Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Edman should never be a platoon player. That is crazy. Gorman needs to DH.
“Edman will play a lot but it might not always be at 2B”. He should start every game at 2B.
Edman should not be replaced…he is very, very valuable. It is total nonsense to even mention him in that regard. Something is wrong with anyone who thinks that way.
Again, Edman makes the Cardinals go. Leave him alone and concentrate on real issues.
“Would love to see Gorman play good enough defense at second and hit consistently enough to take the job. That would free up Tommy for late defense, possibly some shortstop play, and utility. But this will be a transition year so we will see”.
I do not want Groman to ever play 2B…Edman should start every game there. Tommy makes the Cardinals go.I will watch and pull hard for the Braves…I can’t stand Houston.
I agree! I like that line-up but with the likelihood that their is a DH Nolan Gorman fits in there.
“In my mind, if Marmol continues to bat Goldschmidt 2nd then, well, let’s just say that isn’t good”. What would you do? IMO, Edman is the lead-off hitter and some combination of O’Neill, Goldschmidt, Arenado & Carlson are the first 5.
I am fine with Marmol.
Someone, please tell me why Mike Shildt was let go…what did he not agree with management on? Since Shildt and Marmol were close, they must have philosophical differences too if Marmol is going to be puppet-like Manager some posters know to be the case.
What did Shildt push back on? How do you know that Marmol is a puppet?
How will he manage differently than Mike Shildt?
I am not insulted. What has Marmol done to you?
Don’t ever play Gorman at 2B…he is a DH, to begin with, and then 1B to eventually replace Goldy.
I don’t like Baez…much rather get Story or Seager.
Edman is excellent! I see that his improvement could come as a hitter in being more patient and drawing more walks. He makes contact too much. He does not strike much but also does not walk a lot. He has to learn to be more selective.
Schumaker has 4 years of experience…all at the Major League level with the Padres.
I think Skip Schumaker is the likely choice of the known candidates.
He was a good Manager and should still be the Manager.
It does not add up to me either. Mike Shildt was an effective manager and to fire him for”philosophical differences is too vague for me. It doesn’t give me much confidence in Management.
I want to hear what the “philosophical differences are”? Too generic for me. I thought Shildt was a good manager.
I think it is shocking also. Injuries to the starting pitching staff were the reason we didn’t win more than 90 games, not Shildt.
I am not glad to see it. Need further clarification.
How much do the Cardinals save on the Dexter Fowler contract in 2022?
“Even if Edman is moved out of leadoff next season doesn’t mean he can’t be moved back later.”
If the Cards had kept Wong as they should have, would Edman have spelled both him and DeJong and then taken over SS from DeJong – leaving Sosa out of the equation for 2021?
Edman should continue to be the lead-off hitter and start every game at 2B. I like Edman better than Wong.
-
AuthorPosts
