Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
April 21, 2024 at 10:11 am in reply to: StL 2024 Game #22 thread – Sunday, April 21 vs. Brewers #248926
Just wait until September and October, duh….
Clapp may very well be next in line to manage the Cardinals.
Can’t blame Marmol for this roster, can’t blame Marmol for injuries (or can we, sort of?).
Maybe certain players that are blossoming elsewhere got moved because of the way Marmol and staff coached and used them?
When’s the last time the Cardinals traded for a player that came in and got noticably better?
I know it’s a reach but there could be something in this line of thinking…
April 20, 2024 at 9:03 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #21 thread – Saturday, April 20 vs. Brewers #248899Last season the team never recovered from their horrid start. Yeah it’s early – I usually like to wait until the end of May to see what’s what but last season it didn’t take that long…
April 20, 2024 at 9:01 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #22 thread – Sunday, April 21 vs. Brewers #248898Series is lost but yeah, winning one would be nice. if Gray gets 4-5 runs to work with that should get it done and then try to carry some momentum into the Arizona series.
Until the offense wakes up though it’s going to be tough sledding. Team is already 5 off the pace in the NLC – if they get to 10 out I think the team will collapse on itself.
The team is as emotionally dead as any team I’ve seen; they don’t seem to have any fire…
Goldschmidt should have been traded last year at the break or during the off season when he still had some value. Now? What could you even get for him?
April 20, 2024 at 4:34 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #21 thread – Saturday, April 20 vs. Brewers #248867The early returns on this team don’t look promising for sure.
So, even when they get Edman and Carlson back and you can get rid of Scott and Siani – what does that get you?
The way Walker, Gorman, and Goldschmidt are going and even Donovan and Nootbar are hitting under .230.
Outside of Gray and Lynn (somewhat) the starting pitching is spotty and inconsistent.
I mean – it’s starting to look like playing .500 baseball is the ceiling for this team so by the time they manage to get healthy (assuming no one else gets injured) then another 70-75 win season may be just about all you can expect.
April 20, 2024 at 10:23 am in reply to: StL 2024 Game #21 thread – Saturday, April 20 vs. Brewers #248779I would move Nootbar to CF and stick Burleson in LF. That removes the Siani / Scott auto out.
You still have the G boys to contend with but Scott / Siani and Walker are sitting.
I think you absolutely cannot start Scott or Siani no matter what that means in the outfield for now.
The team clearly misread the team leaves with Edman’s injury time table and Carlson’s injury was just bad luck.
Nootbar has to go to CF – for now.
We simply don’t have the bodies to sit Goldschmidt, Gorman, and Walker all at the same time.
Having both Carpenter and Crawford on the bench is debilitating from a flexibility standpoint.
I guess you try an outfield of Donovan, Nootbar, and Burleson (?) with Herrera or Contreras at DH and the other catching.
Winn at short, Arenado at third, that leaves you with Gorman at 2nd and Goldschmidt at first but good Lord move them down in the lineup.
That removes Scott / Siani and Walker from the lineup and would seem to increase the chances to score runs…
Would it be worth sticking Crawford at 2nd? Has he ever played that position at the ML level? Can he at least hit his weight?
Until Scott is ready you (eventually) have Edman and Carlson to cover CF.
Donovan can cover 2b if Gorman can’t remember how to hit – once we have an actual major league outfield again.
When the band is back together having guys in the lineup hitting at least .240 top to bottom is going to feel amazing rather than having 4-5 spots under .200 every day.
April 20, 2024 at 9:44 am in reply to: StL 2024 Game #20 thread – Friday, April 19 vs. Brewers #248769Walking William Contreras in the 10th with first base open was the easiest decision Marmol had last night.
Even if it back fires that is the call in that situation.
With the offense in the crapper for now you just have to walk him there.
Nootbar failing to advance Goldschmidt to third was a real killer in the Cards 10th.
April 19, 2024 at 11:23 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #21 thread – Saturday, April 20 vs. Brewers #248747Well, this game should have more scoring….at least on paper it will.
April 19, 2024 at 11:21 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #20 thread – Friday, April 19 vs. Brewers #248746Good Lord. How in the world do you not have any AAA outfielders?
Well, I guess we do but they are playing in StL…
April 19, 2024 at 10:35 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #20 thread – Friday, April 19 vs. Brewers #248744Hardhead needs to move Goldschmidt and Gorman down in the lineup – I guess.
Twin golden sombreros for those two, lol.
Is no one playing outfield for Memphis? Give ’em a shot – how much worse could they be than Scott / Siani / Walker?
April 18, 2024 at 1:03 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #19 thread – at A’s, Wednesday, April 17 #248596It is neither a good team nor a bad team. It is a very average team that, depending on injuries and year to year ups and downs of player performance, can fall off to either side of average.
The Cards are a coin precariously balanced on its edge and we are all wondering which way it will fall.
There is a way to generally quantity what value a professional franchise brings to a city and county.
The Cardinals are a regional draw and so visitors to the City coming in for Cardinals games generate local sales tax and hotel tax amounts and they eat out and shop to also boost local businesses.
There is an equitable split between public and private dollars that will make some sense.
If the Cardinals pick up and move to say, Nashville – what would the economic impact be to the City, the County, and the downtown hotels, restaurants, and bars? You can put a number on that.
Sure, if offered the owner of whatever pro team will allow 100% public money to be used but unless a City is luring a franchise to relocate that isn’t generally how it goes.
The middle ground is usually the fairest and best choice when it comes to these types of facilities improvements.
Now, the question I have is – Does the stadium actually NEED major improvements or will some maintenance of what is already there work for another 10 years?
April 18, 2024 at 12:33 pm in reply to: StL 2024 Game #20 thread – Friday, April 19 vs. Brewers #248591I break the 162 games into thirds.
There are 54 games you are going to lose now matter what. There are 54 games you are going to win no matter what.
It’s how many of those 54 remaining games that are ‘in the balance’ so to speak that you win or lose that tells the tale of your season.
That’s how I look at it.
April 18, 2024 at 8:40 am in reply to: StL 2024 Game #19 thread – at A’s, Wednesday, April 17 #248560As long as the team can at least hover around .500 making the bloated playoffs is possible.
It appears to me that is all the Cardinals are trying to do – for now.
If I had to guess they are hoping this crop of young position players pans out such that next year they have a really potent lineup.
To that maybe they add another front line starter to go with Gray – and parlay that into a deep playoff run or two before the cost of keeping the young guys spirals out of control…just guesswork on my part as to what the long term strategy might be.
The baseball draft seems to be way more of a crap shoot than the NFL draft. The only picks really worth anything for sure (in my opinion) are top 10 1st rounders kinda like the NBA (which only has 2 rounds now).
After that it’s pretty hard to tell if and when a guy will ever pan out.
Maybe baseball could allow only 2nd round or later picks to be traded and still feel that it is protecting ownership from themselves…
April 18, 2024 at 8:14 am in reply to: StL 2024 Game #20 thread – Friday, April 19 vs. Brewers #248556Gorman is 11th in all of MLB in K rate? That’s bad. I would guess there are between 250 and 300 qualified batters on the entire list?
We will start to find out this weekend how we stack up in the division. The NL Central appears to have improved from top to bottom – the Cardinals did get better but did everybody else also improve?
April 17, 2024 at 8:13 am in reply to: StL 2024 Game #19 thread – at A’s, Wednesday, April 17 #248435Hopefully Marmol does not run the ‘Sunday’ lineup out there today.
Yeah it was 70-75.
Bunting with Noot??
Liberatore is sick, right?
April 15, 2024 at 8:43 am in reply to: StL 2024 Game #16 thread – at D’backs, Sunday, April 14 #248090So, if the Cardinals finish outside of the playoffs again this year what do we expect to happen?
Mo and Marmol out – new POBO who then hired his man to manage or – ownership ejects to keep the band together one more year to get Mo through his 2025 contract?
It is definitely an uncomfortable situation in Oakland right now.
Cardinals are up and down and can’t seem to find themselves – at least not yet.
Too many guys not hitting their weight and the starting pitching is anybodies guess each game.
It may yet all come together.
Remember just be 71-71 then get hot the last 20 games and you are probably in the playoffs.
-
AuthorPosts
