based on past performances is even contrary to critical thinking principals.
I am eager to see the change and growth in Liberatore and Thompson; I hardly expect a repeat of last season.The issue with pitch to contact is that there is no need to extend a pitcher into the sixth or seventh inning if he is allowing runners. It really requires each individual to shift philosophies as the situations evolve.
-
AuthorPosts
