mudville

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 25 posts - 451 through 475 (of 3,517 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Baseball America Cardinals prospect rankings #295688
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I think BA has undermined their own credibility with this ridiculous ranking. After seeing this, I wouldn’t quote them on anything, and wouldn’t trust anything they say.

    in reply to: Player news #295634
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Thanks. No confusion here. I got it.

    in reply to: 2026 TCN Community Top 50 Prospect Voting Thread #295632
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    19. Church
    20. Gastelum

    in reply to: Player news #295627
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Previously released: LHP Zack Thompson, LHP

    Now I’m confused, again. Is Zack Thompson gone, or has he not been reinstated by MLB to the Cardinals because of the technicality that he was injured throughout all of 2025? If he has been released and then reinstated, then I will assume that he is on Memphis’ roster although he is not presently listed there.

    in reply to: 2026 TCN Community Top 50 Prospect Voting Thread #295624
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Personally, I can’t wait for a chance to vote for Andrew Dutkanych IV. His improvement after his surgery puts him in the top 50, or at least close to the top 50, for sure.

    I said that, facetiously, back on Nov. 6. But, bolstered by the preceding comment by Gags, and after thinking about it a bit, why couldn’t a reportedly healthy Dutkanych receive votes now based on scouting reports and his college resume. After all, we just ranked Mitchell based on his assumed good health and high school resume?

    in reply to: Roster Matrix #295623
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    have an $85 Million guy at DH/1B where we already have min wage guys who can do that.

    Totally agree.

    I’ve commented before that I would like to see Herrera at 1B. But I’d be okay with Burleson there.

    The trouble with trading Contreras is that he is going to want more years if he is traded. Time and time again, the Cardinals, and many other teams, find themselves ‘over a barrel’ because of that NTC. I wish they would address that in the next CBA along with many other things. Speaking of the next CBA, I am really skeptical about whether the 2027 season even gets played. In looking at the chaos in the world around us, it’s difficult to imagine the negotiations not turning into a fist fight, if not an all out war.

    in reply to: 2026 TCN Community Top 50 Prospect Voting Thread #295541
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Shouldn’t O’Brien and Svanson be high on the list of top relievers? Just wondering if I’m missing something.

    in reply to: 2026 TCN Community Top 50 Prospect Voting Thread #295469
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Love the intensity here. One poster complaining that Tanner Franklin is getting too much love, and another poster complaining that Nathan Church is not getting enough love. Personally, I can’t wait for a chance to vote for Andrew Dutkanych IV. His improvement after his surgery puts him in the top 50, or at least close to the top 50, for sure.

    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Just want to say that if Walker and Hence and Gorman and Hjerpe had turned out as expected, we would be looking at more of a ‘reset’ rather than a full on rebuild.

    in reply to: 2026 TCN Community Top 50 Prospect Voting Thread #295465
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    As far as I can tell. the next up position players are Ryan Mitchell, Nathan Church and Blaze Jordan, who has been sort of invisible for some reason. Based on his scouting grades, I think Mitchell has the highest potential. Nathan Church is the surest bet to get some MLB AB’s in 2026, although I don’t seem him getting much traction at the MLB level. Blaze Jordan has OPS’d over .800 for most of his career, and in fact, he was OPS’ing .928 for AA Portland before the Cardinals acquired him from Boston, and he’s now at Memphis at age 22.

    Based on Brian’s and Kyle’s reporting and commenting on this weeks Wednesday With Walton and Reis, plus his AFL Fall Star award, Darlin Saladin comes to mind. So for me, it’s between Saladin and Braden Davis here.

    17. – Ryan Mitchell
    Future star, or not? Lots of promise based on early data.
    18. – Braden Davis
    Based on Bod Reed’s comment and a review of Davis’ stats for 2025. Also, appears to have starter potential.

    in reply to: Too early 40 man protection #295423
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    If Siani is left unprotected, I could see another team picking him up and I could see Siani winning the starting CF job at their spring training. Scott is going to get better and better defensively. But for the time being I think Sinai is better defensively.

    in reply to: Wednesdays With Walton podcasts #295422
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    From what I saw of Siani, I think he is the best defensive centerfielder in the entire organization. His hitting isn’t great, but it’s not bad enough to not protect him. He made some true highlight reel plays when he was up.

    It’s going to interesting to compare Brian and Blake’s assessment of players in the TCN 2025 Prospect Guide to Brian and Kyle’s assessments of the same players in the TCN 2026 Prospect Guide.

    in reply to: Roster Matrix #295339
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I know, I know. Winn’s last name is spelled W-I-N-N.

    in reply to: 2026 TCN Community Top 50 Prospect Voting Thread #295338
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    #15 – Lin
    #16 – Ryan Mitchell – Early on, Mitchell checks a lot of boxes. If this kid doesn’t get ranked soon, there can only be one explanation. The sportswriters of America have not given him enough ink.

    in reply to: Roster Matrix #295326
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I wonder why they list Weatherholt as the Memphis shortstop when Wynn just won the GG at SS while reportedly playing with a nagging injury. (I don’t want to sound like a downer, but as happy as I am with Wynn at SS, he is not Ozzie Smith with the glove. No one is.)

    in reply to: Roster Matrix #295312
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Signed: RHP Aaron Holiday (A+)

    Briefly looking over his stats on Baseball Reference makes me think that sometimes the Cardinals sign a player so that he can fulfill a need for the minor league team he gets assigned to. This young man appears to have very little chance of making it to MLB. That said, there is still the possibility that the Cardinals’ talent evaluators saw something in his delivery that they can fix.

    in reply to: 2026 TCN Community Top 50 Prospect Voting Thread #295308
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    They must be hiding Alec Willis under a rock. The only thing I’ve seen about him through all of 2025 was a photo that Brian took during ST and posted on TCN.com.

    in reply to: 2026 TCN Community Top 50 Prospect Voting Thread #295273
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    13. – Hjerpe
    14. – Ryan Mitchell This kid stands at 6’2″ and weighs in at 185 lbs. He has impressive scouting grades as an 18 year old. He was the Cardinals 2nd round draft choice this year and signed for about a half million dollars over slot.

    in reply to: 2025 World Series thread #295272
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    There were reports at the time that some baseball executives viewed the Cardinals as the frontrunner to sign Yamamoto since
    they had been courting him the longest, and because he and Nootbaar had become personal friends. What ended that was the Dodgers swooping in and offering Yamamoto a 12 year contract for $27M a year. He collects his last big paycheck at the age of 39.

    in reply to: 2026 TCN Community Top 50 Prospect Voting Thread #295186
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Way back om October 23 blingboy brought up Curtis Taylor, and minutes later, Cardinals 27 concurred. I couldn’t find my source. But I thought that I had read that Taylor either developed a new pitch, or refined a pitch that he already had. Regardless, if he shows up at ST and pitches the way he did at Memphis this year, he deserves a spot in the forthcoming unproven rotation (‘unproven’ = My wife told me that I needed to be more kind.) Yes, Curtis Taylor has been passed around like a hot potato. But we cannot rightfully ignore the fact that our own (almost a star) reliever, Riley O’Brien, didn’t break out until the Cardinals coaches got hold of him and helped him fix his deficiencies, allowing him to finally break out at the ripe old age of 30, thus proving that miracles can, and do, happen. And let’s bear in mind that Curtis Taylor, just short of only two weeks ago, was named TCN Memphis Starting Pitcher of the Year. No small honor. It is both tragic and shameful that he cannot be fairly ranked because of a technicality.

    in reply to: 2026 TCN Community Top 50 Prospect Voting Thread #295183
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    @Mudville – you voted this early for Cooper Hjerpe, and he has only thrown 25 games in the three years since he was drafted, and only threw 5.0 innings or more seven times.

    LACardFan – I get your point. My point, again, is that Hjerpe’s condition is often successfully cured. And when he was pitching without physical impairment, he looked almost unhittable, at least, to me. Providing that his elbow is okay, if used as a reliever, it might take an opposing team once through their entire lineup for them to figure out what to do with him. He also gets some credit for being a first round draft pick. I rest my defense.

    in reply to: 2026 TCN Community Top 50 Prospect Voting Thread #295178
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    gscottar – That’s exactly the kind of post that made me do a reality check on Hence. I haven’t given up on him yet because as they say ‘Hope springs eternal’. By the way, I looked that quote up and because the whole quote is so beautiful to read, here it is.

    “Hope springs eternal in the human breast;
    Man never Is, but always To be blest.
    The soul, uneasy, and confin’d from home,
    Rests and expatiates in a life to come.”
    ― Alexander Pope, An Essay on Man

    … and, oh, here’s the definition of the word ‘expatiates’.
    (intransitive verb)

    1. To speak or write at length.
    2. “expatiated on the subject until everyone was bored.”
    3. To wander freely. To range at large, or without
    restraint.
    The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, 5th Edition
    (IMHO, definition 3 relates to Hence.)

    in reply to: 2025 World Series thread #295159
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I didn’t realize where Toronto was in relation to the United States. I, more or less, thought it was located somewhere up by the North Pole. I looked it up on a map and was surprised to see that Toronto is located at about the same latitude as Milwaukee and Boston. The entire country of Canada has a population, roughly, about the same as the state of California.

    in reply to: 2026 TCN Community Top 50 Prospect Voting Thread #295158
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    11. – Jesus Baez
    12. – Cooper Hjerpe

    I originally wanted to rank Hence in my personal top 10. But after reading some of the posts concerning him, I did a reality check and conceded that there’s very little reason to expect much from Hence because of his health issues. It seems like the organization is just waiting and waiting for his body to hit a level of maturity where the injuries don’t keep happening. Hjerpe’s health issues don’t seem to be as big of a concern because he’s out with TJ surgery, and more often than not, pitchers come back well from TJ surgery. On the other hand, his submarine style pitching motion is worrisome, and he has had elbow issues ever since the Cardinals gave him $3.182M for showing up in Jupiter after the draft.

    in reply to: 2026 TCN Community Top 50 Prospect Voting Thread #295060
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Not enough data yet for me to support Padilla at #10. Hence, Roby, and Hjerpe are all talented and have high expectations. Voting for Hence almost feels like a fool’s errand because of his relentless health concerns No offense on the ‘fool’s errand’ metaphor, Stlcards25. Someone could use the same metaphor for my choosing to vote for Jesus Baez here. Apparently there are scouts, both within the Cardinals’ organization and in MLB in general, that like him. I agree that there are several prospects that could be in this spot.

    #10 Jesus Baez

Viewing 25 posts - 451 through 475 (of 3,517 total)

First-hand news and commentary on the St. Louis Cardinals™ and minor league system for over 25 years