mudville

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 25 posts - 1,051 through 1,075 (of 3,520 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Sonny Gray #238354
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I guess, if the Cardinals would acquire Soto, we would have Soto in LF, Nootbaar in CF, and Walker in RF. With that outfield defense, our rotation’s cumulative ERA would likely go up by a full run. I think this Soto rumor amounts to nothing more than somebody manipulating the media so as to generate interest in a Soto trade.

    BTW, Walker has not been getting much love around here lately, but IMO, he still has the potential for one day becoming the face of the franchise, just not as an outfielder.

    in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2021-2023 #238346
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I’d still like to see the Cardinals and White Sox make a blockbuster trade , with Hence excluded. Both teams could help themselves, especially the White Sox because, as it stands now, they have virtually no hope of fielding a winning team for the rest of the decade.

    in reply to: Sonny Gray #238342
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Bob Reed – I see Matz and Brett Cecil as panic moves, also, but with less dollars wasted. With Matz they were committed to finding a left-handed starter and Matz was all they could find, and with Cecil they were committed to finding a left-handed reliever and Cecil was all they could find. So they panicked and signed each of them at the time.

    It’s open season for hot stove talk, so here’s my thoughts on this Sonny Gray signing….

    – This signing, along with the Lynn and Gibson signings, show that the Cardinals are not going to sign any unknown quantities. Everyone knows what to expect from Gray, Lynn, and Gibson, and that’s what the Cardinals and their fan base are going to get. So with that, we can scratch Glasnow and Manoah off the list of possible signings, and we should be suspicious of rumors involving the Cardinals and Cease, Snell, Bieber and every other pitcher with a question mark attached to their resume.

    – A rotation of thirty-something pitchers tells us that the Cardinals are going to maintain their ‘build from within’ philosophy. None of the pitchers in this new rotation are going to block Hence, Roby, Hjerpe, Graceffo, Bedell or Rajcic for very long, if at all. And if Hence is the organization’s top pitching prospect, he is not going anywhere until he gets the call to join the MLB team.

    – Given the Cardinals’ conservative approach to this offseason so far, it seems highly, highly unlikely that they will ‘go all in’ on Yamamoto.

    – Now that the Cardinals have established a satisfactory rotation, they are no longer desperate for starting pitching. So possible trade partners like the Mariners, White Sox, and Yankees will be more likely to engage in talks with the Cardinals on an equitable level. We’ll see.

    in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2021-2023 #238204
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    After taking a fresh look at those innings pitched numbers that gscottar posted, I think Glasnow has to be taken out of the conversation about pitching help for the Cardinals. Maybe, if the Rays would offer him for a low level prospect and be willing to take back $20M of the #25M that is owed him, would he be worth taking a chance on. The negotiations for Glasnow will likely be centered around how much of his $25M salary the acquiring ballclub will accept.

    in reply to: Community 2024 Top 50 Prospect Voting #238199
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    #13 Pages
    #14 Bedell

    Pages had something of a breakout offensively in 2023. His defense was always strong. His CS% is quite a bit higher than either Bernal or Crooks, and Pages is doing it at AA. If he makes another stride like he did this year, in 2024 he will easily make it into the top 10.

    After COVID and TJ setbacks since being drafted in 2020, Bedell looked like he was finally back in 2023 at Peoria. He just needs more time and more reps to get fully back with all of his pitches. Eventually, this Mizzou alumnus could be a solid No. 3 starter, if not better, IMO.

    in reply to: TCN 2024 Top 50 Prospects $articles discussion #238174
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I hope I didn’t come off as being critical. I only mentioned that because I wanted to make the point that you’re audience is paying attention.

    in reply to: The Cardinal Nation’s 2024 Top 50 Prospect Countdown #238163
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    What’s a ‘sexy stand out tool that can be slobbered over’ look like?

    in reply to: TCN 2024 Top 50 Prospects $articles discussion #238162
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    To Blake Newberry – Blake your opening comment on Koperniak is
    counterintuitive. i.e ‘Matt Koperniak is another who deserves more love than I am giving him.’ Other than that, thanks for your comprehensive analysis on Koperniak and the others you have covered so far.

    I could see Koperniak as a low cost fourth or fifth outfielder. He has always hit well, he has a good arm, and he has decent speed. I have him ranked even higher than BW.

    in reply to: What’s it gonna take to fix the Cardinals #238161
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Rat – I looked him up. He was a big time Japanese wrestler. Even if he was still alive, I know I couldn’t take him alone. You’d have to soften him up for before I could put him away.

    in reply to: Lance Lynn to the Cardinals… #238160
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Sorry for your loss, UConn.

    I think St. Louis is on the verge of becoming a destination city. Homicides are down 23% in St. Louis proper, and there’s reason to expect the crime rate will further improve. There are several multi-billion dollar mixed use developments in progress, or planned. One is downtown to the south of the Arch, another at Brentwood and Manchester, another where the old Chesterfield mall was located, another at Olive and Hwy. 170, and another at Dorsett and Hwy. 270. The tech corridor near St. Louis University is booming. Tickets for a St. Louis City SC game are nearly impossible to get. (I know someone who bought season tickets for standing room only.) A listing of why St. Louis is up and coming could be pretty lengthy. But the most important reason why St. Louis is a great place is that it’s a place that still holds, for the most part, traditional American values. With that, young couples who want to raise kids have a better chance of their kids not being embued with somebody’s political/social narrative instead of the things kids are supposed to learn in school. In other words, St. Louis is pretty good place to raise a family. Add to all of this that the Cardinals do, apparently, have a reasonable chance to sign Yamamoto and that they might even be able to swing a deal with the White Sox, and you have to be impressed.

    in reply to: What’s it gonna take to fix the Cardinals #238156
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual
    in reply to: What’s it gonna take to fix the Cardinals #238140
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I’m guessing that they signed Lynn and Gibson for reliable depth. There’s little reason to think that Matz is going to last in the rotation, and if Liberatore or Thompson goes to the pen, then they only have one of them left for the rotation when attrition happens.

    Lynn has an option year with a $2M buyout. Then, there’s Hence, Roby, Kjerpe, Graceffo, etc for 2025.

    in reply to: What’s it gonna take to fix the Cardinals #238134
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Here’s what I feel certain they will do….. Mo and the front office will maintain radio silence until a trade, or free agent signing, is done. Then, a few days before the front office announces the it, the writers will start giving us ‘breaking news’ about a trade, or free agent signing, that could happen. Then, when enough conversation has been generated, the front office will announce the trade, or signing.

    As far as ‘which players’ is anybody’s guess. All we know for sure is that, if it’s a free agent signing, it won’t be one that costs mega dollars.

    in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2021-2023 #238132
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I think ‘build from within’ refers to not trying to fulfill needs by signing {expensive} free agents.

    in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2021-2023 #238104
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I was under the impression that both the Guardians and the Blue Jays had some interest in O’Neill.

    in reply to: Community 2024 Top 50 Prospect Voting #238103
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    11. Rajcic
    12. Pages

    It’s hard to put Pages here ahead of Bedell who I have next at No. 13. The tie breaker for me is that Pages is having success at AA and Bedell is doing it at A+.

    I’ve never seen this much talent running into the 11-20 range, and even into the 21-30 range.

    in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2021-2023 #238087
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I hate to see Donovan get traded. He’s a gamer that bring a lot of energy to the field when he plays. But, I think Donovan has earned a chance to be an everyday player, and that’s not going to happen if Gorman is our second baseman. Also, if we can hang onto Edman, we can afford to lose Donovan.

    I get the apprehension about Cease. He may not really be a top of rotation guy, but he should at least be a NO.2. They still really need that true No. 1. Yamamoto would be ideal if his success in Japan would translate to MLB. The obvious problem is that every organization that thinks they have a chance at signing him, is all in on doing just that.

    in reply to: Community 2024 Top 50 Prospect Voting #238085
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    bb – I did listen to Brian’s interview with Crooks. I said about the Pages interview that my opinion is subjective. With that I’ll say that I sense that Crooks has a little swagger. And with Crooks it sounds like it’s based on genuine confidence, and not ego. Almost all of the interview was about Crooks’ offense which was very good (.271/.358/.433/.791) at A+ in 2023, but not quite as impressive as Pages’ offense (.267/.362/,443/.806)at AA. Crooks CS% was around 27% in 2023. Bernal, who is 2.5 years younger than Crooks, had a CS% of around 23%. Pages CS% in 2022 was 30% and in 2023 it was 38%. I was going to vote for Bernal as my No. 11 prospect, but I’m going to move Pages ahead of both Bernal and Crooks. Maybe all three of these players will become everyday catchers, but I’m thinking that Pages will be the first to get the chance.

    in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2021-2023 #238083
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    A few days ago I proposed a trade of:
    Gorman, Walker, Donovan, Hence, Robberse, Honeyman
    for
    Cease, Robert, Kopech
    In a later post, I took Kopech out and added Gregory Santos.
    At first glance this trade looks unrealistic because the
    knee-jerk response is ‘There is no way the White Sox are trading their superstar centerfielder, Luis Robert.’ But when you look at it further, it would seem to make sense for the White Sox. The White Sox were 40 games under .500 for 2023, and there’s not much help in sight for them going forward. They could very well finish behind Kansas City in last place in 2024. All they have coming for position players is their No. 1 top prospect, shortstop, Colson Montgomery. If they would trade Robert to the Cardinals, they could get almost an entire starting lineup that would make them competitive for the foreseeable future.

    I would want to change the trade somewhat. It might not be fair to the Cardinals to have to include Gorman in a package with so many other talented players already in it. Gorman is still only 22 years old…turns 23 in May. He improved greatly over the 2022-2023 offseason, and we can anticipate that he will continue to improve. He might even approach Robert’s 38 HR season of 2023 fairly soon. So, I’m taking Gorman out of the proposal and adding Saggese and Davis. I’m adding Saggese, and adding Davis, because our current system is so stacked that we can afford it, and because Robert could not just fill a need, but could fill a need with a budding superstar.

    There is risk for the Cardinals because Robert has really only had one standout season in his short, major league career. No one knows if he’s going to have a problem staying healthy. And with this trade the Cardinals would be trading away, virtually, their whole system for three White Sox players.

    I guess the risk for the White Sox is that of fan backlash for trading Robert. But, if they don’t make this trade, it will cost them millions in lost revenue because they will be suffering losing season after losing season for the next decade, or more. And if Robert would suffer an injury in 2024, a trade like this would be off the table for 2025.

    The upside for the Cardinals is that with this trade, if Cease and Robert and Santos work out as anticipated, the Cardinals, with one more high end pitching addition, clearly, would have the best team in their Division and one of the top teams in all of MLB.

    So the trade is this:
    Donovan, Walker, Saggese, Hence, Robberse, Honeyman, Davis
    for
    Cease, Robert, Santos

    This is a ‘win now’ trade. It makes sense to mudville. Hopefully, Mozeliak and White Sox GM, Getz, will see the light.

    This GM/POBO job is easy. I don’t understand why Mo always looks like he just stuck his finger into a wall socket at this time of the year.

    in reply to: Community 2024 Top 50 Prospect Voting #238053
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    9. Davis
    10. Bernal

    I’ll admit that I’ve been swayed by the Cardinals’ own ranking of Bernal in the top 10 of their Top 30. I can’t disagree with it because what little information there is about Bernal is positive. I expect him to improve again in 2024. But if he doesn’t, and if Pages continues to improve, then I’m going to rank Pages ahead of him next year. Pages was drafted in 2019, so his development had to have been set back by the COVID years. His calling card has always been his defense, but his offense at AA where he finished the season was well above average for a catcher, also…. .267/.362/.443./806 with 17 HR in 424 AB. Finally, and this is very subjective, I know… but in Brian’s interview with Springfield’s pitching coach, Eric Peterson, it sounded to me like Peterson honestly thinks very highly of Pedro Pages. Pages is going to be my #11 prospect

    in reply to: Happy Thanksgiving! #238050
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Happy Thanksgiving.

    in reply to: What’s it gonna take to fix the Cardinals #237967
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    The Cardinals apparently are still intent on acquiring two top of rotation starters. But if they do that, there’s no room at the inn for Matz, Thompson, or Liberatore.

    in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2021-2023 #237966
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Robert would solve our centerfield question, along with adding his cost controlled impact bat. We would also have that top of rotation pitcher in Cease. Kopech is listed on the White Sox website as being in their bullpen, but he’s actually a starter. I think that this package would be strong enough to add Gregory Santos from the White Sox instead of Kopech.

    With this, the White Sox have their infield established for years to come with Walker at 1B, Donovan at 2B, their own top prospect, Colson Montgomey, at SS, and Gorman at 3B. And they get Hence who has the makings of a #1 starter. Honeyman would hold promise for the White Sox’ outfield, and Robberse gives them a legitimate bullpen candidate.

    It would be especially tough for the Cardinals to lose Donovan because he plays well all over the field. But, IMO, he has earned the role of being an everyday second baseman. Prieto, Fermin, or Kennedy could handle utility for the Cardinals, or maybe, they could pick up utility guy in the Rule 5 draft. Baker would be available for 1B if Goldy needs a day off. Saggese needs more time at AAA for now, and with that bat of his, he probably should not join the big club until Edman moves off of 2B for one reason or another.

    Burleson plays left field. Our fourth and fifth outfielders would be Carlson and Palacios, if Palacios can continue his strong play.

    This trade would be a lot for the Cardinals to give up. But it’s going to take a lot to get a player like Robert and a pitcher like Cease.

    in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2021-2023 #237952
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    Here’s a trade idea……
    Gorman, Walker, Donovan, Hence, Robberse, Honeyman
    for
    Cease, Robert, Kopech

    Is this a fair trade?
    Is it realistic to think that the Cardinals would do it?
    Is it realistic to think that the White Sox would do it?

    in reply to: Roster Matrix #237910
    mudville
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I was hoping W-Rod would be back. I want to see him finish his story here, good or bad.

Viewing 25 posts - 1,051 through 1,075 (of 3,520 total)

First-hand news and commentary on the St. Louis Cardinals™ and minor league system for over 25 years