Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Just about every team is short a starter for their rotation. We are much better off than almost every other club because of our depth. I agree that Flaherty is one of the best pitching prospects in baseball. I wouldn’t include him in a trade for Donaldson unless we could extend Donaldson first. Even then, I may not want to do it. IMO, Flaherty is a No. 1 or No. 2 that is just starting to come into his own. After this season he will be untouchable.
It would be nice to have an experienced closer. But we do have options:
January 8, 2018 at 10:47 am in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #41377Castellanos (last 2 yrs.) WAR 1.3 dWAR -6.3
Gyorko (last 2 yrs.) WAR 6.6 dWAR 2.6Gyorko is a much better player than he gets credit for.
Agree that it would be nice to have Lynn back, but not for 5-6 years and $100M+. If we can’t make a trade for a starter, then we’ll just have to win with what we’ve got.
January 7, 2018 at 5:18 pm in reply to: Former Cardinals in the News – 2017 to Aug. 2024 (closed) #41352Mike. I know you meant Adams, not Lynn as a perfect “Rockie-type” player. Too bad TCN won’t let you edit your post. I think Adams is a good fit for just about any team that doesn’t have a roster full of inflated egos. I always liked Matt Adams and was happy to see him sign. He’s pretty much at a point now where his security is assured although he might be one of these players that’s around for a long time.
January 7, 2018 at 5:09 pm in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #41351Castellanos isn’t that much of an upgrade from Gyorko, if at all. Unless Donaldson becomes available, we might as well concentrate on a closer, or maybe a starter, although I’m willing to go into this season with what we’ve got. We still have a much better team going into 2018 than we did going into 2017. I think we can compete with this team.
I didn’t know about the uptick in velocity, among other things. After he got through last season with no shoulder blade problems, it occurred to me, also, that with another offseason of conditioning, the strength of his shoulder and his stamina would improve even more. Then, his innings per start could maybe increase to somewhere over six innings, maybe even get into the 6.5 to 7.5 innings per start range. Nice piece. Thanks.
January 6, 2018 at 3:47 pm in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #41270Any day now we’re going to hear Boras’ speech about how the owners are colluding, and how unfair the system is to his clients.
I don’t think its so much a strategy that managers don’t want their pitchers to face a lineup a third time, as it is that the pitchers aren’t hungry enough to want to pitch more than 5-6 innings. Its possible that their agents are encouraging them to pitch less to save their arms. But its also possible that they just don’t see any reason to put in the extra effort that it takes to pitch 8-9 innings. After all, wins don’t matter anymore, and won/lost records for a pitcher are irrelevant, so why should they bother themselves. But I’ll say this, also. If pitchers only want to do 60-70% of the work that they did 5 or 6 years ago, then they should get paid 60-70% of what they got paid then. And since the ball clubs are not paying them to win anymore, but only to perform for 5-6 innings, then take some more off for that lack of effort, also.
Here’s my reference:
https://www.royalsreview.com/2017/11/15/16646392/royals-free-agents-how-much-will-eric-hosmer-getI didn’t look any further, probably because I’m just not a big Hosmer fan, so this is about what I think would be reasonable for him. To me a first baseman that’s going to get the big bucks should be a bonafide superstar that hits 30-40 HR with excellent defense like Votto or Goldschmidt. Not saying Hosmer is mediocre, but I don’t see him as a $147M dollar player either.
Pads. Nice post.
I don’t see Hosmer as a $147M+ player. The original estimates for him were were 4yrs./$60-70M, or maybe 6 yrs./$80M.
I’m not saying we should sign Arrieta. But Wainwright is a long shot and Weaver is far from proven.
It was only four years ago that the Cardinals were getting criticized for signing Peralta. That’s when MO had to defend himself by saying ‘We are not the morality police’, which I still think was a cop out. If ‘we’ are not he morality police, then who are the morality police?
I feel confident that steroids are pretty much out of the minor league experience. I’m equally confident that steroids are still being used internationally. Re: Delvin Perez
As far as the major leagues are concerned, there is still evidence that steroids are still being used.
https://www.si.com/mlb/2016/05/05/ped-suspensions-steroids-dee-gordon-turinabol
The question that remains partially open is ‘Have some major league ballplayers found a way to circumvent the protocol that is supposed to eliminate steroid use from the major leagues?’ I think that some players have, in fact, found a way to beat the system. I thought that some of the MLB channel’s hosts were hinting that steroids were still being used when they were comparing a couple of players who were hitting a lot of HR’s last season to players from the steroid era that hit a lot of HR’s i.e. Bonds, McGwireI’ll say this. If Major League Baseball is enabling players and organizations to use steroids, it runs the risk of a backlash from fans, especially fans who think they have been deprived by cheaters of their right to be in the postseason.
The trade I’d love to see happen is Donaldson and Asuna from the Blue Jays. Seems unlikely, but so does Colome and Archer from the Rays. After the beating that the Cardinals took over signing Peralta after his steroid bust, I can’t get enthusiastic about a trade for Colome. MO’s comment that ‘We are not the morality police’ is something of a cop out, IMO.
Hosmer might not take the $147M because he thinks he should get a 8-9 year contract, presumably raising the total to $168M or $189M. I guess he figures that $147M is a done deal. So what does it matter if he holds out for a few more weeks for the $168M/$189M. History tells us that, in the end, either the Padres or Royals will cave, and give him everything he wants.
I wonder when people are going to start noticing Adolis Garcia.
I have a feeling that the length of contract that’s being offered by the ball clubs is what’s holding up the free agent signings. The players and their agents want 5-6 year contracts, and the ball clubs don’t want to give more than 3-4 years. Greg Holland is 32 years old now. I wouldn’t want him on the books for more than 2 years. When you think about it, it seems ridiculous to pay a 36 year old pitcher the same money that you pay to a 32 year old.
Who knows? Boras definitely uses the media to manipulate thinking. The media then gets paid back for letting itself be used by getting news ‘scoops’ about free agents from Boras.
MO has said that the Cardinals are ‘open for business’ and that their offseason doesn’t end until the first day of spring raining.
Its also intriguing to read that there is still conversation going on about Josh Donaldson.
January 2, 2018 at 9:03 am in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #41016We might still be able to get a closer somewhere. But I don’t see where we would get another starter. The Cardinals are not going to give any of the free agent starters 5 or 6 years, so we can rule that out. I think a trade would be too expensive in terms of prospects, also. So the solution will have to come from within the organization. Flaherty could be pushed, but I hope that doesn’t happen. He needs more innings at AAA. IMO, the sleeper starter is Tyler Lyons. He just needs to show that he can do it. Of course, if Wainwright can come back at least for part of the season, and if Weaver can stick in the rotation, then the need isn’t as pressing. Flaherty should be ready for more major league innings sometime during the next season with Hudson not far behind.
Its nice to see that the ballclubs are not jumping to meet the demands of the agents who represent starting pitching. Maybe if the pitchers realize that, if they’re only going to pitch 5 or 6 innings a game, then their value to the organization, and therefore their value in dollars will come down. Maybe, then, they’ll go back to wanting to pitch into the 8th or 9th innings. Its kind of weird that as soon as a pitcher gets into the 5th inning, he starts looking over his shoulder to see who’s warming up in the bullpen.
I always like reading forsch31’s posts. Wish he could let those little skirmishes pass.
We don’t yet know, for sure, how good Kelly will actually be. Molina is still one of the best catchers in the game, and maybe the best defensive catcher ever.
In my opinion, extending Molina was a very classy action by the front office. It allows Molina to be one of the few players in MLB who start and finish their career with the same organization. Molina played under team friendly contracts for much of his career, and its gratifying to see that the organization treating him with the respect he deserves as he enters the twilgiht of his career.
I think Reyes will be a better closer than any of the free agent closers. He’s got the stuff, and he sure looks like he has the mentality, so far. Roberto Asuna saved 39 games for the Blue Jays last year at the age of 22, and he saved 36 games the year before.
The Blue Jays want to be competitive in 2018. They are not trying to rebuild. If the Cardinals, or any other organization, can propose a trade for Donaldson that would make the Blue Jays better this year, I get the feeling that they would make that trade. Who knows what the lueIMO, Gyorko, Baker, and Flaherty would make them better. In fact, I think that would be too much of an overpay. I think we would needto find a way to work Osuna in on that deal. Also, I would not trade Flaherty unless an extension for Donaldson could be worked out first.
Nice post, Nigel T.
-
AuthorPosts
