Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
I hope they don’t add Hosmer or Moustakas.
January 19, 2018 at 5:05 pm in reply to: Cardinals OF roundup, who stays and who goes? (Grichuk) #42150It kind of seems like the Blue Jays picked our pocket on this and the Diaz trade. We couldn’t get them to give us Donaldson. So is this supposed to be the next best thing?
I think just about anybody would like to have Holland. But at what price?
But who wants to be stuck in a mistake they made for years and years? Think about the Red Sox and Price. They’re paying him $31M AVV for the next five years, and he might be spending that time in the bullpen. Then, there’s Heyward. Yikes.
January 19, 2018 at 11:47 am in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #42134Bless you, gscottar. I don’t think there are many who knew you were surrounded by so many Cubs fans.
January 18, 2018 at 11:20 pm in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #42115I don’t understand why people keep harping on Reed. He has health questions. A lot of teams passed on Reed. Philadelphia almost signed him, but backed out. So what’s next? Holland is out there. But Boras wants 5 or 6 years at $16M AVV for him. How does that sound? Once we’ve got him, we pretty much have to play him regardless of if he gets hammered every time out, or not.
January 18, 2018 at 4:45 pm in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #42086What did these self-appointed experts have to say about all the clubs that accomplished much less than what our front office accomplished? Could it be that these characters were influenced by some agents who are pissed that their demands for their clients aren’t being met this offseason? Did these clowns happen to say what we should do with Carpenter if we signed Hosmer? Who do they want us to give up in order to get another rotation piece? Or should we give Darvish or Arrieta 6 years and a large fortune to be that piece? Did they suggest that we sign Holland for 6 years and $80M, which is what I believe Boras is asking for? Its amazing that these ‘experts’ are so shrewd and so smart themselves as to recognize that the Cardinals are really only posturing when they say they are satisfied with the offseason they have. I wonder what Luke Gregerson thinks about their comments.
That’s one way of looking at it, Nooner. But its not the only way. Anyone can be successful without having to dominate.
I’m pretty sure its too early to compare MO to Epstein. Lets make that judgement in another year or two when the Cubs’ star players are getting to be free agents, and their farm system doesn’t have much to support the big club. I get the distinct impression that the Cubs’ ownership does not want to go over he luxury tax threshold.
Pujols has a 10 year personal services agreement with the Angels that starts upon the completion of his contract, or retirement, whichever comes first. That would make it seem that he would be wearing an Angels cap when he is inducted into the HOF. I’m sure glad we’re not stuck with his contract with the way he’s performed since he became a free agent.
Projected BA of .217 is bothersome to me, even if the HR’s are there.
Nice to see DeJong projected for 36 HR’s. That piece last summer about DeJong being another Jonathon Schoop or Corey Snyder has been a bit worrisome. Too bad Pham doesn’t get to be the 30-30 guy he was hoping to become.:) All the high expectations for Bader but, according to this guy, its mostly illusion.
I’d be okay with signing Hosmer and trading Carpenter. Its hard to imagine that happening, though. Besides, after listening to what he had to say at WWU, I have a feeling he’s going to surprise some people this year. He sounds enthusiastic and healthy.
January 17, 2018 at 9:29 pm in reply to: Cardinals OF roundup, who stays and who goes? (Grichuk) #42028I have very high hopes for Pham, also. I have been having the same kinds of thoughts that nbr1hawkeye has posted. Having the kind of mentality that Pham has about excelling and competing is a big deal, IMO. Regarding outfielders, I’m wondering if Adolis Garcia isn’t going to move past Bader and O’Neill at some point this summer. Grichuk, and maybe another promising prospect, seems like it ought to be able to get just about any available player we want. Its surprising that a trade like tha hasn’t happened hasn’t happened.
I never could understand how signing Hosmer would make sense because of the obvious question of ‘What, then, do we do with Matt carpenter?’ It seems that anything gained by having Hosmer at first base would be offset by having Carpenter at third base. And for that our ‘payroll flexibility’ would go down by $20M/yr.
What we could use the most would be an upgrade at third base although Gyorko is far from being a liability there. Rentals don’t make much sense. I don’t want Moustakas unless somebody can explain how he was able to hit 38 HR’s in 2017 when he never hit more than 22 HR’s in any season before that. So what is the explanation?
1. Does he lack the ability to motivate himself except when its a walk year?
2. Juiced ball accounted for an additional 16 HR’s above his highest total?
3. Changed his swing?
4. PED’s?
5. Stopped eating junk food?
6. Hot new girlfriend?
There has to be an explanation. I wouldn’t want to take a chance on him unless I knew what happened.Also, I want to say that I agree with forsch31 completely.
Reed might have been a nice addition, maybe not. If he’s going to get lit up every other time he hits the mound, then he’s not such a good addition and maybe we’d be better off with Gregerson or Tuivailal. Derrick Goold offered at viable explanation for why the Cardinals didn’t sign Reed. Essentially, he said that based on the fact that Reed has had a heavy work load in the past, and that no other teams were rushing to sign him, its possible that the Cardinals didn’t see him as a good fit. Being cheap had nothing to do with it.
We don’t know why they haven’t traded for Colome. Goold said they never were really interested in Colome. Instead they tried talking to the Rays about Archer. But the Rays didn’t want to talk about Archer. Its not about being cheap here either. Its about what they think will work best for the organization and the team. Nobody knows if Colome would be better than Gregerson and others that are already ion the organization. But they don’t think overwhelming the Rays to get Colome is worth the risk. We don’t know how Gregerson and potential others will respond to the stress of closing. But we do know that Broxton, Oh, and a worn out Siegrist are not going to be getting torched night after night. (I sure hope Cecil is a lot better than he was last year.)
I don’t know of a power left-handed bat that would fit into our lineup that is obtainable. We can wish for anything we want. Occasionally, wishes come true. So far that one hasn’t. Donaldson and Machado are both right-handed and would fill the need. Maybe Donaldson could be pried away from the Blue Jays even though they have consistently said that they want to contend and that Donaldson is not available. But he would almost be sure to be a one year rental, and after the 2018 season we would have nothing to show for giving up a boatload of top prospects as well as much o the orgznization’s future. We could get Machado. But first of all, he doesn’t want to play third for us. Instead he has told us he wants to be a shortstop again. Go figure. Regardless of that, we would have to give up Flaherty and another pitching prospect for a guy who would be spending the summer in St. Louis so he can showcase his talent for other teams. His agent doesn’t even want to consider an extension.
There just isn’t a dominant closer available. Gregerson could very well be as good as we’re ever going to get. Hopefully, the organization can ultimately find the answer to the closing question within itself.
Everyone would love to have a No. 2 starter. But do we really want to give up a bevy of talent when we have several promising starters almost ready? Maybe we should. Time will tell. I still think it would be a good idea to bring Lynn back, but MO apparently doesn’t.
All in all I still think the organization has had a very good offseason. IMO, getting Ozuna was an almost unbelievable accomplishment, better for the team and the organization than getting Stanton would have been. Stanton might be a head case. The Yankees have him and his injury history for 10 years.
.
Now that Yadi has made his decision, I bet he will be more of a mentor to Kelly.
If mspaid were GM, we would be forced into tank and rebuild mode in another year or two, followed by several years of misery as we try to recover. I don’t believe mspaid would bet his salary on winning a WS, and probably wouldn’t even bet it on making the playoffs. This thread has degenerated into nothing more than a venting venue for a very few loudmouthed people who apparently live in a world where they are constantly getting screwed by others. Throwing money at a need, or worse, squandering prospects in a shortsighted attempt to dominate the offseason is what got MLB into its current state where it costs hundreds of dollars for a family to go to a baseball game. You can’t blame only ownership, and you can’t blame only the players and their agents, clearly, there are those among the fan base who also use anger and fear and greed as their motivation. The fact is that its supposed to be a team game, not only for the players, but for the organization itself. Many of the problems this team had last year have been addressed, and either wholly solved, or at least mitigated. I think MO and his crew have done a commendable job given the environment that they have to work in. I, for one, am very interested to see if the organization can fix whatever else needs to be addressed by giving players within the organization their chance to contribute, or maybe with more time, developing a sensible trade or making a free agent signing that will benefit the organization, both long term and short term. Its amazing that a few sorry individuals, spitting their vitriol, can make it seem like their opinion is the only one that matters, and that they are supported by many other fans when they most definitely are not.
I don’t want to trade Flaherty and others for Colome. I don’t want to give any closer the kind of money Wade Davis got ($51M), much less Greg Holland. The bullpen is already not going to fail as much this year because we’re not starting off with Broxton and Oh, and we will not be following Rosenthal down the road to TJ surgery. Gregerson and Tuivailala, with possible help from Brebbia who was a closer Independent ball a few years ago should be able to get us through April. Then, Reyes or Hicks or Helsley should be able start closing.
Speaking of Rosenthal, I wish MO would work something out with him. Maybe keep him on the payroll next year for $1M or so, and have a club option for, say, $8M for 2019. When he was good, he was really good. Of course, Boras is going to try to get much more than that. But its still worth thinking about.
January 13, 2018 at 5:29 pm in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #41686I’m not convinced that Reed would have been a better option than what we have available now which is get through the month of April with Gegerson and Tuivailala, then seeing if Reyes, or possibly Hicks, could help with closing games. We all know that just throwing money at a problem is usually not the answer, and signing Reed might not have amounted to much more than that. Also, there is still the possibility of a trade that could help our bullpen.
Really, really like these reports and photos. Almost like being there in Jupiter for Spring Training.
I think they should sign Reed as long as his demands do not exceed his value based on the organization’s analytics. IMO, signing any player, based on fear of what might happen to you if you don’t, is a mistake.
I know Ozuna won a Gold Glove for left field. But he never got a chance to play right field because that was Stanton’s position. I have heard talk on the radio and read comments that Ozuna might be starting in right field with Fowler in left, and Pham in center. Obviously, if Ozuna turns out to be a better right fielder than Fowler, he ought to be playing right field. Either way, the outfield should be much better at the start of the season than it was last year.
No Peralta. No Broxton. Ozuna in right field. This, is enough to say the team is much improved, IMO. But, also, the bullpen looks much better with Rosenthal off to recover his health (wish him the best), and Siegrist in a better place. I think Wong has settled down and, if so, that’s an improvement over last year. Shortstop appears to be more settled than it has been for years. Leake and his sore head cost us some games during the second half, and he’s gone. Fowler should able to contribute more if his foot is healed. Pham is an improvement for center field. Plus, we have a bevy of pitching talent that should be ready to contribute this season including Reyes.
This team is already much better going in to ST than last year’s team was.
-
AuthorPosts
